Resilience and hoarding with Dr Jan Eppingstall
Resilience and hoarding with Dr Jan Eppingstall

What is resilience, and how can we build it?

Show notes

Subscribe

Audio credits

Transcript

Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder. Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast and all my social media, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk. Finally, I am not a doctor, I’m just a hoarder doing her best, so do seek professional support if and when you need it.

That Hoarder: So I am here with Dr. Jan Eppingstall, an Australian counsellor who specialises in working with people who hoard. Jan, how are you today?

Dr Jan Eppingstall: Fabulous and yourself?

TH: Not too bad, thank you.

JE: Excellent.

TH: So today we are talking about resilience. Resilience is, I think, sometimes misunderstood. I think it’s quite important on the long journey that people who hoard go through, that we have some resilience. So, yeah, I thought it’d be good for us to talk about.

So I want to start with the word resilience itself and what it means. Because if you had asked me what it meant, before I started researching this, I’d have said it meant you could bounce back if something goes wrong.

Like people often say, kids are very resilient when something bad happens. And I think the implication is, oh, yeah, they’ll bounce back, they’ll be fine.

Resilience is the process and outcome of successfully adapting to or difficult or challenging life experiences, especially through mental, emotional and behavioural flexibility and adjustment to external and internal demands Share on X

But I looked at the American Psychological Association’s definition of resilience. And they said, “Resilience is the process and outcome of successfully adapting to or difficult or challenging life experiences, especially through mental, emotional and behavioural flexibility and adjustment to external and internal demands”.

That is clearly more complex than I had originally thought.

So in psychological terms, it seems like resilience is more about adapting and flexibility than it is to do with just recovery. Is that fair?

JE: Exactly. So the bouncing back is not the only part of resilience. Grit, which is the perseverance and consistency of effort, like that kind of stick-to-it-edness, if you like, of getting up every time you get knocked down. It’s part of resilience, but not the only part.

I kind of think there’s something a bit psychopathic and obsessive about continuing to do the same thing over and over until you find success. I mean, that’s, that’s not resilience. It is that adapting and being able to flexibly interact with what’s happened, what’s going to happen next, etc.

But yeah, lots of people have got that “oh it’s bouncing back. All you have to do is just get up again and try again”. It’s more than that.

TH: Yeah. So it stands out to me that flexibility and adapting are things that have come up multiple times in the podcast as things that hoarders can struggle with. Does that mean, we may be less resilient than your average person?

JE: I think… I think the answer is yes, if the average person we’re talking about is one without significant mental health challenges.

However, when we’re comparing those who hold with other mental health diagnoses, the inflexibility varies in the form it takes.

So, as we spoke last time, psychological inflexibility, as described in ACT is that flipside of healthy psychological flexibility, and we’re all inflexible in some way. So those who hoard are strongly inflexible kind of in a couple of areas, fusion with beliefs, and the idea that their thoughts are true and should be abided by, like this rule-governing behaviour.

They’re also very inflexible in the area of avoidance, the avoidance of internal experiences that they push down or away or turn away from.

And also the other one is attachment to the self-story they’ve created over time. And living within that story is also high for people who hoard.

But in my experience, one of the things I don’t think we’ve talked about is the ego-syntonic nature of hoarding, which means that the behaviour fits with the person’s view of the world and their understanding of the self.

And that makes the inflexibility seem rational.

TH: Okay.

JE: So those sorts of ego-syntonic disorders, the behaviour, you can kind of rationalise it, ah, well, this is good. Something like maybe anorexia nervosa: being healthy and watching what I eat is is a logical decision that I’m making. Hoarding: I’m preparing myself for future difficult times, or maybe I’m attempting to recycle in the perfect way.

So they’re less likely to learn the skills or enhance their current levels of resilience, because this is rational!

TH: Sure.

JE: And the ego-dystonic nature of other disorders like OCD, for example, means people with this tendency can kind of see intellectually that their thoughts and behaviours are not rational, but are unable to change without support.

So they’re more likely to seek out treatment and therefore enhance their resilience.

TH: Yeah, that makes sense. That makes sense. So the American Psychological Association, again, they say “The resources and skills associated with more positive adaptation, i.e. greater resilience, can be cultivated and practised”.

And I definitely found that encouraging to hear. So it’s something we can learn rather than something you just either possess or don’t possess?

JE: Yes, but some of us are born with a resilient personality. Those who demonstrate this trait have that dispositional optimism and more of an internal locus of control.

We all know those people who seem a bit like a weeble remember those? “Weebles wobble, but they don’t fall down”, that’s so showing my age! I’m sorry, everyone.

But there’s those people who you just see, and they just keep coming back, and they keep adapting. And you’re like, wow!

Some of us are born with that type of personality. And perhaps there hasn’t been trauma impacting how they develop as an individual.

Research into resilience does indicate that we can practice and develop our resilience. And that starts with awareness, then acceptance of where we are right now and a plan to build on our strengths and weaknesses. Share on X

But the research into resilience in the sphere of positive psychology does indicate that we can practice and develop our resilience. And that starts with awareness, then acceptance of where we are right now and a plan to build on our strengths and weaknesses.

TH: It’s always reassuring to find out that if there’s a quality you want to improve on, that it is something improvable within you, isn’t it? Rather than I’ve got that, or I’ve not got that.

JE: Exactly. And I think we’re learning more and more, particularly in the last kind of 15 to 20 years with the focus around positive psychology, that humans are pretty damn amazing. And they can learn new things and behave in new ways.

And that’s something that’s really inspiring for someone like me, who’s working with people, because I always come at my work from that perspective, thinking, what is it that this person coming to me, what do they have that’s in their skill set? They’ve got all these skills let’s, what can we do? What can we do with those skills? How can we develop them? How can we help them build other skills?

Everybody has something they’re really good at. And that’s what I love about the expansion of this idea of positive psychology that has come about, moving away from that disease kind of model, that medical model of mental health. It’s refreshing.

TH: Because I know in my experience, things that my brain came up with to cope with difficult stuff, to cope with various traumas used to be treated as very pathological. Oh, you’re dissociating. That’s bad. We must stop it, for instance.

Until one day somebody said, like you’re dissociating, isn’t that genius? Like, how clever is your brain? That when you were 11, you learnt… you didn’t even learn from anybody. You just thought I know what I’ll do! And disappeared.

