Show notes
- Seriously podcast
- Dr Jan Eppingstall at Stuffology
- https://www.facebook.com/stuffologyconsulting/
- https://twitter.com/stuff_ology
- https://www.instagram.com/stuff_ology/
- Dr Jan Eppingstall on Pinterest
- Website: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding
- Become a Dehoarding Darling
- Submit a topic for the podcast to cover
- Questions to ask when dehoarding: https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/podquestions
- Instagram: @thathoarderpodcast
- Twitter: @ThatHoarder
- Mastodon: @ThatHoarder@mastodon.online
- TikTok: @thathoarderoch https://www.tiktok.com/@thathoarderoch
- Facebook: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Pinterest: That Hoarder
- YouTube: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Reddit: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder subreddit
- Help out: Support this project
- Sponsor the podcast
Subscribe to the podcast
Transcript
Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder.
Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast and all my social media, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk.
Finally, I am not a doctor, I’m just a hoarder doing her best, so do seek professional support if and when you need it.
So I am here with doctor Jan Eppingstall, a Melbourne-based counsellor who specialises in working with people who hoard.
Jan, how are you?
Dr Jan Eppingstall: I’m excellent. Thank you very much for asking.
TH: So we often talk on this podcast about how hoarding doesn’t occur in a vacuum. Many of us who hoard also have overlapping difficulties in other areas too, whether that’s other mental health problems, neurodivergence or loneliness.
Because of that, we might be seeing a therapist or mental health worker who specialises in something else like eating disorders or depression. Or we might be seeing a general therapist who doesn’t specialise. But either way, that therapist finds themselves dealing with whatever difficulty somebody presents with.
So there are therapists like Jan who are specialists in working with people who hoard and only work with people who hoard. But Jan also invariably deals with other issues her hoarding clients bring, whether they’re anxious or isolated or self-harming.
Similarly, we know there are therapists and counsellors out there who are treating a client for one thing and find themselves treating their hoarding issues as well. (Shout out to my therapist!)
The difficulty is that a lot of counsellors don’t feel equipped to deal with hoarding in clients. I hear from them. I’m sure Jan hears from them as well.
JE: Mhmm.
TH: And the fact that some say they learn more from this podcast than they ever did from their training is kind of great to hear on a personal level, but also quite worrying.
So today, we are speaking particularly to therapists who find themselves working with a hoarding client while not being a specialist in that area. A lot of the advice and info we talk about will also apply to other professionals like support workers, professional organisers, mental health staff, and others.
So, Jan, can we start with you talking about the way counsellors work, in terms of some like you being specialists and others being generalists?
JE: So a generalist counsellor is likely to see many clients that we call the worried well, I would say. These are people who are struggling with a particular problem in their lives, be it a breakup, a death of a loved one, maybe work stress, and they need that support for a limited period of time to talk things through.
A client might return in the future and have a number of sessions about another problem and then not see that therapist again, or not see them ongoing.
So they’re kind of the GPs of mental health support and they have general knowledge about the most common kind of mental health issues.
But for a complex presentation, a depth of knowledge is often really required to treat a client’s issue. So a generalist has that shallow knowledge of a large number of mental health issues and a specialist has that deep knowledge of one particular issue. And they perhaps, like myself, found the presentation that’s really interesting to them and they’ve gone down the rabbit hole and become an expert.
I mean, not many have been crazy enough to complete a PhD, but they’ve often taken numerous specialist courses to hone their skills and they’ll always find themselves working with those types of people because they find it particularly interesting.
But specialists don’t generally take on clients who present with other types of psychopathologies because they don’t have the experience or knowledge with it. Like, I don’t work with people who have a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia, however I have worked with people who hoard who have a secondary diagnosis of schizoaffective or schizotypal disorder or something along those lines.
Usually, these people also have a psychologist who supports them well across all the diagnoses that they might have.
So I think that really the generalist is your GP-style counsellor who you would go to for relationship issues, struggles with stress, depression, anxiety at kind of lower levels, and then a specialist is really someone who has a deep knowledge of that problem.
TH: And both types of therapists have specific skills, like the way that with doctors, we need some who are highly specialised in bones or brains or skin, and we need some who have decent knowledge of pretty much everything. It’s the same with therapy.
I know in the UK, there’s quite a big move for GPs, general practitioners, to be seen as specialists in general medicine because it is its own skill.
In your own work, how often do you find yourself addressing issues that go beyond just hoarding in your practice?
'It's always important to work with an individual as a whole and we need to look at how they're functioning, how they're living their life' - @stuff_ology Share on XJE: Really often. The research suggests that something like 70% of people who hoard suffer from at least one other psychopathology. So that means the odds most of my clients are going to have other issues that are co-occurring with significant hoarding symptoms… I’ve never met a person who hoards that doesn’t have another significant diagnosis, and it’s always important to work with an individual as a whole and we need to look at how they’re functioning, how they’re living their life.
And that tends to be why hoarding is the thing that makes the most sense to work with first.
Not always, because I have other clients who maybe have agoraphobia or social anxiety, so those things tend to come first because then we can open that window of tolerance and actually manage and treat other things such as hoarding or depression.
But 9 times out of 10 with my clients, the hoarding has the most impact on their ability to function in their lives, but it doesn’t mean that I’m not constantly looking at neurodiversity, ADHD and ASD, those sorts of things. I’m juggling all of that as well.
But it is important to look at the whole individual and see how they’re functioning and then look for those core processes that need to be tackled in order to improve their mental health.
TH: And as you’ve talked about before, there’s a lot of trauma, there’s a lot of grief, there’s all of these impacting issues, aren’t there?
