Show notes
In this episode, Dr. Jan Eppingstall and I are exploring the impact of self-stigma and societal responsibility in hoarding. We look in depth at stigma and how it affects individuals with mental health conditions, especially hoarding disorder, and how self-stigma can damage us and prevent us from seeking help. Plus, we introduce a new segment — “permission slip”. Stay tuned for some outtakes at the end!
- Impact of Public Stigma and Self-Stigma
- Dr. Jan Eppingstall explains public stigma, including stereotypes, prejudice, and discrimination
- Key facets of public stigma: difference, disdain, and blame
- Understanding Self-Stigma and Public Stigma
- How stereotypes can affect self-stigma, using people’s reactions to TV shows as an example
- The implications of self-stigma, including low self-esteem, hopelessness, and reluctance to seek treatment
- The interlinking of public stigma, self-stigma, shame, and self-consciousness, as well as self-blame and the impact of self-stigma on seeking help
- Variation in mental illness stereotypes by disorder
- Introduction of the “permission slip” segment
- Discussion on the compulsion to keep things and the completionist mindset
- Influence of Socioeconomic Status on Mental Illness Stigma
- Conversation about the perception of hoarding based on socioeconomic status and the value of items being kept
- Comparison of hoarding in different contexts: ample space and financial means versus living in a cramped environment
- Impact of space and wealth on hoarding, highlighted through a documentary about Celine Dion and her extensive costume collection
- Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) in Addressing Self-Stigma
- Dr. Eppingstall outlines the ACT approach, focusing on personal values and psychoeducation on relational frame theory to address self-stigma
- Cognitive behavioural therapy techniques like reframing and peer support groups to combat self-stigma, as well as radical acceptance through a 10-step process
- Influence of Cultural Beliefs and Social Factors on Stigma
- Discussion of the influence of cultural beliefs on mental illness stigma, including the impact of social factors on self-stigmatisation
- Protective factors against self-stigmatisation: quality of life, social relationships, and cultural acceptance of mental illness
- The impact of societal influences on self-stigma and the importance of understanding one’s thought patterns without trying to banish them
- External stigma’s potential influence on self-stigma, with a suggestion that marginalised individuals facing more external stigma might be more susceptible to self-stigmatisation
- Internalised social stigma leads to negative self-concept.
- Self-stigma affects help-seeking behaviours negatively.
- Questioning stigmatisation and hoarding in media.
- Cultural stigma influences self-stigmatisation of mental illness.
- Communities’ response to mental illness.
- Self-stigma’s impact varies based on individual factors.
- Internalised stigma is the acceptance of negative societal stereotypes.
- Self-stigma creates harm, deters seeking help.
- Reflection on hoarding stigma and societal perceptions.
- Public stigma in different cultures affects self-stigmatisation and attitudes toward mental illness and treatment.
- Reflecting on community’s approach to mental illness and its impact on self-stigma.
- Practicing radical acceptance, using self-acceptance talk and behaviour changes to move forward.
- Self-stigma affects people differently based on various factors such as personality, upbringing, and society. Different societies can influence how people perceive and react to self-stigma.
Links
- Podcast ep 145: Understanding stigma and hoarding using Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and compassion, with Dr Jennifer Krafft
- Podcast ep 146: Where Dragons Live and what we leave behind
- Podcast ep 95: Shame and hoarding with Professor Luna Dolezal
- Podcast ep 119: Homelessness and hoarding with Dr Jan Eppingstall of Stuffology
- Podcast ep 66: Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and hoarding – a deep dive with Dr Jan Eppingstall of Stuffology
- Help Hole podcast
- A conceptual and empirical review of acceptance and commitment therapy for hoarding by Jennifer Krafft, Ph.D. and Clarissa W. Ong, Ph.D.
- Who Deserves To “Choose Joy”?: The Role of Socioeconomic Status, Mental Health, And Neoliberal Consumption in Defining Who Is And Is Not A Hoarder by Afifa Bhatti
- Understanding stigma in hoarding disorder: A systematic review by Rachel M. Prosser, James P. Dennis, and Paul M. Salkovskis
- Buried in stigma: Experimental investigation of the impact of hoarding depictions in reality television on public perception by Sage Bates, Andrew J. De Leonardis, Patrick W. Corrigan, and Gregory S. Chasson
- Do they really care? Specificity of social support issues in hoarding disorder and obsessive– compulsive disorder by Victoria Edwards, Paul M. Salkovskis and Victoria Bream
- Testing an Acceptance and Commitment Therapy Website for Hoarding: A Randomized Waitlist- Controlled Trial by Jennifer Krafft
- Factors Influencing Community Responses To Hoarding: Evaluating Operational Culture Of Hoarding Task Forces, Stigma, And Successful Outcomes by Leslie Gail
- Meaning in hoarding: perspectives of people who hoard on clutter, culture, and agency by David M.R. Orrz, Michael Preston-Shoot and Suzy Braye
- “Making It Easier to Live, You Know?” A Qualitative Study of the Impact of Hoarding Behaviours and Social Networks on Older People’s Supported Housing Decisions by Claire Murphy-Morgan, Philip Hodgson, Thomas V. Pollet, and Nick Neave
- Come to a Dehoarding Accountability Zoom session: Accountability Booking Form
- Dr Jan Eppingstall at Stuffology
- https://www.facebook.com/stuffologyconsulting/
- https://twitter.com/stuff_ology
- https://www.instagram.com/stuff_ology/
- Dr Jan Eppingstall on Pinterest
- Website: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding
- Become a Dehoarding Darling
- Submit a topic for the podcast to cover
- Questions to ask when dehoarding: https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/podquestions
- Instagram: @thathoarderpodcast
- Twitter: @ThatHoarder
- Mastodon: @ThatHoarder@mastodon.online
- TikTok: @thathoarderoch https://www.tiktok.com/@thathoarderoch
- Facebook: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Pinterest: That Hoarder
- YouTube: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Reddit: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder subreddit
- Help out: Support this project
- Sponsor the podcast
Subscribe to the podcast
Transcript
That Hoarder:
You are listening to That Hoarder: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding.
