Show notes
- Podcast ep 56: OCD and hoarding with Jenna Overbaugh, OCD therapist (who also has OCD)
- Podcast ep 40: ADHD and hoarding with Dr Sharon Morein
- Podcast ep 82: Dehoarding when you’re drowning with KC Davis of Struggle Care
- My Bed, Tracey Emin
- ADHD 2.0: New Science and Essential Strategies for Thriving with Distraction – from Childhood through Adulthood by Edward M. Hallowell and John J. Ratey
- How to Fail with Elizabeth Day podcast
- Dr Jan Eppingstall at Stuffology
- https://www.facebook.com/stuffologyconsulting/
- https://twitter.com/stuff_ology
- https://www.instagram.com/stuff_ology/
- Dr Jan Eppingstall on Pinterest
- Website: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding
- Become a Dehoarding Darling
- Submit a topic for the podcast to cover
- Questions to ask when dehoarding: https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/podquestions
- Instagram: @thathoarderpodcast
- Twitter: @ThatHoarder
- Mastodon: @ThatHoarder@mastodon.online
- TikTok: @thathoarderoch https://www.tiktok.com/@thathoarderoch
- Facebook: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Pinterest: That Hoarder
- YouTube: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Reddit: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder subreddit
- Help out: Support this project
- Sponsor the podcast
Subscribe to the podcast
Transcript
Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder.
Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast and all my social media, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk.
Finally, I am not a doctor, I’m just a hoarder doing her best, so do seek professional support if and when you need it.
That Hoarder: So I am here with Dr. Jan Eppingstall, a counsellor in Australia who specialises in working with people who hoard. She has a PhD in hoarding and is an all-round superstar.
Jan, how are you?
Dr. Jan Eppingstall: I’m very well and I’m just bowing as you’ve introduced me and said I’m a superstar, but not quite the superstar that you are.
TH: Oh, bless you.
JE: So I’m just I’m just here as a scaffold. That’s it.
TH: I love it. Can’t think of a better scaffold. Marvellous.
JE: Excellent.
TH: So a lot of people believe that hoarding must be pretty easy to diagnose, that it’s quite a self-evident condition.
It's not actually true that all people who live in overwhelming clutter and don't know how to get out of it are necessarily hoarders in the true sense Share on XBut it’s not actually true that all people who live in overwhelming clutter and don’t know how to get out of it are necessarily hoarders in the true sense of having a diagnosable hoarding disorder.
There are actually a range of other conditions that can cause hoarding-like living conditions or hoarding-like behaviours and the way to approach them can vary.
Sometimes, applying treatments and techniques designed for hoarding disorder will be really helpful and other times they just won’t be relevant at all.
There are a range of conditions that can cause hoarding-like behaviours and the way to approach them can vary. Sometimes, treatments designed for hoarding disorder will be really helpful and others they won't be relevant at all. Share on XSo Jan, first of all, why is it important to understand exactly what is causing behaviours that look like hoarding?
JE: I think with any psychological phenomenon, there’s a need, particularly as clinicians, to focus not only on the behaviours but the reason behind them.
Because often the behaviours do look similar on the face of it.
But unfortunately, if we assume we know why someone is behaving a particular way and then begin treatment without clarification, we can actually inflict unintended harm.
Harm’s harm, whether we intend to or not. And if we go down that path without being curious and asking those questions and finding out the reason behind the behaviours, we can go wrong.
TH: Yeah, absolutely.
So what are some of the other conditions that can cause hoarding behaviours that aren’t the same as hoarding disorder?
JE: The conditions that usually come up are obsessive compulsive disorder, OCD, obsessive compulsive personality disorder, OCPD or depression, the neurodivergent conditions like autism spectrum, attention deficit hyperactivity disorders.
'The conditions that usually come up are #OCD, OCPD or depression, the neurodivergent conditions like autism spectrum and #ADHD' - @stuff_ology Share on XBut just as an aside, I kind of want to say here that I don’t consider either autism or ADHD as disorders. I’m just doing some air quotes.
TH: You are! I can see them, listener.
JE: Good.
Their differences, not a problem, but they are actually currently listed in the DSM as such. So I think that’s a bit of a controversy that we’ll tackle later on.
But the other areas, the other types of conditions are acquired brain injuries including dementia, chronic substance abuse, poverty, intermittent homelessness.
All of those could, if you look just at first glance at the physical manifestation of clutter, you might think that it’s hoarding.
But there are just so many things that can appear that way.
TH: And in this episode, we’re going to talk specifically about depression, about obsessive compulsive disorder, autism, ADHD. But as Jan has said, this is not an exhaustive list.
Obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) and obsessive compulsive personality disorder (OCPD) and hoarding
So we’re going to start by looking at OCD because first of all, because a lot of people still believe that hoarding is a form of OCD.
What is OCD in a nutshell and how can it cause problems that might look like hoarding?
JE: So OCD is a chronic and lifelong disorder in which a person has uncontrollable, reoccurring thoughts or obsessions and / or behaviours, compulsions, that the person feels the urge to repeat over and over again in order to offer some relief from the obsessive thoughts.
So it’s an ego-dystonic disorder, which means the person comprehends that those obsessive thoughts are not real. But they’re unable to stop themselves from completing the ritualistic behaviours.
TH: Kind of powerless against them. Well, that’s how it feels.
JE: Exactly. Because they go, I don’t understand why I have to keep driving, turning around and driving back over that bump. It’s so silly. Why am I doing that? But I have to. I just can’t seem to stop myself.
And it can appear to look like hoarding if we do look at that visual evidence only. That is that presence of a large volume of possessions with no clear organisational order.
But those with hoarding as a symptom of OCD may have difficulty discarding due to more likely a specific obsessional fear.
Like they may not want to discard due to a fear of contaminating themselves or others. They might struggle to discard because of superstitious thoughts about letting go of that object, like something bad might happen to a loved one if they discard it.
Another one that can overlap in hoarding, but I think it would be more intense in OCD, is that feeling those feelings of incompleteness. That’s one that I hear quite often: I feel like if I let that go, then something will be incomplete.
And saving to maintain a record of all life experiences is another thing that’s seen in hoarding within OCD. And this is where some people may save bodily products. I don’t like to say the horrible, yucky words, but sometimes they’ll save hair or nails or whatever other sorts of products or rotten food.
They may not, if they have OCD, they may not feel like they can let anything go. Anything that has come from their body or as part of them.
Or when they attempt to discard, that triggers endless rituals like washing or checking,
TH: Checking that you’re not throwing something away that you shouldn’t with the things that you should.
JE: The things that you should. Yeah. So they avoid the discarding because then they don’t have to go through all those rituals of checking and maybe washing their hands or wiping down the objects. Or whatever it is.
So then that just means they just save it as a result and they avoid it completely.
But perhaps the clearest way to identify if it is hoarding or OCD is whether the person A, enjoys acquiring and feels comforted by having their possessions around them. B, if they’re emotionally attached to most of the stuff and C, they save items mainly because they’re beautiful, valuable or they might be useful in the future.
If they do these things, then it’s likely to be hoarding disorder. It’s not likely to be OCD because people with OCD, as I said earlier, it’s ego dystonic. So they don’t feel comfort by having those possessions around them, opposite to hoarding where that is part of the disorder.
And that attachment, emotional attachment to most of their stuff, that’s more hoarding.
OCD, they’re going to have this still sentimental attachment to some things, but not the same level of attachment to most of their objects.
So that is the way you can kind of distinguish the two.
TH: So what’s the difference between OCD and OCPD, obsessive-compulsive personality disorder?
And can OCPD be hoarding related as well?
JE: Ah, yes. OK, so we’ve got the word salad.