And that, it’s a form of resilience, all of these coping mechanisms. And the same with self-harm, another thing that I have experience of. That was always, this is something we must eliminate. Until somebody framed it as, Wow, that’s serving a purpose for you. And hopefully we can get you to a point where that’s not how you cope with things, or where you don’t need to cope, things are improved, so you’re not having to cope as much.

But even something like hoarding is a way of coping with difficult thoughts and feelings and emotions, which is kind of a form of resilience, even if, like with dissociation, like with self-harm, it’s not the ideal way of doing it. It’s still… there’s something in there about… it’s not just lying down and not coping.

JE: Hmm, exactly. And I think one of the things that initial research came up with and I think now, there’s been a few different studies that were a bit more ambiguous, but initially, the thought was hoarding was an alternative to PTSD, to having some post-traumatic stress kind of response.

And the idea was from the initial research, Ah, okay, so people that are hoarding, they’re not demonstrating those PTSD-type symptoms.

So exactly what you’re, you’re describing there is that it is a coping mechanism, and it works up to a point. And that’s what… everything kind of works up to a point.

TH: Yeah. Because you wouldn’t do it, you wouldn’t stick with it if it didn’t work?

JE: No. If it’s not doing the job… we don’t do stuff for no reason, do we? We do stuff for a result.

And there’s always a function to that behaviour. It’s not just out of the blue. So I agree. I think that’s really an important point to make.

TH: And we need to be clear that building resilience in ourselves is not about eliminating the possibility of future pain. It’s about starting to cultivate the skills so that when future pain, which is inevitable, comes, we can adapt to it more effectively. Is that right?

JE: That’s right, exactly. We can never avoid or eliminate pain. Every possible way we try, there’s a cost to our wellbeing, whether it’s physical or psychological.

Why? Because when we try to avoid or eliminate what is painful, we take ourselves further away from joy and happiness.

Short term, as we were just discussing, avoiding pain might be the best thing for us to do if we don’t have the skills and resources to deal with it.

But it’s our responsibility as members of the human race to be accountable for our actions and take every step we can, given our circumstances. And I say that caveat, and available support systems, to build our skills in order to deal with future difficulty.

Because it will come. Resilience is is really about experiencing the pain of loss and disappointment, learning the lesson and adapting so that the future is a little easier.

'Resilience is is really about experiencing the pain of loss and disappointment, learning the lesson and adapting so that the future is a little easier.' - @stuff_ology Share on X

But we still don’t know what we will come up against, we still are preparing for the future through resilience.

TH: So I read that resilience is not constant, you might find yourself with tonnes of resilience when facing one challenge, then struggle more with a different challenge.

And that made me think of how often we have skills in one area but not another.

So we might be great at science, say, but not a practical person. And then someone explains to you that cooking is basically the application of science. And then that person goes, Oh, well I can do science and grows in confidence and they know they can do it.

So I wondered, kind of therapising myself, if it would help if people identified areas in their life where they are pretty resilient already. And this probably wouldn’t be areas around like discarding and acquiring, but they might realise they’re really resilient when they get sick or if work is stressful or something.

Could that help to build your confidence? If you can say, Okay, I do have these skills, just not around discarding or acquiring, but maybe I can have the skills, maybe they’re transferable.

JE: Very, very much so. This is one of the things that I attempt to do with my clients. Often I see people who have skills at work that are not being applied at home in different contexts.

Perhaps they have a lot of organisation and commitment to work and planning their time and day in their job, but when they come home, this is completely abandoned.

And that’s usually because of the overwhelming nature of the clutter on their senses as they walk through the door.

But really, I see myself, see my job, as I lead them to the realisation that they do have the skills, and they are resilient in other parts of their lives.

Perhaps they can take action, perhaps they do have the skills. It’s all about perspective, though. And as you were saying I’m really good at science, but I can’t poach an egg, for example. It’s about that perspective of saying, Well, it’s a scientific experiment, really, these are the elements that you need.

Because we do, as I said, and I often say, we all have skills. And it’s all about how we apply those and transfer the skills that we have in other parts of our lives.

TH: Yeah, so I can’t do A, but I’m really good at B. But what bits of B, are also applicable to A?

JE: Exactly. You know, what parts of those things can I leverage? The things that I’m good at?

TH: I was thinking about how my computer files are meticulously organised, so I was going, what can I apply from my folder system on my computer to my real life?

But then I was like, but I don’t have the backup of like a search bar in my house, where I can type driving licence and it will tell me where it.

JE: Damn, I tell you, we will be millionaires if we could create that, people. Let’s do it! Create a giant database of everything you own. And where it is.

I will admit that I do have a page in my notebook, in my bullet journal, called, where did I put it? For those things that I just know, because I often, when I think of where to put something, I think, Oh, well, where will I look for it? What will be the thought process, right?

So I’ll go through that thought process and I ended up putting it in its home. Then, six months later… I don’t know, maybe I’m a different person in six months, and I go to look for it. And I think where the heck did that go?

So I’ve just started this little list. At the moment, it’s not terribly, it’s not technically savvy enough to search. But you know, I could create an Excel spreadsheet if I had more time than sense.

But yeah, sometimes it’s just weird. Where, dammit, did I put whatever it is?

TH: But if you’ve got this is my life tip. I’ve given this on the podcast before but it’s, it’s a good tip so I’m going to give it again.

If you’re going to a concert or a comedy night or something, and you’ve got tickets, but you buy them six months in advance. I was forever, obviously, I don’t know where something is six months later, obviously.

And so what I do, it’s less applicable now you often get electronic tickets, but if you get paper tickets, and they arrive, add a note in your calendar the day before the concert that says the tickets are in the second kitchen drawer, or the tickets are in the… you know, the whatever, wherever they are.

And you don’t have to remember them and you don’t have to lose them because the day before the gig, you’re like Ah, thank you Past me. I know where they are now.

JE: Exactly. Past Me was being good to Future Me and that’s when the world continues to spin. That’s brilliant, great tip.

TH: It’s a good tip.

So resilience theory says there are factors that help build resilience. So I thought we could go through them and you could just expand on them a bit and how they apply to hoarding in particular.

So one is social support. I often hear that a lot of people who hoard have a lack of social support.

I think I’m really lucky in that I have a incredible friendship group. And I do have that, but from what I understand a lot of people don’t.