I don’t talk in real life about having hoarding disorder, so I talk about it on this podcast instead.
And because I’m anonymous, I can talk really, really honestly.
Subscribe to the podcast and find my social media links, episode transcripts, and every link that I mention at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk.
Finally, I am not a doctor. I’m just a hoarder doing her best. So do seek professional support if and when you need it.
So I am here with Dr Jan Eppingstall, a counsellor in Melbourne, Australia, who I can’t legally say is the world’s leading hoarding expert, but she does a pretty good job.
Dr Jan Eppingstall:
Please. No one no one tell Randy Frost, there’ll be issues.
TH:
Jan, how are you?
JE:
I’m great. Thank you. I’m very well.
TH:
Can you tell I didn’t plan that intro?
JE:
No.
TH:
So we are starting today with a new occasional segment called permission slip.
Do you need a permission slip?
TH:
In which I tell Jan about an item I am inexplicably having trouble getting rid of, and Jan gives me permission to get rid of it.
Or she doesn’t. She says no, you should definitely keep that.
And while we’re doing this, you think about if there’s anything along those lines that you feel like you need permission with.
So, Jan, let me show you this, and I will describe it for listeners. It is a piece of black plastic, long thin black plastic.
And when I got my printer last year, which sits on top of the previous broken printer.
JE:
So it’s a stand. It’s okay. Yeah. Yeah. It’s purposeful. Yep.
TH:
Yep. The printer had this in the packet.
JE:
Right.
TH:
And I have never been able to work out where in the printer it’s meant to go. I’ve tried a few places, and it just seems to get in the way.
So I have used this printer for the best part of a year without ever involving this piece of black plastic.
And yet, I feel a compulsion to keep it just in case the use for it suddenly becomes clear.
JE:
The completion. Wanting to keep everything complete and being obsessed with making sure that all those things are together, even though chances are it will break and you’ll still have that black plastic item that will never ever be used.
You have my permission. You have my permission to let go of that.
TH:
Thank you.
JE:
You haven’t needed it.
TH:
I don’t even know why I would need it. Thank you.
JE:
You’re welcome.
TH:
And if you are listening and you have something in mind, I give you permission to get rid of it, Jan?
JE:
Yeah. I give you permission. Just go for it.
TH:
So today, Jan and I are talking about self-stigma.
When I did the interview with Jennifer Krafft about stigma, I also kept coming across references to self-stigma. So I wanted to look at that in more detail.
Jan, what is self-stigma, and how does it differ from the stigma we might be more used to hearing about?
JE:
Okay. So the type of stigma that we usually are talking about is public stigma.
So this relates to society’s negative reactions towards particular subgroups.
Now, before we kind of talk about self-stigma, I like to go down a little bit of a small rabbit hole
TH:
Love it.
JE:
Regarding public stigma, because I feel it informs our understanding of self-stigma.
TH:
Yeah.
JE:
But public stigma is made up of 3 elements.
Stereotypes, which are shared beliefs about groups generalising the characteristics of the members and not looking at the differences between individuals.
So for example, the mentally ill are dangerous and incompetent is a stereotype.
The second element is prejudice, where which is negative emotional valuations about that subgroup.
And for mental illness, that’s often fear, anger, pity, those types of emotions.
And then discrimination, which is negative group based behaviour against a group like withdrawing help, not hiring a person because they have a mental illness, rejecting them as potential partners, or social distancing from them when you’re in the street walking around them, that kind of thing.
I mean, there’s many, many types of discrimination, but those are kind of some of the things.
So unsurprisingly, mental illness is more stigmatised than physical disabilities because we often need to see physical proof of someone’s capacity.
And when we look at the content of mental illness stereotypes, they correlate with specific emotional and behavioural action tendencies, and they distil down to these two fundamental dimensions of society’s perceptions of the groups.