So OCD is a mental disorder with symptoms that cause marked anxiety to the person and can increase while under stress. And this inhibits their ability to function in the world in any normal capacity.
But OCPD is a personality disorder. So personality is that enduring aspect of our individual differences. It tends to dictate how we think, feel, react, behave in particular situations.
And although it’s stable over time, we can learn and evolve. It’s not fixed as such, but it tends to be quite stable.
So if someone has a personality disorder, they’re unable to react flexibly and appropriately to life challenges.
So it’s this kind of set of rigid or extreme traits.
And OCPD, the diagnostic criteria is actually based on Freud’s anal retentive character. It’s just like cut and paste pretty much.
So a personality that has that preoccupation with orderliness or parsimonial frugality and obstinacy, rigidity and stubbornness.
So it’s all they’ve basically kind of gone, ah, that’s a particular personality type. We will now have that in the DSM.
So in 2023, we see those with OCPD as people who are preoccupied with control, perfectionism and organisation.
So for a very long time, hoarding was considered a subtype of OCPD because one of the criteria was an inability to throw out useless or broken objects because that was seen in presenting cases.
Now, this criteria remains in the DSM today. I don’t know whether it should remain there, but it does, which is really, really interesting.
So what I’m going to talk through now are the criteria that are in the current DSM for OCPD. And just have a listen to them and see if see how they fit, how you think they would fit with hoarding, because there are some things that will.
But the first is a preoccupation with details, rules, lists, order, organisation, schedules, to the extent that the reason for the activity is lost.
So you spend all this time organising and then you don’t actually do the things you’ve planned to do.
Perfectionism that interferes with completion of tasks. Your own strict standards are not met.
The third is excessively devoted to work and productivity to the exclusion of leisure and friendships.
Four is over conscientious, scrupulous and inflexibility about matters of morality, ethics and values.
Five is unable to discard worn out or worthless objects, even when they’re of sentimental value.
Six is reluctance to delegate tasks or work with others unless the delegate does exactly what they say to the letter.
Seven is adopts miserly spending towards self and others. Money is something to be hoarded for future catastrophes.
And eight is shows rigidity and stubbornness.
So there’s some things in there like you probably got it at that first one. Like I’m going to spend all this time and I’m going to I’m going to plan what I’m going to do. And then, oh, it’s 10 o’clock at night. I’m tired now.
Or that perfectionism. You know, I have to get this exactly so. Otherwise what’s the point? So I get that too.
And that over conscientiousness, the scrupulosity around waste. And matters of morality and ethics and values. Well, that all encompasses, I think, what hoarders feel about waste.
So there’s definitely overlap there.
TH: But also I can think of a lot of people who would fit those criteria, I feel like a lot of people who are maybe successful at work are quite tick a lot of those boxes and it feels quite drastic to call that a personality disorder when it does fit a lot of people, doesn’t it?
JE: I know, I know, I know. And that’s the thing. And we’ve just kind of highlighted there the number of things that possibly overlap with other elements in other disorders.
So it’s all a bit of a mishmash of symptoms and signs that are certainly not exclusive to one particular disorder.
So it makes a little bit of a fool of some of us because we like these labels. But really, it’s all about what the purpose of the behaviour is, what the behaviour is and how you and the needs that are underneath that.
But OCPD does tend to be like hoarding, ego-syntonic, which means we see these behaviours as part of who we are. You know, I’m the type of person that…
TH: So I make lists, I plan.
JE: I’m a list maker. I’m a planner. I’m a you know, whatever. Exactly.
So they’re likely to feel that they’re right in those actions and thoughts and feelings. And chances are, they don’t believe they have a problem. It’s not a problem that I do these things.
And those with OCPD tend to work themselves ragged, trying to make these unrealistic standards that they’ve set for themselves.
Now, that could look a couple of different ways, couldn’t it? That’s quite broad. It could it could be in a lot of areas of their lives. So it’s a it’s a tricky one.
I don’t hear many people diagnosed with OCPD. I don’t either.
TH: Because I suspect a lot of psychiatrists fit those criteria and so like to go, oh, that’s not real.
JE: And also, also they’re the markers, a lot of those are the markers of what we perceive in society as being successful humans.
TH: 100%
JE: people who plan, people who spend all their time working hard.
TH: They’re meticulous.
JE: They’re meticulous. Exactly. And they don’t want to delegate because you have to do it yourself, no one else can do it as well as you. All that sort of stuff. That’s kind of what people look for in a good employee.
So no one gets diagnosed with it.
I think the worn out and discarded and worthless objects kind of sits there, doesn’t it? It kind of doesn’t feel.
TH: Yeah.
JE: I don’t. Yeah, I don’t. I think they’ve tried to kind of slip that in with the whole frugality angle and the scrupulosity or something.
I don’t know. It just doesn’t sit that well with the entire disorder.
TH: So there is OCD, there is OCD and there is hoarding and they can also combine, like I have a diagnosis of OCD that is entirely actually unrelated as far as I can tell to my hoarding because it was a bit of a mess, the diagnosis, because I might the form of OCD I have, I have the compulsions without the obsessions.
And that’s quite unusual. And so the psychiatrist is mostly excited to have found somebody with this particular formation of OCD.
And then when it came to like, yeah, but what can I do?
He said, to be honest, he said most of the treatments for OCD focus on challenging the obsessions and that reduces the compulsions.
And so because you don’t have the obsessions, there’s nothing to challenge. So there’s not really much we can do.
So I felt like we came out of that meeting with him quite pleased with himself for having found a rarity and me no better off than I had been other than having a name for this thing.
And my compulsions are thinking based. It’s ritual thinking things.
JE: Ah, right.
TH: OK. It’s not counting, but it’s that kind of thing.
JE: OK, right.
TH: And so I have that and I have hoarding disorder and I feel like they’re not connected at all.
But you can have two or three of those and they can be connected. How can somebody work out what’s going on in that kind of respect?
JE: It’s super tricky, but it’s all about that predominant problem. Like in your case, I can see that these two things are quite separate.
What I usually focus on in the hoarding cognitions and thoughts and things, those things that are driving the behaviour, the reasons.
So as I’m talking with the person and I’m observing and listening to their answers, I want to know if they’re emotionally attached to the possessions. That’s like the number one thing.
TH: Yeah.
JE: Do they feel that excessive responsibility for the welfare of their objects?
And you can hear that pretty quickly as you’re working through the initial assessment.
Do they think their memory is poor? So they need to keep things to jog it.
Or do they like to keep things out in the open so they can see it?
Do they excessively anthropomorphise objects and acquire and save on the basis of being kind to inanimate objects?
Clutter may cause them distress, but does the saving cause them distress? No. Well, then I would be saying, yeah, that’s likely to be hoarding.
So I can kind of separate that out and say, OK, those things.
Then I’ll look at organisation. So can I see any extreme levels of organisation within a home and with some areas in disarray? Like maybe they have particular focus, like the office is amazingly, immaculately organised. And then there’s sort of a jumble everywhere else.
Maybe they have like an exceptional planning and goal setting routine or they’re hyper organised and perfectionistic at work. But at home has become overwhelmed because of a new stress or responsibility or loss.
So then, if that was predominant, I would kind of say, OK, I think that’s OCPD. I think there’s some personality, controlling sort of personality that’s going on in that case.
If the person’s emotionally attached and anthropomorphises and is also rigid and perfectionistic with an overwhelming need to control then maybe they have both. Maybe it is both OCPD and hoarding disorder.
But I haven’t seen this as yet. In fact, it could be the other end of the continuum where individuals actually suffer anxiety and stress because they have an extreme urge to throw stuff out. And can’t keep objects because they have that aversion to clutter or imperfection.
