Embracing imperfect solutions and partial remedies
Embracing imperfect solutions and partial remedies

Show notes

Subscribe

Audio credits

Transcript

Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder. Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast and all my social media, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk. Finally, I am not a doctor, I’m just a hoarder doing her best, so do seek professional support if and when you need it.

So today I’m going to start with a review. I have had a few new reviews lately, so I always appreciate them. So this review is from Amelia Spain, and was left on Apple Podcasts UK. And it was a 5* review. And it says:

“Essential listening. This really is essential listening for everyone who keeps too much stuff. I’m so pleased I came across this podcast, thank you for your time, energy and expertise, invaluable stuff.”

Thank you, Amelia Spain, I really appreciate that. It’s… it’s good to hear, it’s good to hear.

So today, I’m going to talk about the idea that imperfect solutions, and partial solutions to problems are not the enemy.

In fact, they are, I have come to believe, an actual positive. It’s not like, I mean, they are a compromise by definition. But that making that compromise has so many more benefits than the risk of doing something imperfectly.

Over the time that I’ve been trying to tackle this problem and learn about this problem… of hoarding, obviously, in case you wonder which podcast you’re listening to (!), I have come to understand perfectionism a lot better, I guess.

And I’ve come to understand it is as a real limiting factor in my life, and in a lot of our lives.

That it’s not just a matter of wanting to do things correctly. If it was, you know, that’s not a bad thing.

What it is is a need to do things in such a prescribed way that nothing else will do and that that doing something badly is far worse than not doing it at all.

And that kind of rigid thinking is really, really detrimental to many aspects of my life. But definitely with regard to trying to dehoard because every time I go, I don’t know how to clear that the stuff off that table properly, so I won’t, nothing ever gets done.

And I’ve been trying over time to tackle that thinking. And a big shift in that, for me, has been taking the risk of trying to do something knowing it wasn’t the perfect solution, trying to let myself do something even if I knew in advance that it wasn’t 100% ideal.

And that was a really, really hard thing to get my head around doing. It was a really hard thing to allow myself to do. Can I really, really, really risk doing this in an inefficient way or an inadequate way?

Can I really, really, really risk doing this in an inefficient way or an inadequate way? Share on X

And so starting to try and do things, knowing that it wasn’t going to be perfect was – and remains – hard. But the experiments I’ve been doing with letting myself do imperfect things that have proved to me initially, that nothing terrible would happen, which is great. But over time, as I then learned, okay, nothing terrible is going to happen so I can risk doing it a bit more, I’ve come to see that it’s better than just nothing terrible happening. It’s actually that really good things can happen.

So think of embracing imperfect solutions as a counter to perfectionism.

Think of embracing imperfect solutions as a counter to perfectionism. Share on X

Now I’ve done a whole episode before on perfectionism. It was an interview with Dr. Jan Eppingstall, a counsellor who specialises in hoarding in Australia, I will link to that episode in the show notes at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/

So you might want to listen to that as well. But yeah, if you’re thinking, I can’t tolerate imperfect solutions, I can’t tolerate partial solutions, never mind embrace them, just keep listening.

I’m not going to make you do anything! I just want to present a counter to some of those fears based on what I’ve been doing.

Because one of the really transformative things that I got through cognitive behavioural therapy was the idea of trying things as an experiment, treating things as experimentation.

Jan, the counsellor I just mentioned, frames this slightly differently, she frames it as doing things with an attitude of curiosity. But I think I view those two as very much hand in hand.

And so when I started having CBT, I’d been at a point of absolute stasis for a long time. I couldn’t dehoard because I couldn’t do it right. And I didn’t know how to do it. And it was too difficult and just too much, too overwhelming, too everything.

And when I had the CBT, we would agree on a task or something I was going to do in the week. So I would have the therapy session. And then I would do a task. And then in the following one, we would look at how it went and see what we could learn and distil.

