Sunk Cost Fallacy and hoarding with Dr Jan Eppingstall of Stuffology
Sunk Cost Fallacy and hoarding with Dr Jan Eppingstall of Stuffology

Show notes

Subscribe

Audio credits

Transcript

Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder. Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast and all my social media, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk. Finally, I am not a doctor, I’m just a hoarder doing her best, so do seek professional support if and when you need it.

That Hoarder: Dr. Jan Eppingstall has a master’s degree in counselling and a PhD in hoarding. As a counsellor in Australia, she works with people who hoard and has also contributed to research about hoarding. She is a regular guest on the podcast and it is always a pleasure to host her.

Jan, how are you?

Dr. Jan Eppingstall: I’m fabulous. And yourself?

TH: I’m alright, thank you.

JE: Excellent, excellent.

TH: So today, Jan and I are geeking out about another logical fallacy, because we can’t quite help ourselves, but it is very related to hoarding.

And so what we’re talking about today is called the Sunk Cost Fallacy, which we are going to explain. So if you don’t know what that is, don’t immediately tune out!

So it’s the kind of thing that will almost certainly be familiar to listeners, even if they’ve not heard it called that. It’s a way of thinking that can lead us to make poor decisions, and it’s really deeply ingrained.

Think of spending 50 quid in a casino and losing it all. If you’re really logical, you cut your losses and you leave. But the Sunk Cost Fallacy is so powerful that it tells you you’ve got this far, you may as well keep going, you’ve got to win it back.

Or, and I’ve done this so many times in my life. You’ve been waiting for the bus for 20 minutes. You know, if you just go around the corner, you could get a different bus. But something in you goes, I’ve waited this long, I’m going to stay here and wait for this bus.

It’s why some people can’t abandon a book or a film halfway through. They’ve already invested two hours in it, it will be a waste not to finish it.

So Jan, how would you describe the Sunk Cost Fallacy?

JE: Oh, all of those things I have done many times.

I think I may have said before that my first degree was a Bachelor of Economics in the early 90s. And I think if behavioural economics had been a thing, then I might not be here or I might be here talking about this very thing. I don’t know.

But it does fascinate me that for so many years, economists tried to make us believe that there was such a thing as the rational consumer. I just thought it was bizarre when I was studying it, I was going, rational? No one’s rational. It just does not happen.

So that’s why I love this type of discussion, because everyone falls prey to cognitive biases.

But the Sunk Cost Fallacy is a cognitive bias that sees us continuing a particular behaviour despite evidence that it’s not effective because we have previously invested, I’m just air quoting here, significant resources, time, money and / or effort. And if we step away from our investment, it will become a loss.

So it’s got so much in there that is just related to our thoughts about our stuff.

TH: So the Sunk Cost Fallacy can lead us to stay with a partner when the relationship’s unhappy because we’ve already invested years of our lives with them, stay in a job we hate because we spent a year doing a training course for it.

How is that kind of irrational thinking so prevalent in the general population?

'The thinking's hardwired and built into our preferences. So often they're a mental shortcut that helps us make decisions quickly. Unfortunately for humans, our emotions kind of get in the way.' - @stuff_ology Share on X

JE: Yeah, like many of these kind of cognitive biases, like the Sunk Cost Fallacy, the thinking’s kind of actually hardwired and built into our preferences.

So often they’re a heuristic, which is just a fancy word for a mental shortcut that helps us make decisions quickly.

Unfortunately for humans, our emotions kind of get in the way.

I recently just read while I was doing research for this podcast, one study indicated that it might be a way to compensate for the constraints of limited memory. And I’ve kind of thought, that’s an interesting idea.

I mean, you’ve probably all thought this, I’m sure: I’ve been doing it this way for so long. I trust that there’s kind of a logical reason for the original decision to behave this way, even if I can’t remember it.

And besides, I’ve invested so much time and effort perfecting this behaviour. It’d be a waste to stop now. I’ll just keep going.

TH: I find power cables and I think there must be a reason I kept this. I don’t know what it’s for. There must be a reason, I’d better still keep it.

JE: Well, they came into the house somehow, who knows how, and you think, well, yes, I must have some device that these connect to. And I’ll want it. I know when I throw it out, I’ll need it immediately.

Oh, and that whole, well, I’ve kept it this long, there must be a good reason. I’ll continue to keep it, even if I have no room or use for it. Exactly that.

Just the fact that I’ve had it for so long, for as long as I can remember, it means I kind of don’t have to rely on my memory for the reason why.

I often think, isn’t that self-evident? I wouldn’t keep something just because. Would I? Yes, that’s exactly what I do. And we all do.

We don’t rationally think about the opportunity costs of keeping things or continuing the behaviours. You know, that is the consequences of it. The opportunity costs are usually the consequences of continuing the action.

And we don’t think about what we can’t do because of the clutter or what not being able to do something actually costs us.

We only think of what we could do with the stuff. We don’t look at the probability of us actually doing it.

So we kind of think, oh, we’ve got all these objects that we can do things with. Am I actually ever going to do it? That’s not something I ever kind of calculate the probability of.

Or, hmm, I’ve been working on this embroidery as a gift for my nephew for 30 years and he’s now 33. This is not autobiographical at all. He has a baby of his own.

So I can’t waste the time and money I’ve spent on it now. I must keep it and I must finish it, even though it’s unfashionable and daggy now and I wouldn’t give it to anyone.

So, oh, God, that’s on top of mind at the moment. I’m thinking there’s things that I’ve created or half created and really is only about my inability to step away and not complete something. That is the only reason it is still in the house.