TH: Yeah.
JE: So that kind of what has been kind of called compulsive Spartanism, it doesn’t really have a name, but that’s the name I’ve seen.
There’s no research on that phenomenon as yet, but I can kind of see how those two things would definitely… and it’s impacting their life because every time they go to get out the blender, they’ve thrown it in the bin because that’s the blender they don’t use every single minute of every day.
So the urge to throw it out was so strong.
TH: Yeah. Yeah.
JE: So if it’s hoarding within OCD there’s likely to be that significant distress about the behaviour and that kind of bewilderment as to why they can’t let go and stuff like that.
Like, why? I don’t get it.
TH: Hoarders know exactly why they’re keeping it. Yeah.
JE: And they’ve got more than one reason, right? They’ve got a bulk of reasons and they’ll go and this and this and this. And you’ll think, OK, well, that’s logical.
And they won’t have emotional attachment to many objects other than that regular sentimentality.
TH: Yeah.
JE: And then those rituals around checking or cleaning that hold them back from discarding, either because they spend hours doing the rituals or they just avoid discarding completely.
So that’s when I would kind of go, OK, I think that’s I think that’s OCD.
I don’t know how likely it would be to have a combination of all three. It could, though, you could, you could.
TH: Nothing’s impossible.
JE: Nothing’s impossible because if you had the OCD, it could be around contamination and you throw things away or whatever there is a chance. I mean, look, hey.
TH: Never say never.
JE: Never say never.
The listener voicemail segment has a monthly theme to help you to think of something to say!
For September, the question for you to answer is: What’s the hardest thing for you to get rid of?For some people it’s nostalgic items, for others it’s books, or food, or clothes.
This is your opportunity to share your hardest things with us all. Have your say – with your voice!
If you want to record a voice message for me to potentially play on a future podcast episode, go to https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/voicemail and leave a message. The topic for September is the hardest things for you to get rid of.
Let us know what you’re thinking at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/voicemail
Depression and hoarding
TH: So depression is another mental health condition that can lead to living in a situation that might look to outsiders like hoarding, but doesn’t involve the same emotions and thoughts.
You often hear people talk about a depression nest, which can be mistaken for hoarding.
So how can clinical depression cause symptoms or behaviours that look like hoarding?
JE: Ah, yeah. So if you’ve ever suffered from clinical depression before, as I have, you’ll know the lethargy, the insomnia or hypersomnia, that brain fog, hopelessness, helplessness. And you’re just not finding pleasure in things that you enjoyed before.
TH: Everything feels pointless.
JE: Exactly. Everything just feels like, well, why? You know, just getting out of bed is like an Olympic event. And then having a shower is exhausting. If you can’t take time off from work and you’re in that place, you need to kind of plaster the mask on and pretend everything’s fine.
And it’s just exhausting.
So when you get home, you don’t care about the pizza boxes and the coffee mugs and the bin because you’re worthless anyway, right? You know, you don’t deserve a tidy house or an organised house. I
t’ll just get messy again. And no one cares about you. No one’s visiting. So you just give up.
And in these cases, usually the person doesn’t feel attached to all these things. They’ve lost that impetus to maintain their space. And they will usually let you tidy up for them without distress.
I don’t say without shame, though, but without distress, they’ll kind of go, if you’re someone who’s close to them, you’ll be able to grab that plastic garbage bag and just fill it and they won’t feel distress.
TH: Yeah.
JE: I think the depression nest is a good kind of descriptor because it is just it just sort of builds up around you, doesn’t it? And it’s not a protective layer so much as a… pointless just like everything is pointless, it just builds up.
TH: There was an artist years ago, she’s called Tracey Emin and her artwork was basically what we would now call her depression nest.
It was her bed with all the stuff, her unmade bed with like cigarette packets and ashtrays and just all kinds of junk around it.
And it was one of those pieces of art that made people go on the news endlessly saying, what’s happened to art if we think this is good and all of that?
But it’s so… I’ll find a link to it and put a link in the show notes because it’s quite. It’s an evocative thing.
My Bed by Tracey Emin caused huge controversy when it was first exhibited in 1998. Emin nevertheless ardently defended her work against critics who claimed that anyone could exhibit an unmade bed with the retort, "Well, why didn't they? No one has ever done that before." (1/3) pic.twitter.com/3QeUSLzhd7
— Avant Arte (@avant_arte) January 30, 2023
JE: Yeah, because just as you were describing it, I really get that art because it just it’s an expression of those emotions that are internal that they just. And hoarding is the same, isn’t it? For different reasons. Yeah.
And I think if the person can allow someone to come and clean up in inverted commas, then chances are that it really is that it is sinking into that deep clinical depression.
TH: Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I’m just finding a link so I can show you live.
JE: I love it. I love it.
TH: Isn’t it great?
JE: And I have seen so many of those. I think it’s awesome. And I really like that.
TH: You can imagine the white male dominated art world having absolute kittens.
JE: Oh, it’s great. It’s great. And the vodka. Yeah.
TH: Yeah.
JE: Oh, yeah. I’m feeling her pain.
TH: Yes, you know exactly what she was going through. Yeah.
JE: You really do, you know exactly what’s happening? Yeah. Yeah.
The deep, that deep sort of just hopelessness and just helpless. I just lie here and I’ll smoke and I’ll drink. And maybe something will change in between now and when I wake up.
TH: Yeah. Is there a chance that somebody with depression and an extremely cluttered home due to their lethargy and misery and inability to get out of bed could develop essentially hoarding disorder and end up with what I tend to call hoarding thinking that kind of exacerbates the problem?
Or is there always a clear differentiation?
JE: I think that’s a really, really good question. And it’s one I don’t know the answer to.
There’s no clear kind of directionality between depression and hoarding. Like whether one comes first and is followed by the other or the other.
I think if you’re in a deep depression for a long time and you stop making decisions about your stuff. And as a result your default becomes indecision and overwhelm, I think from a logical point of view, it’s possible.
I think the evidence isn’t there yet to tease that out. But I can see that happening over time.
TH: Yeah, I think my thinking with that question was like somebody who goes on a diet and then really likes all the compliments and really likes the sense of control and ends up with an eating disorder.
And that wasn’t what they started with. But they kind of found something in that that they went, oh that helps.
JE: Yeah. And that might be OK, having the stuff around me feels good. That’s one thing that makes me feel good. Therefore… Yeah, yeah, yeah.
TH: And so how if somebody is wondering, do I have depression or do I have hoarding disorder? How can people tell whether they have one or the other or again, both?
It’s not like it’s impossible to be depressed and hoard.
JE: Oh, and it’s very common. One of the most common co-occurring disorders with hoarding.
The thoughts about possessions and reasons for saving are usually there from a young age in like that hoarding mindset.
So they’ll be able to remember having trouble letting go of things, perhaps as an adolescent.
And time is what contributes to the severity in many cases.
An episode of depression may be the first time the person hasn’t kept a clean and tidy home.
So untreated and without support, and as you’ve just said, if it is something that is giving them some comfort, having the things around them is giving them some comfort, that could become hoarding thinking.
And that indecision and brain fog can just make saving and acquiring that default.
I’ll just go for that. Acquiring gives me a little bit of a tiny dopamine hit enough to sort of get me through the day or whatever.
But then when I get home, the lethargy, the pointless, pointlessness of everything just means that I’m just living in clutter.
I’m not sure if I mention it later on, but bipolar disorder you’ve got the highs.
TH: In which you might buy a lot. There’s a lot of excessive spending, isn’t there, if you’re in a high?