And she – the therapist – framed it right from the start as an experiment. And I really liked that because it freed me up. If I did something, and it didn’t go brilliantly, that felt a lot better when it was framed as an experiment, because experiments are there to see whether it goes well or not.

So I wasn’t going in with that pressure to do it perfectly from the off.

I was going in with an open mind saying, Okay, I’ll try this thing we talked about, then we can assess whether it’s helpful or not.

And that was one of the key factors framing things as an experiment that took me from standing absolutely still to making progress.

Before seeing things in that way, I possibly took it even a step further. I felt like… I believed that I had to come up with a perfect solution in my head and then implement it. I would look at say a pile of… I don’t know, anything! And I would think what I need to do is imagine exactly how that’s going to go, plan it all out, and then when I’ve worked out intellectually, when I’ve planned it out practically, I will then do it.

So if I came up with what I thought was a perfect solution and started to implement it, then I would invariably realise it wasn’t perfect. And my approach was to go, okay, that doesn’t work. And stop.

Then start from scratch, trying to create the perfect solution in my head. And then trying to put my complete plan into action again, and failing again, because what I imagined would happen in my head didn’t necessarily happen in real life.

But since embracing experimentation, since embracing imperfect and partial solutions, what I do now, or try really hard to do – obviously, this stuff is really ingrained and I’ve carried it around for a long time. So it’s all a work in progress – but what I tried to do now is come up with a rough solution in my head, and start to apply it.

I don’t go into action with a complete game plan from start to finish, I have learned, or I am learning that that doesn’t go well for me.

And then when something inevitably doesn’t quite work, or doesn’t quite go as I imagined, rather than write the whole thing off, I try to do some problem solving, I guess.

Like, Okay, I thought that setup of bags there and boxes there and the pile there would be what I needed. But the reality is that I’m throwing away more than I anticipated, or I’m moving things around more than I anticipated.

So the current setup doesn’t quite allow for that. Maybe I could grab an extra bag for donations, or maybe I can keep that space there free to move these things.

And so what I’m doing is having a bit of a plan, and then starting, and then based on how it goes, adapting it. And then starting with the adaptation and seeing how that goes. And then based on how that goes, adapting a bit more, adapting a bit more.

Because if you’re too set on a particular course, what I found is that if it looks like it’s going wrong, or if it looks like you won’t achieve what you’d hoped, it’s too easy to abandon the entire thing altogether.

By embracing partial solutions, embracing imperfection, if things don’t turn out quite like you’d hoped, or like you’d imagined, or if things change course, it won’t throw you as much and it won’t make you want to throw in the towel as much.

You’re not invested on the plan that you thought would work. You’re invested in a process that improves over time.

You're not invested on the plan that you thought would work. You're invested in a process that improves over time. Share on X

And also, even if you did come up with a perfect solution today, even if you did, and it was absolutely perfect. What is a perfect solution for you today may not be a perfect solution in the future.

It’s more variable than that. Things change. Something that you initially find really effective, like putting happy music on, might suddenly start to really irritate you. Or even if things change in your home. Something that works on vast piles of things may just be less effective when you’ve only got a few things left to sort out.

If you accept that solutions are more fluid than that, and that imperfect solutions have a place, you will be less likely to stick stubbornly to something that used to work really well but just doesn’t fit in your life anymore.

There’s nothing wrong with that. There’s nothing bad about it. There’s nothing good about it either.

It’s just that things change, priorities change, interests change.

I, a while ago, was praising an app I’d started using that would ping up reminders on your phone to do something.

But what I really, really liked about it was that you gave it parameters of particular times of day and how many reminders you want. And then it popped up the reminder at a random time within those times.

So a couple of times a day, I had a reminder pop up on my phone, that said, throw five things away.

And it was great. I liked the unpredictability of it. I liked that it didn’t feel boring and routine, that like at five o’clock every day, I had to do this thing.

And for a while it was really effective. And then recently, I noticed that I was dismissing more of those… far more of those notifications than I was taking action on.

