Negative self-talk, cognitive restructuring and hoarding
Negative self-talk, cognitive restructuring and hoarding

Show notes

Subscribe

Audio credits

Transcript

Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder. Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast and all my social media, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk. Finally, I am not a doctor, I’m just a hoarder doing her best, so do seek professional support if and when you need it.

So I’m going to start today with one in my occasional series where I share my success of the week and my weird dilemma of the week.

The success of the week is a bit of a boost for me reminds me of something I’ve achieved. And it hopefully is a bit inspiring for listeners as well.

The weird dilemma of the week is just a little insight into how weird your thinking can be when you hoard.

So my success of the week is three more pairs of shoes have gone to the charity shop. Since I have kind of been excavating the part of the house where it seems there are apparently a lot of shoes, I have discovered that I have so many shoes.

I always say I’m not one of these people with millions of pairs of shoes, I’ve only ever kind of got like a couple of pairs of shoes.

And I’ve realised that well, first of all, that’s clearly not true. I think what I mean when I say that, is I only ever wear one or two pairs of shoes at any given time.

So basically, I have a pair of shoes that I love and are dead comfy, and I wear them until they can be worn no more. And then I get a new pair, and so on. You know, at any given period of time, I tend to have like I’ve currently got two pairs of shoes that I switch between that I love.

But clearly, I have discovered that doesn’t mean I only own two pairs of shoes. Because in typical hoarder style, when the pair of shoes that I’ve been wearing for 18 months falls apart, it seems I’m not good at getting rid of them.

I think it doesn’t help that they are a pair of shoes that I genuinely have loved for 18 months or two years or six months or however long they’ve lasted. The reason I wear them all the time is because I I really liked them. And so that has probably made them harder to get rid of.

And then the other kind of shoes I still have are shoes that I’ve bought, often online, that just don’t fit quite right or don’t look… you know sometimes shoes look great until you put them on and then they just don’t look great anymore?

So that’s the other kind of shoes I’ve been coming across: pairs that are perfectly good in theory, but either don’t fit or just I don’t really like them when they’re on. But then the endowment effect thing, I’ve done a whole episode on that that I will link to in the show notes… the endowment effect and feeling like it will be a waste of money to get rid of them because I bought them. All of those things come into play.

Or even sometimes the idea of them. Like I really wanted these shoes to fit perfectly and so I’m going to keep them because if I get rid of them then the dream of them being perfect has to go.

It sounds so ridiculous when you say it out loud.

But yeah, I think I kept hold of some of them because I wanted what I had expected them to be to be true.

So yeah, it does sound ridiculous when you say out loud, doesn’t it?

But the good news, this is my success of the week. The good news is that they are going.

When I come across a pair that I have worn to death. I am kind of taking a moment and appreciating them and then putting them in the bin. And then when I come across a pair that is perfectly good but just not perfectly good for me, so didn’t fit or didn’t look quite how I imagined when I put them on, they are going in the charity shop bag.

And there was I can’t remember it was one pair or two pairs in a giant charity shop donation I did a few weeks ago. And now three more pairs have gone into the bag for my next big charity shop donation.

So yay, more shoes out of the door!

My weird dilemma of the week… well, it’s an odd one, obviously, otherwise, it wouldn’t fit the criteria. I came across a notebook in a pile, and the notebook was in a very bad way. The cover was torn, a lot of the pages were folded over and the whole thing was bent out of shape.

And I was a bit sad, but I was also taking responsibility for that. This notebook is in this state because I hoard. That is the only reason it is in this state. It ended up in a pile and then piles ended up on top of the pile, and then other piles ended up on top of those new piles. And it got wrecked.

It happens. It happens more often than I’d like to admit, really.

And I felt a little bit bad because I felt it was quite kind of disrespectful to the notebook. Again, that seems a little bit odd in my head, but extra weird when I say it out loud.

But I felt like I’d been really disrespectful to this perfectly good notebook that I had never even written in.

And it wasn’t it wasn’t completely unusable. Had it been the last notebook in my house and I desperately needed a notebook. I could have made it make do.

But the truth is, I have many notebooks. I’m a stationery person. And so I didn’t need to make it make do. And in the context of a house with a lot of other notebooks, there was no sense in keeping this battered, wrecked notebook. It didn’t make any sense at all.