JE: Mhmm. And also physical disabilities as well that’s a big one. And often, that just makes the whole process more difficult for them and it means that the hoarding impacts them significantly more. If they can’t get around their house, it just makes their world shrink even further.
So that’s another thing that I deal with. And usually my clients, because I work with a lot of people who have support through the National Disability Insurance Scheme, they have a care team who look after them.
So that way, I can communicate with all these other elements of their care team and we can help them in all ways.
TH: Yeah. Because I’m increasingly beginning to understand my own life as it’s not PTSD plus hoarding. It’s PTSD multiplied by hoarding, if that makes sense. And vice versa, it’s hoarding multiplied by PTSD. Things just escalate.
JE: I think that’s really an interesting way of looking at it and it’s a clear demonstration of… that’s exactly what happens. It’s a multiplier, you know? It does make it exponentially more difficult to do things.
TH: Yeah.
JE: And I like the way you’ve described that. I’m going to use that. I’m taking that.
TH: Feel free!
JE: I’m stealing it because it really feels… yeah, it really does describe the way that hoarding impacts in all these other ways, but it is part of your entire being.
TH: Yeah.
JE: And everything feeds into that.
TH: So in your professional experience, thinking of colleagues of yours who aren’t specialised in hoarding, how well prepared do you think most people are to deal with hoarding when they qualify as therapists?
JE: Well, in my experience, which is admittedly limited in terms of courses and content around the world, I don’t believe any master’s of clinical psychology includes any more than a single lecture on hoarding disorder.
I’m happy to be proven wrong. I’m I’m happy for anyone from any university to call me up and let me know.
There might be some universities that have a hoarding focus. They might have researchers like a couple up in Sydney have a couple of my colleagues working there and they’re really interested in hoarding, perhaps they go and do guest lectures for their clinical psych students. I presented to a master’s cohort at RMIT once when I was doing my PhD.
But it seems that this is something that a person would need to explore on their own as far as I can see, as I did.
You know, I spent years reading, researching, working with people who hoard.
But the regular counsellor or psychologist doesn’t have a thorough understanding of hoarding, and it’s quite unique in its presentation, which means that it doesn’t tend to be something that people gravitate towards. They probably do a couple of lectures on it, if at all, and really just touch the surface of what it what the disorder is about, what the symptoms are, that sort of thing.
But it’s very, very rudimentary, and it’s very surface level.
TH: I hear from student social workers, student psychologists saying, I’m working with someone, but I’ve not been prepared at all. So I’m listening to the podcast all the time.
And I’m glad we’re providing that, but it’s worrying as well.
JE: Yes. Exactly.
I am contacted quite frequently, particularly from Australian therapists or often people in Melbourne saying, please can you help me? Can you take on this client?
And I’m trying to kind of give those people support to take on that client themselves because they’ve already created a relationship. They already have a therapeutic relationship that they can build on. And for me to come in, it’s going to take me time, whereas they can really work well with a running start. They can already be making changes.
So I just try and empower them as much as I can with bits and pieces of advice and they can always call me back and have a consult around the client. There’s no problem with that. I’m more than happy to support people who are wanting to do that one-on-one work with hoarding clients.
TH: And from now on, you can refer them to this episode.
JE: Exactly. Look at that.
TH: So if a mental health professional does feel out of their depth with something a client raises in therapy, for instance hoarding, what should they do?
JE: For any presentation that is not something you’ve worked with before, the first thing is to do research. Identify the elements of the kind of theoretical model that are being explored in the literature. Have a look at some of the basic articles in the literature that give you a bit of foundation.
Perhaps look for a book that assists you in grasping how the symptoms present, and from there, you can have a look at how the disorder’s been treated and the efficacy of that treatment.
But the truth of the matter is that there are not enough therapists to go around.
We do know, however, that that therapeutic relationship that we were just talking about between the client and clinician contributes approximately 30% to positive changes in the client’s mental health. That’s before you’ve done anything else.
So just having that trusted professional listen to you, reflect back, and validate your feelings in an empathetic way can improve your mental health by 30%.
So merely just connecting with a therapist who creates that safe space for you to share your difficulties will take you a third of the way there, pretty much.
So that’s always important to remember. It’s not going to be wasted.
But if you’re a mental health professional and you do feel out of your depth, I do encourage you to continue working with that client and building some of your expertise up in those areas if it’s of interest to you, because you’re already partway there. You’re already helping them significantly, and just taking that next step could be a real success story.
TH: And I would add to that. While there were definite benefits in having someone who really understands hoarding disorder, if you don’t feel you’re a person who really understands hoarding disorder, reminding yourself constantly that it’s not about the stuff. It’s other things that are going on.
You know how to work with other things that are going on, even if you don’t know the latest research in this.
An awful lot of it is what you’re already doing.
JE: Mhmm.
TH: Because it’s not about the stuff. It’s about stuff being wrong inside a person.
Everything feels wrong.
JE: Exactly.
TH: And that’s what you deal with daily. Like, you’ve got this.
JE: Yeah. Yeah.
TH: Also, from having been a client of therapists and from having friends who are therapists, having a good supervisor can make all the difference.
And especially if you’re genuinely thinking, I don’t know if I’m the right person to do this work, and you just don’t know. Hopefully, your supervisor is responsible enough to say either you’ve got this, I’ll support you. Or, I think you’re right, I think you’re not the right person.
But it’s somebody external who knows the way you work and knows you, and I would say that can be a really good resource.
And also read books, listen to podcasts, I have read so many research articles on this subject because of this podcast.
