Show notes
- FlyLady
- Podcast ep 42: Motivation and hoarding with Dr Jan Eppingstall
- Podcast ep 46: Tiny habits and micro-movements with Dr Jan Eppingstall
- Randomly RemindMe app (Android – it doesn’t seem to have an iPhone version but I’m sure there are equivalents)
- @domesticblisters on TikTok
- Nobody Panic podcast
- Website: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding
- Questions to ask when dehoarding: https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/podquestions
- Twitter: @ThatHoarder
- TikTok: @thathoarderoch https://www.tiktok.com/@thathoarderoch
- Facebook: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- YouTube: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Reddit: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder subreddit
- Help out: Support this project
- Sponsor the podcast
Subscribe
- Apple Podcasts / iTunes
- Google Podcasts
- Spotify
- RSS
- iHeartRadio
- Amazon Music
- Audible
- Stitcher
- Podchaser
- Pandora
- Deezer
- Podcast Addict
- Player FM
- Podcast Index
- TuneIn and Alexa
- Castro
Audio credits
- Intro and outro music: grapelemon
- Ding dong: MatthewWong
- Transition whoosh: Vilkas_Sound
Transcript
Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder. Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk and find the links there to follow me on Twitter, Facebook, Reddit and all over the place.
So today I’m going to talk about routines. Now don’t switch off at that idea! It’s about how I hated them, I resisted them, I was scared of them. And how I tentatively, tentatively, slowly, slowly started to successfully incorporate some into my life. Obviously, with regard to dehoarding, that’s the main thing.
And so I have a really complicated history of routines. And most of it isn’t pretty. I have a long history of hating them, basically.
I resisted routines at every turn, because I was convinced I couldn’t do them. They scared me. And every time I tried to set up a new routine, I failed, I failed, I could not do it.
And so I don’t know whether or not wanting to engage in routines came before or after I repeatedly failed at them. I suspect there was an element of vicious cycle in there. I don’t know if I hated them before I realised I couldn’t do them. Or if I hated them because I realised I couldn’t do them. But I spent a good few years avoiding anything that could be vaguely considered to be a routine.
It was just something I figured some people can do it, some people can’t. And I can’t. I gave up trying.
Because as well as feeling like I couldn’t stick to a routine, and indeed proving repeatedly that I couldn’t stick to a routine, I thought that they confined me too much. They felt controlling. I wanted freedom in my life, I wanted flexibility. Routines felt like they were oppressive and controlling and limiting. And that if I had a routine set up, it meant I couldn’t do what I wanted, or I couldn’t do something else.
I needed the opportunity to be spontaneous, basically. And I needed that so strongly that putting things in place with set times and set plans scared me and felt oppressive.
I needed the opportunity to be spontaneous, basically. And I needed that so strongly that putting things in place with set times and set plans scared me and felt oppressive. Share on XBut the irony was that I wasn’t often spontaneous. At all! I restrict myself in far more ways than a routine ever could. But I guess I wanted the option to be spontaneous, I wanted it to be there as a possibility.
And occasionally, I would start a routine that would feel okay. It would be small, it wouldn’t be a demanding one. So for a while, I got into quite a good habit of every Monday cleaning the toilet and the bath and the bathroom sink. And I did it for a while, maybe two months. But even when I had some success like that, I would stick to it for a bit, before it would either dwindle away, like I’d forget one week and then I would maybe do it the next and then forget the next and I was just out of the habit by then and it would dwindle away. Or the alternative was that I would deliberately abandon the routine, feeling like I was breaking free from my shackles. And I would feel good at leaving behind the controlling routine.
So as you can tell, I haven’t had the healthiest psychological relationship with even the very idea of routines. So it was never working for me.
Years ago, like 20 years ago, I came across FLYlady. And I haven’t looked at FLYlady’s stuff for a good 10 years, so I don’t know if this is still the setup. But at the time, I was very enthusiastic about it and I signed up. And basically, I signed up for emails, and I would get like 10 emails a day, throughout the day saying, you should be cleaning your sink now, or now it’s time to do the laundry. And I felt… these emails were relentless. And I felt like to stick to it, I had to have nothing else in my life. And maybe that is FLYlady‘s target audience, maybe it’s, you know, people who don’t have jobs or commitments or other things to do. But it seemed to me, or it felt to me, this is a very personal thing, I’m not criticising her approach for everybody. But my own experience of it was that it was the worst of everything I feared and hated about routines. It was all about not being able to do anything other than focus on the state of the house and trying to fix it.