JE: Yeah. And that can be devastating for a person because they might be on a high for a long period of time and they’ve bought all this stuff and it’s just overwhelming them.
And then they dip into that depression and crash and you’re living… I had a client many, many, many years ago who was bipolar and her bed, you know, the new clothes and things that she’d bought were up to the level of the bed.
So the whole room was completely one level.
And then she was in a deep depression and she was unable to to even just get out of bed in order to deal with the stuff.
So in that way, I can see that the depression and using purchases to kind of give you that lift can be problematic.
TH: And also, while we’re not clear whether clinical depression can lead to hoarding disorder, I think it’s fairly clear that hoarding disorder can lead to depression.
JE: Mm hmm. Exactly. Yes. Yes, definitely. And it co-occurs.
TH: Yeah. Your situation feels unmanageable. If you get to the point where you start to see this isn’t OK, but you don’t know what to do about it or you’re overwhelmed by it. It’s so easy to just sink into misery, isn’t it?
JE: Exactly. And it’s so hard to lift yourself back up out of it, particularly when often we’re very isolated with hoarding, we are a very isolated population, and not having that that support one on one with someone else or a close friend or family member. It’s so easy to stay down, isn’t it? Stay down deep in that depression without having that connection of someone that you can rely on.
And the idea that when we’re with another person, they help us regulate our nervous system, being in the same room as someone.
And when we’re not having that, like during Covid, that was a real eye opener for a lot of people because they weren’t used to being completely alone all the time.
TH: I’ve had friends who are very depressed and I have said, I’m coming over, I’m going to make you a meal, I’m going to make you a cup of tea. I’m going to put a load of washing in your machine and I could do that. And they needed that and they appreciated that.
If your home is hoarded, you would say, oh, no, don’t come. Don’t come.
So even if you have people…
JE: Exactly. And it’s the shame. It’s the shame that is getting in the way of functioning again. I need this person and I know I need them and I can talk to them on the phone, but that’s not enough. I actually need to be in the room with this person to co-regulate.
And that’s what’s so heart wrenching for the people who are really in this depression hoarding kind of situation, because what they need most, they’re unable, due to the sense of shame and anxiety to invite people in.
Neurodivergence: ADHD, autism and hoarding
TH: So whereas OCD and depression are mental health conditions, we are going to talk now about autism and ADHD, which are neurodivergences.
People have people prefer different terminology. So we’re going to mix it up. I I have several autistic friends who prefer to be called autistic. Other people prefer to say they’re on the spectrum or autism spectrum.
So I think if we use a term you’re not keen on as a listener, we’re not doing that to be offensive or upsetting, I think we’re just trying to mix it up a bit.
But as Jan said earlier, kind of avoiding the disorder side of that, because a lot of people celebrate their difference.
They see it as an alternative way of being, like they would prefer the neurotypical world to be a bit more neurodivergent in a lot of cases.
It’s not a problem in need of a fix.
Other people are neurodivergent and struggle with it and find it really difficult.
But diagnoses of both autism and ADHD are increasing rapidly as people realise that not every autistic person is non-verbal and exceptionally good at chess. And not everybody with ADHD was the naughty kid at school.
I think we’re getting a much broader understanding of both conditions and how they can manifest in a range of ways.
And as public awareness of that grows, more people are being assessed.
So let’s look at autism first. What is autism?
JE: So autism spectrum disorder, as you mentioned, is to some people a disorder or a problem to fix.
But I think most of us now are coming around to that new perspective of seeing autism as a culture of its own. It’s got its own cultural kind of norms.
TH: Touch points. Yeah.
JE: It’s a developmental difference and it’s characterised by divergent social interactions, communications, restrictive and repetitive interests and behaviours and sensory sensitivities.
And this is something that has kind of dawned on me recently, that it’s on a spectrum.
It’s not linear.
So in the past, we’ve had this kind of idea of high and low functioning and that’s just outdated.
TH: Like it’s 0 to 100 when it’s not.
JE: Exactly. Exactly. Like you’re either here or you’re here or you’re somewhere in the middle.
An autistic person has a unique profile, like unique as a fingerprint. So there’s all these areas. It’s more like a kind of pie.
So there’s social differences, interests, repetition, sensory sensitivity. They have different ways of regulating their emotions, different perceptions. Their executive functioning is different.
So it’s kind of like that pie and a person’s profile on each area varies.
So they’re really strong in one area or one area is particularly relevant to them, another area not so much.
So, yeah, I’m learning a lot about autism and I’m working with a lot more autistic clients.
And that’s why this conversation is really important, because just becoming aware that this is perhaps something that might be part of your makeup and your neuro universe, I guess, is really, really… I mean, we’re in a day and age now where so many adults are being diagnosed.
TH: So many. Yeah.
JE: Often I’ll have a client who says, oh, my son was diagnosed or my daughter was diagnosed and then I got diagnosed. And it set off this chain of events of me learning more about why things have been so difficult, because neurotypical people have tried to…
TH: Contain.
JE: Exactly. Exactly. Keep me in a box in a way that I had to conform.
TH: Yeah. And how can autism get mixed up with hoarding disorder? What leads, first of all, to the similarities?
JE: It can look like hoarding because some people on the spectrum collect objects. Quite a lot of them do collect objects of a specific, often it’s an unusual area of interest.
And they actually enjoy classifying and organising them according to particular dimensions and things like that.
TH: And again, the stereotype is of a young autistic boy collecting like toy trains or cars or something and lining them up in a particular way. But it doesn’t always look quite like that. But it’s that kind of theme.
JE: Exactly. Like I’ve had someone describe to me their daughter collected rocks, but it was gravel. Basically, it was gravel off the driveway.
But there were different aspects and different kind of dimensions of these rocks. And her daughter would spend hours and hours and hours and hours just reorganising them in her room on the ground.
And she’d have a little pouch that her grandmother had made her and she’d take them all out. She’d be working through, oh, I’m going to do it this way now. I’m going to reorganise it this way.
And that is something that those on the spectrum may do. It’s often known as stimming, which is a way to reduce their anxiety and bring themselves back into kind of a comfortable space.
So that can be what they use their collections for. And they do often want to complete a series of things. Or again, they don’t like incomplete…
TH: Yes.
JE: As well. So that is something else that’s come up in other areas. Right. So it’s like in OCPD. So, yes, so that incompleteness or OCD, that incompleteness is also in autism.
TH: I think the two are often mixed up. You find people diagnosed with one and then ultimately actually diagnosed with the other because the first wasn’t quite right.
JE: Exactly.
TH: And what are some signs that somebody might have autism rather than hoarding disorder?
JE: It’s again, it’s not always easy because I work with a lot of adults and often they’ve gone undiagnosed their entire life and they learn to mask many of their behaviours in order to fit in.
And particularly women and that’s why there’s been this this idea that it’s boys who are a particular way, but there’s just so many women now, adult women who are being diagnosed.
And it’s this masking, I have to do these things in order to fit in, because that was the only way that I would have been accepted at school, accepted by my parents, all those sorts of things.
But one of the first things I notice is with my clients on the spectrum is that they’re very literal and they take every word per the dictionary definition.
So I actually had one client who was explaining to me in quite a lot of detail. She’s not diagnosed, but her son is. She hasn’t had the diagnosis.
But we were talking about something and it was a word that she’d researched the definition and she was very frustrated that everyone used it in the opposite meaning of what it originally was.
So my little radar’s going off. I’m thinking, oh, that’s interesting. Okay.
In the home, the most obvious signs are that they tend to keep their collections quite organised and they’re likely to actually interact with their stuff quite often.