They’re out there, not all easily accessible, but there’s a fair amount that is. I have learned, and you’ve reinforced this, that if you email a researcher and say, please send me a copy of the thing, they are thrilled.
It’s not just that they’re willing. They’re like, oh, somebody wants to read it?
JE: I know. If I ever get anybody, the general public who contacts me, I’m like, well, okay then.
That’ll be the speediest email you’ll ever get.
Because they really are so willing to just share their research and share their thoughts, and I find the same. If I’m interested in someone’s work who does some things in similar areas to me, I just reach out. I just find their email and I just send them a note.
And they are 9 times out of 10 more than happy to start a dialogue about something. And, yeah, they will help.
They’re happy to share. It’s lonely. It’s lonely in the ivory tower, I think.
TH: Yeah. Yeah. And you’re writing things that are very niche, and so will only ever have a small target audience. And so I would imagine when someone’s interested, that’s quite exciting.
JE: Yep. From experience.
TH: Indeed. Indeed.
I am a big fan of all health professionals admitting when they don’t know something rather than pretending they do know to save face and then making it up as they go along.
I say this somebody who’s dealt with many doctors over the years, and I would much rather they say, look, I don’t know anything about endometriosis than think they do and wing it.
But I also know there’s a lot of pressure to look authoritative.
But as a client, I’d say it’s better for a therapist to say, look, I don’t know a lot about this, but I’m here to support you. I will learn whatever I need to learn, than not say that and just wing it.
Is that, though, a realistic approach for a therapist to take, or does that risk a client losing confidence in you?
JE: Yeah. I think it’s perfectly acceptable, and, in fact, encouraged really.
A good counsellor is there walking beside you, guiding you, and should never claim to be an expert on your experience. That’s the whole point.
'A good counsellor is there walking beside you, guiding you, and should never claim to be an expert on your experience' - @stuff_ology Share on XThey’re there to find out about you and your experiences, your feelings, your thoughts, and that is the perfect… being curious about this person. As you said, it’s not about the stuff. You can work out these things by talking with that person and being open, not giving advice. We’re not advice givers. That’s key. We’re a catalyst for change.
So we’re there just eliciting, just trying to find out where that person’s at.
I think it’s perfectly fine for a a mental health professional to say, or any health professional, to say, look, you know what? I don’t know and I’m happy to find out.
I want to work with you. I want to continue working with you. I want to find out all I can and we’re going to learn together and chances are we’ll actually find a solution to this and we’ll be able to find ways to help you move forward.
A therapists who’s willing to learn in order to support you is much better than pretending to know it all. That’s not a good therapist.
TH: I think there’s been a shift, hasn’t there? Like, people of my grandparents’ generation expected their doctor to be quite patriarchal and impose something on them and would have been thrown by them saying, “I don’t know”.
Whereas I think now that is more of an expectation that it is a collaboration. And that in a therapy room, there’s two humans in a therapy room, and it’s not a kind of leader and follower in that space.
'We're not advice givers. That's key. We're a catalyst for change' - @stuff_ology Share on XJE: And if it is, then that’s a big red flag. Yeah. That’s a huge red flag because that might mean that you’re not able to be honest about what’s happening with you and having someone who thinks they know everything about you is not going to listen, is not going to be an active listener or an active participant in the sessions, and assumptions make asses out of you and me.
TH: And we’ve all had that at some point, whether it’s like a doctor assuming that if you’re overweight, you never exercise, for instance. Or if you’re young, you must drink a lot or something like that.
And so they’ll say, oh, just stop drinking. You’ll be fine. And it doesn’t matter that you don’t drink or whatever.
And we’ve all experienced that assumption and then patronising and then going out thinking, well, that wasn’t any use at all.
JE: Exactly. Exactly. And as women we experience that on the daily, we’re like, well, the gender pain gap, the inability for people to understand that these things occur, the lack of research into women’s health, I mean, it’s a whole it’s a whole thing.
TH: It’s a whole thing.
JE: It’s a whole thing. And that impacts on a lot of my clients as well because, as I say, a lot of them have these other issues as well, which means that if they find a therapist who can help can kind of understand them in a holistic sense and see that there’s all these other things that feed in, and, as you say, are multiplied by the hoarding, it gives the person a sense that they’re understood and that there might be a way out of it because often people feel like there’s no way out, that they’re trapped in this home. They’re trapped in the stuff, basically.
They don’t know how they’re going to get out, but if they feel like they’ve met someone who is happy to listen and to help them and is willing to support and learn along with them, then I think that’s definitely a realistic way for a therapist to approach it.
If you’ve got lots and lots of clients in a particular… if you’re only working with mostly people who have x and this one client comes into the mix and you really feel like you don’t have that time to dedicate to that person and you really feel that there’d be a detriment to them, then refer away, I think.
And as you say, talk to your supervisor, talk to those supports around you, talk to your peer group. And say what are your thoughts?
TH: Yeah. Am I having a confidence wobble?
JE: Yes.
TH: Or am I genuinely not equipped to work with? Yeah.
JE: Exactly. Exactly. And that’s one thing that I think clinicians could use more, is that peer group.
I know a lot of the peak bodies have notice boards where you can ask questions, you can ask for help from people, that sort of thing.
I think that’s a really good resource and it does help to get someone’s unbiased opinion about whether they think that this is something you can handle.
So it’s important to reach out to those supports.
TH: So what are some issues a therapist might come across when working with somebody who hoards that might take them by surprise or that might be a bit different to working with other clients?
I make this podcast because I think it’s important. I started it as an outlet for myself, but it’s become much more than that. And I hear from people all the time about how listening to me talk about my experience and interview specialists and experts is helping them.