So that was the kind of routine that, when I left it behind, I felt like I was breaking free. That was the kind of routine, and that kind of approach to routines, was the kind of thing that I left Behind with joy.
And again, not a great attitude. Well, I think, my attitude to that on its own was fine, because it really didn’t suit me. What wasn’t fine was that I extrapolated that to therefore mean that all routines were overwhelming, and limiting, and a nightmare.
And that’s where it went wrong. I went FLYlady doesn’t work for me, therefore, trying to have any kind of plan or regularity in place is a disaster.
And I think part of my resistance to routines was that I had failed at them so often that I felt like trying to create new ones was setting myself up for failure. It wasn’t just that it might or might not work. It was if I set this up, I will fail again. And that will feel terrible. So it’s almost irresponsible to try.
I didn’t want to set myself up for failure. That’s pretty miserable. I’ve got plenty of things in my life that I feel I’ve failed at. I don’t want to create more that I can list off in my dark moments as proof that I’m a failure.
And so every time I would fail to hold on to a routine, fail to stick to a routine, this became… it was like it was further evidence, basically, that routines and me did not mix. They were just something I couldn’t do, full stop.
I would see blog posts or tweets or TikTok videos about something like meal planning and just shudder a bit. To be honest, I still do a bit with meal planning. I really don’t work in that way. But I’ve got no desire to plan my meals so I don’t feel like I’m missing out or failing. That’s not how my appetite or my energy levels work.
But I’d see people talk about things like oh, every Monday evening, I do this, every Sunday morning. I do that. And I would wonder how on earth they did that. How did they manage that? How did they stick to it without hating it and without resenting every minute of it? How did they not know that if they would due to, I don’t know, hoover the hallway at seven o’clock on a Monday, how did they not dread seven o’clock on a Monday from about four o’clock every week?
It’s so beyond the way I approach life, I couldn’t work it out.
And it’s interesting because, as you all know, I am in a process a long, slow, long, slow process of dehoarding. And people think that there are two real ways to approach this. One is in a very planned, structured way. And one is in a very spontaneous, as-the-mood-strikes-you way. And what I’m finding, having been doing this for some time now, is that for me, and I suspect for a lot of people, what works the best isn’t fully spontaneous, or fully planned, but a combination of the two.
And doing some dehoarding, decluttering, tidying, throwing, whatever, when the mood strikes, you is great, I am absolutely a proponent of tapping into that motivation and making the most of it when it appears. Because I find that they’re the moments I can really get a fair amount done. But if you spend your whole life waiting for inspiration to strike, you might wait a really long time to get anything done.
And the thing is that once you start taking action, whether that is spontaneously or in a planned way, that can lead to more action. You get in the habit a bit, you get… it’s like when you haven’t ridden a bike for years, and you try and it’s all seized up and the wheels won’t turn. And then you stick some oil in and slowly the wheels start to turn, but you’ve got to keep turning them, just a bit, once in a while, so that they don’t seize up again.
So sometimes you have to kind of force the dehoarding process in order to take some action so that that can then remind you that you know how to do it, reassure you that it’s not awful. And all of those ingredients that make you, later the same day or later the same week think, oh, maybe I’ll just tackle that corner as well while I’m at it.
So what I’m finding is that some planned dehoarding and some spontaneous dehoarding seems to be working the best for me.
So if I spot something and I want to work on it, I absolutely do. I don’t believe in suppressing that if you have the time and the ability and the will, then go for it. But I also try to incorporate a few small routines into my days. Now these are things that are pretty small in themselves, but can be expanded on. And they also work on the principle that if you’ve been listening for any amount of time you will know I live by, and that is that a little bit is better than nothing. So a little bit on a regular basis is better than nothing on a regular basis.
I’ll be back in a sec.