And like I was talking about with the rocks, they’ll recategorise them, use it as a form of stimming. And that helps them to reduce their anxiety, calm them down, help them cope if they’ve had a sensory overload or frustration or maybe even physical discomfort that can bring them back and they’re able to concentrate on something else other than their bodies.
The other telltale sign is the collection is usually very specific and possibly centred in some cases around a feature like the material that it’s made of or the texture or the shape or colour. So that can be something that like the bells go off as well.
And you kind of go, oh, that’s.
TH: Like a sensory, yeah.
JE: Exactly. Like it’s a collection around one of the senses whether it’s touch or whether it’s a colour that they love or whatever.
So it’s not easy, but it’s something that is becoming a lot more obvious to me and more people are looking for help.
But of course with a neurodivergence, we need to work with what we’ve got. This put putting people in a place of feeling like they need to change themselves to fit in, be someone different in order to be accepted. I mean, those sorts of things are…
TH: Exhausting
JE: Exhausting and anxiety provoking and often traumatising.
One of the things that I’m now realising and taking much more on board is changing an appointment for someone, say you have a regular appointment with them. And they’re on the spectrum and you’ve had this regular appointment and then something comes up and you want to change it the day before.
Now, I think really long and hard about that, whether I really have to do that, because that structure, for some it’s really super important and that’s very, very upsetting or destabilising or sensory overloading if you change. Then others, it’s not so much.
So as I say, every you need to be just constantly asking questions. And learning more about what their kind of profile is super helpful if you can get them to share it.
Like I’ll often ask them if they can share with me their diagnosis and the areas that are most difficult for them, because sometimes it’s hard for them to describe it. And that way I can go, okay, that’s super important. I need to be aware of those things as I’m working with this person, I maybe need to slow down my speech or I need to think about what I want to explain before I see them. So I explain it in a succinct, direct way. Without metaphors, without all that kind of thing.
TH: Yeah, I imagine from your point of view, as a therapist, you have to always be looking for, is that person shutting down? Like, has this gone a bit too far? And if somebody is autistic, that shutdown might look quite different.
JE: Yeah, exactly. Totally. And you’ve got to know, and you’ve got to be willing to ask and be curious about that. And once you are aware of it, then just it just opens up this whole new kind of relationship with that person.
TH: Yeah.
JE: Because you now get it, you now know that you need to say to them, I’m going to do this, and then I’m going to do that. And then we’re going to do this together. And be very specific about what’s going to happen, because uncertainty and not knowing what to do in situations is again, something for a lot of people, not just someone on the spectrum.
TH: Yeah.
JE: A lot of people, particularly those with anxiety or social anxiety, they want to know what’s expected of them. Yeah.
TH: I have a friend with an autistic son, and he hated his birthday, and they tried for ages to unpick what it was. And he didn’t know, and they didn’t know.
Anyway, they eventually worked out that he couldn’t cope with the uncertainty of opening presents and not knowing what was inside.
JE: Ah!
TH: And so once they’d figured that out as a team, as a family team, what they all agreed was that as they handed him something, they would say, this is Lego. And then he could open it and have that moment, but without the uncertainty of not knowing what was in it.
And for him, he now doesn’t hate his birthdays.
JE: Amazing, amazing.
TH: But it took them all to go, what is this? Because he couldn’t articulate it, because he didn’t quite know.
But they got there. And now he likes his birthday.
JE: That’s amazing. And that is the thing. Often clients on the spectrum said to me, I can’t explain, I can’t tell you how I’m feeling. I just can’t describe it. That alexithymia, that inability to describe the emotions or the sensations.
So that again, not pushing people. And when they say, as you said earlier noticing when they’re shutting down, it can look quite different, with those on the spectrum.
It’s listening, asking the question, is everything okay? Or do you need a break? And then they say, yes, I need to be alone.
And respecting that they need to be alone. They don’t want a glass of water. They don’t want you to make them a cup of tea. They don’t.
They just want to be alone. And like, that’s it.
That’s really hard for neurotypical people because there’s all these layers of like societal kind of pressures on what we think we are expected to do for others.
And often all of that is just rot.
TH: I also, I feel like I need to say at this point for full disclosure, I don’t have a diagnosis of autism or ADHD. I feel like if I was assessed for either or both, on a Monday, I might get the diagnosis, on a Tuesday, I might not.
I feel like I have a lot of the traits, but I don’t feel at this point that there would be any particular benefit in seeking a diagnosis.
So I just work with what I’ve got, which is some weirdness that may or may not be either or both of those things.
But I was thinking also that I – and a number of autistic people I know – have special interests and a particular topic that for a while is all they can think about and they know everything about it.
And I would imagine that it’s related to what you were saying about like the gravel and the rocks.
But I feel like a special interest that takes over your life can definitely end up in amassing stuff. And then six months or six years later, there’s a new special interest and you need to amass that stuff as well.
JE: Definitely. And there is quite often like a, oh, I found out everything I can about that thing. And then, oh, I’m over here now. And I’m sweet.
And that’s right. And it’s completely forgotten about. So whatever’s been amassed, whether it’s books on the topic or whatever, it, oh, now I’m on this. And that’s now my focus.
And that’s really hard. It’s really hard to then get that person to switch back to that old interest because they just don’t, I’m not interested in that now.
And I can see how that would be really, really hard to work on because that switch is very black and white.
TH: Why would I be interested in dealing with the old stuff when there are fractions to learn?
JE: Whatever it is, whatever it might be. And as you say, that can just look exactly like hoarding because it’s just an amass of stuff that you’re no longer actually interacting with.
You used to, you used to be looking at it all day and now you’re no longer and you’re on this other path.
So that can be can be quite tricky.
And I can’t say that I’ve dealt with that yet, but I think that there’s a chance I will in the future.
TH: In a previous episode, I mentioned getting suddenly and deeply obsessed with elephants. And I got so many messages going, are you autistic, by the way?
Maybe!
Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), variable attention stimulus trait (VAST) and hoarding
TH: So ADHD, can you explain what that is first of all and how it can manifest?
JE: Yes. Well, at least 5% of the population have ADHD, believe it or not. And similar to autism, successful people with ADHD learn to mask and adapt to the symptoms so the numbers, they’re pretty skewed properly. There’s probably more than 10% of the general population that have ADHD.
It’s an array of traits. And again, they’re unique to each mind.
And they’re all, as with ASD, they’re all different in their presentation.
But ADHD is a way of being in the world. It’s not entirely a disorder or entirely an asset. It’s kind of got a bit of both. Hallowell and Ratey, I’ve just bought their latest book, ADHD 2.0.
TH: Don’t get out of date ADHD. Get the latest ADHD.
JE: Correct. They describe it as a complex set of contradictory or paradoxical tendencies. So each negative has a positive.
But the telltale signs across someone’s life span is unexplained underachievement, which I like.
I like that. That’s your naughty boy who never sits still. A wandering mind, often off with the fairies, as is often said by our elder generation.
Trouble organising and planning. That’s our executive function.
A high degree of creativity and imagination.
Trouble with time management and a tendency to procrastinate.
Strong will, stubbornness and refusal of help.
Generosity, restlessness, unique and active sense of humour, which I like. I like that phraseology.
Trouble sharing and playing with others early on in life, but at the same time wanting to make friends.
JE: Exquisite sensitivity to criticism or rejection.
TH: I’ve heard that called rejection sensitive dysphoria.
JE: And there’s also recognition sensitive euphoria. So when they get recognised, they’re really sensitive to it. And they grow bigger and like push the chest out.
So yes, rejection sensitive dysphoria.
And impulsiveness and impatience.
An itch to change the conditions of life. So they’re the ones that are trying to make those big changes in their own lives and possibly in the world.
High energy, uncannily accurate intuition.