Hearing those stories makes the time and cost absolutely worth it. But if you want to help to ensure that the future of the podcast is sustainable, you can donate to help with costs.
To send a one off or recurring donation, just go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/donate.
Thank you.
JE: The most obvious thing, I think, is that effective therapy doesn’t happen in the office.
So if someone has come to you with hoarding tendencies it will be necessary for you to visit their home in order to help them at least once, I mean a minimum of once.
You’ll also need to see them engage with their possessions. Like I’ve had conversations about letting go of excessive possessions over a cup of tea and then when it comes to the actual act of deciding and parting with the items, they struggle.
Now that’s what you need to see, that struggle. How do they feel, think in the struggle? That’s the most important bit.
So seeing them in their environment. Also the research, and from my experience, suggests that talk therapy is not effective on its own. So it’s necessary to have hands-on in-home support for your client.
If you’ve got a super motivated client who’s fit, they’re self-motivated, they’ll do own things in between therapy sessions, you’ve found a unicorn because I don’t know of any that really are able to keep up that momentum and are able to actually process and remove the things that they’ve decided to let go of.
It’s a whole thing.
TH: The intention can be fully there. It’s not that they’re lying about the motivation, but then actually doing it is like a different task to wanting to do it.
JE: Exactly.
TH: I may speak from experience there.
JE: Just a little, maybe. Yeah. Just a little.
But you’re right. Even getting to the point where you’ve decided, you know those things are going, but then that’s one step, and then there’s these all these other steps that attach to that, and that’s where you kind of really need a trained support worker or a professional organiser if you want to move a bit faster than you would on your own.
And it’s ideal that you can work as a team, so the clinician, whoever it might be, with this hands-on person, and the client are like that team. They work together, they talk amongst themselves, they see where great successes have happened, where a person’s struggling a little bit, what can we do?
I think that’s kind of the ideal situation but that’s not always possible, of course.
But if you can, that’s the way to go.
I mean, if a person’s unable to allow another person into the home except for you, then you’ll need to work with them until they can tolerate hands-on support.
This means you can then start that process of decision-making and moving items out.
TH: And from both therapists and professional organisers that I’ve talked to for this podcast, they often already have connections with each other. A therapist will say, these three women are great.
Because I have so much respect for professional organisers, but there’s a real spectrum in who they prefer to work with and who they’re good at working with.
Some are very good at going into offices and organising those. Some are very good at making neat homes beautiful. Some are more dig into high clutter.
And from people I’ve spoken to, the therapists who work in this area and the professional organisers who work in this area often already know each other.
JE: Yep. And we kind of work as a team.
We talk amongst ourselves and say look I’ve got a new client, I’m thinking that this might work, I think your personalities would really fit if you’ve got capacity, can you help?
And you get to know them and how they work and you get to know the client and you get quite honest answers from the client about how things are going and what they might be having difficulty with, which means you can then communicate that back to the professional organiser and they can tweak what they’re doing.
Because most of them will admit, well, look, I’m not in their heads. I’m not in their head space. I don’t really know all of everything.
But I can come sit down with them and say, okay, what’s happening? Where are we going? What’s our plan? And then the professional organiser comes in and can really execute that plan.
They might have been thinking of a completely different plan because their head was working in a different way, but we can come up with a plan together.
But we do know each other. We do work together. I wish there were more of you, pretty please, and I really wish there were more who found that working with the tougher, sort of high levels of clutter, I wish there were more people working in that space.
But there are some fabulous, fabulous women who I work with and shout out to them if they’re listening because they know who they are. I take my hat off to them. They’re a brilliant brilliant bunch.
TH: Yeah. It’s a real skill. It’s a real skill.
JE: Oh, yeah. And my skills are a bit rusty. I do a bit of my own hands-on stuff, but, I much prefer working with a professional organiser who’s got that skill.
TH: Yeah. Let people do the bit they’re best at. I mean, makes sense.
Are there any things that mental health professionals kind of almost absolutes that you should or shouldn’t do when working with hoarders?
JE: Yes. There certainly are. There’s so many.
TH: That was a sit down and get comfortable. Mhmm.
JE: Yeah. There’s so many I could think of.
There’s so many things I could mention that I’ve learned over the years, but I think the most important ones that come to mind, do visit the home. Like, this is a difficult one to achieve, but without kind of seeing the situation and the functional impairment the person’s experiencing, talk therapy will not be effective. You’ll be talking around and around in circles even if they admit that they’re hoarding. You’re not going to get the real picture.
TH: Can I just say, my therapist has not seen my home. But based on something you said a few months ago, I am building up to sending her a photo.
And that’s because of you.
JE: Yay!
TH: So check-in in another 6 months.
JE: Yes. That is a good way. If you, as a person who hoards, really can’t manage that, the step of taking space, the amount of information, I mean, pictures tells 1000 words.
I can see from that. I can get a sense of what’s happening just through experience by going, okay.
TH: Totally. Yeah.
JE: I go, okay. I see. Okay. That helps me.
TH: I totally get your logic for seeing people’s homes. It makes complete sense to me. But equally, I am so, like, no on it.
But this feels like a little chink. Like, okay. Maybe that’s a controlled thing I can do.
And then maybe I can do another and that feels… so, yeah, I fully agree with your logic. I just am so rigid on this.
JE: I know. And it is super hard and so many of my clients have said to me, I was petrified when you first came. I was absolutely petrified.
And now they’re opening their home to other support that can come in and help, and it’s like opening the door just a chink for me to come in meant that they kind of gained confidence to say, well this is how it is and I’m working towards changing that.