Hey collectors, this is Rachel Seavey, host of the Hoardganize podcast. My podcast is chock full of tips and tricks on how to overcome compulsive hoarding disorder and chronic disorganisation. I’d love for you to tune in so that you can learn about why you save things, and how to help yourself or how to help a family member or friend who struggles with clutter. You can find me at hoardganize.com Or download my podcast on any of your favourite podcast app.
If you haven’t listened to the last two episodes I did with Dr. Jan Eppingstall, do. I will link to them in the show notes because both episodes, which are about creating habits, are full of gold. They gave me new ideas, but they also came up with, well, Jan herself and the research she did, came up with detailed explanations for why I’ve been more successful in the last year of trying to create routines than I have in the last 20 years of trying to create routines.
Because it turns out that some of the things I’ve started doing are exactly what experts recommend. And part of this is as a result of chance. Part of it is a result of learning what does and doesn’t work for me. And part of it is a result of reading and research and trying to work out how I can do better.
So when I started picking up five things, every time I go in the bathroom – which I do, every time I go in the bathroom, I pick up five things that are not where they’re meant to be and I put them either in the bin, or whether they’re supposed to be in the bathroom, or whether they’re supposed to be in the rest of the house.
So when I started doing that, I didn’t know that there are researched psychological explanations for why that would work. But there are, which I learned in those two episodes with Jan, which I will link to in the show notes. And similarly, when I started taking rubbish bags out with me every time I left the house, I didn’t know that there were researched, psychological explanations for why that works as well. But there are.
And so it was quite gratifying, and I guess validating, to hear her explain those mechanisms and be able to think, okay, that’s why that’s working. And so these are kind of the key ingredients for when I try and add something else to my routines.
So Jan, explains, far better than I can. But the gist is that they are actions that are both attached to things that I was already doing, like going in the bathroom, like leaving the house, but also with a bit of stretch. So it’s adding something that’s not million miles from what I’m already doing. But is just a little bit, a little bit further.
Now, part of even classifying these things as routines has, for me, involved shifting what I understand a routine to be. I am never going to be the kind of person who cleans the bathroom at 10 o’clock on a Monday morning and the kitchen at four o’clock on a Tuesday afternoon. That degree of planning doesn’t work for me. And what I’m learning is that it doesn’t have to work for me.
What I need is not what works for Gillian down the road or Meera on the internet. What works for me is what works for me and it doesn’t matter if that’s the same as what works for you or your next-door neighbour or your sister.
So, I would have classified routines very much as the 10am Monday morning you do this, kind of thing. But when I relaxed that definition a bit, and when, okay, it’s something I try to do on a regular basis with some kind of structure, then that fitted and it also didn’t tap into that bit of my brain quite so much that was afraid of trying.
I need flexibility within the routines I set up. But that’s okay. It’s okay. You may need absolutely rigid structure. And that is also okay.
I’m learning what works for me and what doesn’t work for me. And the only way I’m learning is by trying things. I have spent a lot of my life trying to think of solutions to things without trying or testing anything. I kind of believed that one day I would work it out, kind of intellectually and then once I done that, I’d be fine and I could just do the whole thing.
What has become clear is that that’s not how progress works. And that what works is trying something not with the approach of saying this is the complete solution. But with the approach of saying, I’m going to try this and see which aspects of it work and which don’t. And then once I’ve assessed that, I can ask myself if there’s a way I can slightly adapt it. Say, I like this aspect of it, can I do more of that, and less of the bit that I hate, that kind of thing.
So a big key is that in the past, I would try to create a new routine and I would fail at it. And I would say, see, I can’t do routines. It was 100% proof that I couldn’t do it.
So what I do now is I say, okay, that didn’t work, so – this is the key bit, right? – so it wasn’t set up quite right for me. What can I do that might make it more successful? And then I tweak it. And I do something a little bit differently and assess whether that’s easier or harder. And then I try that and say, okay, would it work better if I did it like this and test and tweak and test and tweak until I get to a place where I’m doing the thing. I’m doing the thing.
When I was having CBT, she framed all the work I did between sessions as an experiment. And that is something I have absolutely incorporated into my approach to dehoarding ever since. I don’t say, am I going to fail or succeed at this this week? I say, I’m going to try this and see how it goes and assess after that.
