Podcast episode 195 cover for "Overcome Compulsive Hoarding," discussing why uncertainty is hard to handle with hoarding disorder, featuring Dr. Jan Eppingstall, on a purple background.

Show notes

Why is it so hard to deal with uncertainty, and what does that have to do with hoarding? This week I’m joined by Dr Jan Eppingstall to unpack how our brains handle ambiguity, why fear of making mistakes can keep us stuck, and how intolerance of uncertainty feeds into hoarding behaviours. We break down practical ways to build up your tolerance for not knowing and share some strategies that might actually make a difference.

  • Uncertainty and Its Challenges
  • Definition and context of uncertainty
  • Evolutionary reasons for discomfort with uncertainty (Selfish Brain Theory)
  • Contrast between historical resource scarcity and modern abundance
  • Our minds’ outdated ways of managing uncertainty
  • Cognitive Closure
  • What is cognitive closure?
  • Difference between cognitive closure (psychological need for definite answers) and “closure” in pop culture (emotional resolution)
  • How it relates to need for certainty in present/future, not just past events
  • The creation of cognitive closure measurement scales by researchers
  • Factors influencing need for cognitive closure:
  • Personality traits: Conscientiousness, neuroticism (now called emotionality), openness to experience, extroversion
  • Trauma history and its effects on the nervous system
  • Neurodivergence (with emphasis on autism and “sticky thinking”)
  • Combination of personality, trauma, and neurodivergence
  • Intolerance of Uncertainty
  • Psychological definition of intolerance of uncertainty
  • Negative cognitive bias: How it affects perception and response
  • Manifestations in people experiencing uncertainty as distress
  • Its direct relevance to hoarding behaviours
  • The Link Between Hoarding Disorder and Intolerance of Uncertainty
  • Research findings: intolerance of uncertainty as a predictor of hoarding symptom severity
  • Usefulness in early intervention strategies
  • intolerance of uncertainty as a transdiagnostic factor (across anxiety, some depression, and other mental health conditions)
  • How heightened anxiety sensitivity in hoarding perpetuates avoidance
  • Experiential avoidance in hoarding (saving and acquiring behaviours)
  • Connection between maladaptive behaviours and intolerance of uncertainty
  • Fear of Making Mistakes and Perfectionism
  • Common fears of mistakes in hoarding (disposing, acquiring, putting things away)
  • Perfectionism’s role (fear of failure, not wasting)
  • All-or-nothing thinking and rigid decision-making rules
  • Paralysing effect of avoidance due to fear of mistakes
  • Not making a decision as a potential mistake itself
  • Interaction and reinforcement between perfectionism and intolerance of uncertainty
  • Comorbidity and Severity
  • Research on multiple diagnoses: More than half of psychiatric patients have more than one diagnosis
  • Diagnostic challenges and overlapping criteria
  • How comorbidity compounds issues: More symptoms and more complexity
  • Higher intolerance of uncertainty linked with more severe hoarding, especially when other conditions are present
  • Impact on treatment difficulty
  • intolerance of uncertainty’s Impact on Acquiring and Discarding Behaviours
  • How acquiring reduces fear of missing out and future needs
  • Difficulty discarding as protection against future regret
  • Shame around mistake-making
  • Common inner questions: Future use, responsibility, relationships
  • More complexity leading to more avoidance
  • Nuances in intolerance of uncertainty and Hoarding
  • Study on sub-factors of uncertainty:
  • Factor 1: Negative self-referential implications (linked to hoarding severity)
  • Factor 2: Perception of uncertainty as unfair (not linked)
  • Internal vs. external perspectives on uncertainty
  • Relevance of anxiety-driven self-criticism
  • Changing Relationship to Uncertainty: Curiosity and Reframing
  • Rilke’s quote on “loving the questions”
  • Transforming approach from fear to curiosity
  • Curiosity as a therapeutic tool
  • Creativity in imagining alternatives and solutions
  • Relevance of loss aversion and cognitive biases
  • Modern Life and Uncertainty Intolerance
  • Research linking increased use of technology (instant answers) to rising intolerance of uncertainty
  • Smartphone/information overload and decreased tolerance “muscle”
  • Relevance to hoarding (desire for backups, information saving)
  • Example: IMDb, screenshots, saving digital info
  • Treatment Strategies
  • Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) effects on intolerance of uncertainty in anxiety
  • Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and exposure-based methods: Pros and cons
  • Importance of a therapist experienced in error-related distress and uncertainty
  • Key skills: Observing distress, sitting with uncomfortable feelings, gradual exposure
  • Self-help approaches:
  • Reframing mistakes as learning
  • Practicing self-compassion
  • Values-based decision-making
  • Systematic exposure to small errors
  • Gradually breaking rigid rules (e.g., waste, tidiness)
  • Recognising individual differences and seeking appropriate support
  • Embracing Mistakes and Humanity
  • Learning from therapist/client anecdotes
  • Cultural expectations around perfectionism vs. real human messiness
  • How mistakes can be positive or even entertaining
  • Letting go of the need for perfection
  • The Four Cs for Managing Uncertainty
  • From Elizabeth Weingarten: Curiosity, Conversation, Community, Commitment
  • How to foster each:
  • Curiosity: Approach with questions and exploration
  • Conversation: Discuss uncertainties with trusted people
  • Community: Build social support
  • Commitment: Dedication to exploring questions and knowing when to let go

Links

Subscribe to the podcast

Transcript

That Hoarder:

You are listening to That Hoarder: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding.

I don’t talk in real life about having hoarding disorder, so I talk about it on this podcast instead.

And because I’m anonymous, I can talk really, really, honestly.

Subscribe to the podcast and find my social media links, episode transcripts and every link that I mention at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/.

Finally, I am not a doctor. I’m just a hoarder doing her best. So do seek professional support if and when you need it.