But my dilemma came because of that whole thing where hoarders anthropomorphise objects, like we turn them into people with personalities and feelings and characters. And I felt bad about throwing it away, because I thought I’ve already disrespected this poor notebook by letting it get in this state. And now if I throw it away, that’s disrespecting me even more, and it’s going to feel really hurt. And it’s just unreasonable of me.

So I kind of kept it around for a few days before, thankfully, I eventually got to a point where I did throw it away. It went.

It was wasteful. But the waste wasn’t in throwing it away. The waste was in keeping it in a setting that allowed it to become like that. Throwing it away wasn’t the waste, the waste was keeping it in a hoard and letting it get battered by its surroundings.

Also an update: a weird dilemma I did recently was I had found I had a pair of shoes that I had wanted to keep, but didn’t fit. And so I kept keeping them in the hope that somehow one day they would magically fit and obviously they didn’t.

And my weird dilemma a few weeks ago was that I had finally decided that this one particular pair of shoes could go to the charity shop because they didn’t fit – however much I liked them didn’t make them fit. And then the dilemma was that I realised I could only find one of them. And so I didn’t know what to do with the one shoe.

And this has also come up since, and there are other shoes that I have decided I can donate but that I can only currently find one of them.

And after I did that weird dilemma, some of you made suggestions about where I could keep the one shoe, because my dilemma was: how do I not now lose this one and find the other and have one around forever?

And I just want to thank you for your optimism, those of you who suggested I put the single shoes where the shoes live, so that when I find the other one, I’ll be able to find the original one.

And I want to thank you for your optimism in assuming I have a place in my house where shoes live! That is something I’m working on.

I’m closer to having a place where shoes live, they are gathering together in a little pile of unwanted left shoes, or right shoes.

But yes. So hopefully one day there will be even more shoes going to the charity shop because I have found the matching half.

So I’m going to talk today about negative self-talk. I am really aware of my own inner dialogue, and how much of a hard time I give myself.

Whenever anything goes wrong, I find a way to yell at myself in my own head about what a terrible person I am and how awful I am and why everything in the world that's bad is my fault. Share on X

Whenever anything goes wrong, whether it’s something terrible I’ve done, all the way to just being in a traffic jam, I find a way to yell at myself in my own head about what a terrible person I am and how awful I am and why everything in the world that’s bad is my fault.

It’s a really exhausting way to live and yet it is pretty constant in my head.

And I know when I hear from you that it’s not just me, we all I think give ourselves a really hard time, we are our own worst critic.

Even if we do something really good, we can turn it into well, yeah, I did. But I should have done this, there’s something I could have done better. There is something that wasn’t quite as it should have been.

I did a talk at an event. And afterwards, the organisers of the event sent me a summary of people’s feedback forms, people who’d attended the event had filled in feedback forms at the end of the event.

And one of the questions had been did you enjoy this another was did you find it useful? And then comments, and they were so positive and so gratifying and encouraging.

And then the final question was, should we ask this speaker to come again?

And it was something like 96% of people said yes. And 4% of people said no. And of course, I was like, oh my god, people 4% of people like hated me. This is terrible. I did such a bad job!

And I could even see that it was ridiculous. 96% of people said yes. And yet I focused a good 80% of my focus on Oh, I’m so bad. 4% of people don’t think I should be invited back.

It’s that kind of thing. Now, there’s a term that I keep coming across when I read about this, which is automatic negative thoughts and that sums things up and that’s often a abbreviated to ANTs, automatic negative thoughts.

And they can be so prevalent in our brains that we’re not even that consciously aware of them. They’re just a permanent fixture.

And it can then change what we do and guide what we do. You might blame yourself for things that there is no evidence that they’re your fault. You just beat yourself up whatever goes on.

Somebody is in a bad mood and you think, oh, no, what have I done? This is awful.

And often with that kind of self criticism, I think that I think it will keep me motivated, like, it will keep me on my toes. But actually, it has the opposite effect.

It flattens my mood, it makes me want to quit, makes me want to not try because I’m so useless. Why on earth would I even bother trying? All of that.

And it can start off… I think sometimes we justify it because we think we’re being objective, or we think we’re being neutral. Like, okay, I will look back at that talk I gave. That bit in the middle, I’m not sure it was as on point as it might have been, for instance.