JE: Yes. First, before we just touch on social support, it’s helpful to understand that these factors we’re going to talk about are all interrelated. So I’ll point out some of the ways in which hoarding can negatively impact these really resilient factors, if you like.

So social support, there’s a strong relationship between it and mental health. So lower rates of anxiety and depression, higher self-esteem, greater empathy.

What’s important to note about social support is that it is perceived social support that is important.

TH: Okay.

JE: So for people who hoard there can be a distinct mismatch between the support those around them perceive they’re giving, and how that’s received.

Because hoarding behaviours can be rationalised and intellectualised as beneficial, as we were talking before, around that ego-syntonic nature. And as the rational person can kind of accept saving and acquiring in terms of preparedness up to a point, again, we were talking about earlier, attempting to help can be seen as the opposite of support, I guess. It can feel like an attack.

Often there is social support available, but it might be confronting because it strikes at the heart of what the person believes is their reason for being.

And that I think is really key, that perceived social support is what is the factor, particularly for hoarding,

TH: Which makes me think… you brought up anorexia earlier, same as trying to persuade an anorectic to eat. For that person, it feels like an attack on their very being.

JE: Exactly, exactly. And that makes anorexia nervosa and hoarding particularly difficult to treat. Because you can’t really use those cognitive behavioural rational Socratic methods to question is that real? Is that truth? It just doesn’t work.

So I think that’s one of the things that comes up quite often when working with people. It is striking at the heart of what they believe in and what they believe is right.

TH: Yeah. So another factor is self-esteem.

JE: Yes, so I think the point with self-esteem, I don’t really like… I don’t, self-esteem is a tricky one, because it’s been given a bit of a bad rap, because of the things we did in the 80s with giving everybody a trophy, etc.

So I tend to use self-worth in its place. But our perception of who we are is integral to our sense of self-worth. So self-awareness and understanding the real you is essential in making change in your life, which I think we have mentioned in the past.

So for those who hoard, often there is a sense of ambivalence and lack of understanding about who they are, that perhaps leads to difficulty making decisions and ending up getting all the stuff, you don’t know which person you are, if you think we talked about, am I a frog? Or am I a strawberry? I don’t know. I don’t know! I’ll get both! And what their values are and what their true personality is, and what they’re capable of hasn’t been explored.

And that’s often due to trauma responses that are actually helping – attempting to help us by slipping the person into fight flight or freeze collapse, or please and appease.

I mean, it’s really difficult to find out what you can do to improve yourself-worth if you can’t stay connected to your cortex long enough to try.

Often there’s that sense of helplessness and hopelessness from people because when they try to approach the hoard, their nervous system stops them from engaging, so they stop trying. And that significantly impacts your self-esteem, your self-worth, your self-efficacy. And you don’t know if you can do it because, right in that moment, your nervous system is stopping you.

TH: And that makes me think of times when I’ve thought for the sake of my self-esteem, I need to not try to fix this. Because trying to fix it is so disheartening that if I don’t try… it feels, yeah, it’s dangerous to try because it’s so damaging to my self-esteem when I can’t do it. So it’s safer to continue just oblivious.

JE: Exactly. And that’s our perfectionistic tendencies, isn’t it? If we don’t try then we can say, we weren’t bothered. It’s like the test at school. I didn’t study and if I do really well, and didn’t study, then awesome, or tell everybody I didn’t study. And if I did poorly, oh, well, I didn’t study so it doesn’t matter.

You know, we do want to try and maintain our self-esteem when we can, and you’re right, it feels safer to us to not try.

JE: Yeah, I always did very, very well at school. And I remember working really hard on a particular piece of work and doing fine, but not super well. And it nearly killed me. Because I was used to doing super well on an average amount of effort and then I put a lot of effort in and did meh and yeah, it destroyed me.

JE: Exactly.

TH: Another factor, coping skills.

JE: So there are healthy and unhealthy ones, coping strategies.

TH: Which is what we were saying before. Self-harming or talking it out.

JE: Exactly. So the strategies that I see often in those I work with are often ineffective and they actually exacerbate many of their mental health problems. Like some things like busyness or suppressing emotions, toxic positivity in some cases, everything’s roses all the time, over-analysing, overthinking, isolation or venting, substance abuse, impulse shopping and acquiring. As you said, overeating, under-eating, self-harm, denial, sometimes, behavioural disengagement.

Learning alternative coping styles as substitutes is really important. And when we use unhealthy coping behaviours, we’re less honest with ourselves and those closest to us. Not because we want to be deceitful but because we just haven’t stopped doing the coping behaviour long enough to see what we might be able to do without it.

It’s kind of: just keep on the treadmill

TH: Yep. So another factor that comes up a lot in resilience theory is communication skills. How does that apply?

JE: So our ability to ask for and receive social support is mediated by our communication skills. First, we have to accept that we need support, then we need to kind of decipher what help we need. And then it’s important we communicate those needs in order to receive the support.

I mean, this is difficult, relationships are hard.

If we’re pushing down or avoiding our reality, asking for help is often also pushed aside and impossible.

And when you’re isolated as well, often people will isolate because there’s a sense of shame and guilt around how did I get in this position? You know, what was I thinking etc. And then it just makes communicating so difficult and actually saying, I need you to help me is incredibly, incredibly difficult.

TH: It is and I know I’ve been in relationships where I… I’m thinking of one ex in particular. I need somebody to say to me, will you do this, or I need you to do this. Whereas my ex would be frustrated because I wasn’t psychic. And I didn’t know what I was meant to be doing.

And it was a frustration on both sides. You know, my ex was frustrated because I didn’t get what was needed. I was frustrated because she was annoyed at me for something I didn’t know I was meant to be… there are communication styles aren’t there? And some people like me, I need to be I need… I think a lot of people are not psychic! And so people need to say quite clearly, I would really appreciate it if you would do this or it would help me a lot if you would do this.

But as you say that’s really hard to say. Because if you say it outright and that and the other person says no. That’s really, really hard.

JE: If you’re rejected when you ask for it, because that is that is one of the really difficult things about relationships. You aren’t psychic, you can’t read their mind. But there’s this idea that if you love me or if you care about me, you will know what I need, what I want, etc. You know, it’s that kind of romance, crazy stuff that we…

TH: It’s that clichéd argument of why are you annoyed at me? Well, I’m even more annoyed because you don’t know! It’s a real… you just go around in circles.