So I am here with Dr. Jan Eppingstall. Jan is a therapist. She specialises in working with people who hoard in Melbourne, Australia.

Jan, how are you?

Dr Jan Eppingstall:

I’m grand, thank you. I’m grand.

TH:

Glad to hear it.

JE:

Just trying that out.

TH:

I love it. I love to hear it.

Today we are talking about uncertainty, why it can be so hard to deal with, and also what is the connection to hoarding and uncertainty?

I feel like there are parallels with something we’ve talked about before, or I’ve talked about before, about distress tolerance, being able to tolerate distress. There are parallels, but it’s not the same thing.

So let’s talk in general first.

Jan, why is uncertainty so unsettling for a lot of people to tolerate?

JE:

I really think this is a super, super topical point right now with everything that’s going on in the world, but it’s not new.

TH:

Yeah, we just know about more of it.

JE:

We just know about more of what’s going on! Right! So it seems more uncertain, it’s just knowledge.

But I think what is uncertain might be different, but why we’re intolerant of it as a species is evolutionary.

So the selfish brain theory helps us explain why uncertainty feels so uncomfortable to us.

This theory suggests that our brains are literally wired to avoid expending extra energy to process ambiguous or uncertain situations.

And this was originally a smart evolutionary adaptation when food was scarce. We need to conserve mental energy when resources are limited and that made survival sense for the human race.

So this theory provides insight into why people often struggle with uncertainty and engage in behaviours like hoarding that seem on the surface to reduce uncertainty in the moment, but then bring about other problems in our resource-abundant modern world, I think that’s key.

You know, we’re now no longer struggling to find resources, but our minds are still behaving in that way.

TH:

So there is an interview online that I will link to in the show notes along with all the papers and everything that we mention with a woman called Elizabeth Weingarten.

And she said individuals vary in their need for cognitive closure, which is a concept coined by the psychologist Arie Kruglansky in the early 1990s.

And he, along with other researchers, created a scale to help people measure their desire for answers and their ease in the unknown, and found basically, our need for that cognitive closure is influenced by a range of factors that include personality and experiences of trauma.

So, two parter – at least – question here.

Can you first of all explain cognitive closure? Like, we hear the term closure a lot, don’t we? Is it the same as what people talk about?

And also, what are these kinds of factors that can affect how much we need that cognitive closure and how might they influence how well we deal with uncertainty?

JE:

So much there. So much there. Let’s unpack that.

TH:

I feel like if there was a drinking game for this podcast, one of them would be a question That Hoarder writes that seems reasonable on paper until she says it out loud.

JE:

Exactly. I would be blind…

TH:

Yeah. And another would be when Jan says more research is needed.

JE:

Yep, exactly.

I mean, cognitive closure refers to an individual’s desire for definitive answers.

TH:

Okay.

JE:

And discomfort with ambiguity. So it’s different from closure in pop culture, which is really about emotional resolution.

TH:

Yeah. Like the end of a relationship.

JE:

Breakup, death, trauma, that kind of stuff.

Getting answers or explanations that help you, in inverted commas move on, a sense of completeness or finality that allows healing.

I mean it’s usually about processing past events and finding peace with them. It’s not measurable, as it doesn’t have a clear definition, and nor do many people believe it can be achieved.

You know when something terrible happens and they interview the family and some journalists ask them, will this give you closure? And they say, nothing will ever give us closure. And it’s just. It’s a circle.

But cognitive closure from the research is referring to an ongoing psychological need for certainty and definitive answers.

So that discomfort with ambiguity in general, not just past events, and kind of a personality trait about how you handle uncertainty in daily life, it’s much more about that present and future decision making than past resolutions.

And it’s measurable. These guys have created a measure, and everyone wants to create a measure as a researcher, because then you get referenced constantly.

TH:

The Eppingstall Scale.

JE:

I have created a measure.

TH:

I have invented a manoeuvre.

JE:

That’s exactly right.

But yeah, it’s that pop culture is looking backwards.

Cognitive closure is forward looking and being certain about decisions.

Let’s move on to part two of the Giant Question.

The factors that research has identified as influencing our need for cognitive closure.

Certain personality traits. So conscientiousness, one of the big five personality traits is where you’ve got that preference for structure. Clear outcomes. Yes. You’ve got your finger pointed. Me too.

I’m very high on conscientiousness. Clear outcomes, order and planning. We like that. So we feel we need to know what’s going to happen.

Emotionality, what which isn’t a shock. Formerly known as neuroticism. Again, a tendency to seek to reduce stress and anxiety.

TH:

But who doesn’t seek to reduce stress though?

JE:

Oh, I guess crazies. The. The extroverts.

TH:

Bungee jumping people.

JE:

Yeah, the bungee… The openness to experience. Yeah, so those.

So, so neuroticism and conscientiousness are about, gosh, I need this closure to know where I’m going and what I’m doing.

But openness to experience, there’s that willingness to see ambiguity as an opportunity for creativity and being wacky and keep your options open, all that kind of stuff that relates a bit.

TH:

We were talking before the call that I’m trying to do better at being spontaneous and that feels kind of relevant to that.

Open to experience rather than planning everything to death.

JE:

Yes. And let’s see how it goes, see what happens.

And extroverts are more comfortable with that collaborative and iterative decision making, aren’t they?

Oh well, I’ll decide to do this and then I’ll see where that takes me and then… which freaks some people out. I mean, I’m getting better at it in my old age, but it is a bit scary.

TH:

I’m variable with that. Sometimes not having a plan is nice, sometimes not having a plan is baffling. Let’s meet and then we’ll decide where to eat??!