Transparency to the point of being honest to a fault. So they’ll just tell it like it is.
They are susceptible to addictions and compulsive behaviours. And that’s that itch of wanting to change conditions. And sometimes their impulsiveness leads to addictions and compulsive behaviours.
Tendency to externalise or blame others while not seeing their role in the problem.
And they do have a distorted negative self-image.
The whole ADHD thing, there’s some more there that we could talk about.
But it’s highly heritable. And if you have one parent with ADHD, the risk is one in three for a given child. But if both parents have it, the risk rises to two in three.
So if both your parents are attention deficit or hyperactive or both, then yeah, the genetics are there.
But other than that, environmental stressors can cause ADHD. Like head injuries, a lack of oxygen at birth, early infections, those types of things.
And yes, trauma.
TH: I was just going to ask about trauma. Yeah.
JE: Definitely. Definitely.
And there are people nowadays, which is very interesting, now younger generation, who have ADHD-like symptoms. Because modern life brings out something.
TH: You don’t have to concentrate for more than three minutes on a video. Because that’s how long they are.
JE: Yeah, that’s how long they are. They’ve decided that they like the idea of calling it VAST. Which is Variable Attention Stimulus Trait.
And it’s important that they say it’s a trait. Because it’s something that is not a disorder as such. It’s what you do in the environment.
But the constant bombardment of stimulus. I mean, our brain is just trying to go faster. We’re slaves to instant gratification and constant stimulation. I mean, my kids won’t read…
One will, I’ll give him that one, who reads books. The other one, oh, that’s boring. Oh, there’s too many words on that page. I’d rather watch a video.
It’s like, oh my goodness.
So there is no disorder per se. But it is that trait driven by the environment that we find ourselves in.
So even if you don’t have ADHD, you might have those symptoms purely because of the environment you find yourself in. It can just show up like that because we’re all in that space right now.
TH: Yeah, you open your phone to use the calculator. And you’ve got a notification from Instagram. So you check that. And then you go, oh, my friend’s posted. I’ll look at that. And you don’t know why you picked up your phone.
JE: Oh, I cannot say how many times I’ve done that this week.
TH: The app designers know what they’re doing. They know how to grab your attention and make you stay on their app. That’s their whole thing.
JE: That’s their whole reason for being. It’s people out there making millions of dollars trying to suck you into their apps.
And it’s working. And we do.
TH: It works on me!
JE: It works on me. I’ll go to Google something on my phone go, oh, I’m reading a book. And I want to find out about that particular person or whatever. You know, I can never just read the book, watch the movie. I’ve got to read every book. I’ve got to watch every movie.
TH: What else was she in? Let me just look that actor up because I recognise her, but I don’t know where from.
JE: Oh, look, seriously. Look, seriously, that is my modus operandi 99% of the day.
But I go, oh, I want to look up a particular queen or something. I’m watching a TV show going, is this queen real? Who’s Queen Joan? Whatever.
I go to Google that. But I get sidetracked on some news article. And then I’m down that, and I’m down another rabbit hole and down another. And then I go back to my book and I’m like, oh, I was looking up that person because I was reading it. Oh, wow.
And that is just a loop that we’re all getting ourselves sucked into. That is just time wasting. Unbelievable.
And it makes us feel like we were disorganised. I feel that way.
And then I’ve got the sense of shame that I wasn’t able to stay on stay on track and do what I said I was going to do. Spiral.
TH: So executive dysfunction is a phrase that frequently comes up when you read about ADHD. And a lot of it does apply to people who hoard as well. In my episode with KC Davis, we talked a bit about that. And also Jan and I are going to do a future episode specifically about executive dysfunction and hoarding.
But is executive dysfunction one of the reasons ADHD symptoms can lead to problems that look like hoarding?
JE: Yeah, definitely. Executive dysfunction, nd it’s a big topic. I think it’s right that we go deeper into that. And there’s definitely some very similar problems in ADHD and hoarding.
So they really kind of overlap. And it’s hard to tell often what is it.
And often people will have a diagnosis of both because there is that planning, that impulsivity, the creativity, thinking of new ideas, all those sorts of things, and the executive dysfunction related to planning, organising, cognitive flexibility, all those sorts of things.
Now, when we go through and talk about that, it’s actually quite interesting because the research is very mixed regarding hoarding and executive dysfunction.
There’ll be one article that will find definitely this is a problem and another article will find no, that’s not a problem.
So there are two or three things that are really worth talking through.
But I think the thing is with hoarding is that a lot of that emotion impacts on the executive functioning. So it looks like ADHD.
But that will be worth talking about.
TH: Yeah, you think I can’t get started, that’s executive dysfunction, whereas actually you can’t get started because the pile you’re meant to be working on is too emotional and you can’t face it.
JE: Yeah, you’ve opened a doom box and it’s like, oh, no, I can’t. And you can’t seem to switch. You don’t have that ability to kind of switch. And then you’re stuck and you decide not to do it.
So yeah, I think there is some of that going on. So it’s worth it’s worth talking that through. That was something I did a lot of research on when I was doing my PhD. I did a whole chapter on executive dysfunction.
Before anyone else had done a review, why didn’t I publish that? That was stupid. I should have published that.
I didn’t. And then someone else did. So that’s all right. It’s all good. Share it around.
TH: So as I said earlier, I don’t know whether I have ADHD or not. I don’t think I had the symptoms as a child, which makes me think I don’t. But that’s not particularly important. What is is that whether I have it or not, I often find that tips and advice for people who do have ADHD are really useful to me, too.
So whether I’ve got it or not, I can use that advice.
So can people with ADHD benefit from advice that’s aimed at hoarders?
Can people who hoard benefit from advice aimed at people with ADHD?
JE: Definitely. Look, definitely.
I mean, currently, we kind of don’t know if the indecision in hoarding is structural, like a physical difference in the brain, like it is with ADHD. Or is it Hebbian, meaning the neurons that fire together, wire together, that learned behaviour, whatever the case, indecision or inability to focus on boring or complex tasks.
But all of those tips and tricks offered by those with ADHD can certainly help.
And the opposite. I mean, there’s excellent references out there, books…
TH: Podcasts…!
JE: Podcasts, like this one, you know, all that sort of stuff.
So, yeah, I definitely do think it’s worth, and what look, trying out whatever might possibly work. And if it works, good. If it doesn’t, it wasn’t you, it wasn’t right for the place you’re in at the moment.
TH: That’s absolutely my attitude, to advice and self-help.
When I was younger, like, I would read a self-help book and go, well, that didn’t fix me. And then read another self-help book and go, well, that didn’t fix me.
And it took a long time to go, okay, but that bit in chapter seven was quite useful. So I’m going to take that forward. And then in the next book, oh, I quite like that bit. So I’ll take that forward.
Took me a while to get there. But now I’m very pro treating it like a buffet table and taking the bits that help.
JE: Exactly. And then just creating your own sort of smorgasbord. Like, just I’ve got this all these bits and pieces in my toolbox that I can try.
And look, if it doesn’t work, it just wasn’t right for me. It’s not a failure if something doesn’t work.
Because I do think a lot of these people out there who write self-help books, it’s often an area they’re very good at. So they write all this stuff. They need put no effort in to be good at that thing. And it’s like, well, just do it. Just do this.
And you’re like, I’d much rather to hear from someone who’s struggled a lot with this particular thing and found a way to get through it rather than…
TH: I’ve just been trying to think of the logical fallacy that that is. Survivorship bias. So they’re good at it. So they think they’re good at it because of the things they do. But actually, they’re just good at it.
JE: Yes. Yes.
Oh, that’s a good… I didn’t know that that’s what it’s called.
TH: Yeah.