So it’s so pervasive. Everybody is going through this type of fallacy with themselves every day, multiple times a day, I think.

TH: And in terms of people who hoard, I feel like the Sunk Cost Fallacy comes into play frequently.

As you’ve just said, you know, I’ve kept it this long, I’d better keep hold of it. Or I paid so much for it, I’d better keep it.

I've kept it this long, I'd better keep hold of it. Or I paid so much for it, I’d better keep it. Share on X

What are some of the ways that this kind of thinking can trip hoarders up?

JE: I mean, the definition that I was just talking about before, continuing a particular behaviour despite evidence that it’s not effective because we’ve invested significant resources, time, money and or effort, that’s kind of saving in a nutshell for hoarding. That’s kind of everything about our saving urge.

And research has found that those who have a mindset that leads them to rumination on the past are more likely to be trapped in that Sunk Cost Fallacy. And it sounds like many people I talk to, it’s kind of this endless, endless loop.

The other kind of things we’ve talked about, you know, I’ve kept it this long or I’ve paid so much for it. Another thing that people often, I believe, you know, hold on to things is I’ve wanted this for so long, I have to keep going. You know, that kind of this opportunity of something that comes to mind when I think of stories I’ve heard about projects that kind of take over someone’s life, like building a house with your bare hands. The person feels like there is no choice but to keep going, even when there’s kind of no end in sight.

And they almost become as one with the project. This is how I define myself. And if I stop, even though really now I don’t, you know, my family’s gone and I’m the only one left and I’m still here, you know, working on building the house with my bare hands. It’s… I see that a little bit.

Or perhaps I’ve spent years collecting these thingies. I can’t stop now.

Not only that, you know, if I ever consider selling my collection, I’ve got to recoup the cost of my time and effort because otherwise I’ve actually lost money. I spent hours scouring op shops or whatever it might be.

But we equate the time, effort and money put into something as representative of its worth, don’t we? We kind of equate those two things.

But that may not be monetary either. It could be emotional value. And I think that’s what makes it super hard for people who hoard.

I think we’ve spoken about this before, about upholding our rigidly held values can take so much time and effort, like that environmental perfectionism, that we feel we are worthy and morally superior purely based on the effort.

It’s such a laborious task. So that must mean that we’re better people.

And researchers have found that people will subordinate their pleasure, if it means avoiding waste, they will not, you know, not be as comfortable, not be as happy as long as it avoids waste.

And that again is kind of hoarding in a nutshell. I think it’s quite pervasive and it can trip you up in lots of different ways with hoarding.

TH: The thing you said about something you wanted for a long time made me think of, when I was a kid, I really wanted this knitting machine. It was like a children’s version of a knitting machine.

And I really wanted this and I wasn’t allowed it because I was told I would be interested in it for three weeks and then never use it again, which was probably accurate.

But then about 10 years ago, I saw one in a charity shop, the exact one. And I was like, I’ve got to have that. And I bought it. I have never touched it since.

But there was something in me that felt like I was almost like closing a circle. Whereas in fact, what I was doing was buying something else to sit in the spare room.

JE: It’s such a like, it’s that whole closing the loop on a, yeah, a want or something or something that you could have been or yeah, it’s really interesting how we just can’t seem to let go of that.

And that’s a perfect example of it. It might have fulfilled something in you back then and that would have been lovely. But now it’s kind of, you’re no longer that person. You’re a different person.

TH: I’m not 10.

JE: You’re not 10.

TH: So let’s look some more at how the Sunk Cost Fallacy can lead to problems. The Decision Lab website, which I will link to on my website, says “The Sunk Cost Fallacy means that we are making decisions that are irrational and lead to sub-optimal outcomes. We are focused on our past investments instead of our present and future costs and benefits, meaning that we commit ourselves to decisions that are no longer in our best interests.”

So how does this kind of thinking get so ingrained?

JE: I think we’re often, one of the things I was thinking when I was researching this is we often are overly optimistic about the odds of making our money back or kind of having a win out of something that we’ve held on to.

However, you know, if we acted rationally, only future costs and benefits would be taken in account because regardless of what we’ve reinvested, we’re not going to get it back, whether or not we follow through or not on that decision.

So it is the emotions that get in the way. I think that’s why it gets so ingrained. It’s embarrassing to give up once you’ve taken something so far And that’s what… we feel shame and our pride takes a hit.

So I think that’s why we often double down, because we do, the emotions are in the way of our decision making, which is why I always thought it was bizarre that we were the rational consumer and we would be thinking about everything according to, you know, economic laws and rules.

We just don’t. Emotions are what make us human and it also makes us make bad decisions.

TH: And so giving up on a book, a relationship, an item is saying I misjudged or I was wrong. Keeping hold means I was right.

JE: And I can delay feeling bad about it, although in so many other ways it’s not doing me a service to hold on to it.

I’ve always found it so hard to put down a book that I’ve not enjoyed and now I kind of have some rules around that for myself. I kind of think if I read the first chapter and it just doesn’t grab me, it’s okay. It’s okay. I can put it down.

And there’s ways to do that now. You know, you can get the first chapter as a sample, via an app. And at least then you think, oh no, that was, that wasn’t, or I’m not ready for that. I’m not ready to read that at the moment. I’ll just leave it over there.

But we often will buy things and feel that we absolutely have to use or engage with it because if we don’t, then it means we’ve made a mistake and we just do not want to believe that we make that many mistakes in our lives.

TH: And it’s like I talked about in the episode about avoiding discomfort: when we avoid one kind of discomfort, we’re just creating other kinds of discomfort for ourselves.