JE: Exactly. Exactly. That’s the stuff, the I don’t know if you have watched any of the Gottman, husband and wife team who do a lot of work with couples? And they can predict with something like 95% accuracy from just viewing how people communicate and fight with one another, whether their relationship will survive.

And one of the things is that saying what you want, just saying, this what I need, or this is what I want. That is one of the areas that often causes a great deal of hurt, and also just miscommunications because you think and you might try something, and it’s just completely off.

It’s just completely not what’s happening.

And just saying, Oh, God, I was actually just thinking, this is what I was thinking, just saying it aloud. And then the other person sort of says, What are you talking about? No! That’s not what I meant.

It’s just so it’s just so enlightening, when that happens. And the more you say those things out loud, chances are that person will start to really get to understand what makes you tick, and then they may, over time know, what’s happening.

But hopefully, they’ll say, I think this is what’s happening, rather than just assuming,

TH: Yeah, I know in that relationship, I would try and be as reassuring as I could, that if what she needed was in my power, I would do it, whatever it was. And if she would just say, then I would do it. And I think over time, it did start to be absorbed a bit. Like, okay, it is safe to say what I need, and it’s not going to be ridiculed, and it’s not going to be denied, and it’s not going to be… but you know, it’s difficult stuff.

JE: And also, when you’ve had that experience in childhood, your attachment figure may be wasn’t someone who wanted to hear what you needed, and certainly didn’t offer up what you needed. That’s when it’s very hard to break that habit in a way of relating to your partner or your friend or…

TH: Or your kids, yeah. So emotional regulation, that’s another factor.

JE: Ah, the coping skills that we’re using to regulate our emotions. I mean, that’s what those coping skills are for. Can be unhealthy or healthy.

We can also engage in coping skills, like I mentioned before, to prevent feeling any emotions before they even have a chance to come up.

So that’s avoidance. It’s regulating our emotions, but in a way that takes away the joy and spice of life.

So emotion regulation and coping skills, inexplicably linked.

TH: Yeah, absolutely. The ways somebody views and engages with the world, that’s quite a big one.

JE: It is actually, there’s lots of elements to that. The way a person sees the world affects their ability to effectively communicate the support that they need and their level of self-worth and the strategies that they use to cope: are they a glass half empty? Do they feel like things happen to them? Rather than they’re in control of what’s happening… that external locus of control, which is common in a lot of a lot of people who have mental health issues.

Do they believe in signs and magical thinking? Are they waiting for the light bulb to strike? Do they have a growth or fixed mindset? That will significantly impact whether they believe they’re able to learn use new things and new skills, so that they can actually improve their resilience.

But the ways we see the world, that’s a really tough one, because that’s tied into all of our values, our experience, possibly even some epigenetic kind of situations going on. So It is a tricky one.

TH: The availability and quality of social resources is another factor in resilience.

JE: Yeah, so seeking out and asking support and assistance from family, neighbours, community, the church or agencies or whatever, is really difficult for people who hoard. As we’ve mentioned, the shame, suspicion, fear of rejection can hold us back.

And many may not see these social resources as accessible, because in order to take advantage, they have to admit, I need help, and also accept the help that’s offered. Because we have different opinions about what needs to happen for your safety, or you know, or helping you with decluttering, or significantly reducing the amount of possessions you have in your home.

That is where it’s… that’s the centre of the matter, isn’t it?

What you think you need and what others believe you need can be quite different.

They need to communicate their needs effectively, manage their emotions when the help is being delivered. And then problem solve, when things get difficult.

It’s all of it moulded into one and they might have available and quality resources, they might have that access, but it’s about their perception of whether that’s the right thing.

TH: Yeah, if somebody offers to help, but then you can’t cope with the emotions when things leave the house, then you’re back to where you started.

JE: So it doesn’t actually matter whether they’re available and quality in that way.

TH: So yeah, so as you said, at the start of this bit, it is all interconnected, isn’t it? It’s the same things all mapped together.

JE: Exactly. They all kind of contribute to one another. And if you can, I guess, work on one area, then chances are it will change those other areas, and therefore you’ll probably get more of an exponential growth of resilience, because they do all inter-relate.

TH: Yeah, strengthening one bit… strengthening your social support might improve your self-worth.

JE: And you get to practice the communication skills and you get to see what resources are out there and attempt to engage with those.

TH: And the final one on the list, I don’t know whether this is covered under coping skills, I don’t quite know how it’s different, was specific coping strategies.

JE: Ahh. It’s some of those other things we talked about, but for those of us who hoard, our coping strategies, saving acquiring disengaging, isolation, overanalysing, overthinking, and our hoard is our strategy to have our needs met. Therefore, finding other healthy ways to meet these needs, again, is central to improving health.

And I think they’re talking there about depending on what this person, this individual, how this person presents in the world, what are the specific coping strategies they might use? And for hoarding, those are the things that are typical.

TH: That makes sense. That makes sense.

So research shows that resilient people have greater levels of wellbeing, less overwhelm, better life satisfaction, and lower stress levels, which all sounds idyllic. But these aren’t people with perfect lives though, are they?

JE: Certainly not. I mean, it’s a bit of a kind of mind twister, but to build resilience, you need to get up and try again.

But resilience can actually literally save your life. In fact, my dear friends, Peta and Stuart Taylor have a profound story about the power of cultivating resilience. I met them… I want to say a long time ago, when they were both studying psychology at night, I started my studies and I met them in one of the night classes, and they were building their business and raising four young children.

So we kind of clicked, we were study buddies instantly. And I didn’t actually know their story until a while later.

After being diagnosed with brain cancer in 2001, and given three to four years to live, Stuart realise that that kind of hamster wheel of corporate life was literally killing him. So he and his wife Peta decided to change tack and get off that treadmill.

I mean, it’s a pretty big ask, you’ve got four children, and they were little. And you’re attempting to remain healthy after brain surgery, and build this new business.

But they discovered positive psychology and in particular resilience.

So since that time, they’ve worked with hundreds of organisations, large and small, they work with government departments, etc, to improve the resilience of management and staff.

And they’re on the cutting edge of resilience research. And they’re just amazing humans.

Stuart is still with us, contributing fully to build our understanding of resilience, especially burnout, and how that relates how that relates to COVID-19, etc.