JE:

Feeling uncomfortable about something that's uncertain will shut down our connection to that prefrontal cortex where decisions and plans are made. - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on X

A notepad quote about uncertainty affecting decision-making by Dr. Jan Eppingstall, on a blue background promoting the "That Hoarder: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding Podcast" episode 195.But the research also mentions trauma histories, as we were saying earlier, that influences our need for cognitive closure.

And this makes sense from a safety system perspective because you know, our nervous system is constantly scanning our environment for danger and life threatening and feeling uncomfortable about something that’s uncertain will shut down our connection to that prefrontal cortex where decisions and plans are made.

So that’s going to shut us down and not allow us to actually achieve cognitive closure.

And I also wanted to just quickly mention autism and neurodivergence as another factor that may impact someone’s need for cognitive closure. Although, the research in that area is a bit nuanced.

Individuals with autism exhibit higher intolerance of uncertainty compared to neurotypicals or allistic individuals.

So they experience significant distress and anxiety in response to unpredictable or ambiguous situations.

However, the relationship with autism and need for closure is a little bit more complex.

There’s this push pull. So they may seek certainty but struggle with decision making to actually achieve closure. So there’s this push pull of that.

So a preference for predictability over decision making and sticky thinking, which is reduced cognitive flexibility. It’s just a fun way to talk about being able to shift and change with your thought patterns means they tend to get stuck on ideas or solutions and then have trouble adapting to new information.

And that’s stuff that we’re much more aware of.

TH:

So as you’re talking, something else I’m thinking of is there’s personality, there’s trauma, there’s neurodivergence.

What I was thinking as you were talking was also, there are neurodivergent people with trauma and that personality type or… those things can combine for sure.

JE:

Yes, definitely.

And whenever I think about cognitive closure, I keep thinking about that episode on the Big Bang Theory where Sheldon just couldn’t cope with the fact that they didn’t have the final episode of a show and he just, he had some sort of existential meltdown.

And sometimes I see that with people. I feel it myself. Like I just need to know, even if it’s not a good outcome, I just want to know what’s going to happen.

And so if you’ve got all of that piled on top of one another and maybe something’s going on for you right at the moment, the need to feel certain is heightened.

TH:

Yes. I have a friend who is very into jigsaws and spent literally weeks on a jigsaw that ended up without a final piece.

JE:

And no. Oh my God. Oh my God.

I’m feeling that viscerally.

TH:

Yep, I haven’t done a jigsaw for 20 years, but I can feel his pain.

So there is a phrase that came up in a lot of the studies I read when preparing for this episode, and that’s going to come up in the rest of our conversation, and that is intolerance of uncertainty.

So in terms of the psychological studies and theories, what is intolerance of uncertainty?

JE:

So to quote the 2022 Hillman article that looks at the roles of intolerance of uncertainty in hoarding, it’s defined as a negative cognitive bias, there’s those little buggers again, that affects how a person perceives, interprets and responds to uncertainty situations on cognitive, emotional and behavioural levels.

More specifically, those who are high in intolerance of uncertainty, they will experience uncertainty about the future as stressful and upsetting, which results in impairment in functioning and subsequent avoidance.

Very, very, very applicable to hoarding. Just feels like that definition is screaming hoarding to me.

TH:

I read in a number of studies when I was preparing for this conversation that intolerance of uncertainty was associated with hoarding symptoms.

That had been found again and again.

And what was interesting was that that was the case whether or not people in the studies had other mental health problems as well.

So it showed up when somebody just had hoarding, but not depression or anxiety or whatever else.

So what might this link be between hoarding disorder and intolerance of uncertainty?

JE:

Just continuing on from that, what you were just saying there, the research today indicates that intolerance or uncertainty is a significant predictor of hoarding symptoms, severity.

So as you said, after controlling for all these other things like general worry, depression, obsessive compulsive symptoms, so this makes it extremely useful in early intervention.

If we can have a look at whether someone has these thoughts about needing certainty in the future, then we can actually look at intervening earlier.

We’re not doing that at the moment, but this is an area that would be definitely worth researching and creating more interventions to focus in on it, because I think that the interventions kind of do it, but they’re not really targeting it in a way that I think would bring about change.

So this has opened up a whole lot of stuff for me as well, doing this podcast. There’s a whole lot of things that I think I might change in the way I approach it.

But intolerance of uncertainty is actually increasingly recognised as a trans-diagnostic factor, which means it’s implicated across multiple mental health diagnoses, particularly a range of anxiety disorders, and to a lesser extent, depression.

And this makes sense, right? Because that’s what anxiety is all about. You know, when we’re intolerant of uncertainty, we become stressed and anxious when faced with decisions, even simple ones.

And people who hoard are more sensitive to anxiety. That’s the other part of the research that dovetails with this, that is that they rate their level of anxiety to be higher in ambiguous situations than healthy controls.

Enter the avoidance mechanism. You know, in my research I found that experiential avoidance was extremely high. And hoarding behaviours, both saving and acquiring, offer ways to reduce this distress related to uncertainty.

Intolerance of uncertainty is central to the perpetuation of maladaptive behaviours - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on X

A notepad with the quote: "Intolerance of uncertainty is central to the perpetuation of maladaptive behaviours - Dr Jan Eppingstall." Podcast title and episode 195 are also shown.So intolerance of uncertainty is central to the perpetuation of maladaptive behaviours. And hoarding, it’s just kind of the core of it.

TH:

If you want to get even more from me, I have a weekly newsletter that goes out to email subscribers.

As a bonus, when you sign up, you get a printable version of a series of questions to help you make decisions when you’re dehoarding.

Sign up for all of that for free at overcome compulsivehoarding.co.uk/newsletter.

And as I was doing the reading, there was a topic that had come up a few times in the dehoarding accountability zoom sessions I run that felt very relevant and that was people talking about being afraid of making a mistake, whether that was getting rid of something and that being a mistake or not acquiring something or that kind of thing, even putting something in the wrong place, which is a very simple solvable mistake.