JE: See, I learn something from you every week.
TH: If there’s… Say there’s a car crash and a lot of people say, oh, it’s a really dangerous road. And then there are people who say, well, I drive down it. It’s actually about being a good driver because I drive down that and I’ve never had a crash.
And it’s like, yeah, you think that because you’ve never had a crash. It’s survivorship bias.
JE: Definitely. And that is quite frustrating. You want your advice to come from someone who’s really struggled with a particular thing. And had to work hard at it.
Not someone who just has a gift and like, oh, this is how it goes.
And sometimes I find, I feel like some of the organising books are very much that.
It’s like, beep, beep, beep, bop, bop, bop. And everything’s beautiful.
And you think, that’s actually does take a lot of cognitive functioning to get to that point. It’s not something that everyone can do.
And yeah, writing a book about something that you’re exceptional at, just kind of like a giant pat on the back.
TH: Yeah, it’s great for people who are almost exceptional at it and want to go that final mile. But not for the people who are… Like, if you’re a good runner and you want to be a great runner, then a book by a great runner could really turn the dial for you.
But if you’ve never run more than three feet for the bus, then a book by Usain Bolt will be no use whatsoever.
JE: Yes. Sound bite.
TH: I don’t know, I felt as strongly about that as I clearly do.
JE: Sound bite.
TH: So, although autism and ADHD are not mental illnesses, as we’ve said, people who live with them are actually more prone to mental health problems, especially depression and anxiety.
And I think we’ve covered some of that in terms of people have to mask, people feel they have to mask their differences. And that is overwhelming and exhausting and of course can leave you very anxious. What if people don’t like me? Am I doing this right?
Or depression because you’re so tired and you believe… there’s a lot of that.
And then autism and ADHD can also co-occur, which is becoming known on social media as AuDHD.
So are there conditions or illnesses that are particularly known to frequently co-occur with hoarding disorder?
JE: Yeah. So interesting.
A recent study found that up to a third of psychiatric inpatients were found in this study to have clinically significant hoarding.
They hadn’t brought it up.
TH: That’s not why they were there.
JE: That’s not why they were there. It was added in to the suite of questionnaires and up to a third.
I’m like, wow, that blew my mind.
TH: That’s mind blowing.
JE: It blew my mind.
The other thing, a study found that a group of hoarding participants that had co-occurring depression and ADHD, inattentive type, reported more severe hoarding symptoms. They’re the ones that find it most difficult.
TH: The inattentive, yeah.
JE: Inattentive, ADHD, depression and hoarding. Because you’ve got low mood, low energy, low motivation. You’ve got ADHD where you’re scattered and you haven’t got good planning skills.
So you come at the hoarding from this place where the odds are stacked against you, basically.
So, I mean, the thing with ADHD is that it is treatable with medication. You know, if you have a diagnosis of ADHD, there is medication that is very successful in treating it.
And depression, well, that’s another whole story of whether medication works for more than a third of the population.
But if ADHD is something that you really feel that you have, it’s worth looking at diagnosis and medication for that, because chances are it will help with the hoarding.
But other conditions that frequently occur, OCD, generalised anxiety disorder, bipolar, as we talked about before, that excessive buying and the high and then followed by the depression.
Social anxiety, because you’re kind of protecting yourself against the world.
Interestingly, bulimia and binge eating. Binge eating, I understand. Bulimia, I understand, I guess it’s similar.
It’s that filling a hole, filling a gap in your life.
Gambling and definitely personality disorders, like lots of personality disorders are linked to hoarding.
So there’s lots of different things that co-occur. I mean, it is one of the most difficult disorders to treat because of the physical element of it and all those other things that co-occur.
But that doesn’t mean it’s insurmountable.
TH: Diagnoses can be important to help people understand their problem and to help others treat them appropriately, especially where, like with ADHD, treatments are more evidence based.
However, I do also believe that diagnoses are not the be all and end all.
And if somebody doesn’t have a diagnosis or is waiting for one at the moment, they can still learn about themselves and test out different things that might help them, as long as they do so cautiously.
What other things can people be doing if they’re just not sure what’s going on underneath their hoarding behaviours?
JE: Yeah, I think talking about diagnoses, I mean, there’s no biological tests or markers for these things, for ASD or ADHD or whatever. So that is why it’s so tricky.
I mean, many, I’ve said this before, but many of the criteria are the same across disorders and there’s inconsistencies in the quality of assessments.
And OCPD and ADHD, there’s a number of identical behaviours.
And that diagnosis is based on that bunch of questions that a clinician asks a person in an office where they’re feeling anxious and they’re only observed at a single point in time.
So an inexperienced clinician using those questionnaires might not see the body language, the eye contact or lack of, or the tone of voice or…
TH: I used to get, when I was in mental health services in a more consistent way, I would see a psychiatrist periodically and whenever a psychiatrist moved on and was replaced, I would get a whole new diagnosis and they would go, oh, you’ve not got that, you’ve got this.
And I would learn all about it and then they would move on and someone else would go, oh, you’ve not got that, you’ve got this.
And I got to a point where I thought some people clearly do have a very clear diagnosis. I think something like bipolar, for instance, can be quite cut and dried. You know what you’re dealing with.
And basically with me, ultimately, eventually somebody went, well, this is obviously PTSD and everybody went, yeah, this is obviously PTSD and that one stuck.
But before that happened, it made me realise how subjective a lot of this is.
And if you get a psychiatrist who doesn’t believe in a particular diagnosis or who believes every young woman who self-harms is borderline, then it’s so subjective.
And I’m not downplaying, I know people can feel seen when they get the diagnosis that fits. And I know that getting the right treatment is invaluable.
But if you’re like I was before the PTSD diagnosis, where one person says you’ve got bipolar and one says you’ve got this type of depression and another person says you’ve got that type of depression and you just think nobody knows what they’re talking about or I have 12 things, then it doesn’t have to stop you making progress.
JE: No, exactly. And I do have a client who has 11 diagnoses. Look, so many of them overlap. And I’m like, wow, that is just absolutely crazy.
And you’re right, it can be comforting. And look, it’s often a way to get the help that you need.
TH: Completely, yeah.
JE: So you’ve got to kind of weigh up the pros and cons of all that. I think that’s important to weigh up.
And other times it’s shame provoking. You find out you have something that you just completely, and you can’t cope with that.
So each person needs to weigh up those things.
But I think if you’re not sure what’s going on underneath the behaviours, it’s really important to kind of ask yourself some questions around… self-awareness kind of gives you that clearer picture before you go to see a professional.
Because as you said, it can be very, yeah, you find from one person, you get this diagnosis. So you learn all about that.
And then you go away and someone new and they give you a new one.
If you’re able to kind of be more self-aware and ask yourself some of the questions that might highlight why, the reasons behind the behaviour, that gives you a kind of base to go on before you go and see a professional.
Because we’re not all, we’re certainly not always right.
TH: You shock me, Jan.
JE: I know. We’re certainly not always right. We certainly make errors.
And also, as you said earlier, we’re different people, on different days and we’re different people in different environments, contexts.
So a diagnosis, it really is better for a clinician to look at what are the behaviours and what are the functions of those behaviours?
What are the difficult things that you’re attempting and what are the functions of those?
And if we come back to that, then we can see where we’re in a loop and we’re just looping around and around and around.
And the only way to do that is to find out what’s underlying.
Are you emotionally attached to the majority of…? Really think about that and sit with that, you know.
Do you really feel like the possessions are kind of an extension of you?
TH: Yeah, would you let somebody come in and just throw it all out for you?
JE: That was my next thing. How would you feel if someone came into your house right now and said, I you have to throw out, donate or sell 75%? How would it feel?