Now that seems like an objective review of something you’ve done. But even that kind of objective criticism can start to spiral down and down and down. And we have to be really… we can’t be complacent.

And we have to keep an eye on it. Because we start to believe it, we start to believe the abuse that we aim at ourselves, whether it’s true or not, basically.

And this stream of you’re rubbish, you’re awful, you’re useless, you can’t do it, you’ll never do it, it gains strength, and we believe it more and more.

And it does start to dictate how we live our lives.

If we had a literal person following us around all day telling us how terrible we were, first of all, we would make efforts to stop them following us around. But we would also – understandably – just collapse and give up. I can’t go to work because I’m useless at it. The guy sitting next to me, all they all they do is say I’m rubbish. Of course we give up!

But because this is going on in our heads, we might just accept that it’s there and not realise how powerful it is.

So even if we think it’s motivating, or it keeps us on our toes, I think it does limit our chances, ultimately, of achieving what it is we want to achieve – in this case, dehoarding our home, stopping acquiring, all of those things.

And it’s convincing! We think, I think this about myself, there must be evidence for it otherwise I wouldn’t think it.

Or we find evidence or we manufacture evidence if it’s not apparent. We go, I am such a fraud. I am doing this talk and everybody’s going to see through me because I don’t know why I’m doing, this is that whole imposter syndrome thing. It’s really pervasive.

And there might be somebody from your past or from your present, whose voice it is. It might be a critical parent’s voice or critical partner’s voice, or it might be an amalgamation of a number of people in your life.

I mean, I know exactly who my critical voice. It’s somebody who’s always been very critical of me and I’m pretty clear that most of the time, the critical voice in my head has come directly from that person.

And I think that’s because other people’s criticisms influence us. And they always have.

From when we’re tiny, maybe somebody says, Oh, you always make such a fuss or You’re so noisy, or you’re not very clever, are you?

Any of those kinds of things.

We believe it! We believe what we’re told, especially if we’re told something repeatedly.

And so we then start to find evidence, and we look everywhere for evidence that yeah, I am rubbish. Yeah, I am making a fuss. Yeah, I am really noisy, I’d better keep quiet and not speak up.

And it has an effect, obviously, on our confidence, it can create the kind of perfectionism that is really limiting. I did a whole episode with Dr. Jan Eppingstall on perfectionism, which I will also link to in the show notes at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/

Because it’s interesting that perfectionism is something that sounds on the surface like it might be a positive attribute. It might be something like, Yeah, I’m such a perfectionist, I do everything perfectly.

But what happens in real life is that perfectionist thinking is so rigid, and so controlled, and so impossibly perfect, that often we go, Well, I can’t achieve perfection so I may as well not try. Or I’ve done this thing, and it will never be good enough. Or I could try but it would never be good enough. So what’s the point?

And of course, it can make you miserable as well, let’s face it, it’s not all just about productivity. It’s not all about what it stops you doing. It also can just make you feel awful.

If somebody is in your head 24/7 telling you that you… whatever pushes your buttons, chances are, the self-critical voice knows that and we’ll go straight for it. So it might be for you it might be I am a terrible parent. That might be like the worst thing you could hear. And so the critical voice knows that and pushes that button again and again and again.

It might be I’m wasting my life. And so the critical voice knows that for you, that’s one of the worst things and push that button again and again and again.

When I did an interview with Elizabeth Nelson, who is the child of a hoarder, she said a great quote, which was “parents can push your buttons because they installed them”. And I feel quite similarly about negative self-talk.

There is evidence that negative self-talk can… well, it’s complicated… Certainly negative self-talk is a feature or can be a feature of several significant mental health problems like depression, anxiety, and a number of other things.

The question is does negative self-talk cause those things? Or does the mental health problem cause the negative self-talk? Or do they just happen to exist together? Like the kind of person who is susceptible to depression may also be the kind of person who has a lot of negative self-talk?

I think that’s a bigger question than I can answer on this podcast, but it is certainly undoubtedly the case that negative so of talk is a feature of a number of mental illnesses. And hoarding disorder is one of them.