So there’s these 2 emotional elements, which are warmth and competence.
So warmth, low warmth, high warmth relates to the intention of the stigmatised group member.
And competence relates to whether they’re considered low competent or incompetent or they are highly competent or high status.
So I guess the perceived worth, contributions and capacity of the group.
So what’s interesting is that there’s 4 types of these combinations of warmth and competency.
So high warmth, low competency, people like older people or people with a disability, and they elicit feelings of pity and sympathy from us.
Then there’s low warmth, high competence, which are rich people, and feminists, funnily enough, in the research. That popped up. And we feel envy and jealousy for their status. I’m not quite sure. Maybe they should have said rich white men instead of just rich people.
I don’t know, but that idea that they’re cold hearted, but they’re competent.
Then high warmth, high competence. This is like our in group. So this is whoever we relate to, the middle class, usually, the Joneses – we feel admiration and pride because we relate to them.
But finally, we have the low warmth, low competence. And this is where people who are homeless, people with mental illnesses, which often are part of the same group, they actually provoke disgust and anger.
TH:
And a lot of those combinations high warmth and low competence can mean that somebody is treated nicely, but it’s incredibly patronising.
JE:
Patronising. Exactly.
TH:
And underestimated. And so few of those combinations are great in terms of how people are perceived, basically.
JE:
Exactly. Exactly. I mean, the whole high warmth, high competence that’s your Joe Blow, whoever lives next door to you or whatever, you tend to see those people because you know them, and you’ve actually had interactions with them.
TH:
Yeah. And that’s why somebody who’s racist in general might say to someone, “oh, not like you” to a black friend. You know, you’re different.
JE:
You’re alright. I mean, it’s the others that I don’t like. Exactly. Exactly.
And a more recent conceptualisation suggests that there’s a couple of things that are included in the public stigma, which is difference. They aren’t like me, which we’re just talking about.
Disdain, they’re bad. And blame, they’re the ones with blame. These are key facets of public stigma too.
TH:
I found the disdain, blame, and what’s the other one?
JE: Difference.
TH:
Difference. Fascinating.
JE:
Me too.
TH:
When I was researching this episode, it really helped me to put my finger on where prejudice can lie, I think.
JE:
Exactly. I mean, interestingly, within mental illness, stereotypes vary by disorder.
TH:
Of course. Yeah.
JE:
So for example, schizophrenia and DID, dissociative identity disorder, or addictions are seen as especially low warmth And low competence, and therefore, especially disgusting. You know?
I mean, hoarding stereotypes or what? Lazy, crazy, and filthy. I don’t know. I’m not sure. I mean, there’s not a great deal of research at this point, but that is where public stigma sits.
So self-stigma or internalised stigma is us taking that negative stereotypes from a society, the society that is widely endorsed, that refers to our group, and applying it to ourselves.
So it becomes our self-talk and our self-concept.
It’s really about having those thoughts, taking on those ideas that our culture often layers over us, the stereotypes that we believe that are true.
TH:
Yeah. And there’s a lot of interlinking between public stigma, self-stigma, shame, all of this stuff is very tied together.
What would you say are the differences, if any, between self-stigma versus self-consciousness, versus self-blame, that kind of thing? How do they interact?
JE:
Yeah. So self-consciousness is being aware of yourself and your appearance or actions.
So everyone’s looking at me and judging, which I’m putting up my hand because I’m always worried about what other people are thinking, and they’re always worried about what other people are thinking. So no one’s worried about…
TH:
What you look like in the supermarket. Yeah.
JE:
Self-blame or self-censure is when we attribute the occurrences of something traumatic or stressful. We attribute that to ourselves. I caused that. It’s my fault.
And self-stigma, as we said, is the acceptance of negative attitudes of society. We need to accept them first, recognise that they’re there, accept them, and then apply those to ourselves.
I’m worthless, disgusting, hopeless, because that’s the kind of stereotype of my label.
Whatever I feel I’ve been labelled with, that’s how I’m viewed by everybody that I meet.
TH:
And self-stigma, the problem with it isn’t just that it makes you feel bad.
'The impact of public stigma, it separates you from your community. You're less likely to reach out. Isolation then reduces your self-esteem and trust of others. It's a self-fulfilling prophecy, really' - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on XThere was a study by Rachel M Prosser and colleagues who summarised that for self-stigma to occur, there must be awareness of stigmatising beliefs, agreement with these, and application to oneself.
'Self-stigma may lead to harm through low self-esteem, hopelessness, and discriminating behaviours against themselves' - @RachelMProsser Share on X“This may then lead to harm through low self-esteem, hopelessness, and discriminating behaviours against themselves.”
And it also, and I speak from experience, does prevent people from seeking help.
And Leslie Gail wrote a PhD dissertation that says,
“The field of community psychology views stigma and self-stigma as social constructs that can undermine intentions of treatment.”
And then another study by Claire Murphy-Morgan and colleagues says self-stigma is
“associated with reduced willingness to engage with treatment, difficulties trusting others without feeling judged with negative impact on help-seeking behaviours.”