And he’s encouraging radical change in the corporate world.

He’s currently undergoing some treatment. But Stuart has lived 17 years longer than predicted.

TH: That’s incredible.

JE: It’s just incredible. They’re founders of an organisation called Springfox. And they really have – and we’ll put those links in the show notes – they’ve dedicated their lives to helping others build resilience in organisations across Australia.

So shout out to Stuart and Peta and family for your continued love and support. Stuart has actually written a book called Assertive Humility: Emerging from the Ego Trap, which I highly recommend.

TH: I like the sound of that!

JE: Yeah, I will put a link to the show notes for the ebook. He defines assertive humility as having more care and compassion for others and yourself while your behaviour and decisions are consistent with your values and beliefs.

TH: Well it’s got values in, so I know that check several of your boxes already!

JE: It’s ticked my box.

I also highly recommend you check out Peta’s podcast. She has a podcast called Resilience Real-Time. It’s corporate related. But you know, you can hear her dulcet tones, speaking with clarity and authority in an Aussie accent about this important concept

TH: Amazing, I’ll put that in the show notes as well.

JE: I think she’s got about 30 or 40 episodes, and they’re about sort of 20-30 minutes type thing. But I think that’s a really, really amazing story about how resilience can change your life.

TH: Absolutely. And if resilience can help people who hoard to get to a point where they heard less, that changes their life.

So we know that to improve our self-esteem, coping skills, emotional regulation, none of these are small tasks. Each of those already feels like a life’s work!

So where can we start if we want to start improving our resilience, particularly in relation to hoarding and acquiring?

JE: Yeah. So again, the fact that all of these areas are inter-related and they impact each other, this means that working on one will boost the others, or it will highlight where you need to go next, which I think is really a nice signpost.

So self-worth and self-compassion are impacted by our understanding of who we are and our strengths and weaknesses. So hearing people when they tell us we’re good at something, especially when it’s outside of the sphere of our home environment, and applying it to our problem is important.

So case in point, this podcast, you’re using your exemplary communication skills, research, social skills, your self-awareness and insight into your specific hoarding struggles to help yourself and others. Perfect example.

And that then builds your self-esteem. So it’s a nice little almost perfect case study of ways to improve self-esteem.

TH: Aww I like that, yeah

JE: Definitely. And this is also building your social connections. For you, they’re across the world, for people who are hoarding, maybe it’s applying some of those skills that you’ve got.

But now you’ve made a difference not only in your own life, but in 1000s of others, who will hopefully then pass the wisdom on.

So that is really a nice little case study for the whole idea of resilience.

Understanding that emotions are not something to be gotten rid of, or pushed aside is super important. They have something to tell us.

TH: Sorry, I didn’t mean to laugh at that but it obviously hit something in me!

JE: It hit the funny bone.

It’s only when we’ve pushed them aside for so long, in so many types of situations that they become unreliable.

So starting to feel emotions again, positive and negative, allows us to hear the messages our whole being is trying to tell us.

And remember, if you push down negative emotions, you’re unable to fully experience all the positive emotions like joy, happiness, love and excitement that life offers.

So some of the things you can be doing to cultivate healthy coping strategies are things like cognitive reframing, or the CBT technique, I like to call it cognitive reappraisal, because I think that sounds a bit less, I don’t know CBT ish, can improve resilience. Or diffusion in ACT, which is accepting the thought or emotion or image or whatever it is, and creating that gap between stimulus and response.

You know, things like I’m having the thought that I suck at decluttering. Thanks, mind for trying to protect me by keeping me home. I know you mean well, but I’m going to the therapist. That sort of stuff is going to build your resilience to actually step up and do the things that you want.

TH: So like, I can see that this is what my instincts are saying. But I don’t have to believe that.

JE: Exactly.

TH: I can just say, Oh, look, there we are.

JE: There it is. It’s popped up again thanks. I know, you really do just want to keep me safe. That’s all you want. I know that, but I can handle it.

Because often, I think the emotions that pop up are often eight years old. And they’re kind of going this is scary, don’t do it, don’t do it, stay at home and you’re like, Oh, that’s so sweet. But I am actually 50 now, and I can cope. You’re so sweet to worry about me. But I’m going down this path.

And I guess it’s cognitive reframing, reappraisal or whatever. But that is a really important coping mechanism to start to cultivate.

Meditation and breathing techniques, for those who are experiencing nervous system hijacking. This can help. So investigating ways of meditating especially. Remember that meditation isn’t only sitting on the cushion, you know? There’s lots of different ways you can do it. You can do walking meditations you can listen to some meditation app or something, it doesn’t have to just be sitting there, “om”, it’s a bit more than that.

And it’s worth it’s worth learning more of those techniques.

TH: Yeah, because some people respond really well, to a guided meditation, don’t they? Where they’re imagining themselves… Other people can’t stand that and need something very quiet, or they need music to be on or they need… and you don’t know until you try, I guess.

JE:  And the other thing is, often when people have had a great deal of trauma, meditating and sitting on the cushion can be too much for the nervous system.

So perhaps try yoga or walking meditation, something that keeps you in your body can be more helpful.

TH: Yeah, that’s very much my experience. I can’t just sit with my thoughts. I just can’t, it’s a no. And so yeah, if I can have some kind of focus, whether that’s on moving in a considered way or something like that, it becomes less terrifying and kind of less potentially overwhelming.

JE: Exactly, exactly. And that’s important to take into account when you choose some type of meditation to practice.

TH: And mindfulness isn’t the same as meditation, but obviously, they’re very linked. And I remember there was… I can’t remember what it was called… But for a while, there was like the book on mindfulness and mental health by Thich Nhat Hanh. And one of the first examples in that book is about washing the dishes mindfully. And rather than going, I’m doing this so that I can then go and sit down and put the TV on, you just focus on exactly what you’re doing.

And I remember I, when I read that book, I decided that for one cup of tea a day, I would have a really mindful cup of tea. And appreciate every sip, and appreciate every moment of it.

And what I discovered was because obviously, obviously, tea is brilliant.

JE: Obviously

TH: And taking five minutes out of my day, to appreciate even more, just gave me the best cup of tea of the day, by far. Because every mouthful was like, oh, that’s the perfect temperature, or like, oh, that tastes really…

And it gets away from that thing where you pick your mug up, and it’s empty, and you haven’t even noticed that you’ve drunk it.