And now I have help. Now I have someone coming in and cleaning once a week. Now I have someone coming in and taking my son out who has special needs. Whatever that is. Yeah.
But it is really really hard and especially when you live alone, I think that’s just super difficult because it is your sanctuary. It’s your little safe space and having someone come into that that you don’t trust.
But building that trust is really, really hard and the photograph is an option. Yeah. But be patient.
TH: And I think of, like I saw for a while a dentist who was specialised in phobic patients. And the way that worked was my first appointment was literally me walking in and them going, hi. I’m such and such. And introducing me to people, and then I left.
And then the next appointment was sitting in the chair, still just having a little chat, but sitting in the chair.
And it was really that degree of… it’s months till you have to open your mouth. Like, we’re fine.
And I think the photo feels a bit like that.
JE: Yes. Yes. And we’ll talk a little bit about this later on, but it really is exposure therapy, you know? That’s exactly what it is.
So one of the things I really want to emphasise is that you’ll need to be patient and take things very slow.
So that’s an exact example of that. I’m going to come around and we’re going to stand outside and we’re going to talk. And then I’m going to come around and whatever. Or we’re going to be in our office and we’re going to talk about things and then so many sessions down the track you’re going to bring a photo in and we’re going to talk about the photo or whatever.
But building up that, exposing them gently and opening the window of tolerance gently is the way to go.
If they admit to hoarding, which some clients might not do for years into their treatment,
TH: Months, actually.
JE: We’re talking about anyone in particular.
TH: If we were, it would be months.
JE: If we were, it would be months.
But validate that and emphasise that it’s a brave move. Like, this is a huge move. Actually, just saying the words out aloud is huge.
And, my other do is just show empathy just to think about how it would feel if the only photograph of your great-grandmother was ripped up into tiny little pieces and thrown in the bin.
Now imagine that that person is feeling that about all of their stuff, and if you can feel that feeling, then you can understand that that’s the level of empathy that you need.
Observe them making decisions based on their values and take note of the thought processes that they go to.
And then you’ve got the evidence of the core processes that are holding them back.
But you need to show that empathy in order for them to feel like they’re in a safe space and expose that.
But the don’ts are classics. Don’t touch anything without permission. Put your hands behind your back. Ask permission if you wish to touch anything when you go into their home.
Don’t judge. Don’t show disgust. You’ve got it, you need that poker face.
TH: They will be looking at your face for a flicker. I know this.
JE: A flinch, they will notice. Yeah. If it’s a squalid environment, and definitely if there’s children or elderly living in the home and you’ve visited, you’ll need to alert the person that it’s unsafe and you’ll need to take ethical action regarding that.
And familiarise yourself with safety regs and don’t put yourself in danger if you’re going into the home.
Make sure you look after yourself because you can’t help someone if you have a respiratory illness and you go into the home and it’s unsafe.
But don’t assume either, like, don’t assume anything.
Ask questions. Be curious.
There’s often a reason behind the saving behaviour that you’ve never thought of. So asking them to explain why they’ve kept all those rusty nails and things. I’m just curious, why have you kept all the rusty nails? Oh, I dye fabric using the rusty nails.
TH: Yeah. Yeah.
JE: Okay! And you can also then uncover the underlying inflexibility that’s contributing and then you can work on that.
But never assume, always ask questions.
And particularly if it’s something you’ve never dealt with before and even if you’re only in the office, asking them questions about why and how they do things is super important.
And don’t expect them to toss large volumes of stuff without looking through it. They will want to look through every single item.
They will want to open every plastic bag. They will want to flip through every book.
Every pizza box, every because you know what? There are sometimes important, either valuable monetarily or valuable sentimentally amongst the stuff.
TH: There will be a passport in with the magazines, and there will be £100 in notes in a paper bag.
JE: Yep. Yep. There might be a bomb like I found.
TH: No. So, you know an actual bomb. Have I not heard this story before?
JE: I can’t believe you haven’t heard my bomb story. But, yeah, there was a bomb. The client called the bomb squad. And the next week when I went there, she said, oh, yes. The bomb squad came in. What? The bomb squad came in.
We had to exit the premises. They checked it out and it wasn’t live, but it was a World War 2
TH: Wow.
JE: Bomb in her wardrobe, which incidentally, her wardrobe had no clothes in it, just the bomb.
TH: Nobody keeps their clothes with their bombs, Jan (!)
JE: True. True. True. I get that now, and I’ve made sure that I don’t keep my clothes with my bombs.
There was always clothes on on the floor, but there was nothing in the wardrobes, which is really common because of the I want to keep things in sight. If I can’t see it, I don’t know it’s there.
And so the bomb was in there. And when we got to the wardrobes, opened the wardrobe cupboards, I’ve gone, oh, what’s that? Oh, yeah.
That’s my ex’s bomb.
TH: Wow.
JE: So you should check out whether it’s live. I think would be a good thing between sessions. Yeah. Just check out if it’s live. Thank god.
But, yeah, you can find all sorts of things amongst stuff.
But as you know, expecting them to really let go of large volumes of stuff is not going to happen, So be aware.
TH: And, also, I expect this is true of all therapy, but especially this kind of therapy. Progress one week doesn’t mean progress the next week.
JE: Mhmm. And being able to discuss that with the client, to say this is the whole mountain and the line looks like it’s straight up to the top of the mountain and then, when you zoom in on it, it’s up and down, up and down, you know. That’s what it is.