But there’s a big overriding fear of making a mistake that people were talking about.

So  then I was writing these questions and it really struck me that there must be a link between uncertainty and fear of making a mistake.

JE:

What do you reckon, perfectionism enter stage left?

You know, like perfectionism’s core, it’s a fear of failure.

And while intolerance of uncertainty involves the fear of making errors about items’ future utility, perfectionism in hoarding often involves, like, demanding standards about not wasting anything, which is a mistake that we’re trying to avoid every day.

Fear of throwing out something that might be needed later, all or nothing. Thinking I can’t waste resources at all, ever.

And rigid rules around what constitutes proper decision making.

I’m so often asked by clients and people just in the general population, they ask if I can teach them how to make decisions. However, what they really want to know is how to not make mistakes.

Yeah, yeah you kind of have to really.

But the intolerance of uncertainty specifically relates to hoarding through the fear of making mistakes, about future utility of items and just that whole I’m uncertain about outcomes. I don’t know what’s happening in my life.

I might regret it, I might regret it and there’s that using of hoarding behaviours to avoid uncertainty-related distress and then becoming kind of paralysed in the face of that, you’re kind of not sure what’s going to happen.

I just won’t act. That’s the easiest and simplest way to stop the distress and, and come up with a better solution, I guess, of how to manage it.

Maybe an act of God will occur and I won’t have to make the decision. Yeah.

TH:

I sometimes find it useful to remind myself that choosing not to make the decision may be the mistake.

Choosing not to make the decision may be the mistake. Share on X

A torn notebook page with the quote: "Choosing not to make the decision may be the mistake. - That Hoarder" on a blue and pink wavy background.JE:

Yes.

TH:

And if I want to avoid making a mistake…

JE:

And actually, putting it that way is brilliant. Right. Because I would have said not making a decision is a decision in and of itself.

But you saying not making the decision might be the mistake is even more powerful.

TH:

I have my moments.

JE:

I love that. I love that. I really like that because it just brings it home.

There’s this reinforcing cycle. The two factors, perfectionism and uncertainty intolerance reinforce each other.

So uncertainty triggers perfect perfectionistic thinking. What if I need this later? Leads to I must not make the mistake of discarding it.

And then perfectionistic standards increase uncertainty. The demand to make the perfect decision about each and every item creates more uncertainty about what the right choice is.

And then avoidance is the solution rather than risk it. Rather than making an imperfect decision, you just avoid it all together.

But you’re right, it could be not making a decision is the mistake. Definitely.

TH:

Interestingly, there is a link that people who have the most difficulty tolerating uncertainty might also have the most severe hoarding symptoms and that it’s worse when there’s more than one mental health problem.

And that sounds kind of logical based on what we’ve said, but it’s interesting that the research has found that as well.

There's this reinforcing cycle. The two factors, perfectionism and uncertainty intolerance reinforce each other. - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on X

A quote from Dr. Jan Eppingstall about the reinforcing cycle between perfectionism and uncertainty intolerance, featured on Episode 195 of the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding Podcast.JE:

Right, yeah. And before I start on the why, I just want to make a couple of points about multiple diagnoses.

Because research shows more than half of people diagnosed with one psychiatric disorder will be diagnosed with a second or a third in their lifetime and about a third will have four or more diagnoses.

You can argue about why that is. I mean, the high rate of comorbidity. Comorbidity is partially due to like overlapping genetic risk factors among certain disorders, but it also could be related to that overlap of symptoms and signs in the diagnostic criteria in the DSM. I mean, I won’t bang on about that again…

TH:

I had a long period where psychiatrists could not work out what my… I had a different diagnosis with every different psychiatrist because they couldn’t…

And then eventually somebody went, this is obviously ptsd. And everybody else went, oh, yeah, it’s obviously PTSD. And everybody agreed. But I also have a diagnosis of OCD that stands and other things. And so, yeah, absolutely.

But I also went through a number of diagnoses that were not accurate or correct, but they just didn’t quite know which box to put me in.

JE:

Exactly.

TH:

And each decided on a different one.

JE:

Yeah, yeah.

TH:

I mean, until finally someone was like.

JE:

Oh, wow. I mean it’s never really cut and dried and it depends on the ability or the experience of the diagnostician what you tell them or how you are on the day or. There’s so many factors.

TH:

And some people fit very clearly into one diagnostic criteria and some people just don’t because the diagnostic criteria are artificial boxes.

You know, they serve a purpose, but we don’t fit naturally into boxes as humans.

JE:

We do not fit naturally. The number of overlaps are just off the chart.

TH:

It’s just clusters of symptoms, isn’t it, that go, oh, we often see these together. Let’s call it something.

JE:

Yeah, Symptoms and signs. Oh, we see these together. We’ve just thrown a hunk of stuff at the wall and gone, oh, yeah, that’s OCD.

You know, really seriously, we need to be looking at the function of the behaviour rather than looking at…

But there’s a few reasons why intolerance of uncertainty is worse when there’s multiple diagnoses.

One reason is the compounding effect, where each disorder contributes its own uncertainty-related challenges.

It could be increased cognitive load. So more symptoms to manage, more treatment decisions, more unpredictable aspects of life, just general overall complexity, which naturally increases uncertainty.

And again, treatment complexity can play into that. Those with higher baseline levels of intolerance to uncertainty experience fewer gains in treatment.

It’s much harder to change.

TH:

Yes, I read that. Yes.

JE:

Yeah, yeah, so. And of course, reduced coping capacity due to the multiplication effects of intolerance of uncertainty and emotional dysregulation, like all of that impacts on why it might be worse and then why treatment may not actually be that effective.

Once you move on to treatment, once you’ve identified it, then you move on to treatment, it’s going to be harder.