JE: Exactly.

TH: And this making me think I need to get back into having a mindful cup of tea every day. Because that, for me, is something I can do far more easily than sitting cross legged for half an hour, thinking calm thoughts.

JE: Exactly, that’s going to make a much bigger impact for you, the mindful cup of tea, or whether it’s, yeah, washing the dishes or something that you do that you enjoy.

This is embarrassing for me to admit, but mine is folding clothes. Sorry, don’t hate me. Mine is folding clothes. And I fold them very, very, very mindfully. And I you know, look at the garment and I check it and you know, that was my thing.

TH: There’s a woman on TikTok whose whole account is folding clothes, and people are obsessed with her. Even just watching, it’s a beautifully relaxing. To watch this woman will folding anything, it’s not just clothes, she does fitted sheets, she’s a pro.

JE: That’s my favourite fitted sheets. Love it.

TH: You just need a TikTok account and you’ll be the next folding clothes woman on TikTok.

JE: Okay, I’m on it.

But journaling, again, once again, this is an amazing reflective practice when you’re facing a challenge. It helps you examine your current understanding of the situation and gives you the chance to problem solve effectively, it’s kind of outside of the problem looking at it rather than being in the problem.

TH: And what kind of approaches to journaling… because there’s all kinds, aren’t there? There’s prompts, you can just write whatever’s on your mind, you can write about your day, is there any particular approach that you advocate?

JE: It all depends on you, I think, but I do feel like it needs to be purposeful. You know, it needs to be intentional. Because it can feel like a chore or it can feel you know, in some ways, almost like a punishment. You have to write in your journal, it’s like you must do it.

But really, it should be flexible enough that you do it when you need to. And when you’ve got something that’s rolling around in your head and just can’t seem to get a grasp, but you just can’t seem to work it out. And it might be anything from where to declutter next or you know, it could be for me, when I was doing my PhD, there was always these things tumbling around in my head, and I couldn’t make the connections. And so,

THL Or like an argument you’ve had with somebody or

JE: Exactly, an argument that you just, you can’t understand their perspective or something. And so you just start, right, like you just start writing going on they were swearing at me. And that was saying this, and I’m not quite sure why. Maybe it was this, maybe it was that.

And then you start to have these alternative kind of reasons or solutions to whatever the problem is.

And then you can kind of walk away and come back and go, Oh, wow, now I see. Now I can make those connections.

It’s just the act of writing, pulling out what’s up here, even in a jumbled way, and then you can make connections that you couldn’t make when it was in your mind.

I mean, prompts and stuff are good, too. If you’re following someone’s prompts, I know, lots of people have prompts on the internet.

Just exploring who you are as well, we talked earlier about that whole, heck who am I? What are my strengths? What are my weaknesses what are my dreams, all those sorts of things that can be exceptionally you know, an exceptionally good thing to journal.

TH: There’s a practice called Morning pages came from a woman called Julia Cameron, if I’m remembering rightly. And the idea is just that the first thing you do when you wake up, before anything else, is you write for, I think, five minutes. And if you don’t know what to write about, you write about the fact that you don’t know what to write about, you just write.

Or it might be a certain number of pages, I can’t remember, it’s a long time since I read the book.

And I did it for a while. And it is interesting how you wake up and you think I’ve got nothing to say. But once you start writing, it does start flowing. Even if it’s about the fact I hate doing this, this is a ridiculous practice. I don’t know why I… and things start coming out. And I didn’t stick with it because it was too prescriptive. And I started to feel like a chore, as you mentioned, I would rather do it kind of when it calls to me than because I have to.

But it was an interesting discipline to have for a while. Because it showed that even when you think you’ve got nothing to say, there’s something in there.

JE: Exactly. And the other thing is reading back over that and looking at themes, looking at what keeps popping up. What are you thinking about when you get up in the morning? Is it I hate doing this? Is it I hate going to work? You know what I mean? And these things kind of pop up, and they keep popping up and you thinking, wow, that’s the fifth time I’ve written I hate my job, or, you know what I mean?

And it just really does give you a pattern of thought that you might not have seen if it’s just rolling around in your head or images or just kind of flashing through your mind.

Yeah, I do think journaling and I do think I could do more journaling myself. Because I do see the benefit. And I have done it before like yourself and really found it very, very interesting to see what pops up.

TH: it’s a habit. I often wish I had. Like I had the very stereotypical teenage diaries. I used to pour my heart out in those and I just got out of the habit.

And I think it’s about for me, I wouldn’t want it to be something I forced myself to do daily. And equally, yeah, it’s something I should probably do sometimes, because it’s absolutely beneficial. It can really help you work out… sometimes you feel wrong, and you don’t know why and you start writing and you work out why.

JE: Exactly, exactly. And you might just be in a really super good mood, for example, and you’re like why am I writing about it? Wow, gosh, now I’ve highlighted all this stuff that I love that I’m not doing enough of.

Or you write about something that was super difficult for you to approach but you did. So that you can then have a record of that bouncing back that resilience of going, I tried it and damn it. The first time I did it, epic fail second time I nailed it or whatever or I did a better job.

That kind of stuff can really help you have a concrete record of working through these problems improving your resilience, looking back on it and going, wow, two years ago, and you know, and now I’m, I’m in a much better place.

TH: Yeah. So this is a horrible situation. I’m, I hate my boss. And they think, Oh, hold on, I hated my boss at the previous place. What did I write about it then that got me through, or?

JE: Yeah. Or is there some theme here? Is this something that I can learn about myself that I get frustrated when people you know, don’t have the same ethical perspective as me or,

TH: Or when I’m micromanaged or?

JE: Exactly, yeah, exactly. Whenthe person is constantly knocking on my door asking me, where’s the report? rolling my eyes that sort of stuff. And it does give you that opportunity to go what, I know what I don’t want, and you can write about what you don’t want.

And then you might, from that, flip it and see what you do want.

I do really think that it’s a great practice, and it doesn’t have to be every day. But when there’s something that’s niggling away that’s taking you away from focus. That’s when it’s worth spending the time.

TH: And you know what I would, some people, I’m sure would disagree with this. But I would say, you don’t have to handwrite a journal in a notebook. If that’s not what calls to you. I think you can do it on your computer, I think you could do it in the Notes app on your phone, there are probably dedicated phone apps for journaling.