And I think in the past, I might have berated myself for that. But what I was able to do this time was just say, Okay, this isn’t working for me at the moment. I’m going to disable the app for the time being, and maybe come back to it in a while.

But I could appreciate that it was useful for a few months, while not beating myself up for losing interest in it, or for it losing effectiveness, or probably a combination of the two.

And if we can roll with it, if we can roll with that kind of thing, it’s better than… what’s that saying? It’s better than flogging a dead horse. That’s a pretty horrible saying actually when I think about it.

So another flaw of trying to come up with the perfect solution is that even if there was one, and I’m not sure there is, it doesn’t guarantee that it will still be the perfect solution in six months or 10 years.

So if you’re more able to test things out, experiment, do something a bit rather than all of it, you’re more equipped for those things changing.

And key to this, but something that definitely took me a long while, is that this isn’t about just tolerating imperfect solutions. Doing something imperfectly is good! Because you’re still doing it! Doing some of your dehoarding is amazing.

That needs congratulation. Even if it wasn’t amazingly efficient, even if it took you ages, even if it wasn’t as productive as you’d hoped. You’ve done some and that’s brilliant.

I recently set about trying to reduce the volume of a massive mound of clothes. And I looked at this mound from a distance and thought I need to get rid of three quarters of that.

So I started this task saying for every item of clothing I keep, I need to get rid of three. So if I keep one top, I have to donate or throw away three tops. If I keep one pair of trousers, I have to donate or throw away three pairs of trousers.

Which is a good goal to have. And from a distance, looking at a generic pile, I could eye it up and say, Yeah, I need about a quarter of that.

But then of course, when it came to going through them and picking each item up, it was harder than that.

But what happened was I probably managed to keep half and donate half.

And there’s two ways of looking at that. One, if I was feeling bad about myself, would be, I really failed. at getting rid of three quarters of my clothes. That was a massive failure. I wanted to get rid of three quarters of my clothes, and I wasn’t even close to three quarters of my clothes. What a disaster.

The other way to look at it, which is what I chose to go with, is Blimey, I got rid of half of that pile. That is pretty amazing!

Half of that pile is far more than if I hadn’t tried at all. Half of that pile is far more than if I had spent six weeks trying to work out the perfect plan in my head and putting myself under so much pressure that I never started.

Sure, at some point, I’ll need to go back through them and try and get rid of some more. But if I look at that as a failure to get rid of three quarters of my stuff, I’m doing myself a real disservice.

Because aiming high but not insisting on perfection means that a big pile of clothes has left my house.

And if I had insisted on perfection, none would have left my house, not a single thing.

Like I’ve talked before as well about my kitchen chaos. And I have a weird partial… very partial solution going on at the moment.

Basically the very short version is my cupboards are too full. So I stopped putting things in cupboards. So I ended up with bags and bags and bags in front of the cupboards so then I couldn’t clear out the cupboards of old stuff. Because there were bags in front. And so then because I was using the bags as cupboards, I never knew what I had. So I kept buying more than I needed. Which would just add more bags, which would add more piles.

It was a bit of a disaster situation. And this went on for longer than I should have allowed it to.

And I had a big, big, big, big, big series of sessions and started to implement a very partial, incredibly imperfect solution.

Out of date stuff thrown away, everything else sorted into bags by theme. So all my tins in one bag, all my chocolate in another bag, all of my rice and pasta in another bag, that kind of thing.

This helped me in a number of ways. Because I was putting like with like, I stopped over buying because I could see at a glance what I already had.

So whereas before I’d have thought, oh I don’t know if I have any tinned tomatoes so I’ll buy some just in case, I now know that I have more tinned tomatoes than a medium-size city could use in a month so I really don’t need to buy any.

And this is a messy solution, it would look if somebody came in, probably not much better than it looked before I started this process.

However, to me, it all makes a lot more sense. And I know what I’m doing, and I feel like I’ve got a handle on it. And it is so far from the ultimate solution. It’s really… yeah, it’s not great.

But do you know what it is? It’s better than it was.