So the tweaking thing, like, I tried for ages to get into a routine that when I left the bedroom, every time I left my bedroom, I would pick something up from the floor on the way out. And I couldn’t do it, I kept not doing it or failing or forgetting or…. I just wasn’t, wasn’t, wasn’t getting there.
And I eventually realised that it’s it was just a practicality thing. Generally speaking, if I’m leaving my bedroom, it’s because I really want a cup of tea, or I really need a wee, or something. There’s a reason I have to be out of my bedroom quite quickly. And I don’t want to have to pause, pick something up, make a decision, decide what to do with it, all of that, when all I want is a cup of tea.
And so rather than going I tried to have a routine of picking something up every time I left the bedroom, it failed, I can’t do routines, I sat with it for a while. Because that’s the other thing, this isn’t fully an intellectual process. Sometimes you have to go okay, that’s not working and I’m not sure why; I’m going to sit with it and at some point a solution will come to me. In the meantime, try and do something different in a different part of your house.
But I couldn’t establish the bedroom one and then I thought maybe rather than trying to pick something up every time I leave the bedroom, maybe I can pick something up on my way into the bedroom. And this is quite a new realisation. I can’t fully say yet whether this is something that’s going to stick and work in the medium term or the long term. And I do keep forgetting to do it. But it’s working better than trying to pick something up every time I left my bedroom.
And it may be that I stick with this for a few weeks and then come up with an even better way. Or it may be that I stick with it for a few weeks and start to remember more effectively and it’s actually great. And I don’t know which it’s going to be, and I’m learning to be okay with that uncertainty. I don’t have to decide today whether this routine is the one I stick with, or whether this routine is still in that process of iteration. It’s still in the meh, almost, not quite, but I’m getting there way.
And if I can sit with that uncertainty and just say, I’ll keep trying this for a bit and see what happens, then I’m more likely to succeed, I’m less likely to beat myself up. And I’ll get there, whichever… whether it’s right as it is, or whether it still needs some work.
So that is a good example of how getting rid of that defeatist thing where every “failure” proved beyond a reasonable doubt that I couldn’t do it, and instead saying, okay, what can I do that’s a bit more suited to the way I live my life, means I’m tweaking and tweaking, and ultimately getting things I can stick with for longer.
Another way that I’m able to set up routines in a way that doesn’t feel controlling and oppressive is a phone app I’m using where you can set up a reminder, or as many reminders as you want, I think, and you choose how many times a day it pops up, but it does it at a random time. And so for me, twice a day, this reminder pops up that says put five things in the bin. And I’m not gonna say I put five things in the bin every time it pops up. But I am gonna say I put five things in the bin more times than if I didn’t have the reminder.
And it means that I still get the nudge from my phone, that kind of external prompt, but I don’t feel constrained in the same way that I would if my phone beeped at seven o’clock every night to put five things in the bin. That would stress me out, I would spend all of my time from five till seven waiting for the beep and resenting it and hating it and not doing it and yeah, that’s not how I work. The randomness seems to work with the kind of brain I have.
So I guess what I’m saying is that it doesn’t have to be that your dehoarding actions are 100% spontaneous, or 100% planned out. It’s not like a chart with spontaneous at one end and planned at the other end. And you can only work with zero or 100. There is room in the middle and having some kind of fluidity and picking the helpful bits from a range of approaches is often what works.
What I’m doing is I’m setting routines, but in quite a fluid way. I am also embracing my spontaneity when it hits. I’ve spent the last four or five days making incredible progress, none of which was planned. But for some reason, I’ve been sitting around and looking at things and instead of thinking that needs doing, I’ve just been doing it. And if I could bottle whatever it is, I would absolutely do so because I do not know what’s made the difference. And I’m just having to go, well take advantage of it while it lasts. It won’t last forever, I know this about myself. But as long as it’s here, I will do it. And then when it passes, that’s okay too. And I’m combining that spontaneity with some planned routines that are not in a formal timetable.