Perfectionism is a big feature for a lot of hoarders. Depression is a big feature for a lot of hoarders. OCD is a big feature for a lot of hoarders.

And I keep referring to other episodes, but I interviewed an OCD therapist: again, I will link to that in the show notes. And she described OCD as the doubt disorder.

So if you have OCD, your negative self-talk voice might be the voice that’s questioning everything you do. Did you turn the light off? Did you turn the gas on? Did you lock the doors?

But also, did you throw away something you shouldn’t have thrown away? You better go out to the bin and check the rubbish again.

What if you need it? All of those questions, it’s all such a feature in hoarding.

And because negative self-talk is to pressingly present in my head, constantly, I’ve been trying for years to try and get a handle on it.

And so I’m going to talk about some of the suggested ways… it’s been studied in a number of ways, and I’m going to talk about some of the suggestions and how they might help people who hoard, because I do know it’s not just me who have this.

Whether it’s a constant feature for you or not, I think there are tips in here and information in here that can be really valuable. And that hopefully, you’ll be able to apply in your life as well.

So having said I’m going to talk about what to do, I’m going to start by talking about what not to do.

And something I came across a few times reading about this, for me, is a what not to do, purely on the basis of I just don’t believe it works. Or not in any significant way.

But some people advise stopping your thoughts. If you have a negative thought, stop it.

And I wish that worked! But it’s not… I don’t know… how on earth do you stop a thought?

I mean, they recommend doing something like saying out loud stop! And I don’t know… I don’t know what world that works in.

If that works for you, I’m very excited for you. Because it seems quite simple. And go for it.

I know in a previous episode, Jan talked about… the example that always comes up: don’t think of a pink elephant. And as soon as you say don’t think of a pink elephant, you think of a pink elephant.

And this is evidence that you can’t stop yourself thinking of something because by even having the thought I must stop thinking about, that involves thinking about that thing.

And this is why I think trying to stop your thoughts is just not how things work.

One thing you can try is replacing your thoughts. This may be a little bit more effective than trying to stop it.

So when you think I’m a terrible person, you might replace that with I’m a good person, or just kind of make a conscious effort to think it.

Or if you think I am useless, you might want to try and replace it with no, I am a functioning person.

Something that reassures you and counters the negative voice.

Or it might be that rather than replacing a negative thought with a positive one, if that feels like it’s going too far, or if it feels disingenuous if you really, really don’t believe the positive alternative, you might want to just change that narrative to something more neutral.

So rather than saying, I’m a terrible person, you could say, I’m okay. Or rather than saying, I’m useless, you might say I’m not doing a bad job.

Probably a more effective… I have some scepticism about those. Again, I just don’t think it’s as simple as thinking something bad about yourself and then forcing yourself to think something good about yourself. I don’t think it’s that simple.

One way that, for me, seems like it will be a bit more effective: rather than saying, I’m bad. No, I’m good. Or I’m bad. No, I’m okay. Rather than reacting like that, it might be helpful to try and just insert some more positive thoughts about yourself or your situation through the day by things like a gratitude journal.

Spending two minutes at the end of every day writing down five things you’re grateful for. sounds a bit cheesy, but it could be a good way to focus your mind and just remind yourself that there are good things going on.

Similarly, taking a few moments to be mindful at any point in your day, maybe when you get up, maybe when you’re driving to work, maybe when you’re cooking in the evening, just take a moment and think oh I really slept well last night.Or this mushroom omelette is going to be delicious. Or something positive.

Making an effort to insert a bit of positivity, not in a direct reactionary way to a negative thought but just to remind yourself through the day that there is good stuff going on and there is good stuff about you.

I think that is a more realistic approach than being reactionary towards the automatic negative thought, the ANT.

But I think before trying to force happy thoughts, positive thoughts, especially in that reactionary way, I think can be quite toxic. That whole toxic positivity, we can’t set about forcing everything to be amazingly happy all day long.

It’s not realistic, it is quite damaging, because we can then start to feel guilty or start to feel ashamed or start to feel like we’re doing something wrong if we don’t feel joyful at every given moment.

And in order to avoid feeling… I feel like that would just add more ammunition to your critical inner voice. See, I can’t even do positivity, right! You know, you don’t need any more ammunition, you don’t need any more things to yell at yourself about, however, well intentioned it would be.