And the situation I was in before where I would have dozens of bags, each with just one or two things in, it was absolute chaos. I would like to say that I would have come in with a perfect solution. But I had been avoiding that for several years.

And this is imperfect. But it’s starting to work. It’s starting to make sense. It’s starting to fall into place.

I know what food I have, I know where it is and how to access it.

I had been completely frozen. I was making zero progress, not bits of progress, I was absolutely stuck.

You know, using bags instead of kitchen cupboards is obviously not a complete solution. But it is better than no solution.

The alternative is sitting in fear and overwhelm, doing nothing.

And I know that’s the alternative because that’s where I was, for a really, really long time.

The whole idea of trial and error includes making errors. And making errors for somebody like me is not something I find easy.

I like to be efficient. I like to be reliable. I like to be successful.

And so I think I’ve always thought of trial and error as really meaning trial and success, I guess.

I try things out in order to succeed.

And I think I have overlooked that error is part of it. And there’s no single 100% right choice. Not the only way but a really effective way of knowing what might help is knowing what doesn’t help. And a really effective way of knowing what might work is understanding what doesn’t work.

And the way to find out what doesn’t work is to try it and let yourself make mistakes. Let yourself make errors.

And even as I say this, even though I’m working really hard on this, I find it uncomfortable to say.

I don’t like making mistakes! I don’t like making errors! But there has to be some failure on the way to success.

You know, you can look at like some of the biggest books of all time were rejected by dozens of publishing houses. You look at scientists and engineers who invented and discovered incredible things. And they didn’t get there on their first go. And part of what got them there was doing things wrong and learning from it.

Making mistakes in the pursuit of better things is something we have to learn to cope with Share on X

Making mistakes in the pursuit of better things, I think, is something we have to learn to cope with in ourselves.

If, like me, you find that difficult, try and sit with the idea for a bit. You don’t have to take gigantic risks. But if the fear of making mistakes prevents you from taking even the tiniest risk, then it’s really, really getting in your way.

Because sometimes it is the things we do wrong that make us go, Okay, that was a disaster. But what if I did the opposite? Or what if I did it like this instead?

Sometimes it is like a launchpad for doing better.

Something I’m working on at the moment is I’m trying to find the most efficient way of getting charity donations out of my house and into the charity shop without setting off big panicky alarms in my head. And also without overwhelming myself with practicality.

So I’ve been developing a bit of a system and my current system is overly elaborate. It involves too much, okay, I’ll put it in this bag, and then transfer it to that bag and then move that there and then do this and do that. A lot of palaver.

But despite this, things are leaving the house and going to the charity shop. And that is not to be underestimated.

I feel confident, based on the work I’ve been doing over the last year and a bit, that I will hone the process over time.

But until then, it’s still better to have an overly elaborate, overly work intensive and probably a bit ridiculous process than it is to have no process, waiting for perfection and meaning that nothing leaves the house.

In the past, I would have said, this way of doing things is overly elaborate and a bit ridiculous – I will stop doing it until I’ve worked out the best way.

And everything would have stopped.

Now, I say this is overly elaborate and a bit ridiculous. But doing it this way will help me to work out a more efficient way to do this. And in the meantime, I will at least get some things out of the house.

Sometimes when we’re waiting for a perfect solution, it’s essentially a great excuse to not start.

Not only can you not fail if you don’t try. But also if you don’t try, then you don’t have to get rid of any of your stuff.

And that’s powerful when you hoard, because all of your instincts are saying I need all this stuff.

So something to think about if you are waiting for the perfect solution is: is that a way of stalling? Is it a way of postponing having to start?

There are other areas of our life where we probably are better at imperfect solutions. If we step away from trying to dehoard, if something breaks, you might stick it back together with duct tape until you can get it fixed or get a replacement.

If there is more month left than money, you might throw together all the leftover randomness from your fridge rather than cook something that you know works.

If your favourite brand of washing powder is out of stock, you might pick one that you don’t like as much.