JE: Exactly. It’s like water. It will find its way through, you know, or find its way to you somehow. If it’s not that down that path, it’ll be a different path.

We can’t avoid discomfort. Yeah. Full stop.

TH: And we might feel that abandoning a plan partway through, because that would mean we’d wasted the original investment of time or money or effort, plays into hoarders’ overall fear of waste in general, and also loss aversion, where we feel loss more than we appreciate gains.

JE: Yeah. So they’re all kind of related. So loss aversion is the underlying mechanism of the Sunk Cost Fallacy.

So yes, they kind of all feed into each other. And I don’t think there’s been any research done, but I really do feel like those who suffer from hoarding do feel it even more strongly, that they’re more averse to loss.

We know they’re more sensitive to anxiety. It all kind of plays into the reason that, that we continue to behave in this way.

But I thought something else was interesting. A study published last year found that individuals with lower childhood socioeconomic status tend to perceive loss of prior investments as more wasteful than those with higher childhood socioeconomic status.

I mean, it’s a bit Captain Obvious, yes, but we always need to investigate these things empirically, just in case we kind of have our assumptions about something and our logic has missed a point.

But that totally makes sense, because really, we have been raised, we have been taught as children, every little bit counts and I can’t waste.

And we take that with us throughout our life, doesn’t matter, really doesn’t matter how much we earn. At the end of the day, we will continue to be waste averse, loss averse.

And I just feel like hoarding is particularly… hoarding in general is literally loss averse.

TH: And I think as well as the socio economic thing, I think of like, my grandparents’ generation in the UK, who were young adults during rationing and had to make family meals out of virtually nothing.

Of course, they couldn’t let anything go. Not that my grandparents were hoarders, but that mentality of a small waste is huge.

JE: Yes, I mean, just I’ve noticed, my mum doesn’t do it now, but keeping the paper off the butter, you know, because you use that to grease the pans or whatever, you know, and I found myself doing that going, I am doing that. I don’t need to do that. Wow, I just do it because that’s what my mother and what my grandmother did.

And the constant feeling that, well, in my day, we couldn’t waste those things. So therefore, you need to be more cautious about everything, wasting anything. It’s not only socio economic.

TH: I remember there’s a story that went around years ago. It was a bit cringy, but made a good point, which was a woman teaching her young adult daughter how to make a roast dinner and how you cut the end off the joint of meat. And the daughter said, why do you cut the end off? And she said, oh, I don’t know. It’s just what my mum did.

So she asks her, why do you cut the end off? And she says, I don’t know. It’s just what my mum did. So she asked her mum and says, oh, it’s just that we had a really small pan and the meat didn’t fit in it.

And yet this had carried on through the generations.

JE: Someone told me that exact story. Someone told me that exact story this week.

And it is just exactly that. We just keep doing without questioning, I think, is the hardest thing to recognise that we’re just doing it because this it feels like it must be done.

And that’s part of what we need to change for ourselves is to question everything, be curious about why we do those things.

TH: And it’s hard to know which bits to question, because if you question literally every move you make in a day, you wouldn’t get anything done.

So there are certain things that you have to have a shortcut for, just to get through the day. So you don’t always know which bits you’re being irrational about.

JE: Exactly. That is so true.

TH: Do you want to be a Dehoarding Darling? You can be now at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling   

If you love the podcast and want a bit extra, you can finally sign up to be a Dehoarding Darling.

Members will get an exclusive monthly post with an additional top tip, some podcasts and music recommendations and a personal update from me about how things are going.

Find out the full details at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling  

So something I found interesting when researching this was how many studies found that people feel this need to avoid a sunk cost, whether they invested money in something themselves or whether someone else had paid for the initial thing.

And I can really see how this could scupper hoarders in particular. Like somebody else made us spend a lot of time making this I’d better keep it. Or I got this in a charity shop, but I bet it was worth a lot more when it was originally bought so I’d better keep it.

JE: Yeah, I thought that was really interesting too. I think the example one of the examples I read was about an expensive cake. You know that was bought by you at a patisserie miles away versus a cheap supermarket cake and there was this tendency to keep eating the expensive cake despite being full kind of regardless of who bought it.

The idea that we’re kind of compelled to honour others’ investments as much as our own.

I can see that happens with you know things handed down from family members like it made me think of the Antiques Roadshow. You know, someone comes on with an extremely ugly something that they’ve had hidden in the cupboard for 50 years.

But now that they know it’s worth a thousand pounds it’s on the mantelpiece and it’s pride of place.

I mean, I’d sell it, that’s just me, I would extract the gains from that very quickly and pass it on.

But yeah, I think there is a lot of, so those of us who are kind of biased towards sentimentality and workmanship and handcrafted pieces, we’re more likely to keep the doilies that we bought from the op shop that our granny didn’t make. It wasn’t anyone related to us but someone else did and they spent hours doing it so we want to honour that.

In fact I had someone tell me that the other day, oh gosh I wish people would keep their family heirlooms to themselves and not put them in the op shop because I feel compelled to save someone else’s family heirlooms and that I have no connection with whatsoever!

TH: I have a friend who buys old photos like old family photos on eBay. She’s got hundreds of like other people’s grannies. It’s so odd.

JE: But it is it’s that well it was important to someone and that must mean that it’s just generally important.

TH: My weird dilemma of the week a few weeks ago on this podcast was a mug I’d found that someone had clearly painted, like hand painted not in a professional way. And it’s unlike me but I had no memory of this mug even existing.