And of course feeling better about yourself is a good thing to aim for. If we start to add, and I can’t even stay positive, as another thing to shout at ourselves about, it is absolutely counterproductive.

We have to learn to deal with those automatic negative thoughts, those ANTs in a way that is more realistic, and more holistic, and more constructive.

And I think improving our relationship with the thoughts we have about ourselves is a better long-term solution than just trying to yell over the thoughts we have about ourselves.

The first thing we have to really, really, really do if we want to start tackling these self-critical thoughts is to notice when we're having them in the first place Share on X

So I think the first thing we have to really, really, really do if we want to start tackling these self-critical thoughts is to notice when we’re having them in the first place.

Especially if like me, they’re pretty constant, then we can tune them out, we can just get so used to it as an ongoing chatter in our brain that we don’t even notice they’re there.

So we need to become aware of what we’re saying to ourselves and we need to become aware of why we’re saying it and when we say it.

Are there particular patterns? Are there triggers? Does seeing a particular person make you feel worse about yourself? Does trying to do a particular task make you feel worse about yourself?

Is it when you feel you failed at something? Is it when you feel undermined by somebody? Is it when somebody makes you feel bad?

And that kind of self-awareness, I feel like is the basis from which we can start to address some of these thoughts and change our relationship with them and change the things that cause us to think this way about ourselves.

And then, once we are aware of what we’re thinking, what we’re saying to ourselves in a critical way, it’s worth reminding ourselves gently that these thoughts and the feelings that come as a result are not necessarily true.

Just because we think it doesn’t make it fact.

It might feel like facts and we might be able to provide evidence. But there can be evidence of, say, you doing a bad thing but that not making you a bad person.

But the critical voice will say, well, there’s evidence of you doing a bad thing…

And that taking one small fact and making it apply to everything isn’t a super helpful thought process.

It’s pretty common, I think, but it’s not really helpful.

And a lot of the negative thinking is actually connected to thought processes that are quite irrational. They just don’t necessarily make sense.

And when we’re aware of the thoughts, we can become aware of the “reasoning” and just take a moment to assess whether it is reasonable to draw that conclusion.

Just question it a little bit. Okay, I did fail to throw out my planned five bags today. That is true. But does that make me a failure in everything I have ever attempted in my entire life?

Just question it. Because maybe no. Maybe it doesn’t make you a failure in everything you’ve ever attempted in your entire life.

And with this kind of challenging that you’re doing with yourself, you can also externalise that a bit by talking it through with somebody.

Maybe you have a therapist, maybe you have a good friend. Anybody in your support system really.

Is there somebody who you can check these thoughts out with. Somebody to say, this happened! Is it reasonable to conclude this?

I failed this exam – does that mean I will never achieve anything in my life?

Just check it out with somebody.

Sometimes we just need somebody external to the situation to bring a bit of objectivity and let you know whether you’re being reasonable or unreasonable in your criticisms.

💭 Think about effort versus outcome Share on X

An idea I really like and find really useful is to think about effort versus outcome, right?

So rather than judging yourself by the end results of something, judge yourself by how much you tried, right?

There was a study done that I will link to in the show notes that compared effort talk, ability talk and self-talk.

They got some children to do some maths and compared how well they did based on whether they did positive self-talk, positive ability talk or no self-talk at all.

So positive ability talk in the study was things like, I am really good at math.

Positive effort talk in the study was, I will do my best at maths.

And what it found was that the kids who did the positive effort talk – I will do my best – did better in their maths than the kids who did the positive ability talk – which was I am very good at maths.

And the thinking the researchers concluded was that when the kids prioritised the effort they were putting in over the outcome that happened at the end, they were a little bit detached from negative thinking about how good they were, and how clever they were.

They were a step away from that, and instead just tried their best. You’re more likely to have success, and less likely to beat yourself up ,crucially, if your goal is to put in good effort, rather than the size of the pile by the end of it.

Another suggestion I came across that is, I think, less weird than it might initially sound, is to give your inner critic a name.

And at first I thought Yeah, no.

But then I had a friend with an eating disorder. And she called her eating disorder Ed, right for ED – eating disorder, called him Ed. And it enabled her a bit to separate herself from this illness.