We cannot be 100% on target doing everything right all the time and that’s one of the things that with hoarding disorder, that perfectionism is so strong and so inflexible. I have to do exactly what Jan says or I have to do exactly what whoever says every time and if I don’t, I’m going to cancel the appointment because I failed.
There are going to be weeks where you do nothing. There are going to be weeks where I come around or your professional organiser or support worker comes round and just goes, wow, look at what you have done. That is absolutely awesome.
But that’s just therapy generally. That’s the way it is. It’s not a straight line up to the top.
TH: Does the mode of therapy make a difference? For instance, whether it’s CBT versus ACT versus person centred?
JE: You know, I think because hoarding is like the physical manifestation of your maladaptive kind of thoughts and behaviours, it really requires an eclectic approach. No traditional package kind of works.
I know there are self-help books that you can work through using bibliotherapy. You can sit down and do all those, and I think that can work.
But I have not really found that many individuals who are able to do that on their own. They need to be in a group therapy sort of situation, and even then, it’s so separated from what’s actually happening in their home that I’m not sure how well it supports the person just to be doing the activities chapter 1 through to 10 or whatever.
But recent developments in the therapy space are looking at evidence-based interventions that have shown in the research that they bring about change.
So you might have seen some new publications about what they’re calling process-based therapy.
Now this is just basically a way of considering the core processes that are implicated in the individuals that are suffering and targeting them with treatments that have worked consistently in research.
And this means we’re less worried about the name of the therapy, the type of therapy. We’re more interested in that core process of change that’s backed by evidence.
So it’s a bit of a twist for the therapy research area.
So when we go through the processes that are actually evidence based for hoarding, some of the central ones are values clarification. That is super effective.
Establish what the client feels is most important to them, not society, their parents who probably died 20 years ago, but to them. This is central to kind of bring about change and evidence is there that that’s a super important part of the process.
And I use that always.
Some of them have already done it, which is brilliant. You come around and they go, well, I’ve already I know I’ve been working on this and I know what my values are, and I’m like, sweet. Let’s talk about that in relation to your stuff. How can that work?
But the other thing the other sort of process that has evidence to support it is problem solving, which is super important in hoarding because clutter is physical and often this is where I start.
We consider the person’s values, what’s most important to them, discuss how they’d like to live in the space and in the world, and then we consider the space and problem solve how that might become a reality.
So sometimes it takes a bit of time once the client’s been working in an area for a certain length of time, they soon realise that it doesn’t really matter. It isn’t a matter of, like, not enough space or storage, it’s too much stuff.
And they come to that realisation on their own.
This has to be an organic process where they recognise, ah, okay. I often have the session, it might be a few sessions in and it’ll be, I’ve been thinking about this and, really, it’s just not going to work. I need to let go of these things. This is super hard but I know that I need to do that. How can I go about it?
And when they’ve opened up to that, then you can come in with some of those solutions.
TH: Yeah. It didn’t matter how many people told me I had too much stuff until I worked out that I had too much stuff.
JE: That’s right. And it is, it’s about working and looking at the problem and going, okay. Well, maybe if I move everything into that one room, it could work.
TH: It’s just a matter of shelves. If I can just master the shelving situation, everything will be fine.
JE: Yeah. And then you start and you work at it, then you realise that is not physically, you know the physics of that are not going to happen.
But it’s about that realisation of the client and that’s where you come in to help them with that.
But you can’t tell anybody. It’s not going to work.
But then working together to decide on how they’d like to pass on the possessions to those who need them, which might take a bit of googling but that process is another whole part to the person who hoards’ ethos about letting go of things.
You need to recognise that there is, they have a value, 9 times out of 10, I don’t want to be wasteful, this has to find a home that will be appreciative of it, etcetera. And that has to be part of the process. We need to remember that we need to, as clinicians, help them problem solve that part as well.
Because we can help them say, yes, I wanted to get rid of it and then where to?
TH: Can I tell a little story about something I held onto for years because I loved how it looked? I loved how it looked. It was me all over in terms of the design.
It was a tablecloth, and it was gorgeous. And I’ve had it for years, but I do not use tablecloths.
And I finally, a few months ago, thought it’s time to let this tablecloth go. And it was really hard because it’s perfect, but I sold it on Ebay.
And yesterday, the woman who bought it sent me a photo of it with her wedding cake on at her wedding.
JE: Oh my god.
TH: I know. There is no more perfect way of reassuring me that it found its perfect home than a woman who would put it not just at her wedding, but with the cake on.
JE: That’s so gorgeous.
TH: That filled me with it needed to be there, not here, just perfect.
JE: And that is something that that core memory is really important moving forward because then you’ll be thinking, I wonder which gorgeous little girl might want my sticker collection or whatever it might be and thinking that you did find the perfect person for that tablecloth, there is someone else out there that will cherish and love this object or this these things, but also respecting that that may not always happen.
TH: Yes. Of course.
JE: But if it does happen, it’s like it’s kismet. It’s just beautiful. It’s just the most heartwarming story and I’m so glad you told me that. I’m feeling a bit teary. It’s, like, so gorgeous.
TH: I know. Yeah. I listed it for quite a high price, I think, hoping that nobody would buy it.
JE: Yes. That’s great. That’s good.
TH: But I’m equally, because I’m donating stuff, I’m selling bits and pieces, the more I do that, which I have been doing fairly consistently, there’s just an awful lot of it to go. The more I do it, the less invested I feel in what happens to it once it leaves me.
I feel a lot better at dropping a bag off at a charity shop going, hopefully, they sell most of it. Hopefully, whoever buys it wears it, and not feeling too invested in that. But then the odd moment like this tablecloth is just yeah.