So somebody painted it for me and gave it to me and I don’t know who and I don’t know when and I have no emotional connection to this mug but I was still like well somebody painted it, somebody put the time in I should probably keep it. Even though I don’t know who, it doesn’t look great. I couldn’t give it to a charity shop because it doesn’t look great and in case whoever painted it came across in the charity shop! So I ended up throwing it in the bin and it was quite a dilemma and it was that kind of somebody else’s sunk cost. And I don’t even know who!

JE: And they were thinking of me and they gifted it to me, you know? And also the guilt of not remembering I think is also… and keeping it kind of means that you can fudge that a bit you can kind of yeah you know if someone were to come around and see it see you drinking tea out of ah you still got my whatever.

TH: Yes yeah because normally I’m that kind of hoarder who could pick up any item and tell you the whole story – what shop I was in, what mood I was in when I bought it, what shop it came from, what the weather was like. Which is part of the problem – I have so many kind of associations with every little piece of tat.

But so it’s quite unusual for that to mean nothing to me.

It did go but it was a real like I don’t know what to do.

JE: And it was probably a bit of, you know your hand putting it over the rubbish bin then going oh no oh okay no. That’s so hard!

TH: And so one excuse that a lot of people who hoard will use is ‘But I paid good money for this’, to justify keeping something. ‘It would be a waste to get rid of it’.

This is fully the Sunk Cost Fallacy in action. And the argument I always advocate in those circumstances is that the money has been and gone the waste happened when you bought it, getting rid of it now doesn’t make any difference to the waste that happened then.

And so when the waste happened long ago, what we do with the thing now has no impact on that.

Similarly, we might think it’s taken up space for so long I should keep it to justify it having existed here the whole time.

Or even like I’ve paid to store it I can’t get rid of it now.

I wonder if there’s a place to try and replace it’s been a waste of money, time, space I better keep it with it’s been a waste all these years so that’s more of a reason to reclaim the space?

JE: Yeah. I do think that we can reframe it. I think some acceptance that we made a mistake is needed here too, we can’t change what we’ve done in the past.

It might not have been a mistake in fact to buy or acquire the item, we may have needed it at the time and actually used it.

But keeping it longer than we needed it and losing that valuable living space was the mistake, I think.

And being able to accept that it’s been a waste all these years. Really if I part with it now, I’m able to gain something from that parting.

It’s okay to admit you were wrong in your decision to keep it. You thought you were doing the right thing and now you know better.

It’s okay to change your mind and it’s okay to decide now rather than before. You weren’t ready before, you’re ready now to reclaim that space.

'It's okay to admit you were wrong in your decision to keep it. You thought you were doing the right thing and now you know better. It's okay to change your mind. You're ready now to reclaim that space.' - @stuff_ology Share on X

And that kind of reframing I think is important because space gives you opportunity, doesn’t it, to do things? To be the way you want to be.

TH: And I feel like there’s even a step before ‘it’s okay to admit you’re wrong’ and that is ‘it’s okay to be wrong’

JE: Yes, yes.

TH: And then it’s okay to admit it.

JE: Yes exactly!

TH: That’s clearly something I’m working on.

JE: It’s okay, I’m often wrong, I’m often wrong. I just happily admit it.

TH: I also wonder whether we could in some way twist it to our advantage in our head and say I’ve got rid of this much stuff, may as well get rid of it all.

JE: Yeah I really do! I really can see that! I’ve come this far letting it go, just exactly like the complete reversal of I’ve kept it for this long. I’ve let go of this much really, I’m close enough to being there.

TH: If 10 mugs have gone and there’s still not quite space in the cupboard for the ones I’ve got left, may as well just get rid of three more.

JE: Yeah yeah exactly, and then it will fit neatly in the cupboard I’ll have just enough.

I do like that idea of you know the appropriate amount of stuff, just enough of whatever it might be.

Because having extra doesn’t always serve you, it can just get in the way and make things more difficult to do.

So having just enough I think is nice, it feels comfortable.

TH: And it’s hard. Even knowing what just enough is!

JE: Yes and that’s part of also the disorder isn’t it? We just don’t know how much is just enough. Other people can say well you know and they kind of calculate it in their head and they think about i. But with hoarding there’s a lot of emotion in inbuilt into that. There’s also the whole idea that letting go must be a bad thing because that’s the way we feel about loss.

TH: I like those water bottles that are insulated so they keep your water really cold. And I have to really stop myself from going I like the insulated water bottles, I therefore need all the insulated water bottles.

In practice, three is probably ideal so I can have a couple on the go, one in the wash.

But all of my instincts say but insulated water bottles are good, so surely more insulated water bottles is more good.

And that with everything!

JE: Yes yes yes. I think what I what I’ve I tend to do and suggest to others is kind of think at the time of purchase, okay where is it… like really literally doing though where is it going to go? How many do I already have? How hard is it going to be to let go of even a broken one of those or one that I’d worn out or whatever it might be? How hard was it to let go of that?

Now if I bring a brand new one in, am I going to let go of an old one? Probably not, so that means I’ve now got four instead of three and it’s that whole oh gosh it’s so hard to get rid of anything, I think I’ll wait until I really need it and then I’ll get it.

But I’ve often done that. I used to do that a lot. I’d buy new shoes but I’d still have a pair that were perfectly fine and so I keep wearing the perfectly fine ones or I would just stop wearing the perfectly fine ones, wear the brand-new ones, feel guilty because I’ve wasted the other ones.

TH: And I tried to implement a rule that if I was replacing something, I had to throw away the thing before replacing it rather than after. Because I knew that I always promise I will throw the other thing and then I don’t.