And this is how I’m starting to stop blaming myself for failing at routines. It’s how I’m not decrying all routines as either evil, or too hard, or just not a good fit. It’s how I’m taking this thing and adapting it to fit with my personality type, to fit with my energy levels, to fit with the state that my home is in.
This is how I'm starting to stop blaming myself for failing at routines and not decrying them all as either evil, or too hard, or just not a good fit. Share on XDefinitely start tiny. If you haven’t done any decluttering or sorting or tidying for 10 years, don’t set yourself a 40 hour a week timetable starting next Monday. That’s not how life works.
Start tiny, knowing that you can build on your successes if a tiny plan works out. That’s how these things kind of bed in. It’s how they become more established, rather than throwing yourself all in to a routine that can’t be sustainable, and then crashing and burning a few weeks in.
So there’s a woman on TikTok, where I definitely don’t waste too much of my time. Oh, by the way, I am on TikTok. Now, so follow me. I think I am at @ThatHoarderOCH, because somebody already had @ThatHoarder, which is rude, frankly. But go follow me if you’re on TikTok. The link is in the show notes if that username is wrong, I do think it’s that though. But yes, this woman on TikTok, I think I’ve quoted from her as a Top Tip before but she’s caught @domesticblisters. And she has done lots of trial and error and come up with what she calls her losing duties.
Have a listen to what she’s got to say.
Closing duties is how I close down my home, clock out, relax and still keep things functional. Three things that really helped are putting 25 minutes on my timer, turning on some amazing music and putting on a very cute apron.
Closing duties is a routine I came up with that basically means I have five or six things on a list that I do every single night, right as my kids are going to bed.
I don’t worry about what the rest of the house looks like, I just try and make the kitchen functional for morning me. That means running my dishwasher, even if it’s not full, wiping down the highchair for the baby in the morning, making cold brew coffee for us to drink. Then I’m going to make some space for myself on the countertop.
Again, I’m not looking for a spring clean here, I’m just looking for a functional space. The key is to choose things that are going to make morning you happy.
Here’s a very important thing on my list that I routinely forgot: getting my daughter’s lunchbox out of the car and then putting it into the freezer so it will be ready in the morning. Yes, I took the lunch out first.
Anyways, you can put care tasks like taking your meds, brushing your teeth on your closing duties lists so that they have a spot to get in the flow and get done routinely. I take out my trash, even if it’s not full, because starting with a empty trashcan makes my day better.
I always double check the list otherwise I forget things and then call it a day. I don’t worry what the rest of the house looks like, Iust worry about having a functional kitchen in the morning.
Look at that. Five minutes left. So that’s when I typically will sit down and get ready to watch something cool on Netflix, wait for my husband to come down the stairs and then we hang out.
So I will link to her in the show notes. As I will link to every episode I’ve mentioned.
Now this was not a system that @domesticblisters dreamt up one day and immediately mastered. It is something that she built up until it was right for her, both in that it was effective enough, while not being over ambitious or unrealistically hard.
Because that is ultimately what we’re all aiming for. I pick up five things every time I go in the bathroom. But when I started that, it was three things. And as I realised, after a few weeks of that, to my endless surprise, that I was making it work, I stuck with it and then raised it to four things every time I went in the bathroom. And then after I was definitely certain that I could stick with that, it’s now five things.
The trick is to not aim too high and burn out, while still keeping things bubbling over and not grinding to a halt.
Because that’s definitely one of the benefits of routines, right? If you… say you clean the bathroom sink once a week, and you really push yourself to do it even when you don’t want to, it keeps some kind of momentum going.
And it’s easier to keep going than to start in a lot of cases. I think it’s normal to have times when we’re pretty motivated and keen to make progress, and times when we hate it and don’t want to do any of it and want to hide in the corner and hope it all goes away.
So keeping some momentum going by giving yourself that push of a routine – the kind of routine that works for you, not the kind of routine that works for me, or anybody else whose blog you read or book you read, it keeps you in motion.
And it’s that balance between something that is manageable and doable and repeatable. So not too much, but enough that it has some effect. Even if it’s a small effect, you don’t want to put regular energy into something that makes no difference.
So imagine like some weighing scales, some old-fashioned weighing scales with two sides, and you’ve got to kind of balance so that one is not overtaking the other, you need something that’s effective enough and manageable enough.