TH:

Yeah. One PhD paper I read said that intolerance of uncertainty predicted difficulties with acquiring, discarding and clutter. There was also a research paper that said there wasn’t necessarily a link with clutter, but there was with acquiring and discarding.

So it seems to definitely have a link with acquiring and discarding and maybe with clutter. But even with that uncertainty, what is it about uncertainty that might make somebody more likely to keep hold of things or acquire new things?

JE:

Well, acquiring behaviours serve to avoid uncertainty about future needs. So you want to reduce the fear of missing out on an opportunity. Or future capacity to acquire. Like, whether that be financial, physical or mental, you’re worried about those things in the future.

So, hey, I’ve got to acquire this right now, because right now I can financially, physically or mentally. Yeah.

TH:

Get hold of whatever it is, it’s reduced in price. Or I’ve got a lift to the supermarket so I can get it home or…

JE:

Yeah, exactly. Or I’ve just remembered that I that I have a need for something right here, right now and I’ve also got the money and I’ve had the lift, so I will buy it. You know, all that kind of stuff is just, you know. Oh, and also just not being able to think clearly quite often is just. I’m mentally foggy, I’m out.

TH:

Gosh, do I need. I probably need beans. I’ll get the beans. Because I’ll probably need beans.

JE:

Yeah, exactly, exactly. And it’s just that, well, I certainly don’t want to get home and not have beans. I mean, geez, that would have.

TH:

On my toast.

JE:

How can I have breakfast tomorrow?

Difficulty discarding protects against the uncertainty of making a wrong choice and preventing future regret.

You know, this protects us from the predicted shame of making a mistake. I mean, mistake making is kind of a shameful thing for many of us.

TH:

It shouldn’t be, but it is.

JE:

It shouldn’t be, but it is. Totally. It is. We feel this sense of shame. Well, I couldn’t even make a decision right about that.

People who hoard are constantly asking themselves, am I doing the right thing?

People who hoard are constantly asking themselves, am I doing the right thing? - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on X

A notepad with typed text: “People who hoard are constantly asking themselves, am I doing the right thing? – Dr Jan Eppingstall.” Podcast branding surrounds the note.Whether that is to do with sorting a loved one’s possessions – should I be touching and moving this stuff? Will that loosen the ties to that person? Will I need this as soon as I decide to let it go? Will someone else have a need that I could have filled?

You know, all of those.

TH:

Am I getting rid of it in the most responsible way humanly possible? You know, there’s so many things that we tie ourselves in knots about.

JE:

That and just oh, the more, the, the more elements of that that we put into the mix, the more uncertain we are, the more likely we are to just avoid the decision.

TH:

So I read in the paper by Castriotta about two sub-factors of uncertainty.

So factor one is uncertainty has negative behavioural and self-referent implications. In factor two, uncertainty is unfair and spoils everything.

Factor one was associated with hoarding severity whereas factor two was not, which isn’t surprising to me at all.

I don’t really think of uncertainty as unfair and… well, it might spoil everything but it feels like the way of the world. So not unfair.

But did that surprise you? Because it didn’t surprise me.

JE:

No, no. Because the factor one focuses on how uncertainty leads to negative self-judgements and behavioural consequences.

It emphasises that personal internal impact of uncertainty on the individual.

And this factor is more closely related to anxiety, likely due to that emphasis on negative self-judgement.

The other one reflects like a more external philosophical stance I guess about uncertainty, that it’s inherently wrong or unjust, that it’s an external force that ruins experiences.

Which I kind of feel like is a bit more grandiose, don’t you think? It’s kind of like poor me.

TH:

And also a bit childish as well. Like this isn’t fair, like stamping your foot because you can’t have an ice lolly.

JE:

And of course, as you said, factor one was associated with hoarding symptoms and factor two wasn’t and it just aligns with that hoarding often about fear of making mistakes and, and a self-critical, anxiety-driven set of behaviours.

TH:

So back to that Elizabeth Weingarten interview that we mentioned at the start.

She quotes poet Rainer Maria Rilke in 1903 as saying “To love the questions themselves as if they were locked rooms or books written in a very foreign language”.

So the idea of almost relishing the questions rather than fearing the questions – and the questions meaning that feeling of uncertainty, it feels to me like it’s got a lot of potential in changing our relationship to uncertainty.

That rather than seeing it as something to fear, we can go… oh do you know, I’ve just realised that Jan’s going to bring curiosity into this answer. Yes, we approach it with excitement and curiosity rather than dread.

So does that make sense to you too?

JE:

All roads lead back to curiosity, my pet perspective.

TH:

Yes, that’s the other thing in the drinking game Jan mentions.

JE:

It does have significant therapeutic potential. You know, it’s a fundamental shift.

TH:

It does. A bit like resentful journaling. I do do a fair bit of resentful curiosity.

JE:

Exactly. Like resentful journaling and resentful curiosity. Similar benefits.

You know, you’re not looking at the uncertainty as a threat to be avoided or controlled.

We should be embracing uncertainty with curiosity rather than fear.

We should be embracing uncertainty with curiosity rather than fear. - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on X

A notepad with a quote by Dr. Jan Eppingstall: "We should be embracing uncertainty with curiosity rather than fear." Podcast details are visible in the background.It’s a complete reframe for someone who hoards. Like, what if I need this later? Fear based.

To, I wonder what would happen if I let this go. Curiosity based.

TH:

I wonder what I could use in its place if I suddenly did unexpectedly need this.

JE:

Exactly.

TH:

I wonder how creative I could get.

JE:

Creative I could get. Yes. Mic drop.

That’s exactly it. How creative.

We’re so creative, especially people who hoard. The workarounds are, like, off the charts.

TH:

And also the immediate way in which if somebody says, why don’t you get rid of this? We can think of 20 uses it suddenly has.

I think that in itself is evidence of creativity.