But I found, I’m still working on it. But what I found is that the fear in my brain says if you throw it away and can’t get a replacement, then you have none.

And so I feel like it’s a good idea in theory, but my brain isn’t quite on board yet.

JE: Yes, yes. Or even if you go to the shop and it’s out of stock even. You know what I mean, then is that I’m without something, I’m without. Yeah. And that can be hard to cope with, that fear of really not… I mean, as you say, even if you can’t, well, it’d be way worse if you couldn’t get it anymore if they discontinued it or whatever, but it’s just as bad as if they don’t have it in stock. Like this…

TH: Panic!

JE: Yeah, fear, scarcity, panic.

TH: Oh, and we’re going to talk about scarcity in a future episode, aren’t we?

JE: Yes, we are scarcity, scarcity.

TH: So this tendency to allow costs that are already gone to influence future decisions might have some kind of strong pull for us. But the phrase, throwing good money after bad comes to mind.

The money is gone, the space is gone, the time is gone. All we can control is what comes next.

How can we really get ourselves to believe that? I think we know that in theory, don’t we? But how do we get it to absorb?

JE: Yeah, you know what I think, and we’ve talked about this often and you’ve been doing this a lot is experimenting.

So really explore the outcome fully. Give yourself that opportunity, cost it out, you know, establish a price for your time. Work out the value of the real estate that this stuff is occupying, cost out how much you’re spending because you can’t use the space.

Maybe like if it’s the kitchen, how much are you spending on takeaway or prepared meals because you aren’t able to cook?

And don’t forget to think about what you could be doing instead of this laborious process of letting things go. You know, you could be spending that improving your qualifications or reading a good book or catching up with friends.

And make sure you even cost out how long it takes for you to work out all these calculations! Because the fact that you have to work all this out, because you don’t want to let go of things that you might need.

TH: Yeah.

JE: And the other thing is compare attempting to sell something for the price you believe it’s worth. That often can really work. Pop it on eBay, and don’t just think about it like actually put it on there. What does it cost you in time, postage, petrol, inconvenience?

And don’t forget to take into account learning how to list it! I mean, some people don’t even know. They’ll say I’ll sell it on eBay. And you ask them, and they’ve never done it, I don’t know.

And that’s a big gap in your process.

TH: I’ve been getting rid of recipe books recently. And I’m keeping a handful, but I’m getting rid of most of them.

And a couple of the I’ve thought, I wonder if this is like with selling, just the odd one?

There are two ways you can look. You can put it into like Amazon, and see how much the second-hand ones are selling for. Or on eBay, you can do a search for completed items and see how much that thing sold for in the past, just to get an idea of whether it’s worth doing.

JE: Whether it’s worth it. Yeah.

TH: And even a few years ago, I would have been like, oh, that sells for three or four pounds, it’s probably worth selling, right?

But as you say, once you’ve listed it and photographed it and answered weird questions and got to the post office and wrapped it and all of that. It’s so rarely worth it.

For me now, I look up the odd book, because it used to be that I would look up every book I was getting rid of in those two ways. I don’t do that now. I look up the odd one. And it would really have to be worth… I don’t have like a number, but considerably more than three or four pounds for it to be worth doing.

And being able to look those things up, it can be a distraction. But if there’s one you’re really wondering about. It can be worth doing just to see whether your valuation of it is the same as what other people would actually value it as.

JE: Exactly, exactly. And as you said, replying to all those weird questions about the item, and then if it doesn’t sell, you know, the cost of doing it a second time, and then it doesn’t sell and then you’ve still got to go and get rid of it somehow.

So then then price just dropping it in the bin. Too far? Taking it a bit far, I think maybe!

TH: You know, there’s a place for it, there’s a place for it.

JE: Yeah, yeah. But you know, if that’s too far, price kind of driving around trying to find someone who will take it in as a donation. Because often donations are not being accepted these days.

And if you have to make inquiries on whether someone will accept your donations, how long does that take? Price it. Or you could go maybe 1800 got junk and pay $300 and fill a track and decide, you know, they can then decide for you about what should be donated dispassionately, but again, it’s that whole maybe I’ve gone this far. Now, maybe that’s just the final step of committing to something like that and saying, Okay, I’m going to do this. And I’m comfortable because I’ve been working on this whole d hoarding thing for so long that I feel confident that I can let those last truckload of stuff go.

TH: I just remembered a really weird example that I now think is Sunk Cost Fallacy related.

When I had a dentist appointment, and I’m not great at the dentist. I hate it.

And I was so nervous and I had worried for a week and then spent just absolute terror in the waiting room.

And somebody said to me afterwards, well done for going in, after all that. And I was like, I didn’t want to waste that anxiety!

JE: Waste the worry!

TH: Like once I’d spent a week worrying and then a morning in terro,r to then just leave… got to make the most…

JE: Make the most of your complete terror. Because otherwise you might have to do it all over again. I love that. Yes. Oh, yes.

Don’t waste the worry. Because the worry… we do often worry because we think it’s helping. It’s giving us ideas on how to… and look that’s what worry I guess is, anxiety is for, you know to plan our attack if something goes wrong.

It’s just that these days you know, we’re not running away from lions or wildebeests or whatever. We’re really just…

TH: And it’s a matter of degree, isn’t it? You know, a bit of worry might help. Doing nothing but worry doesn’t get you anywhere.

JE: No, exactly it just ties you up in knots, it really does.

TH: And if you’ve been paying to store stuff like if you’ve got a storage unit, that seems to me like an obvious ‘this is costing more to keep than it would to get rid’.