Those are all partial solutions or imperfect solutions. And we do them because that’s life, sometimes if something breaks, you stick it together until you can get it fixed.

And we cope.

It may be that I just gave some random examples there, it may be that one of those horrifies you and you think I could never possibly use the wrong laundry powder. And that’s okay.

But there may be other areas of your life where you realise that you do actually compromise a bit on perfection. And where you cope with an imperfect solution from time to time.

Another problem with chasing perfect solutions is that if an apparently perfect solution goes off course somehow, the temptation is to abandon it altogether, isn’t it?

We all know the situation of abandoning an entire healthy eating plan because we eat one packet of crisps.

With an imperfect healthy eating plan, eating a packet of crisps is a wobble. And you carry on with your healthy eating without doing too much damage. One packet of crisps isn’t going to hurt you.

If one packet of crisps is so unacceptable, because your plan is perfect and complete and rigid and unaccommodating, it throws you off course completely. So you do none of it and eat 10 packets of crisps.

Now, which have if those approaches leaves you with healthier eating? The one packet of crisps, or the 10 packets of crisps?

So the options are perfect solution: one wobble and you abandon the entire thing. Or an imperfect solution, where wobbles are built in, and you still eat 80% healthier on an ongoing basis, with the odd steak pie thrown in.

It’s not the one packet of crisps that ruins your healthy eating. It’s throwing the entire thing out because something went wrong.

And it’s the same with dehoarding. If your rigid, perfect solution can’t cope with things not going to plan, you’ll lose a lot more progress than if you have a partial solution that can cope with unexpected things happening.

Whether that is unexpected things external to you, like having a crisis at work or something breaking or whether it’s an unexpected internal thing, like having a reaction to an item that you weren’t anticipating.

Imperfect solutions allow you… encourage you, even, to prioritise consistency over perfection. And consistency is what gets you to your goals in a gigantic project. And dehoarding is a gigantic project.

Bursts and rushes and flurries help but you can’t sustain them. Consistency is what gets you to the end of the marathon.

It’s always worth asking yourself, What is the worst that will happen? If the worst that will happen is: the way I do this will be slightly less efficient than is ideal, you’ve really, honestly got nothing to worry about.

Try to think more of the process than some kind of unattainable, perfect result.

If you’re creating a process, it feels more adaptable, it feels more like something that can change and grow over time.

It’s not a straight line from which you must never deviate.

And talk yourself out of some of the caution you might feel desperate to hold onto.

That caution is there to protect you. But it’s become so rigid and controlling that it is damaging. It’s like a computer file that’s become corrupted, it might have been useful once, it might have served a purpose once. But now it’s in your way. And it’s not helpful.

It might have started off helpful, it might have started off a good idea, it might have started off a way to survive. But that’s not what it is now.

And keep in mind that things change over time. If you’re too wedded to the idea that something is perfect, and therefore ultimate and ideal, then when you make progress, or if your life changes, you’ll be stuck because your perfect solution doesn’t work anymore, doesn’t apply anymore.

Perhaps currently, you have a policy that you have to donate half of your books. And you’ve got 2000 books. So once you’ve donated 1000 books, your perfect solution has been implemented.

And this prevents you from reassessing and thinking, actually, I live in quite a small space and 1000 is still a lot of books.

And doing what I’ve done so far has reduced my sensitivity to getting rid of them. It’s got easier, I find it straightforward now to get rid of a lot of books that I would have found impossible a year or two ago.

So maybe I’ll get rid of two out of every three books from now on. So overall, I will end up with 300 books.

If you stick with your original, no, I said I will end up with 1000. And I will end up with 1000 because that was what I said and that’s how things are. You’re scuppering your own progress.

Whereas with an imperfect solution, built in from the start is the idea that it will grow and develop as you work out what helps the most.

And then as your circumstances change, and as your surroundings change, it won’t be a wrench to adapt it because that was always the plan.

If your original perfect solution turns out to be rigid and not at all adaptable, you’re stuck with a decision you might have made in 2020, before a global pandemic, how does that apply now?