JE:

So turning it on its head.

TH:

Right, we can go, that broken thing could be used for all of these things.

And so why don’t we apply that same creativity to, if I get rid of this and…

JE:

Then later need it, I know we suddenly revert to, I have to have the exact tool. I need to have my grapefruit knife for when I want to have grapefruit segments for breakfast when grapefruits are in season. I can’t use any other kind of knife that wouldn’t work.

It’s at odds. The fact that we can be so creative about uses for something that we fear we’re going to lose.

It’s loss aversion again, isn’t it? It’s another cognitive bias, really.

We try to find ways to make sure that we don’t feel that distress of letting it go. Yeah.

TH:

There’s also research from Nick Carlton at the University of Regina in Canada that as we use smartphones more and as just the internet takes over our lives, so our intolerance of uncertainty has increased.

And what Weingarten said about that was, of course, this is a correlation and doesn’t necessarily indicate causation.

However, Carlton suggests that having answers at our fingertips all the time means we are regularly missing out on opportunities to practise sitting with uncertainty. And like a muscle, this can atrophy our capacity for it.

And I felt this. Like sometimes you’re in a bar and you hear a song and whereas 20 years ago we’d have just gone, oh, I wish I could remember who that song was by. But now I open Shazam. It tells me in five seconds who sang the song.

That’s a very minor thing. But 20 years ago I would have had to sit with that very minor uncertainty, and now I no longer have to.

JE:

Yeah, yeah.

TH:

So do you think this has relevance for people who hoard in any way?

JE:

Look, I know, like you, it impacts me every single day. I mean, I can’t stop myself from checking my answers, like checking that I got the damn actor right. When I recognise, recognise them, shout out to IMDb, IMDb every time.

TH:

And what else were they in? What did I see them in before?

JE:

What did I see them in before? And then I’d go, yes, I’m a super recogniser. I did recognise the right person, even while they were wearing a costume.

TH:

And the last thing I saw them in was 1996.

JE:

And I remember what I was doing then.

So having it at our fingertips just means we are missing out on that practise of sitting with uncertainty.

But I think also people who hoard want a backup of that information. So it’s almost like they’ve got the double whammy. They can find out straight away, but they also want to have some concrete evidence of that somehow.

TH:

Yes. We’re talking in a future episode about trusting ourselves, aren’t we? And this feels relevant to that as well.

JE:

Yeah it’s potentially. Yeah. They could start wanting to screenshot everything, which it moves pretty easily from. I search for it on IMDb and I want to remember that again. So I’m going to save the picture of it.

It’s an extension, so it could even be worse, it could even add another element to it.

Extra ways of feeling uncertain and wanting to save that information.

TH:

Yeah, yeah.

So, as always, a lot of the research is into cognitive behavioural therapy. And also, as always, little of the research is about hoarding disorder.

But we do know from the research that does exist that in anxiety disorders, cognitive behavioural therapy, CBT, can help people with intolerance of uncertainty, so it’s feasible that it would help people with hoarding disorder too, but we don’t know for sure.

The PhD I mentioned earlier by Baldwin looked into a brief acceptance and commitment therapy intervention on intolerance of uncertainty to see if that would help people with hoarding disorder.

It wasn’t that conclusive but and it was tiny in any case so it’s difficult to build anything on that.

But if people are looking into some kind of mental health treatment or therapy and they’re listening and they’re recognising that intolerance of uncertainty is actually a massive barrier for them, what is a good approach to take?

Where can people start?

JE:

Look, I think I’m still pretty pro acceptance and commitment therapy and exposure-based training and experience for a therapist.

I think sometimes CBT, particularly cognitive restructuring and things like that, people with hoarding are a little bit like Teflon with that. It doesn’t really change their thoughts.

I think the key is finding someone you’re comfortable with and can trust to come into your space and help you.

Because this work of increasing uncertainty tolerance is context specific.

So you really need to look for someone who has experience teaching people to observe their error-related distress.

You know, if they’re making a mistake. you need to have someone who can teach you to observe that without immediately acting on it.

So trying to put some distance between stimulus and response.

You want someone who has helped people increase their tolerance for the uncomfortable feelings that arise when mistakes happen and sit with that uncertainty rather than avoiding it.

So someone who can do those things will be a good place to start.

If you want to try some things on your own, I’ve got a few ideas. But first start with reframing mistakes.

So again, relishing the question and viewing mistakes as learning opportunities rather than failures.

Curiosity shout out, just having another swig of the whisky.

Self-compassion. Develop kinder internal dialogues about imperfection. Everyone is imperfect.

We all have the same issues.

TH:

I did a whole episode recently about self-compassion. It’s a such a…

JE:

And there’s some new research around that. Isn’t it like you had someone on a little while ago. I can’t think of her name.

She was fabulous.

TH:

Yeah. I went to a two-day conference about shame a few weeks ago and the self-compassion episode basically came out of that.

That the antidote to shame is compassion. And it really helped sitting listening to people talk about how damaging shame is for two full days.

JE:

Yeah.

TH:

Really cemented something in me that I was, and I say this in a non-shaming way, doing it wrong.

JE:

Yeah. Yeah.

TH:

And even I basically concluded that even if I didn’t feel like I deserved self-compassion, I should just do it anyway because even if I just went let’s look at the evidence, the evidence is that self-compassion works.

And so whether I deserve it or not, because that was always what tripped me up, do I deserve the self-compassion?

I’m kind of trying to bypass, do I deserve self-compassion and just go to self-compassion anyway.

JE:

Yeah, I mean we need to flip the shame from victims to the perpetrators in all cases.

So that’s another thing about self-compassion. We need to remember that it wasn’t our fault.

Whatever happened to us wasn’t our fault.

So self-compassion is huge.

Values focus, make decisions based on values, which again is another thing I bang on about all the time.

