Show notes
- Website: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding
- Twitter: @ThatHoarder
- Facebook: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- YouTube: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Help out: Support this project
Subscribe with:
- Apple Podcasts / iTunes
- Google Podcasts
- Spotify
- RSS
- Podcast Addict
- Stitcher
- Amazon Music
- Audible
- Podchaser
- Pandora
- Deezer
- Player FM
- Podcast Index
- TuneIn and Alexa
- Castro
Audio credits
- Intro and outro music: grapelemon
- Ding dong: MatthewWong
Transcript
Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder. Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk and follow me on Twitter at @ThatHoarder and on Facebook at facebook.com/ThatHoarder.
So today, I’m going to give you nine reasons why you should not set goals this new year. If you’re listening just as this episode is released, it’s going to be 2022 In a few days, and everybody’s talking about setting goals for the new year.
This episode is likely to be different to other podcasts you listen to that are talking about how to set goals, the best way to set goals. Firstly, because the internet does not need its 13 millionth guide to setting SMART goals. SMART, as you must know by now, being goals that are specific, measurable, attainable, or achievable, realistic, and timely.
But the other reason this isn’t about how to set goals and how to set SMART goals is because after many years of setting different goals every January, I’m increasingly convinced that setting goals just doesn’t work.
And worse than that, I think that setting goals can be counterproductive and make things worse.
Setting goals can be counterproductive and make things worse. Share on XSo I’m going to talk about why I don’t think goal setting is the answer. And what we can do instead.
So firstly, 99% of the time, setting new year goals does not work. Who do you know who is still going to the gym today, or walking 10,000 steps a day today who vowed to do those on January 1st this year? Who do you know who went on a diet on January 1st this year, and is still on that same diet today?
If you know anybody, I would be quite impressed.
I, throughout my life, have set many dozens of goals if not hundreds, probably. You know how many I’ve stuck to in the long term? A handful, at most. Short term, I can stick to them. Long term, they don’t work.
And this isn’t a failure on my part. I increasingly believe it’s that goal setting is not the panacea that people present it to be.
My second reason you shouldn’t set goals is that your priorities might change. A year is a really long time to do the same thing without having the option of revising and revisiting and looking at whether your original plan was the most useful way to improve your life.
What your priorities were on December 31st won’t necessarily match your priorities on August 15th.
A new year resolution goal is a big commitment. And you just don’t know what your priorities will be in a few weeks in a few months, this time next year.
My third reason you should reconsider setting goals is that when you’re doing something because of a goal you set months ago, that can make anything feel like a chore. If, by September, you’re still against all odds doing the thing you said you’d do in January, you may well feel like “Oh, God, this again!” when you might have been doing the same task, but have had the chance to enjoy it a bit if you’re doing it because you wanted to, because you chose to, not because you’d committed to however long ago.
My fourth reason to not set goals is a big one, to be honest, and that is that failing at your goals feels horrible. There’s no two ways about it, you feel like a rotten, terrible person.
Even though it’s the very nature of goal setting that nearly always causes the failure, it’s not anything to do with you, it’s that goal setting is not the solution to everything that some people present it as.
So you’re being set up to fail. And then when you fail, you feel personally responsible, and like you’re useless.
And you’re not.
It's the very nature of goal setting that nearly always causes the failure, it’s that goal setting is not the solution to everything that some people present it as. Share on XReason number five is goal setting can in itself be a form of quite elaborate procrastination. It does feel good to set goals. Like you feel like you’ve got your life in order, don’t you? And you’ve got three goals to enter the new year with or your focus word for the year or whatever it is.
It reminds me of like doing exams when I was at school, and I would spend so long putting together a revision timetable that I could look at and say, “Okay, I’m revising maths on Monday morning, biology on Monday afternoon, and then Tuesday morning, I’m revising RE and English. Then Tuesday afternoon, I’m revising music”.
And then I would colour code my revision timetable so that all my maths sessions were yellow, and all my music sessions were red. And I would spend so long putting together my revision timetable, because it meant I didn’t have to actually revise because I was doing a legitimate revision task.
Elaborate procrastination!
So while it feels good to put your goals together, when it comes to enacting them, you definitely feel less enthusiastic, especially if you’ve been trying to achieve the same goal for a while.
A guy on TikTok called Brave Dave, who I will link to in the show notes but his username is @brave.dave summed this up quite nicely. It’s in regards, in his example, of kind of making plans. But it’s the same philosophy, I think.