So all of that is to say that this isn’t just about it makes you feel sad.
JE:
No. No. I mean, the biggest one is that unwillingness to reach out for support because rejection’s anticipated.
And if we believe the stereotypes, then, of course, we’ll expect rejection because it makes sense. People think hoarders are lazy, crazy, and filthy. I’m a hoarder. I’m all of those things.
Ergo, I will be rejected. So why try? I’m not worth help.
All of those sorts of…
TH:
I will be rejected, and rightly so.
JE:
Yeah. And rightly so, because look at me, they’d be right to do that.
And not being able to trust anyone to help because of the fear of judgment and misunderstanding of our needs and wants.
So even if we do engage in treatment, we’re so overwhelmed and hypervigilant that we can’t receive the full benefits because our nervous systems either shut down completely or on a high alert.
TH:
Backing up what you just said, there was a paper by Victoria Edwards and colleagues about how stigma can be a factor in the reduced social support that people who hoard can experience.
We’ve talked a lot before about a lot of people who hoard are very isolated and lonely. And the PhD by Gail said “people living with mental illness may learn to anticipate the rejection of others”, which is exactly what you just said. It just all causes a whole mess of problems, doesn’t it?
JE:
Yeah. Yeah. And it does mean keeping secrets, isolating yourself and therefore loneliness, because, heck, if I’m judging myself this way, imagine how someone else will judge me.
And it really does lead people to just basically their lives start to shrink.
And that’s what I see working with clients is that things just start to… the anxiety of these various things keeping secrets, it just shrinks their lives.
And they wake up one day and find their living space is just one small area.
TH:
One chair, one sofa. That’s it.
JE:
Yeah. One chair. Exactly. Exactly.
'It’s not necessarily about stopping those thoughts as much as recognising that the thought is just a thought' - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on XTH:
I’ve been thinking a lot and reading a lot about who is stigmatised and who isn’t. On a recent episode, I reviewed a film called Where Dragons Live, which is about some adult children dealing with their parents’ home after they died.
And even though the film wasn’t about hoarding, there were a lot of themes in it that spoke to me about hoarding.
But there was something I said in the episode along the lines of the parents weren’t hoarders. They just had an awful lot of stuff, but they had a huge house with lots of nooks and crannies to keep it in.
And I’ve questioned myself about that statement since I made it. Like, would I have said they weren’t hoarders if they weren’t incredibly well off, for instance?
And when I spoke to Luna Dolezal in the episode about shame, we spoke about how people may be more susceptible to struggling with shame if they’re already marginalised and shamed for other aspects of their identity on top of hoarding or a similarly stigmatised problem.
Then I read a paper by Afifa Bhatti about the judgments people make about hoarders depending on how they’re portrayed in TV shows, which is fascinating. And how the judgments and the portrayals depended on their socioeconomic status, so how well off they were, essentially.
So here comes the question – eventually. If some people are more stigmatised by others than other people are, might this impact how much we self-stigmatise as well?
So if somebody is subject to a lot of external stigma, might they be more susceptible to self-stigma?
I’ve got a favour to ask that could make a big difference.
If you’ve been enjoying the podcast and want to support it, here are some ways you could do it.
Consider making a donation. Every pound helps me keep the podcast running.
Alternatively, show some love by leaving a review. Your words really mean a lot to me, and they help others to discover the podcast.
And do spread the word. Share the episodes with anyone who might benefit from listening.
Whether it’s a donation, a review, or just sharing, your support keeps me going. Find out more at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support.
JE:
I think it would definitely be a factor that would increase the likelihood of them self-stigmatising.
I mean, the impact of public stigma, it separates you from your community. You’re less likely to reach out.
Isolation then reduces your self-esteem and trust of others. It’s a self-fulfilling prophecy, really.
But I think that conversation about socioeconomic status and hoarding and how that’s perceived I mean, if the stuff’s “good”, in inverted commas, if it’s designer clothing, antiques, art, and therefore valuable in a monetary sense, the person has room to store it, manage it and stuff, then they can employ people. Is that still hoarding?
I’ve grappled with that a lot, and I say yes if they have the cognitions and behaviours that meet the criteria, but it’s the issue of distress and impediment to doing the everyday stuff that makes it a disorder.
So if they have more room and storage, it’s not impacting them or others physically, is it?
TH:
Yeah. Whereas if they were exactly the same person keeping exactly the same things, but living in a 1 bedroom flat. How is that… it’s fascinating, isn’t it? How is that different?
I watched the, Celine Dion documentary about her illness on Amazon Prime. It’s very interesting and very it’s pretty heartbreaking.
I’ve never especially been a Celine Dion fan, but you can’t ignore her impact on music over the last 20 years.
And she’s now in this place where singing is incredibly hard and unpredictable. And what I got from it was that she kind of doesn’t know who she is when she can’t sing.