JE: Exactly, and when you start to kind of do the numbers…

TH: But equally, I can see how, but I’ve paid to store it for this long could really come in.

JE: Yeah, yeah, really hard because people will say, Oh, well, that would mean I was wrong for all this time. And then when they add up how much they’ve spent, they just can’t admit to themselves that cutting their losses now is a good plan.

It’s really quite hard to convince people, but chances are, what’s in there is not worth what you’re paying monthly.

Seriously.

I mean, the prices are, you know, it’s so expensive. And I get quite upset, a little bit cross when I see the advertising on the side of the storage places. Are you decluttering? Come and stor itd here. Like I know that that’s the idea. I think it’s for storing, you know, things that are precious that you haven’t got room for or elections or dead body… I mean.

TH: Yeah, or like if you’re moving into a bigger house. Yes. I’m trying to think of how to word it. Yeah, like you’re, you’ve moved from a big house to a temporary, small house, and then you’re going to be moving back into a big house that you store your stuff. That makes sense.

JE: Exactly

TH: For three months while you’re moving.

JE: Exactly renovations, and you just need to be downsize for that time. And then you move back, but it has become a permanent kind of concept.

And really, we know that people who hoard, they just don’t interact with their staff, their stuff’s there, but they’re not really using it or being with it. Quite often it is in a storage shed or in a storage unit.

You have to do a lot of mental gymnastics to make that seem worthwhile. In my mind.

It’s possible, you can do the gymnastics, it’s just that really you’re doing yourself a disservice.

TH: Christopher Olivola, from Carnegie Mellon School of Business, researches the Sunk Cost Fallacy. And he told Time, “There’s nothing you can do to regain money that’s lost. And pursuing something that makes you unhappy not only isn’t going to get your money back, but it’s also going to make you worse off, you’re just digging a deeper hole”.

So what can we learn from this?

JE: Whenever I hear digging a deeper hole, I think of the ACT, the Acceptance and Commitment Therapy metaphor, you know, you fall into a fairly deep hole, and the only thing you have to help you get out of it is a shovel. And since you don’t know what to do, and you feel desperate, you start to shovel away. And little by little, you get deeper into the hole. The hole gets deeper and deeper, and it’s harder to get out.

So wouldn’t it be better to use the shovel in some other way? Couldn’t you’ve waited to see if someone could come and help you out?

So this is exactly what happens. You know, with experiential avoidance and the anxiety you feel about getting out of the difficult situation, makes you bury yourself even more in that difficulty.

So what can we learn? Maybe you have to suffer at the beginning, but the long-term solution will be more beneficial.

It is about us… we avoid any sort of negative experience. But basically, it will build up to be a much bigger, more difficult experience at the end of the day, if we don’t deal with it earlier.

We can’t avoid suffering. We’re always going to be suffering in some way. It’s just the human condition.

But it’s how and when and how much that matters.

So I think that’s what we can we can learn from that.

TH: And is me holding on to… I’m just looking around. Any of this is me holding on to David Attenborough his book on The Life of Mammals more important than saying 15 years ago when I bought David Attenborough’s book The Life of Mammals, I thought I would read it. I was wrong. And I can let it go.

Is that really… it’s not that much of a leap. And yet we hold back, don’t we?

JE: Yeah. Yeah. And we all do it. We all do it at some level. It’s not unusual. None of these things are unusual. It’s just that you might have 10 David Attenborough books that you haven’t been able to read.

And we do feel like… Not only the mistake, but we feel less than because we haven’t been able to live up to that person that we thought we were. And that again, is part of it, isn’t it?

TH: Yeah, I picked that completely at random. And I’m already going, but David Attenborough is so lovely. And the book’s probably got beautiful photos. I’m already questioning.

JE: Yeah, exactly. And when everything’s nice, I’ll have it on my coffee table, and it will be lovely. And people come around and have a cup of tea and look at it.

And it’s like, yeah, probably not. Yeah.

But it is a beautiful book. And maybe it’s sitting in your bookshelf, you know, maybe it would be appreciated more at the local school or kindergarten, or, you know, somewhere else that might actually open it and look at it.

That’s the hardest part is to is to think that someone else may actually be more deserving than you are.

TH: Yeah, someone who would actually enjoy it.

JE: Yeah.

TH: So I’m a big believer in having kind of strategic questions we can ask ourselves, that cut through the crap basically, and are designed to make us think a bit differently when we’re trying to decide whether to get rid of something or indeed whether to acquire something.

Are there any good questions we can ask ourselves that can be useful in challenging some of that innate tendency to the Sunk Cost Fallacy?

JE: Yeah, so funny. I Googled this, how to avoid Sunk Cost Fallacy. And the answer I got was quite amusing. Track your investments in future opportunity costs, don’t buy into blind bravado. Let go of your personal attachment to the projects and look ahead to the future.

So the last two, maybe three are hard for people who hoard aren’t they?!

TH: I was just going to say, let go of your personal attachment. Like you’d go, oh okay then!

JE: Yeah. Okay then!

And also look ahead to the future. What? I just thought it was that it was so amusing. Oh, yeah, that’s right. Okay.

I guess we need to kind of be willing to step back from our ideas and see them objectively and say, Well, what would someone else think about my choices?

Try to be dispassionate about them and kind of diffuse from them.

Realistically, who is going to want to buy your stained baby blanket for their newborn? Just because it’s been handed down for generation?. It’s harsh, but fair.

So we need to be that dispassionate kind of observer. And really look at what we’re doing.