But rather than avoiding all possible errors, am I moving towards, am I living in the life that I want to live towards those values that I hold?

But gradual error exposure, I mean systematically exposing you to situations where errors are likely or inevitable.

I don’t know what that might be for you. For some people it might be actually just handwriting in a notebook.

I’ve got so many clients who don’t want to write in a notebook because they feel that it won’t be perfect or there’ll be some error that will be made and that’s unforgivable. That will have ruined the entire notebook.

TH:

I deliberately left a spelling mistake in my to-do list recently.

JE:

So proud of you.

TH:

Thank you very much.

JE:

So proud of you. And you know what I did recently? I put a line through something that was wrong.

TH:

Well done.

JE:

I didn’t get out the white out. I just did it. I just did it. Well, that was wrong. That sort of stuff.

It sounds silly, but we get hung up on that and we make such a big deal out of it.

TH:

Then we do it and nothing goes wrong.

JE:

Nothing goes wrong.

You start with something low stakes, some mistakes, and gradually increasing.

Like I did it today, very proud of myself, putting a piece of paper, recyclable paper, in the bin, not in the recycling.

And I didn’t put my hand back in there and pull it out.

Huge, huge step forward. Sounds silly, but I do it.

TH:

Yeah. What it does, it proves to us that the world doesn’t collapse.

And it means that next time we might be able to forgive ourselves a slightly worse mistake and so on.

JE:

Exactly. Yep. Theoretically it’s going to help the brain learn that errors aren’t catastrophic.

It's going to help the brain learn that errors aren't catastrophic. - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on X

A note on lined paper displays a quote from Dr Jan Eppingstall about learning errors aren't catastrophic, over a blue, wavy background labeled "OCH Episode 195".That’s what you’re wanting to do.

TH:

There are catastrophic errors, but we’re not talking about air traffic control, we’re talking about putting paper in the wrong bin.

JE:

Yeah, and we’re not talking about making a beef Wellington.

TH:

We’re not, with poisonous mushrooms. With Jan’s relative giving evidence in the case.

JE:

Some distant relative with the same surname as mine. Yes.

TH:

If you’ve no idea what we’re talking about. There’s been a high-profile trial that Jan and I have been mutually obsessed with for a while where someone poisoned… and we can say this because she was found guilty. She poisoned her extended ex’s family.

With beef Wellington.

JE:

Yeah, yeah. Oh, everyone, everyone listening to this podcast will know all about it, surely. Come on. Surely they’ll have all of their pet ideas on how it went down.

TH:

But even if we’re a brain surgeon at work, when you really don’t want to make a mistake, that still doesn’t apply about not using the whole onion before you throw it away.

JE:

Yep, yep. I mean, experiment.

Look, this is really, this is the one that you got to build up to.

But throwing out items without checking them thoroughly, maybe just throwing out the newspaper into the recycling without looking through everything to check to see if you’ve read it all or to check that you haven’t left a piece of paper in there or whatever, just give it a try.

You know, test your window of tolerance by making those small, potentially imperfect decisions.

And the other one is gradually changing rigid rules. About your waste is a big one.

But don’t forget, we’re all different.

I mean, some people have more sensitive error-detection systems because of genetics or trauma or other factors. So we need to think about that when we’re looking at interventions, and tailor them to individual tolerance levels and that kind of thing.

But yeah, you may find that this is something that you think is central and you might need to seek out some professional support with it.

But you can give this stuff a go on your own. It’s something that you can actually focus in on and become more aware of even if you’re not looking to change it initially, just start noticing.

So I actually had, this is many, many years ago. I actually had a client when I was doing my counselling training and I was about to go into the session with her and I had a cup and I put it accidentally in the recycling and I went in with my hand and she said you don’t have to be perfect all the time.

And I think about that often. I think about her saying that often.

Yeah, you’re right. I don’t have to try to be perfect all the time. We don’t, because we’re not. You know what?

TH:

I can’t think of anything more boring than spending time with perfect people.

JE:

Oh, me too. In perfect houses where you can’t touch anything or do anything. Oh, my God. Just.

People don’t want you to be perfect. Just remember that they want to come into your home and feel relaxed and comfortable and think, oh, she’s just like me.

TH:

A friend of mine recently in a big Microsoft Teams meeting with important people from across her city, all in this Microsoft Teams meeting, she put something in the chat with a devastating typo that made it sound very rude. And she sent this to the great and good of her city council, council, basically, and then realised what she’d done.

And she took a photo of her screen and messaged me and was like, oh, my God, I can’t believe I’ve just sent this. And she immediately apologised and she was mortified.

But what I said, and I meant this, was that for everybody else in the meeting, a probably boring meeting just got fun. Because what was a probably boring meeting due to her typo became funny.

It became something you’re going to tell your partner about when they get home.

And so, sure, she was mortified, but her mistake will have cheered at least 10 people up.

JE:

It’s cheered me up. Brilliant. Brilliant. Throw a few more of those into the chat. Thanks. Good on her.

TH:

So make more mistakes. It’s good. It’s good for the people around you.

JE:

If you make more mistakes. Yep. I agree.

TH:

I enjoy making this podcast and it helps me on a personal level. It’s a lot of work, but the feedback I get makes it worthwhile.

I fund everything about the podcast myself, so if you want to help to ensure the future of the podcast, you can help me to cover the costs by sending a one off or recurring donation at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/donate

So back to the Weingarten interview. She says the four most important elements for people who are able to change their relationship to the questions in their life and to the uncertainty, the experience, the four Cs: Curiosity, Conversation, Community and commitment.

I like these. Can you talk us through how we might do better at incorporating those into our lives?

JE:

Okay, well, curiosity. I’m flogging a dead horse. I may literally have flogged a dead horse, but relating to the uncertainty in your life with more curiosity than fear.