But there’s a scene where she’s in this giant warehouse that just contains all of her costumes from her various… you know, she’s been she’s been in the industry a long time.
And she’ll go to a particular dress, and she can tell you exactly how they came up with the design and exactly what it felt like to be fitted, and exactly why this was like that and why this was like that.
But she has the means to store these things, and she holds the same kind of memories and associations that a person who hoards might as well.
Like, pick something up and go, I wore this when this and it felt tight on my waist. And so I had to… you know, it was it was fascinating, but she’s incredibly rich and has a warehouse to store them in that’s temperature controlled and all of that.
JE:
Humidity controlled. Exactly. Exactly.
I saw a doco about an actor. Can’t think who she was. She was in all the tabloids because she descended into hoarding and clutter, according to their kind of judgments. She had these mountains and mountains of clothes kind of piled high in disorganised piles, and they had photos of it in one of those trashy mags.
But I had the sense that depression and maybe addiction had impacted her ability to manage her whole life, and maybe when she was earning money, it wasn’t a problem. But when the jobs stopped coming, she was anxious and going, well all of this stuff’s worth money, maybe.
And it it’s just levelling, isn’t it? It’s just levelling.
Everybody has the same kind of… It’s just degrees and extent.
TH:
I think this thinking around, are you a hoarder if you have enough space? Yeah. Are you a hoarder if your stuff is objectively valuable? Is a fascinating one. Yeah.
It’s usually Jan that commissions someone to do a PhD, but this week, I’m going to commission someone to do a PhD on that.
JE:
Yes. Yes. I do usually send people off to just sort to sort out those questions that we’ve got. But, yes, I think that’d be very, very interesting.
Because you’ve got people like Andy Warhol, he was the scoop and dump king. He would just scoop and dump everything off his desk, including chewed chewing gum and whatever, pop it into a box, archive it, and you can go and view his Scoop and Dump boxes.
TH:
It’s interesting that because he’s important, people… I wouldn’t say encourage it, but want to see that and see value in that. Whereas if you’re a nurse and a single mum, I don’t think people think that’s valuable.
And I do think where that line is fascinating.
JE:
Yes. And it’s very blurry, I think, in some cases. Infamous or famous, I don’t know.
TH:
Yeah. So, I grew up Catholic, and Catholic guilt is not a myth.
JE:
No. No. No.
TH:
I think because of growing up Catholic, I’m especially susceptible to an instant understanding of anything and everything being my fault and being something wrong at my very core.
In Catholicism, that’s not done by halves. Like, it goes deep into who you are. And that is really instilled from birth.
And obviously, there’s all kinds of things that influence that. Societal, all that kind of stuff.
So what other social factors impact how much we self-stigmatise, would you say?
JE:
I think, there’s definitely evidence to suggest that the level of public or group stigma in a particular culture really influences self-stigmatisation.
Mental illness in Japan is stigmatised way more than in Australia.
And some religions have very strong relate beliefs about what the source of mental illness is. And some believe it’s lack of grit or weakness or even demonic possession. There’s all these kinds of ideas that come into play.
But risk factors for self-stigma include the severity of the behaviours, how stigmatised the disorder is in the culture, the attitudes and belief of the culture and the actual individual around psychological treatment, which is one that I feel is really important to know because some countries, some cultures, receiving treatment is acceptable. In others, it’s not.
But also in some subgroups within cultures, it’s acceptable. In others, it’s not.
TH:
Yes. I think middle class white women can go to therapy, and that’s a self-enriching thing to do.
And I think a poor Asian woman, it’s indulgent or it’s weird.
JE:
Yeah. Why can’t you just sort it out yourself kind of thing.
How aware the person is of the stereotypes in their culture as well, whether they’ve actually been exposed to those.
And then actually having experienced prejudice and discrimination in the past.
All of those things are going to impact how much we self-stigmatise, but there are some protective factors. And this is interesting because this ties into what we were saying before.
One of those is the quality of your life, which indicates that socioeconomic status is key, because that quality of life measure that they use includes material and physical well-being, relationships, social community and civic participation, personal development and fulfilment and recreation, all the things, if you have no money or connections or other factors, you can’t engage in that.
So that’s not a protective factor that will assist you.
Social relationships that you have can protect, a level of social functioning. Again neurotypical versus neurodiverse that that there’s a whole layer there.
And, again, how accepting your culture is of your particular mental illness. Because I know that there’s been some research around particular cultures having more somatic / psychosomatic sort of disorders.
TH:
So you feel it in your body. Yes.
JE:
Yeah. Rather than more cognitive things. So I think there’s some something to be said about that, but the risk factors, and the protective factors do seem to tip to the side of those who are who are socioeconomically advantaged.
TH:
And as you were talking about the way communities view mental illness, I thought of a story, and it will involve me being that awful, ignorant white person saying “somewhere in Africa”. Because it’s a long time since I heard the story, so I can’t remember where.
But talking about a particular area where if somebody is struggling with mental illness, the community comes together and says, where did we go wrong? What are we doing wrong as a community that has enabled this person to get this unwell?