Is this the right thing to do? Is someone really going to want this, it is quite hard to do, but that will help you open up to the reality of whether they should stay or go.

And I think overcoming the fear of letting your efforts go to waste. Our efforts are really hard. How much effort did I put in? How much effort can I you know… how much can I get for that effort? What am I going to gain?

Nothing is ever a waste of time if you can actually take something from it.

So what’s my pearl of wisdom from letting go of this object? What can I take away from that?  I now know that puce is not my colour, or a pencil skirt was on a good idea or you know, facts! I now know that, I’m going to remember that next time I go shopping.

We need to tell ourselves that money I’ll never recover won’t dictate my future decisions. Only additional costs matter. If I throw $100 into the wishing well or I chuck it on the dogs at Randwick or wherever. You know if I put it in a wishing well my wishes and granted should I then toss another $100 down after it? No.

Is this really worth following up with more costs?

But it is accepting that there are these other costs as well, isn’t it? Like, what are the other costs?

TH: Yeah, what are they?

JE: What the heck are they? What am I missing out on? And actually asking yourself that question, can break that down going, Oh, okay. Yeah, right, not only am I spending my last couple of dollars on this tchotchke, I also know that I’ve got a big bill coming up, and I don’t want to go into debt for it.

There’s all sorts of costs, filling up rooms that you can actually use for the purpose etc., there’s so many you need to know what they are, and you need to kind of put a value around that.

TH: And even like, if I can’t do a repair in my home because of the stuff, then in 10 years’ time, it might be a much more costly repair.

JE: Yeah, and also, it may mean that the things that you do really care about, the things that are really important…

TH: Crushed…

JE: Crushed or hurt. I think that’s one of the hardest ones for me is like, you know, I see these things, and people uncover these amazing treasures. And I think I totally agree with you, those are beautiful. And you need to keep them and you need to display them.

But there isn’t that opportunity to display, there is the concern that they might break or get broken in the hoard.

If you are able to display those beautifully, I think you would get more joy and you’d be more connected with whoever it was that owned it or gave it to you then it is now being hidden under all these things.

That’s really hard though for people to cope with.

TH: It is, it is. And I think there’s something around this thing about making mistakes as well. That sometimes that may be a question like, if acquiring this had been a mistake, would that be that bad?

Because that kind of opens the door a little bit to then, okay. It wasn’t mistake, because you’ve already kind of gone. Wouldn’t be that bad. Surely.

JE: Yes, yes. Yes. I mean, just being able to acknowledge that if it was a mistake, you know, even just thinking if it was if just let’s just pretend that it was.

TH: A thought experiment.

JE: Exactly. Thought experiment. How bad could it really be? Let’s be honest with ourselves, let’s not catastrophise and end up homeless in the street.

Let’s just try and think through more reasonable consequences, not the catastrophe.

TH: And then, if I keep it now, would that also be a mistake? Because we presumably don’t want to make further mistakes?

JE: That’s right. That’s right. And maybe that will help us, if we can start avoiding mistakes, bringing things in, then potentially, it means we don’t have to fear mistakes at the other end.

I don’t know. I don’t know. That’s how I kind of think of it.

That’s how I’ve been kind of managing my stuff. Because we all have to manage our own staff. I mean, we all had the same concerns.

And I certainly do, given that my mom’s downsizing. I’m trying to make room for some of those things that I want in my life from her home.

So it meant that I had to let go of a lot of things that really had just been avoided decisions.

TH: Yeah. Whereas if it was me, I would be thinking these are things I really want from my mom’s house. But I wouldn’t then go to so what do I need to get rid of in order to fit them in?

That’s the kind of disconnect, isn’t it? I would probably ask, How can I make space but that would be moving things around. It wouldn’t be one in one out.

JE: Yes. Yeah. Because I always look at the home and go, Oh, that that really looks. There’s too many things there that draw my eye. So I want to reduce what’s there. So I’m really focusing in on that beautiful object or whatever.

But I think there’s that’s not necessarily the way people who hoard think it’s more well, I’ve got it I have it. Even if it’s not displayed beautifully, at least I won’t feel the fear of either making a mistake or having a loss, etc.

Yeah, I think that fear that we have of acknowledging a loss can keep us looking backwards as well, at events that we can’t change. Where really what we should be interested in is what’s coming next.

What’s happening next, we can’t change the past, we can only do what we can do now to make the future better, I guess.

It’s really that forward looking rather than backward looking. Which is hard to change. Because it’s a mindset.

TH: Yeah. And if something is important to you, because it belongs to somebody you’ve lost, getting rid of the thing doesn’t make them any more gone.

You know, it’s awful that they’re gone. The thing isn’t the awfulness, the awfulness is that they’re gone, and keeping everything they ever owned, I get, you know, you might want to hold on to a couple of things from somebody who’s gone, that all makes sense.

But keeping everything doesn’t mean they’re still there.

JE: No, it doesn’t make them any less gone. And it means that nothing special, everything’s there, and nothing special as well.

I do really like the idea of thinking about that person and their essence and who they were, and really pulling out things that just represent that, you know, like my dad, it might be a fountain pen, and, a weird kind of picture of him, a caricature picture that I’ve got up there, I’ve got about three or four things, things like that. It’s just a couple of things.

And those connections that you have in your mind will just open up like a flower when you look at it.

But if you’ve got a whole rummage of stuff, that doesn’t happen, it almost the loss almost feels more painful.

TH: Yeah, I know I’ve talked about this before, but I’m going to talk about it again.

After my grandparents died, and my family was going to their house to sort everything out. I couldn’t go for various reasons. And so was asked, you know, is there anything you want from your grandparents’ house.