TH: Would you be relieved or would you be terrified? Right, exactly.
JE: So those sorts of things can really, okay, I’d be, oh God, I’d be relieved. Okay, all right. Well, that tells you something.
TH: That’s a depression nest. Ok!
JE: Exactly, that’s a depression nest.
If terrified, okay, that sounds a lot more like hoarding.
And then going through those sort of questions, whether it is, whether you feel like you’re a walking ghost or do you feel like you don’t deserve a clean house? Well, there’s a layer of depression and it might be, it might be both of those things.
Are there rituals that you avoid? You save stuff and you just can’t comprehend why and do you have maybe some other OCD kind of compulsions in other areas as well, like you were saying?
So yeah.
But for the kindred spirits out there, the questions of, do you spend hours planning your life down to the last second and then never get anything done?
Put my hand up.
Do you feel out of control when you let someone take over a project and micromanage them to death?
Yep, I got my hand up.
Do you like things to be aligned at right angles? Does your perfectionism stop you from starting to organise?
TH: Yes.
JE: So those, if it’s all that kind of stuff, well, there’s an element of that there.
But what we were talking about earlier was pulling things, so once you’ve kind of got a little bit of a sense of almost your profile, if you like, what are those things that are in the loops that you’re just looping around?
Once you’ve got an idea of that, then you’ve got your, you’ve got your banquet and you can just pick which bits work.
But I do think that if there is some sense of autism or if you had that sense that eye contact is difficult or even painful, those sorts of things. Do you collect and interact with this collection and move on quickly? Those sorts of things.
Perhaps there might be, and it depends on how impaired it, yeah, how difficult it makes your life.
I mean, that’s the whole point. How difficult is it?
And if it’s super difficult, okay, let’s think about that because there are a lot of supports, particularly in Australia, there’s a lot of supports for those with autism.
So it might be worth going down that path, but it’s expensive. You know, you’ve got to have a full assessment, which can, can cost $1,500 to $2,000.
And you may not even need that. You may just need to recognise that those are some of the things that hold you back.
TH: And read a book about it. Yeah.
JE: Read a book about it and that might be, that might be enough.
TH: And also, I hate that we have to play this game, but I think medics don’t like it if you turn up and say, I read on the internet about OCD, I think I’ve got OCD.
I think they then roll their eyes and try and disprove you.
Whereas I think if, because certainly within the NHS in the UK, initially you get referred to whoever has a free space.
And so you see whichever psychiatrist.
But it might be that in that conversation, you say I wonder if there’s an OCD specialist you could refer me to, because there are some traits maybe, and I think it’s quite interesting. And maybe there’s a question.
And I hate that we have to play that power game, but we kind of do because there’s a lot of arrogance in medics and they don’t like being told things.
So if you let them think they’ve worked it out.
JE: Especially by a woman.
TH: Especially by a woman. And it might be that you need to be referred to an OCD specialist psychiatrist or an ADHD assessor.
Certainly here, there are now dedicated pathways for an autism assessment or an ADHD assessment now.
JE: We have the same.
TH: So it might be, yeah, that you just say to your GP, please can you refer me for an ADHD assessment? And that might be that.
But if it feels more complex, and if it feels like you do think you’ve got OCD, but it’s not a typical presentation, something like that, I think it can be worth, especially if you live in a city, there are psychiatrists with special interests in different areas, and they can refer between them.
If you can get that to happen, I think that’s more fruitful.
JE: Yeah, I couldn’t agree more.
And you may be able to be able to find a researcher who’s particularly interested in your presentation.
And that might lead to not a formal diagnosis, but it might lead you down the path where you kind of understand yourself better.
And most of them, I’ll tell you just a secret. Most of them, if you find their university email, and you send them an email, I reckon about 65 to 75% will reply, perhaps higher.
So don’t be shy.
Try to be succinct, and clear about what your interest is in their area of expertise, but seriously, they will, they will reply.
TH: So tune in next month, when we are going to be talking about executive function and executive dysfunction.
In the meantime, Jan, if people want to find you online, where can they do so?
JE: Yeah, it’s a good question. You can trot along to stuffology.com.au, sign up for the newsletter, which is a weekly Sunday afternoon slash night publication. You can just send me an email, I will reply, Jan@stuffology.com.au.
On the socials, Instagrams, @stuff_ology, on X, am I calling it X? X, I’m @stuff_ology, or on Facebook, check me out at Stuffology Consulting.
TH: Jan, thank you so much. It has been a joy.
JE: Oh, it’s always a pleasure to join you on the pod.
May we take a moment to reflect on the meaning of place and acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land on which we record and listen to this podcast today.
I’m speaking on the lands of the Boonwurrung people of the Kulin Nation, and I acknowledge their connection to country, both land and sea and culture.
We pay our respects to their elders past and present and extend that respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples listening today.
Do you want to be a Dehoarding Darling? You can be now at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling
If you love the podcast and want a bit extra, you can finally sign up to be a Dehoarding Darling.
Members will get an exclusive monthly post with an additional top tip, some podcasts and music recommendations and a personal update from me about how things are going.
Find out the full details at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling
So my top tip today is also a shout out for the How to Fail with Elizabeth Day podcast, which is an excellent listen.
And she, in this mini clip, is talking to singer songwriter Lucy Spraggan about having compassion for yourself. Have a listen.
That idea that you’ve been trying to prove who you are your entire life. How’s that journey for you today?
Well, based on a response from that quote, it’s I just don’t feel like I have to prove anything anymore to anyone.
Because I feel like I’m always trying to just, it’s not about proving anyone, it’s just about finding out. And I’m constantly just find out more about myself.
And every day, I feel more compassion towards myself. And that’s where I feel like you start to win. Yes.
Like more compassion, less competition. I don’t feel like I have to prove anything.
Some days I do. Some days, I’m like, Oh no, I’m worthless.
And other days are easier, it’s not binary.
That’s beautiful, more compassionate, less competition with others, but also fundamentally with yourself.
Yeah.
So I will link to that in the show notes. It’s well worth listening to on a regular basis I would say especially if you have a big fear of failure.
Okay, thank you for listening, and I will speak to you next time.
Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. You can find more online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk
You can find me on Twitter @ThatHoarder. And on Facebook at Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder.
To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support and do subscribe to this podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.
There may be links in this podcast that earn me money. This doesn’t come at any extra cost to you if you make a purchase through those links and it helps to support the future of the podcast.
Audio credits
- Intro and outro music: cheesepuff
- Transition whoosh: Vilkas_Sound
- Piano Playing Classical Music: IESP
- Hallelujah chorus: deleted_user_2906614
- Uh oh: stib
- Angels: pycckuu20032003
- Phone: HarryPeeks and Aesterial-Arts
- Yay!: Reitanna
- Fanfare: humanoide9000
- Explosion: Iwiploppenisse
- What? What? What? max_cristos
- Why? Why? Why? Why? Reitanna
- Celebration: Gabriela_Melo
- Not again: xtrgamr
- Atmosphere 17: DaveJf
- Wah wah: SpliceSound
- Giggles: kim.headlee
- Help me: brandonreese
- Please don’t flush: PMBROWNE
- Horror laugh: klankbeeld
- Oohs and aahs: noah0189
- Applause: Sandermotions
- Heartbeat: Tobias Ludwig
- Countdown – female : Tim Kahn
- Game Over – evil: Rocotilos
- Countdown – male: jppi_sstu
- Oh yeah: metrostock99
- Amen: klankbeeld
- Cuban happy music: szegvari
- Suspense: Warped_Tension
- Ding dong: MatthewWong
- Former intro and outro music: grapelemon