Something really interesting I’ve found since really trying to embrace this is that my negative self-talk has calmed down a bit.

Now, my negative self-talk is always overactive. It’s always there, giving me a hard time.

But some of it has eased, some of it has eased up. So rather than kind of constantly berating myself, I said I’d get rid of 75% of my clothes, and I didn’t, I’m a disaster, I’m a failure, I’m so rubbish.

Instead of that, I can negotiate with myself a bit. And navigate decisions and policies as I go. And say, I hoped to get rid of 75% of my clothes. But I’ve got rid of 50% of not all my clothes, but that big pile of clothes… and actually, I’m quite impressed with myself!

Whereas if I’d stuck from the start with that rigidity, the negative self-talk would have won.

“Good enough” gets the job, at least partially done.

Is it perfect? No. Is it good enough? Yeah.

Perfection delays things. “Good enough” makes progress.

Maybe one day you will find a perfect solution. But until then, partial solutions will have to do.

But what’s more, starting with partial solutions is almost certainly the way to get close to working out what a complete solution might be, if such a thing is able to exist.

So at best, partial solutions will get you to perfect solutions. At worst, partial solutions will lead to improvement, even if not perfection.

So a couple of times now, I have asked listeners to send me their hoarding secret. And I’ve set up a form so that people can send in their secret and I’ve got no idea who they are. I’ve got no way of knowing who they are.

It’s as anonymous as it’s possible to be… that I can work out anyway. I certainly have no way of finding out who sends in what.

So what I’m going to do from time to time, is read out one of the secrets that somebody has sent me.

And I feel so privileged and honoured that people are trusting me with this, even though I don’t know who they are, it’s still a big deal. Because I’ve made clear every time I’ve asked for secrets, I’ve made clear that this is to talk about on the podcast.

And I know from doing the podcast myself, it’s hard to publicise this stuff. It’s hard to be open, knowing other people will hear. So this is one person’s hoarding secret. They say:

“I work in the field of art and design in a demanding, rewarding, high-pressure job. My public work space (office) is exceptionally tidy and carefully designed, while my personal living space is disordered and cluttered. My secret is my chaotic home space. Part of the problem is that exhaustion from the demands of my job prevents me from de-hoarding, compounded by procrastination, “I might need that item someday”. To keep up in my profession, I funnel all my energy into my job, and haven’t yet figured out how to carve out time to create an orderly home.”

Thank you so much for sending that in. I expect a lot of people will relate to this. People look at their public persona, their work persona, and think of them as really effective, professional, impressive people.

And that can add to how shameful it feels to live in chaos and disorder, I think.

So I just want you to know that it’s not just you.

And listeners, if you want to send in your secret you can do so https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/secret

Do you have any burning questions you’d love me to answer? I’ll get to the top tip in a second. But my first Q&A episode was really popular so I’m going to be open to questions on a rolling basis and then, when I have enough, I will make another episode answering them.

Contact me on Twitter, Facebook, TikTok, Reddit, YouTube or plain old email – all the links are on my website at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/

Ask me anything and I’ll do my best to answer it.

Now, your top tip.

My top tip this week is a mini clip from a podcast called Creative Women International. And it’s about taking risks, have a listen.

“And I love that idea that you know, if we don’t try, we’re not moving forward. If we don’t try we’re stagnant. If we’re not failing sometimes and you know people think of failure as a negative, it really isn’t.

It proves that you’re doing something. It proves that you’re taking risks and putting yourself out there. And as a creative I know how difficult that is because your work is so personal, only you can do it comes from you.“

This is something I definitely find hard but I’m really trying to improve on so let’s all see if we can take a little risk. Let’s give it a go.

All right. Thank you for listening, and I will speak to you next time.

Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast. You can find more online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk

You can find me on Twitter @ThatHoarder. And on Facebook at Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder.

To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support and do subscribe to this podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.

 

Image: Jakob Owens