And I thought about it and there were two things I really wanted that I fully associated with them and still look at and just are perfect.

And I was very lucky that I didn’t have to go to the house and sort it out. Because I know that the minute I was in there, I would be going I have to have this. And I definitely have to have this. I can’t not have this.

But if you do have to sort out a house after somebody’s died, I think, as a thought experiment, before you go in, saying, if somebody asked me, What two things do you want? The answer to that is the essence of those people for you. And the rest of it is extraneous.

And what was like perfect for me, you know, would be something different to another member of my family, because we all have different associations and meanings.

JE: Exactly.

TH: So even if you do have to go in and do the physical sorting out, if before you go in, it’s crucial that it’s before you go in, think what would those items be? I feel like that would help.

JE: Yes, really, really sitting with it and kind of, and I’m trying to think about my mum and my dad. And that is exactly… there’s probably three to five things that really, you know, you really feel the essence when you look at them or when you touch those things. And that’s it.

If you do it before you go, then you’ve got a much better chance of selecting the things and not coming away with all of those extraneous items that will be really hard to get rid of once they’re in your own home because then it’s Wow, but that’s grandmas or that’s dads or… Yeah, yeah, the more you…

TH: And I know that’s diverted a bit from sunk cost, but it’s a big issue that a lot of people face, that kind of associations with a person.

And then once you’ve kept it for a while, then the sunk cost comes into play, because I’ve kept it for a while I must have kept it for a reason. I better keep it because I’ve kept it.

And what’s where you need to start asking does this serve my future?

JE: And it also becomes the next generation’s. Oh my goodness, we’ve kept it, we must keep it because Mum kept it and it was grandma’s and then it just keeps on going down, down, down.

And it’d be hilarious to know what grandma really thought of you keeping that object probably just think, well, that was crazy.

TH: She might have kept it because someone gave it to her, but she hated it,

JE: Hated it! Exactly. I know, if you were able to ask them, but it is it’s then you’ve kept it and then it becomes Yeah, well, I’ve kept it this long now.

It’s a tiring thought. The whole Sunk Cost Fallacy. It just makes you feel tired.

TH: And it’s so often the case in the discussions we have that these kinds of things affect everybody, but then hoarders maybe to an additional or more intense degree.

And this is another one of those, isn’t it?

JE: Exactly. It is, it really is. It is something that we all struggle with, but in the hoarding mind, it just seems to impact that exponentially more and just across more objects and more areas of their lives too.

TH: So Jan, if people want to find you online, where can they do so?

JE: They can find me at @stuff_ology, @stuff_ology, https://www.pinterest.co.uk/stuff_ology/ . And you can pop over to Facebook if you like. Stuffology Consulting and drop me a line.

I like having emails in the inbox. jan@stuffology.com.au

TH: And do head to stuffology.com.au to sign up for the email list, where you get a weekly email on a Sunday full of wisdom.

JE: Correct. Although this week, it was late, but I did do it.

TH: And that’s what counts.

JE: That’s what counts.

TH: Thank you, Jan. Always, always wise.

JE: Thank you for having me.

TH: I make this podcast because I think it’s important. I started it as an outlet for myself. But it’s become much more than that. And I hear from people all the time about how listening to me talk about my experience and interview specialists and experts is helping them. hearing those stories makes the time and cost absolutely worth it.

But if you want to help to ensure that the future of the podcast is sustainable, you can donate to help with costs. To send a one off or recurring donation, just go to https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/donate.

Thank you.

So my top tip today comes from the Eco Chic podcast, which I will link to in the show notes.

And she’s giving you a tip about conscious consumption. And even though she’s talking about Black Friday sales, it applies to any sale. And certainly these days, there seems to forever be a sale on.

It’s the winter sale, the spring sale, the summer sale… So have a listen:

Conscious consumption is not just about giving to others, but it’s also that pressure to buy for yourself.

Let’s all acknowledge it. When you see a sale for something that you’ve been eyeing for a minute, it’s really easy to start buying for yourself during the holiday season.

So tip number one is do I need this?

And it’s not to say that you can only buy things that you need, but really think through have I even thought about this purchase before? Or am I buying something on impulse? Am I buying something because I feel pressured? Because I’ve seen it so many times on social media?

I feel like a good answer to the do I need this question is something that you have thought about for a long time and you’ve stopped yourself from purchasing it, because it’s just a little bit out of your price point.

So if there is a Black Friday deal on the hairdryer that you’ve been eyeing for quite some time, and now it’s in a price range that you can justify a little bit more, go ahead and do it because again, if you have the means and you’ve really thought this through them, that’s a conscious consumption purchase, especially if it’s something high quality that you’re going to have for a really long time.

The flip side of that is being susceptible to a holiday gift guide or a sponsored ad for Black Friday advertising a 30% off sale of a clothing brand that you’ve never shopped before.

Do you truly need that? Have you thought about purchasing from that brand before? Is the item that you’re purchasing something that you actually want? Or are you just buying it because it’s 30% off?

So yes, my number one tip for more conscious consumption is actually just stopping yourself and thinking have I thought about this purchase before?

And it might sound, you know, fairly sensible, but it’s good advice.

Okay, thank you for listening, and I will speak to you next time.

Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. You can find more online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk

You can find me on Twitter @ThatHoarder. And on Facebook at Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder.

To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support and do subscribe to this podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.

There may be links in this podcast that earn me money. This doesn’t come at any extra cost to you if you make a purchase through those links and it helps to support the future of the podcast.

 

Photo by Francesco Paggiaro