So say we were going out for lunch, she was able to say, oh, Ed’s telling me I shouldn’t eat.

Which is a much better way of putting it than I shouldn’t eat, which was her alternative.

And being able to separate it gave her that little bit of distance that then enabled her to challenge it – quietly, carefully, gently.

Just say, Well, Ed’s saying I shouldn’t eat. Is Ed correct? Let’s look at that.

And so if our inner critic is called Bob, sorry, to any Bobs listening – also sorry to any Eds listening for that matter.

Say your inner critic is called Bob. Then we might say Bob’s telling me I will never dehoard this house. And then we can say well, is Bob right? Or is he wrong?

And that’s a better place to start the discussion than I can’t dehoard This house, which feels more like a statement of fact, rather than an opinion.

And it is an opinion It’s an opinion based on a lot of self-loathing in a lot of cases.

Because challenging your negative thoughts, whether or not you give it a name, I do appreciate that might feel like a bit of a step too far for a lot of people, it is slightly weird.

But whether you give it a name or not, challenging your inner critic in a kind of logical way can be really effective.

Cross examine it! Really say, Okay, what is the evidence for what you’re saying? How true is that? Is it really true that I did a terrible job at that speaking event, when in fact, 96% of people wanted me to come back and do it again?

What’s the evidence? What’s the evidence for the fact that I will never succeed? What is the evidence for the fact that I am useless? What is the evidence for the fact that I’m disgusting?

A lot of these automatic negative thoughts are quite exaggeratedly bad, aren’t they? We don’t go Oh, you’re so marginally slightly mean! It’s always like, you are awful.

So if you think you’re really bad at something, ask somebody: am I really bad at this? How do you think I’m doing at this?

And just try and contradict those thoughts. See if you can start almost a dialogue with yourself and say, okay, really? Is that really true? I don’t know. Prove it to me.

Or maybe not prove it to me that can just double down.

But yeah, check the evidence, check the evidence.

And also, start thinking with a bit of compassion for yourself. I mean, it’s a saying, isn’t it, we can be our own worst enemy. And I think automatic negative thoughts are a perfect example of that being in play.

We can be terrible to ourselves. Absolutely vile. And it can be worth saying, okay, would I say that to a friend?

It’s a bit of a therapy cliche, but with good reason. Because say you spill a glass of water. Your automatic negative thought might be God, you’re useless. Or why are you so clumsy?

And then think through: if your best friend spilled a glass of water, would you say Why are you so useless? Or would you say, Oh, you spilt a glass of water? Let’s get a cloth.

Or if your best friend spilt a glass of water, and she said, Why am I so useless, you would immediately say, you’re not useless, you just spilt a glass of water!

And if we can treat ourselves a little bit closer to how we treat people we love and make ourselves think, would I say that to a friend?

I’ve got past a lot of negative thinking by questioning that.

I can justify a lot of my self-hate until I picture a specific friend, I just pick one of my friends, and make myself address the fact that if they did what I just done, or if they didn’t do what I just not done, would I aim the same torrent of abuse at them?

And in every single case, ever, I have had to admit, no, I wouldn’t.

And that then makes me question all of it.

If I’m being too harsh on myself here, maybe I’m being too harsh on myself in other areas, and maybe I need to back off and give myself a break for a minute.

So think about if your friend did what you’ve just done, would you yell at her in the way you yell at yourself?

And also think: if your friend did what you’ve just done and yelled at herself out loud, how would you counter that?

Because being compassionate and loving and supportive to other people is wonderful. But being compassionate and loving and supportive to ourselves is also wonderful.

Offer yourself the empathy and support that you would offered somebody else.

Something that some people find useful is to say to yourself, Okay, I can have this conversation with myself, I can tell myself off for doing something, but within parameters.

So you might say, Okay, I’m going to save all of this self-talk for six o’clock tonight, get it all out in one go, and then get on with my life.

Or I’m allowed to think for as long as it takes to write it down. And then I’ve got to put it away.

It just places bit of a limitation on how constant and how degrading that kind of conversation is.

In a similar way, some people almost visualise themselves putting it to one side.

You might visualise yourself putting these thoughts into a box into a drawer and closing it. It kind of allows you to think the thoughts, look at them mindfully and then say, Okay, I’ve heard you. Now let’s just put it to one side, you’ve got your message across.