And so I feel like we try, I try on the podcast and in conversations with you before, at least to some degree, to look structurally at things as well as individually.
Like, especially when we talked about homelessness, for instance. That there’s individual responsibilities, but there has to be a structural look at things too.
And so as you were talking, I was also thinking that if community looks in that kind of, Where are we all going wrong, as a community, that this has happened to this person, that I imagine could reduce self-stigma significantly.
JE:
I think so. I think so. Because then you’re understanding being heard, being seen as an individual rather than just avoiding that person, ignoring that person, working walking across the street.
TH:
Banishing them, even. Yeah.
JE:
Banishing them. Yeah. Exactly.
So I do think that if we were a more enlightened society, then perhaps that would be the route we would take. But, unfortunately, we’ve…
TH:
Got a way to go.
JE:
We’ve got a long way to go. We do.
TH:
And even when we point out that there are societal and structural and all those kind of factors that are involved in any kind of mental illness, including hoarding, we also are responsible for our own behaviour and actions.
How do we maintain that line between, on the one hand, being accountable and responsible for what we do, and on the other, not despising and stigmatising ourselves for the problems we, or those around us, are facing because of our hoarding?
JE:
It can be really difficult because accepting, taking accountability can slide very quickly into berating yourself about how did I get here, and this is so shameful. And I can’t believe I let this happen is what I commonly hear from people.
And I think it’s not necessarily about stopping those thoughts as much as it is recognising that the thought is just a thought.
It doesn’t mean that you’re really despicable and dirty and horrible. It popped up and recognising that, acknowledging that, I think. Yeah. I don’t know if I necessarily agree with it, but I’m acknowledging it’s there, and I’m…
TH:
going to carry on as I was.
JE:
Yeah.
And we do have to be responsible. It’s like, well, my actions, my behaviours that I repeated over a period of time have resulted in this.
It’s not a blame game. It’s more recognising that’s what happened and reverse engineering that to work out, well, what were the emotions? What that led to the behaviours? What was I thinking at the time? What was going on in my life?
And taking responsibility for those actions and behaviours, but also recognising that maybe that was the best you could do at the time.
And now you’re able to do more. Now you’re able to thank your mind, thank Gloria or whatever you call her.
I don’t know. I call mine Gloria. Just thanks for that. I know you’re trying to help.
TH:
And what’s it trying to tell me beyond you’re useless?
JE:
It’s usually trying to protect you, to be honest. It’s often trying to protect you from failure saying, oh yeah, you’re disgusting really, and you’ve tried before and remember what happened.
I don’t want you to be hurt again by failure. I’ll just keep telling you that you can’t do it because then you won’t fail and feel disappointed.
Most of the time, it’s trying to protect you.
It’s not right. It’s not a rule to be followed, but it can derail people because they really live in that space where they listen to what their brain is telling them, their mind is telling them.
TH:
So one paper I read, and as always, I list every paper we talk about in the show notes. So it was by Jennifer Krafft, former guest, who was talking about
JE:
Shout out, Jen. Shout out to Jen.
TH:
To Jen. I nearly went in to shout shout out to my ex. Oh. I don’t know if I know any of the rest of the words.
JE:
I don’t know. I don’t know that song.
TH:
Anyway, this paper by Jennifer Krafft and Clarissa Ong talked about using Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, which for new listeners is the kind of therapy Jan works in, to work on self-stigma.
And in a separate paper, Jennifer Krafft again said,
“ACT appears to help address self-stigma and its emphasis on values, clarification, and flexible attention could theoretically help address motivation and inattention in hoarding”.
So how would you, as an ACT – acceptance commitment therapy – therapist, go about working on self-stigma with a client?
JE:
I think first, which Jennifer mentions, I would ascertain personal values.
I’ve really focused in on what’s important and how the person wants to live their life.
That is step 1.
Then I would probably focus on some psychoeducation of relational frame theory. That’s the foundation of ACT. We did a whole podcast on that, so I’m sure you’ll link to that.
But it’s how language allows us to do so many amazing things, which have advanced our society, but when we apply them to our emotions, they create suffering.
So stereotypes are this mental shortcut. We use them to make quick decisions about the way people are likely to behave.
That’s the benefit of a stereotype.
In relation to public stigma, we compare ourselves to that stereotype and form these beliefs about ourselves.
And I was thinking about this when I was contemplating how various clients have reacted to watching those shows.
Some of them will compare themselves to the TV show and believe they’re nothing like them at all, that there’s just no way that they are that bad, in inverted commas, when perhaps they’ve got slightly rose-tinted glasses because they collect something completely different. And this person collects one thing, they collect something else, and they can use the toilet, so they can’t possibly be that bad.
Others might make the comparison that are not factual and believe they’re beyond help and are just like the people in the show. And then that leading to learned helplessness that, oh, well, these people really struggled and I watched them, and it was painful for me to watch them. And it will be equally painful for me to go through that, which I find is one of the problems with people watching this type of show.