JE: Oh, that’s just such a beautiful story. I just love that story. It’s gorgeous. Absolutely gorgeous. And I just take my hat off to that wonderful person who sent you the photo.
TH: Yes. How nice!
JE: I know. That is just heaven. That is just the most perfect dispossession story I’ve heard.
But, the other thing about it is that it’s really about that exposure. It’s about doing that.
TH: 100%. Yeah.
JE: Doing it and doing it and doing it and just seeing how you feel and being curious about how you feel.
Because exposure is another therapy technique that’s evidence based, you want to work with the client to establish a hierarchy of feared situations and that might be with this that if I let this go, this is me, although this says everything about me, but it’s kind of impractical, isn’t it, to be one of those 10 things that tell your story. Right? It’s kind of, well, it’s I don’t have a table. I don’t use it. I’m not going to yeah.
So exposure to that feared situation of letting it go and it being tossed in the garbage or whatever, well, now we have the experience to add that the fear I had didn’t actually happen that way. This great thing happened and this other person has got the joy and wonder out of this wonderful, gorgeous, probably handmade, hand stitched, one of a kind and that’s just beautiful.
But really, exposure is what we need and that’s what you’re doing as you’re slowly, slowly considering items, either putting them on eBay or passing them on to charity stores, every time you do that it gets less difficult each time.
And that’s just how it works.
The other thing I think that works well with hoarding is acceptance and diffusion. They’re adaptive emotion regulation strategies and that can kind of improve your flexibility and reduce hoarding symptoms.
So being able to detach from those thoughts and feelings and not getting caught by them, which we’ve talked about before, that is super effective as you’re going through the process of deciding, saying these things, thought listing, saying all this stuff aloud to the ether, no one has to be there, you don’t have to be talking to anyone in particular, but you can actually then get a bit of a distance from the thoughts and go, is that really true? I think we talked about this before where we go, oh, I couldn’t handle letting that go.
And then we say, really? Yep. Yes. Really? Oh, I do it all the time. I do it all the time. And I’ve got all my clients doing it. Really? You know what? Yeah. It’s really not true.
TH: Yeah. Don’t stop at your first answer. If you go, could I handle letting this go? No. Nah. Don’t stop there.
JE: Just really? Yeah. You know what?
You know what? That’s what I always think. I always say really, and then I go, you know what? That’s rubbish. You know what? I can. I can do that.
The other one is behavioural activation, which is something we talked about, but we probably didn’t call it that. Right? This is the tiny habit process that we did the podcast on.
So really it’s taking those tiny steps on the reg to get you doing that activity that you value in tiny little steps.
And that’s super good for depression, and hoarding in particular, and then we can add more to the habit either by doing it more often or for longer periods, record activities between sessions with our therapist, but behavioural activation in the form of tiny habits is super, super effective.
The more controversial one for hoarding is called cognitive reappraisal, which definitely works in some cases where we reinterpret the meaning of the stimulus so that we can alter our emotional response.
So we modify unhelpful thoughts that bring us emotional distress.
I have found that this traditional CBT restructuring isn’t as effective, we talked about this as well. It’s not as effective as cognitive diffusion in hoarding, and I think that making that making that creating that distance between stimulus and response and looking at the thought, recognising that it’s not a rule, it’s not something we need to agree with, we can accept it but take action where we want to go with our values. That, I think, is one of the core processes for hoarding, it’s a muscle we need to practise and it can open us up, and increase our flexibility our cognitive and emotional flexibility.
So that’s really important.
But all those things, they come from all sorts of different types of therapy and it’s about finding working out what the core processes are that the person needs to work on, looking at how they function, and then targeting those as you go with various different types of techniques.
TH: And so, like, whereas I, as the hoarder or the client, if I face a situation, I have quite a clear kind of visual image of a toolbox. And I go, this is the challenge I’m currently facing, and I kind of rummage around the toolbox and go, which is the bit that would be helpful for this?
And I guest therapists are doing exactly that as well.
JE: Exactly. I don’t do it every with every client, but I quite often will create a kind of a map of how all the various parts of this individual, all the various parts of their functioning, how they interrelate and where there’s good things feeding back which are creating positive cycles and then things where there’s negatives.
And then it can give you a kind of visual map of what’s going on.
And as you work on those things, you can then reassess it and create a new model and go, well, these things are really… that’s escalating and helping with all these other things.
But sometimes it can be just one little thing, often it’s not.
TH: If there’s one thing a therapist can do today to improve the way they work with a hoarding client, either one they have now or a potential future client, what would that be?
JE: Listen to as many episodes of this podcast as you can. Take notes. Research hoarding. Read all you can get your hands on.
And as I said earlier, look to your peak body for support, post questions on the forums and get feedback from your peers if there’s something you’re not sure on.
Talk to your supervisor. Sign up to my free weekly newsletters.
Make a time to talk to a hoarding specialist for a consult if you need to, if you’re stuck.
If you’re going quite well and you just want to reflect with someone who works in the same sort of space, just find that person. Why not create your own little peer support group of people who are new to this area? Be the change you want in the world and create your own little peer support group of clinicians who are working, who are new to hoarding and who want to talk.
And then ring me up and invite me along and I’ll come and chat. But that sort of thing would be really good.
TH: Yeah. This whole podcast came about, at least in part, because I wanted there to be a podcast by somebody who hoard rather than a professional. And look at us now!
JE: Yeah. Exactly. And that’s the thing. The resource of this, of hearing your voice as a person with hoarding disorder makes such a difference to the lives of people. I’m just so proud of what you’ve done because I just think that that’s what people needed.