It’s always worth trying to remember perspective as well. I was on a bit of a nostalgia trip the other day, and I was watching some Monty Python songs.

And one of them really stood out to me and it’s the Galaxy Song. Because it’s all it’s all about perspective, basically.

I will play a mini clip here but then I will link to the full video in the show notes at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/

But this is the Galaxy song:

The universe itself keeps on expanding and expanding

In all of the directions it can whizz

As fast as it can go, at the speed of light, you know

Twelve million miles a minute, and that’s the fastest speed there is

So remember, when you’re feeling very small and insecure

How amazingly unlikely is your birth…

It’s that whole thing of lying on the floor on a dark night and looking out at the stars and realising how absolutely insignificant the thing you’ve been worrying about is.

You think that you threw away something and you regret it. And that’s been the biggest worry of your day. And then you look out at the universe and realise it absolutely does not matter one bit.

And similarly, looking really long term, a kind of bird’s eye view of almost visualising a timeline, can help us to see that something that feels very, very important – important enough to shout at ourselves about – is actually not of any consequence at all.

Or not of any not have enough consequence to give ourselves the hard time that we’re giving ourself.

It’s about minimising the damage these thoughts do to you. And it’s a good way, I think putting it in perspective going, I am a tiny speck in this vast galaxy, and not only am I a tiny speck in this vast galaxy, I am a tiny speck at this tiny bit of time in this vast galaxy over an eternal amount of time.

And so, sure, I didn’t recycle that bottle. And it may have been better if I had. But really does it matter? Is it worth this amount of abuse to myself?

Now there’s something called cognitive restructuring, which is often a feature of CBT, of cognitive behavioural therapy. And it can definitely apply… it’s a way of basically looking at thoughts and challenging them to see whether they are rational, to see whether they are fair, to see whether they are helpful, basically.

And there’s a number of different ways to do cognitive restructuring. And it’s a whole technique of its own, but I want to share some of the questions that can be used in cognitive restructuring, because they are perfect for this very thing, for looking at your negative self-talk, looking at your automatic negative thoughts, and assessing them a bit.

So here are some questions that you might ask yourself:

  • Is there substantial evidence for this thought?
  • Is there evidence against this thought?
  • What would a friend think about this situation?
  • Will this matter in five years?
  • Am I overgeneralising based on past experience?
  • Is there a different way to view this situation?
  • What advice would somebody I trust give me in this situation?
  • Is this thought helpful? That’s a big one, isn’t it? Is this thought helpful?
  • Is this thought making the situation worse?

So with this kind of cognitive restructuring, it’s also called cognitive reframing, it helps you to identify the thought and challenge it a bit.

And then they say modify or replace it, that’s where it gets… I have less confidence in that bit.

But certainly, I see a lot of use in challenging these thoughts with a bit of logic, but gently. Not attacking yourself with logic, not kind of continuing the process just by attacking yourself in a different way.

And it may be that you have far more success than me at stopping or replacing your thoughts, in which case, fantastic, I’m really pleased.

But even if, like me, you don’t find that super helpful, you can still find it helpful and useful to use this kind of questioning to assess what’s going on and begin to create an environment in your mind where you don’t have to shout at yourself the whole time.

And then the final bit of advice I came across was something I’d never heard of before, but I quite like.

And that is they suggest performing a cost benefit analysis of your negative thoughts.

Now, what this means is comparing how much it costs you compared to what you get out of it and then assessing whether or not that cost is worth it for that benefit.

And so, basically, you look at your automatic negative thoughts and consider, not whether they’re true or not, but the advantage or disadvantage of having them at all.

So you might say, Okay, I’m shouting at myself, because I don’t believe I can dehoard this room.

So the first question would be, what do I get out of shouting at myself? What does that give me? What does that give the situation?

And the next question would be, what does shouting at myself take away from me? What are the disadvantages? What does it cost me? Both immediately, and in the long term?

And so, you might say, okay, what do I get out of saying, You will never achieve this? What I get out of saying this is, perhaps I like a challenge. And perhaps it will motivate me.

Or what I get out of it is the comfort of it being very familiar to shout at myself.

Or I might get out of it that nobody else can hurt me because I hurt myself first.