It would be my focus to look at working with the person to diffuse, as I was explaining before, from these comparisons as well.
Looking at the stereotype, comparing myself to the stereotype, looking at the TV shows, comparing what I’m collecting or how I’m living with those and help them practice diffusion when their self-talk turns to self-stigma.
Accepting the thoughts, thanking their mind, moving forward, regardless, towards those values.
Really, that’s the core of ACT, and it does allow people to get some separation, some distance between stimulus and response, which is what we’re attempting to do.
We want that space so that we can observe what we’re thinking and take action in the direction of our values, not just towards that thought.
That’s the key.
TH:
And what about other types of therapy? Are there other effective approaches that might be able to help self-stigma?
I enjoy making this podcast, and it helps me on a personal level. It’s a lot of work, but the feedback I get makes it worthwhile.
I fund everything about the podcast myself. So if you want to help to ensure the future of the podcast, you can help me to cover the costs by sending a one-off or recurring donation at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/donate.
JE:
Perhaps cognitive behavioural therapy techniques like reframing might work.
Empowering people to bring others together in a peer support group like you’re doing can help significantly to allow a person to see that the stereotype is just that, that it’s a generalisation about a group of people.
It’s not individual experience. Everyone’s different. Everyone has a right to be heard and understood.
I think that’s what the peer support group can really do for someone with hoarding.
Maybe radical acceptance could be useful, like a dialectical behavioural therapy technique, which is a 10 step process where you observe that you’re questioning or fighting reality. It shouldn’t be this way, and if you’re really self-stigmatised, you’re going to think, it shouldn’t be this way, and it’s my fault, and I’m dirty and filthy and crazy and all of those things.
The reality, remind yourself that the unpleasant reality is just as it is, and it can’t be changed.
This is what happened. No judgment. No berating yourself. It is what it is. Alright?
The reason, remind yourself that there are causes for the reality, how it happened. All of those factors that you’re thinking about that were physical or psychological reasons that possibly catapulted this into a an unexpected overflow of stuff.
This is how things happened.
And then practicing accepting your whole self, mind, body, spirit, and using more accepting self-talk, relaxation techniques, mindfulness or imagery.
And there’s a bunch of other steps, but I think it’s about looking at what behaviours you would engage in if you did accept the facts, and then engage in those behaviours as if you’ve already accepted them.
Like, what would I do if I could move forward? And then just move forward. Pretend that you’ve accepted it.
I think radical acceptance is just about saying, I accept that this is the reality. This is where I am, and that allows you to then move forward.
It can be very powerful. A lot of people hear acceptance and they think giving up, they think
TH:
This is how it is.
JE:
Well, this is how it is. I can’t do anything.
But it’s more about not fighting with the reality because we often do fight with, again, many, many of my clients perseverate on what has happened. And it’s my role to sort of bring them into the now, this moment, because it’s already over.
This moment is already over. The next moment is about to happen. We’re in the moment now. Those things were in the past, it’s happened.
And the other point I often make is we need to focus on the living in our lives. Because many of my clients have a lot of grief around loss. And it may not be people, but it might be pets. It might be maybe there was a fire and they’ve lost a lot of things.
We need to be thinking about the living, ourselves and our family members who are here now. Not those that have passed because I think they would be disappointed to think that you were so anxiously considering whether you should let go of something rather than living your life.
TH:
Absolutely.
So I think one of the important things we have identified in that whole conversation is that if you’re affected by self-stigma, trying to say no thank you to it, isn’t necessarily going to work.
Whereas acknowledging its existence, maybe looking at why you think that, maybe looking at would I judge somebody else if can be really helpful.
JE:
Yeah. That’s a really good point. Would I treat a friend this way? Would I treat a fellow peer group member this way?
No. It’s always no.
TH:
That’s it. And also that different people are affected by self-stigma different in different ways and to different degrees.
But that that can depend on everything from your personality to your upbringing, to the society you’re living in.
You know, I look at my stats for podcast downloads, and there are some places that are quite predictable, and there are some places that surprise me every time.
So to the 3 listeners in Lithuania, you may be hearing this entirely differently to the 200 in Brazil to the several thousand in America based on the society you live in.
If you live in, say, your parents migrated somewhere and you’re in that kind of dual society thing, then there’s more layers still.
So understanding it in, part of the way I feel about this is based on my makeup, the makeup of my brain and my personality. Part of it is influenced by all of these things.
But if I recognise that it’s not a helpful way to think of myself, but that banishing it isn’t necessarily the goal. The goal is to say, there’s that thought again. What’s that trying to tell me?
What can I do? What can I do differently?
JE:
Exactly. Exactly. It’s looking at it rather than pushing it down. Yes.
TH:
So, Jan, if people want to find you online, where can they do… I feel like I could record you doing this bit.
JE:
Why? I love it so much.
TH:
Where can people find you online?