JE: Yep. You could do a voice recording, yeah, you could do a little voice recording go, Oh, my God, I remember and listen back. But you can type it, you can write it, you can say it aloud, you can use your notes app, all sorts of different ways.

Lots of people do have a written a typed up kind of journal that they write. And from there, they pull out that that stuff for inspiration for other writing.

And that’s one thing I tend to do, I find that if I get stuck with my ideas on something I’m writing or particularly like, with my newsletter, or a new area of research, just getting out my notebook and just starting to write about that topic. Usually it takes me about a page and then I’m like, right, I can get onto the computer and I can you know, start writing.

It just gets me started. I just find that handwriting gets me started. And that might be you know, the same for some other people out there.

TH: I’m now wondering if this podcast is my journal?

JE: It is kind of Yeah. Yeah. Hmm. Interesting thought, huh.

So positive thinking, I know we, we’ve got your toxic positivity. But optimism allows us to focus on what can be done in the present rather than kind of ruminating on the past failures or worrying about what might go wrong.

I mean, actually ruminating may feel like it’s helpful. But unless you learn and grow from the attempt, then ruminating is just kind of pointless navel gazing, really, I mean, you just keep hashing over the same stuff.

But if you can actually. Rather than do that, you can try and adapt and attempt again, that’s what resilience is all about. And that’s something that will improve it if you think positively about your, your skills that you’re building.

TH: And there is a difference isn’t there between optimism and toxic positivity. You can say I’ve learned this skill and I’m proud of myself, and I think it will really help me. And that’s really different to saying, I’ve not allowed any negative thoughts. And if I want it enough, it will come true, I think they’re very different things.

JE: Very, very different things and that toxic positivity of just going oh, you’ve got to be happy about everything. You know, that’s just another avoidance technique, isn’t it?

TH: And it becomes oppressive if you’re not allowed begative thoughts or feelings, you just bury it and pops right back up again.

JE: Oh, yeah, twice as bad as last time. That’s true.

The other one I like is laughter or tears, they can help release stress hormones and humour can improve our mood, of course.

I don’t know if you’ve been doing this yourself. But rewatching those sitcoms or stand up shows that made you laugh. Recent research has confirmed what you may have discovered yourself anyway.

But in times of uncertainty, it’s kind of comforting to rewatch shows or movies that you’ve seen before. Knowing how it ends reduces your stress and anxiety.

I’m currently rewatching Parks and Recreation. I don’t know if you’ve done any work with it. But both laugh out loud, funny and also optimistic. And I know I know the majority of the storyline. Everything is kind of a little bit fresh again, because it was quite a long time ago that I watched it. And just the laugh out loud moments. Just you really feel the stress.

TH: Yeah, it’s interesting, because I’m a big stand-up person, I watch a lot of stand-up. And there used to be routines that I had watched 100 times. And it makes me a bit sad now that because of the internet, we have access to so much, we don’t need to rewatch things.

And so I think we’re missing something a bit when we don’t have a routine that we’ve rewatched 100 times, because there’s always more now, and you feel like you should watch the new and fresh stuff.

JE: And you do you get that FOMO I’ve got what, why am I sitting here rewatching Parks and Rec when I could be watching some brand-new shiny sitcom?

The other thing about it is that it really, really allows you to see how far we’ve come, in a lot of these comedies, some of the inappropriate stuff! Like I’m laughing at this, but I know I shouldn’t be. This isn’t right!

TH: And I’ve just started watching a show, because somebody told me it was like the Aussie version of Sex Education. It’s called Heartbreak High. And I’ve only watched a few episodes. I only started it this weekend, but I’m enjoying it. And it is the Aussie version of Sex Education – Jan and I have talked before, off podcast about how much we both enjoy Sex Education!

But yeah, they have a haha club at the school where they just stand in a circle and laugh. And because these are kind of cynical teenagers it adds an extra layer of being quite funny.

And there used to be like laughing yoga, have I dreamt that?

JE: I think you’re right. I think you’re right. There’s been all these sorts of things. I mean, yeah, I mean, laughter does really help it. I would say that it has to be genuine though.

TH: I was just going to say I feel like put some comedy on and left genuinely rather than laugh for one minute because it’s how haha club time.

JE: Yeah, plenty of funny things out there.

TH: That’s it, stick some good stand-up on, stick a good sitcom on.

JE: Rewatch that stuff that you thought was funny when you were a kid and see whether you still find it funny.

TH: Or whether you go oh my god that’s so racist.

JE: Rewatch the Young Ones for example, and see if you still laugh.

TH: Yeah.

JE: One of the other things we could do is put like what like I was talking before coupled with journaling is determining an alternate solution to the problem. And journaling can help you distance from the emotion of the situation.

So I think, curiosity and looking at the problem you have, seeking out a solution, is where we start to build that resilience. I tried that, it didn’t quite work. That’s interesting, why? And then iterating from there.

Eliciting the help of a counsellor or therapist, someone who doesn’t have any skin in the game, can be a great active listener who can reflect back your feelings and behaviours. So that’s going to help resilience.

Talking with a trusted friend who can listen without judgement is important. And this also helps us with self-compassion, and our communication skills. So it’s lifting a couple of different areas for us.

There is a place for controlled distraction. You were talking earlier about dissociation etc. I was recently talking to someone who used solitaire as a way to de-escalate a panic attack. The deliberate nature of the game allows your nervous system to come back to connection.

Or it could be picturing yourself in your happy place, listening to music, watching a favourite comedy as we’re talking about, but in moderation, because we can find ourselves numbing out for hours and then feel feeling guilty or useless as a result.

But that all idea of dissociation being bad, and you’ve got to stop it. Well, it’s a coping mechanism that is biological, and…

TH: And telling you something shouldn’t doesn’t stop you doing it!

JE: Nope. Nope.

TH: And there’s that thing where if you’re in a suicidal depression, then sure, distract yourself as much as you need to. Fill your boots with distraction.

JE: Exactly.

TH: But if then you try to distract from every slight feeling of discomfort, that’s when it’s an issue, isn’t it? It’s about exactly scale, and proportion. And if it’s literally saving you from feeling the worst, then do what you need to do.

JE: That is exactly right.