I wonder why I feel this way about letting go of this item, considering those sorts of questions as you’re working through and trying to get a handle on why this uncertainty is so intolerable.

Conversation. With the right techniques, we can use conversation to help us create a sense of safety and security, allowing us to sustain curiosity rather than that spiralling into fear.

So we could discuss uncertainties with trusted others rather than avoiding them. Have a chat with someone else about a particular thing that you’ve been avoiding and see if you can work through that in a safe space.

Community. I was going to say we’re a pack animal. That sounds a bit harsh but we’re all about community.

And it evolved to help us feel safe and secure. So it shouldn’t be surprising that a key feature of being able to love the question is using social support around us to explore the uncertainty.

I think that’s another thing. We just push it aside. I’m uncertain, I won’t make the decision.

But if we were to explore it a little bit more, particularly with others that we feel safe with, we might kind of uncover some of the reasons behind it, but also maybe dispelling some of the myths about why we think it’s not the right decision or it’s a mistake.

Commitment, commitment and acceptance and commitment therapy, the whole thing, curiosity, all of this stuff is related to ACT.

We need to commit to the process of exploring our questions while observing which ones are no longer worthy of our attention.

We need to commit to the process of exploring our questions while observing which ones are no longer worthy of our attention. - Dr Jan Eppingstall Share on X

A podcast episode graphic with a quote from Dr Jan Eppingstall about committing to explore questions and letting go of those unworthy of attention. Episode 195, That Hoarder podcast.Dedication to the process of exploring questions while learning when to let them go.

Most difficult for our audience I think is learning when to let things go.

TH:

Both physical things and ideas and thoughts.

JE:

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Really hard. Really, really hard.

But like we’ve discussed, that idea that humans are wired to reduce uncertainty because when we navigate that, it requires more metabolic energy.

But if we approach uncertainty with curiosity, we can make this energy expenditure actually feel worthwhile rather than draining, transforming the uncertainty from an energy drain into an energising exploration of what’s happening.

This shift from that fear-based avoidance to curiosity-based engagement could fundamentally change how someone who hoards experiences the decision-making process around their possessions, potentially reducing the paralysis and avoidance that maintains the behaviours.

If we can flip that, make that shift. A lot of stuff that we need and want to do is about a shift and that’s kind of uncertain and scary, I get that.

But we have to kind of explore that.

Because growth and change is inherently uncomfortable, isn’t it? I know you’ve been talking a lot about that lately, and I really resonate with that because it’s just… It is really hard.

TH:

It is really hard.

JE:

It’s really, really hard. But you’re doing it.

You’re doing a good job. Everyone’s doing their best.

TH:

That’s it. It’s really hard. But it reaps rewards.

JE:

Yes.

TH:

Also this sense that staying the same, we think is comfortable and it isn’t necessarily.

JE:

Yeah, yeah. Especially when everything’s kind of moving and changing around us.

TH:

Yeah.

JE:

I think that’s the thing that we kind of pop our heads up and go, oh, my goodness, this is a completely different world to when I went into my shell. Now I’m coming out and I’m looking around going, things have changed.

TH:

Yeah.

So, Jan, it is time for the extra question. I need you to pick a number between…

This is the bit where I ask guests an extra question. It’s sometimes a slightly silly one.

And dehoarding darlings get access to this extra question and the answer. If you would like to become a dehoarding darling, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling.

Okay, back to the podcast.

So, Dr. Jan Eppingstall, if people want to find you online, if they want to find out a bit more about you or get in touch or see what you’re up to, what is the one best place to do that?

JE:

I think head on over to the website, go to stuffology.com.au and feel free to just browse around.

I’m getting ready to do a refresh of my website, so any feedback? I’d love that. That’d be great.

But yeah, just come on over there. You can email me from there. You can comment there, whatever you would like.

TH:

Fabulous. So, Jan, thank you very much. That’s been really interesting.

I really think that this uncertainty thing is so core to so many aspects of hoarding disorder.

It kind of permeates all the different factors, doesn’t it? Yeah, I think this is a really core issue.

JE:

Yeah. And after doing a deep dive there, I found some things that I thought I could incorporate myself.

TH:

Amazing.

JE:

Definitely very worthwhile. And thank you.

May we take a moment to reflect on the meaning of place and acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land on which we record and listen to this podcast.

Today, I am speaking on the lands of the Boon Wurrung people of the Kulin Nation, and I acknowledge their connection to country, both land and sea and culture.

We pay our respects to their elders, past and present, and extend that respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples listening today.

It’s the bit where that hoarder shouts out someone wise.

TH:

So shout out this week to friend of this very podcast, Paige Pritchard, talking on her own podcast, the Money Love Podcast.

Have a listen.

Paige Pritchard:

I feel like 80% of the time, in most instances, for most people, we already have what we need.

Going back to the running example, most of us already have a pair of tennis shoes and most of us already have clothes that we can wear running. It’s like you don’t need to go out and do all the aspirational spending and get all of the new things, just start running.

Because the running, the activity, is how you’re actually going to develop your identity as a runner. Having an Apple watch and a new pair of tennis shoes, that does not make you a runner, nor is it going to help reinforce your identity as a runner.

So use what you have and if you don’t have it, try to borrow one from a friend.

I think between what we already have and then being able to borrow things from other people, that should really cover 95% of use cases of things that we would need.

TH:

Okay, thank you for listening and I will speak to you next time.

Thank you for listening to That Hoarder: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast. It’s been a pleasure to have you on board.

You can find all the links I’ve mentioned and a transcript of the episode online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk to find out more about how you can support this, this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support

And do subscribe to the podcast so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.

There may be links in this podcast that earn me money. This doesn’t come at any extra cost to you if you make a purchase through those links. And it helps to support the podcast.

 

 

 

Audio credits