JE:
Online. They could pop on over to Instagram at stuff_ology or x. I’m a bit slack on x, but, at stuff_ology. Pinterest, hey. I’ve been told that my, Pinterest boards are very aesthetically pleasing. Some of them have been up there for 10 years.
So please explore at stuff_ology. And on Facebook, Stuffology Consulting.
But check out the website stuffology.com.au. Join, sign up for the newsletter, which I send out once a week on a Sunday night, my time.
And drop me a line, jan@stuffology.com. I’d love to hear from you.
TH:
Can I just correct your email address there ?
JE: What did I just say?
TH:
Jan@stuffology.com .
JE:
Why? What did I say?
TH:
You just said. com. Yeah.
JE:
Did I ? .com.au.
jan@stuffology.com.au .
TH:
So thank you, Jan. As always, that’s been really interesting and given me a lot to think about.
JE:
Excellent. Thank you for having me yet again.
Ciao for now.
May we take a moment to reflect on the meaning of place and acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land on which we record and listen to this podcast today.
I am speaking on the lands of the Boon Wurrung people of the Kulin nation and I acknowledge their connection to country, both land and sea, and culture.
We pay our respects to their elders past and present and extend that respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples listening today.
TH:
Shout out this week to the Help Hole podcast.
Have a listen to this little clip of Sofie Hagen on the Help Hole podcast, and they are talking about a book about flirting. But if you set aside the flirting content and think about the overall message, I think it’s really interesting.
Have a listen:
I read it on Kindle, so all of the most of these were under you could see when other people have underlined something. Oh, wow. Because they found it helpful.
And I was like, oh, these are all underlined. This has been really helpful for people.
It’s just really nice things like when you allow yourself worth to be influenced by strangers, don’t be surprised when it doesn’t go the way you want.
Using someone else as a means to help you feel good about yourself just reinforces your fear. It perpetuates a negative cycle in which you become more dependent on the positive affirmation of others, which in turn strengthens your fear of rejection.
It’s essentially don’t make other people’s opinions about yourself matter.
Like, if you go up to someone and however you flirt, if what is underlying is you saying, hi. Please make me feel pretty. You’re just giving them a power, and then you are dependent on them. And that’s like a not a good idea.
TH:
We do put a lot of emphasis and judgment on what other people think of us, don’t we, and what we are looking for when we get feedback from another person.
And we do need to really learn to find that within ourselves as much as we can. I will link to the Help Hole podcast in the show notes at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk.
Okay. Thank you for listening, and I’ll speak to you next time.
Thank you for listening to That Hoarder: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast. It’s been a pleasure to have you on board.
You can find all the links I’ve mentioned and a transcript of the episode online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk.
To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support, and do subscribe to the podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.
There may be links in this podcast that earn me money. This doesn’t come at any extra cost to you if you make a purchase through those links, and it helps to support the podcast.
JE:
Can we pause for one second. I apologise. I have pet troubles.
Off you go. Off you go, Gretl. Go. Go. Go. Go. Go. Go. I gotta gee gee.
Gotta get out because this is too much. It’s a menagerie in here.
TH:
Is it really a Zoom call if a cat doesn’t walk by?
JE:
Well, I think you’re right. I don’t think there’s any… or a baby or a child going.
Yeah. I mean, cognitive behavioural therapy techniques like reflam reflaming, not reflaming. I’m sorry. Reflaming. No. Reframing.
Although I have bought stuffology dotau, but I haven’t set it up. That’s irrelevant. No-one needs to know. Oh my god. I don’t know why I said that.
TH:
And I was about say well, you could just auto forward it to and I was like, oh, shut up. Nobody cares.
JE:
Shut up.
No one cares. We care. We all care. We care. We care a lot.
Audio credits
- Intro and outro music: cheesepuff
- Transition whoosh: Vilkas_Sound
- Piano Playing Classical Music: IESP
- Hallelujah chorus: deleted_user_2906614
- Uh oh: stib
- Angels: pycckuu20032003
- Phone: HarryPeeks and Aesterial-Arts
- Yay!: Reitanna
- Seriously? rydra_wong
- Retro power up MaoDin204
- Fanfare: humanoide9000
- Explosion: Iwiploppenisse
- What? What? What? max_cristos
- Why? Why? Why? Why? Reitanna
- Celebration: Gabriela_Melo
- Not again: xtrgamr
- Atmosphere 17: DaveJf
- Wah wah: SpliceSound
- Giggles: kim.headlee
- Help me: brandonreese
- Please don’t flush: PMBROWNE
- Horror laugh: klankbeeld
- Oohs and aahs: noah0189
- Applause: Sandermotions
- Heartbeat: Tobias Ludwig
- Countdown – female : Tim Kahn
- Game Over – evil: Rocotilos
- Countdown – male: jppi_sstu
- Oh yeah: metrostock99
- Amen: klankbeeld
- Cuban happy music: szegvari
- Suspense: Warped_Tension
- Ding dong: MatthewWong
- Ticking clock: ycbcr
- Former intro and outro music: grapelemon