And that may take some practice, it may take some work, it may take some adapting. But that’s okay because you don’t come into these things fully formed, you don’t have an idea… well, you might occasionally have an idea and it works brilliantly from the start. But most of the time, if you’re open to instead of saying I tried and it doesn’t work, instead of that to say, that’s not working for me, what is it that isn’t working? And breaking it down so you can work out what is working and what isn’t working. And then see where you can adapt it. See which little changes you can make. If the thing that’s not working for you is like me not picking something up on the way out of the bedroom, because I was normally in a rush, the key – or the first key – is to work out how I could do it when I wasn’t in a rush.
If you try to clean the kitchen before the school run every day, it’s a great goal and it could have a really good effect. But before the school run is chaos, you’re trying to get children dressed and find socks and remind them about their homework and get everybody fed and watered and hair brushed. That’s not the time, most likely, to clean the kitchen. And so then, if that’s what you try and it’s not working, you don’t say, see, routines don’t work. You say okay, cleaning the kitchen every morning is great. But before the school run isn’t working, can I do it when I get back in? Or could I get up a bit earlier? It’s about that kind of shifting… shifting a bit and saying that doesn’t work, what can I try?
So I’m finding, against all my expectations, that there are benefits to routines in my life. And I use the word routine loosely, I do not mean – as you’ll have gathered by now – strict schedules. Unless you know, that’s not what works for me – if that works for you, brilliant.
But the benefits of routines that I’m finding are that it keeps your progress in some motion, even when you’re struggling mentally or physically to make significant progress, it keeps something happening. And then, over time you can either expand them, add more, or take advantage of those moments when you feel spontaneous and motivated and just do something in the moment.
How do you find routines? Let me know. You can find all my contact details on the website. Say hi, let me know your experience of routines.
In just one second, I’ll give you my top tip of the week. In the meantime, please do subscribe to the podcast, review it (five stars would be amazing!) and share it with your friends or anyone who might be interested, or who might benefit from it. It all really helps.
To find more ways to support the website, the podcast, and my overall dehoarding project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support
Now, back to your top tip.
So this week’s top tip is a mini clip from a podcast called Nobody Panic. It’s one of my favourite podcasts. And this episode was when one of them tried out Marie Kondo. Now I have very mixed feelings about Marie Kondo and her process, which I may one day do an episode on. But in this specific bit of the episode, they’re talking about donating your things and how you can think about it if you’re feeling a bit resistant to donating or selling your stuff.
But I like to think when I give like something away to a charity shop or sell it on – I put a lot of the old things on Depop and stuff – I always am happy to do it because I’m like, someone is excited. Yeah. They’ve spotted it and gone, oh, I want that. And that coat deserves to feel like that because everyone deserves to feel loved. And I do love it but everyone deserves to be worn.
Everyone deserves to be worn.
It’s such a good one. My friend Emma was saying the other day that she had given to a charity shop a skirt that she’d like loved and worn but like and treasured, but then hadn’t worn it for years and had really been like, okay, okay, gut wrenching but like, gotta go, gotta go to the charity shop.
And then a couple of weeks later, in the same area, saw this girl walking across the park and the skirt had, it was like a long, very specifically coloured skirt, which had on it an element that Emma had customised, which is how she knew for sure this was the skirt.
And she like saw it walk across and the girl looked so proud in it. And she’d also styled it in like a totally different way than Emma would have done it, but it’s like she really felt as though the skirt like was at the end of a heist movie. Where like, like it turned just be like just to nod to the protagonist and then go its separate way of being like yeah, let the things, let them go, let them be loved, let them go. They don’t want to just live in your cupboard covered in moths, like because you’re like oh the memories, but let them go.
That does make sense to me. It’s something it’s… I quite often look at it that way, so it’s interesting that from two people who presumably are not hoarders that they have that kind of view of their items as well.
So I will link to the podcast in the show notes Thank you for listening and I will speak to you next time.
Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast. You can find more online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk
You can find me on Twitter @ThatHoarder. And on Facebook at Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder.
To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support and do subscribe to this podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.
Image: Gianmarco Concepción