And then you think about what are the costs of shouting at myself in this way? And the costs of it might be it makes me feel terrible.

Another cost might be, because it makes me feel terrible, I give up and I don’t even try.

And another cost might be it becomes the truth because I tell myself I can’t do it and then it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy and I don’t do it.

So the cost, ultimately, is that I feel terrible about myself and then I prove the negative thoughts right because I don’t dehoard that room.

And so when you look at your negative thoughts in a cost benefit analysis way, looking at that scenario I just described, I would say that the costs of the negative thoughts, compared to the benefits of the negative thoughts, it becomes quite clear rationally, for me at least, that they cost me more than they help me.

Having those negative thoughts does more damage than they do good.

And it’s an interesting way to look at it, isn’t it? It’s almost like having a courtroom and weighing things, you know, giant weighing scales even and putting good on one side and the bad on one side. Not just of are they truthful, but is it objectively helpful to have the thoughts at all?

And I like that kind of reframing. I like things that make me think of things in a different way. And that certainly did.

So I think automatic negative thoughts, they are really difficult to tackle. I wish they weren’t because they’re pretty relentless in my head.

And I think there is some bad advice about them that’s overly simplistic, and then people feel even worse because the advice they hear doesn’t work for them. And that proves something negative about them. And it’s just a vicious cycle.

But I think looking at some of the more useful techniques, maybe listening to that maybe one or two ideas stood out to you as something that you could resonate with.

And we’re never going to have bliss 24/7. That’s not how life works for anybody. It’s certainly not how life works for people with quite a profound mental health problem like hoarding disorder.

But don’t aim for 24/7 bliss! Aim for maybe five minutes today where you’re not yelling at yourself, aim for maybe 10 minutes tomorrow where you give yourself a break.

And if you can use any of those tactics I’ve talked about, then use them. And if they’re helpful, use them even more.

Because we’re all learning all the time. And it all helps and builds up together to get us, hopefully, to a place where we’re doing better.

Because it’s really important that we don’t feel constantly miserable. But also, it’s not just that negative self-talk makes you feel miserable, it’s that it stops you from taking action, it’s that it stops you from achieving anything, which then reinforces the negative mood.

And so even if you have so much self-loathing that you don’t feel justified in trying to stop the negative talk on the basis that it makes you feel bad, if you can think of it in terms of okay, well forget how it makes me feel, it actually stops me from doing as well, maybe you can justify trying to address it on that basis to start with.

Do you want to be a Dehoarding Darling? You can be now at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling If you love the podcast and want a bit extra, you can finally sign up to be a Dehoarding Darling.

Members will get an exclusive monthly post with an additional top tip, some podcast and music recommendations and a personal update from me about how things are going.

Find out the full details at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling

My top tip this week is a little clip from the Marie Forleo podcast. Marie Forleo is business woman, very impressive, very successful.

And she has got two questions to ask yourself that are really useful, I think:

These are two fantastic prompts. And I promise you, if you really take a moment, think about them and answer honestly, it could change everything.

I want you to imagine that you are 96 years old, you’ve had this rich, full, beautiful life. And here you are, reflecting back on all of it.

Here are the prompts, I want you to respond to: number one, my goodness, I spent way too much time worrying about…

And I didn’t spend nearly enough time doing things like…

Here’s why these prompts are so genius. First of all, I hope that you make it way past 96 and have the most healthful, rich life. But the truth is, none of us know how much longer we’re going to be here and no day is guaranteed. And rather than getting caught up in the minutia, and feeling overwhelmed and feeling like you’re stretched in a million directions and having your phone or your computer or whatever pull your attention, why not take a step back and really assess while you still have the chance? The chance to make a change, the chance to aim this most precious resource of your time, your attention, your love, to what really matters to you.

And so the first one, I spent way too much time worrying about ___.

And I didn’t spend nearly enough time doing ___

Answer those questions, answer them from your heart, answer them honestly. And I promise it’ll provide a roadmap to some significant change that you can start right now.

So give it a go. Okay, thank you for listening, and I will speak to you next time.

Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast. You can find more online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk

You can find me on Twitter @ThatHoarder. And on Facebook at Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder.

To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support and do subscribe to this podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.

 

Image: Andre Hunter