They needed to hear from someone who was experiencing what they were in a voice that they could hear without feeling shame, without a sense of feeling less than, and that just makes all the difference.
And all the people that come and listen to the podcast, they’re hearing your voice. You’ve got guests coming in, giving their kind of expertise, but that’s not really what’s most precious about it.
I think it’s the fact that you’re a person who is experiencing this and you’re just expressing it so beautifully, so that others can kind of feel accepted and validated. And I think that’s absolutely beautiful.
TH: Thank you.
JE: Oh, you’re so welcome.
It’s a pleasure.
TH: And on a more practical level, every episode has an accompanying blog post on the website, where any studies we mention, any books, any articles, any anything is all linked to.
And so you can find all of that at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk. When you buy a website with a really long name, not expecting to say it out loud for the rest of your life.
JE: That’s too funny. I was also going to just slip in there and say that if you prefer to read, there’s always a transcript. Which is really great if you’ve if you’ve listened to the pod and you kinda go, what was that that hoarder said about that? I want to go back, and then you can look at the look at the transcript. I think that’s important to remember, that it’s there for you to refer to.
TH: Yeah. Absolutely. Yep. Oh, little love-in.
So, Jan, this is a shocker of a question that you’ve never had before. If people want to find you online, where can they do so?
JE: Oh, gosh. Now I have to think really hard. So, if you want to catch up with me on Instagram, Pinterest, or x, I am @stuff_ology. Facebook at Stuffology Consulting, you could pop me a email, jan@stuffology.com.au. Come on over to the website, stuffology.com.au. Sign up to the newsletter. It’s free every week.
TH: And it is full of honestly incredible insight. Like, really, really, really good.
JE: I try. I try. I try to bring new things, new ideas, and I’m going to sort of move into a few different areas this year. So hopefully, you’ll get some insight into some other sorts of things that might assist you. And I’d love to hear from you. Always read all the emails, reply wherever I can. So drop me a line.
TH: Would that be at jan@stuffology.com.au by any chance?
JE: Correct.
TH: Thanks ever so much.
JE: Thanks for having me. And remember, it’s just stuff.
May we take a moment to reflect on the meaning of place and acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land on which we record and listen to this podcast today? I’m speaking on the lands of the Boon Wurrung people of the Kulin nation and I acknowledge their connection to country, both land and sea, and culture. We pay our respects to their elders past and present and extend that respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples listening today.
TH: Do you have any burning questions you’d love me to answer? My first Q&A episode was really popular, and so I’m open now to more questions. Contact me on Twitter, Facebook, TikTok, Reddit, YouTube, or plain old email.
All the links are on my website at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk.
Ask me anything, and I’ll do my best to answer.
So my top tip this week is from a BBC podcast called Seriously, which I will link to in the show notes at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk.
And guest Professor Ian Robertson is talking about how to build up your confidence to take action.
Have a listen:
The way confidence works is you believe you can do something that maybe slightly stretches you. It’s not certain you can do it, but you say, I can do that.
Your brain registers that as a future success.
That increases the reward network activation, gives you a little boost of dopamine and that’s a natural antidepressant and a natural anti-anxiety drug.
So immediately your brain’s better prepared to actually do the thing.
It also increases motivation and makes you a tiny bit smarter because of the increased dopamine activity in the frontal lobes.
All of that is contrasted with apathy, where your mood tends to be lower, your anxiety tends to be higher and there’s this feeling of inertia.
Yeah. It’s like if you want something done, ask a busy person type idea.
There’s so much truth in that because confidence works like a geometric progression, like compound interest.
Small successes make it increasingly likely you will get future successes and that builds up on each other, exactly like compound interest in the bank and you end up with quite small events leading to quite big achievements in the long term.
TH: And it makes sense, doesn’t it? A little success leads you to be confident to try the next thing, which might be a bigger success, which improves your confidence to try the next thing.
Worth a try.
Okay. Thank you for listening, and I will speak to you next time.
Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. You can find me online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk. You can find me on Twitter @thathoarder and on Facebook at That Hoarder: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast.
To find out more about how you can support the podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support, and do subscribe to the podcast to make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.
There may be links in this podcast that earn me money. This doesn’t come at any extra cost to you if you ever make a purchase through the links, and it helps to support the future of the podcast.
Audio credits
- Intro and outro music: cheesepuff
- Transition whoosh: Vilkas_Sound
- Piano Playing Classical Music: IESP
- Hallelujah chorus: deleted_user_2906614
- Uh oh: stib
- Angels: pycckuu20032003
- Phone: HarryPeeks and Aesterial-Arts
- Yay!: Reitanna
- Seriously? rydra_wong
- Retro power up MaoDin204
- Fanfare: humanoide9000
- Explosion: Iwiploppenisse
- What? What? What? max_cristos
- Why? Why? Why? Why? Reitanna
- Celebration: Gabriela_Melo
- Not again: xtrgamr
- Atmosphere 17: DaveJf
- Wah wah: SpliceSound
- Giggles: kim.headlee
- Help me: brandonreese
- Please don’t flush: PMBROWNE
- Horror laugh: klankbeeld
- Oohs and aahs: noah0189
- Applause: Sandermotions
- Heartbeat: Tobias Ludwig
- Countdown – female : Tim Kahn
- Game Over – evil: Rocotilos
- Countdown – male: jppi_sstu
- Oh yeah: metrostock99
- Amen: klankbeeld
- Cuban happy music: szegvari
- Suspense: Warped_Tension
- Ding dong: MatthewWong
- Former intro and outro music: grapelemon