TH: If it’s just that it’s Sunday night, you wish it wasn’t Monday tomorrow, that’s not something to try and distract yourself out of it. So yeah, scale and proportion.

JE: Scale and proportion. Exactly. And that’s one of the things that I guess, we’ve, we’re kind of continuing to learn in the area of psychology about the nuances of stuff and you know, dissociation bad this good! Bothing’s black and white. Everything is pretty grey.

And if you need to distract, because you’re in suicidal spiral, that’s completely different.

TH: Yeah. I always understood dissociation as a black and white thing. And it’s really not.

An example that’s often used. But that is a good one is kind of the last 200 yards of your car journey home. You get home and you can’t remember the last few roads, because you’ve done it 1000 times. Or the last the last bus stop on your journey. You just get off the bus and you go, I don’t remember those last few stops, because you do it every single day.

And seeing that as a form of dissociation is quite interesting, because it’s a scale thing.

JE: It’s on a continuum isn’t it?

TH: Yeah, completely.

JE: Because just distracting yourself with your phone or whatever, or numbing out or sitting down and even meditating is in a way, but then you’ve got right up the other end where you completely shut down and nothing’s connecting and but chances are you use that as a method to cope because of inescapable danger that you experienced as a child, or has happened in your life. And that’s evolution.

TH: Yeah. And it got you through, it got you through. And then having a stressful commute is not that same degree of danger. And so if you’re using it then as well, that’s when you need to look at it.

JE: Yeah, that’s when you need to kind of say to yourself, it’s okay. We’re safe. Yeah, it’s not we’re not back there. Were in this moment on the bus.

TH: All those grounding techniques. What can you feel? What can you see?

JE: What can you hear cetera? Yeah, yeah. And really pushing your feet into the ground into the floor, that sort of stuff too.

TH: Touch soil. It’s a bit of an internet meme. But touch soil? Yeah. There’s truth in it, isn’t there?

JE: Yeah.

TH: Or is it touch grass? Touch grass. I don’t know. Either way.

JE: Feel your bum in the seat. Feel your hands on the armrests, that sort of stuff

So resilience. It can be built, it can be developed.

TH: It can. And we have it already, in some areas of our life. Nobody is completely unresilient. You know, we’ve all got a strength somewhere.

It might be that, I mean, chances are, if you’re listening to this, you don’t have it in the areas of discarding stuff. But you do have it somewhere. And it might be something… you might have to look around a bit to work out where it is.

But you do. You’re an adult with coping skills. And if you can cope at work, or if you can cope with sleepless nights with a new baby, or if you can cope with whatever… cooking a big meal for 12 people… then you can also use some of those skills in this.

JE: Definitely, definitely, it’s there. You might have to mine it a little bit, dig it up a bit. And that’s where that journaling comes in, really, and listening to what people around you say and really hearing them.

I know a lot of people almost don’t hear compliments, or nice things that people say about them, or they disregard them and say you’re just trying to butter me up or you just want something. Actually listen to those things. And that can give you an insight into some of the things that you do do really well.

Or if you really really bold ask someone. What do you think I’m good at?

TH: Yeah. Yeah.

You know, I did a work thing a couple of years ago that I was really terrified about and I got so much amazing feedback afterwards that I took a screenshot of everything. And I created a folder on my phone called Impostor Syndrome. And I put every screenshot of every bit of praise into this folder. And ever since then, I have screenshotted… not every bit of praise I get, but when it occurs to me, if somebody says, Oh, that was a great piece of work, or that meeting was really good or whatever, I just screenshot it and put it in that folder.

I don’t often access it, but knowing it’s there is good.

And if I am having, say, another scary work event, I could just scroll through a few of those pictures and go, Okay, well, they thought I did well then, they thought I did well then. And you could equally have a folder for nice things my friends say about me.

JE: Exactly. Exactly. And it’s almost like it’s an antidote to those times when you really can’t see it yourself. Someone else has seen it, and they’ve put it down in writing or they’ve said it in words.

They’ve looked you in the eye and said, You did an awesome job. Yeah, what you’re doing is helping people, those sorts of things.

And that can just be the difference between trying something again, or giving up.

TH: Completely. So if people want to find you online, where can they do so?

JE: They can go to my website http://www.stuffology.com.au. They could go to Instagram at @stuff_ology or Twitter at @stuff_ology. Facebook, Stuffology Consulting. And shoot me an email if you like jan@stuffology.com.au

TH: And when you go to http://www.stuffology.com.au, sign up for the email list, which is a weekly knowledge bomb.

JE: Knowledge bomb!

Thank you so much for your kind words.

TH: It’s all true. Thank you, Jan, you’re always a wonder.

JE: Thank you so very much. I love, love, love doing our pods.

TH: Do you want to be a Dehoarding Darling? You can be now at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling  If you love the podcast and want a bit extra, you can finally sign up to be a Dehoarding Darling.

Members will get an exclusive monthly post with an additional top tip, some podcasts and music recommendations and a personal update from me about how things are going.

Find out the full details at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling

So my top tip this week is a clip from the It’s All Clutter podcast. And it’s a clip with a bit of advice about where to start.

Another thing you can do right off the bat is commit to decluttering areas that are not emotional, stick with the easy stuff first.

Do not go into a closet full of memorabilia and decluttering landmines and expect to have success right off the bat.

Decluttering is a muscle. You need to learn how to declutter and flex those decluttering muscles and get stronger at it by starting with the easy, emotionally easy categories first. Period.

Declutter your pencils and pens. Declutter something super easy to begin with and that’s going to motivate you to continue to move forward.

So set yourself up for success right in the beginning of this process by knowing yourself, knowing your time limits and sticking to the emotionally easy things.

Now, I’m a big fan of this advice, I use it myself all the time.

If I get to something that is just too difficult and I get I can feel my brain clamming up, I think, Okay, can I just shift my attention to something a little bit less emotionally charged for the time being?

I know I will, at some point, come back to say the nostalgic stuff, whatever it is that’s difficult. But there’s usually something is you can be doing in the meantime, and it’s better to make progress, even if it’s not quite the progress you planned, than it is to freeze and give up.

Okay, thank you for listening. And I will speak to you next time.

Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast. You can find more online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk

You can find me on Twitter @ThatHoarder. And on Facebook at Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder.

To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support and do subscribe to this podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.

 

Image: Marcus Woodbridge