I’ll put the link as I said in the show notes, but just have a listen to Brave Dave.
“I scheduled some plans, deliberate plans. Boy, I can’t wait for the day of my plans! Oh, here it comes the day my plans! What is all this? Why are there plans? I can’t believe that I have any plans. I’d rather be home than to have any plans. Who the hell even scheduled me plans?”
My sixth reason that goal setting can be problematic is that following pre-set rules means you can’t follow your instinct. If your goal says, this afternoon at four o’clock, you’re doing half an hour of decluttering in the kitchen but it’s quarter to four and you really, really want to tackle your bedroom, you’ll be torn.
What do you do? Do you risk failing at your goal? Or do you do the thing that you’re feeling a bit inspired to do?
And one option is that you’ll do your goal in the kitchen, because that’s your goal, and you’ll resent it and you’ll hate it. Another option is that you’ll say “no, I’m in the mood to do my bedroom, I’m going to do my bedroom”, which blows your goal. And so you feel like you’ve failed because you haven’t met your goal, even though you might have made good progress in the bedroom. Another option, the worst of both worlds, is that you’ll admit defeat, do neither and make no progress at all.
My seventh reason that setting goals can be counterproductive is that setting goals can put you under pressure and feeling under pressure, if you’ve got a certain kind of personality, can make you want to shut down. You just can’t cope, you can’t face it, you just do nothing.
Shutting down means you achieve nothing at all. Which takes you back to failing at your goal which feels terrible. And because you feel terrible, you’ll then make no further progress.
Reason number eight is that getting the balance right, if you do set goals, is almost impossible. Every goal you set is either way too optimistic, hoping for things you couldn’t possibly achieve. Or it’s so underwhelming in a bid to avoid putting yourself under too much pressure that there’s no point setting the goal in the first place. It might be little more than you’re doing already.
And as things change throughout the year like your workload, your energy levels, your other commitments, then a goal that worked in January may be far too optimistic, or far too pessimistic, by April.
And my final reason why goal setting fails people is that when you fail to stick with your goal, you give up entirely.
How often have you heard somebody say, I was on a diet, but today, I went to McDonald’s, I’ve screwed up my diet, so the diet is off? And they stop dieting altogether.
Now dieting is very like goal setting in this respect. It’s designed for people to fail. But when they do fail, they feel it’s a personal failing rather than a structural failing. If you wobble on your diet, and then eat all the food, that’s counterproductive. If you wobble on your goal setting, and then say, sod it and throw away all the goals, you don’t achieve things.
So at the very least, don’t go for big, grand-gesture goals. Instead, focus on improvements in gradual but steady increments. People are very “all or nothing” when they focus on goals they set, and that is damaging and counterproductive.
So instead of setting goals, what can you do? I would say focus on your motivations instead. Think about how you will get to where you want to be, but also why you want to be there, and start along that path, with regular reassessments whenever things change, or whenever you feel stuck. If you think “I want to be able to walk to the front door without stepping over things”, think about what you need to do to get there but focus on why you want to do it, rather than a series of steps that have no flexibility in them whatsoever.
In addition to that make dehoarding as pleasant as possible. Sounds weird, it’s pretty unpleasant as tasks go! But whether that’s putting good music on or rewarding yourself afterwards, this is a long term thing we have to embark on and avoiding it being horribly unpleasant can only be a good thing.
But focus on the journey, focus on the process, rather than focusing on some arbitrary goals that feel like a good idea today, but will feel entirely irrelevant, or will feel like shackles around you, by March.
In just one second, I’ll give you my top tip of the week. In the meantime, please do subscribe to the podcast, review it (five stars would be amazing!) and share it with your friends or anyone who might be interested, or who might benefit from it. It all really helps.
To find out more ways to support the website, the podcast, and my overall dehoarding project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support
Now, back to your top tip.
So my top tip this week is just a bit of advice. If you’re a hoarder, you have probably been a hoarder for a long time. It’s taken a long time to create this problem and it’s going to take a long time to resolve it.
So you’re going to need patience. This is going to take time, potentially a really long time, but if you accept that as part of the process, rather than see it as a failing, you’ll beat yourself up less, hate yourself less and shut down less, which should help you make progress in the long run. Give yourself a break, basically. Give yourself the time you need.
Okay, thank you for listening, and I will see you next week in 2022.
Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast. You can find more online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk
You can find me on Twitter @ThatHoarder. And on Facebook at Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder.
To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support and do subscribe to this podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.
Image: Glen Carrie
