Pop culture and the media can do real harm
Show notes
- Does hoarding really have a 97% recidivism rate?
- Ten Percent Happier podcast
- Dr. Robert Waldinger
- Website: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding
- Become a Dehoarding Darling
- Submit a topic for the podcast to cover
- Questions to ask when dehoarding: https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/podquestions
- Twitter: @ThatHoarder
- Mastodon: @ThatHoarder@mastodon.online
- TikTok: @thathoarderoch https://www.tiktok.com/@thathoarderoch
- Facebook: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Pinterest: That Hoarder
- YouTube: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Reddit: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder subreddit
- Help out: Support this project
- Sponsor the podcast
Subscribe
- Apple Podcasts / iTunes
- Google Podcasts
- Spotify
- RSS
- iHeartRadio
- Amazon Music
- Audible
- Stitcher
- Podchaser
- Pandora
- Deezer
- Podcast Addict
- Player FM
- Podcast Index
- TuneIn and Alexa
- Castro
- Goodpods
- pod.link
Audio credits
- Intro and outro music: grapelemon
- Ding dong: MatthewWong
- Transition whoosh: Vilkas_Sound
- Angels: pycckuu20032003
Transcript
Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder. Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast and all my social media, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk. Finally, I am not a doctor, I’m just a hoarder doing her best, so do seek professional support if and when you need it.
So I’m going to start today with a review I received on Apple Podcasts USA. And the review was by 7-8 Teacher and it says:
Found your podcast today.
As I currently type this I laughed out loud. The podcast on “Avoiding Distraction” began to play. Wow, talk about the power of suggestion. I immediately paused this episode so I could finish my review honestly and then return to it with rapt attention. Thank you for speaking truth and leasing me a safe space to explore this part of my life. I have not let any family member or friend in my home for more than four years. It is shameful. I am so glad I found your podcast because you have become a person I can count on. Thank you so much! Sincerely, Stephanie
Thank you, Stephanie. I’m glad you found me.
I, too, haven’t let family members or friends in my home for far too long. And it’s definitely not just us. This is a really difficult problem to be dealing with. And I’m glad I can be of help.
And you have also been of help because every time somebody leaves a review, it helps other people to find me. And that’s great.
So thank you.
So today I am going to talk about how the portrayal of hoarders in popular culture, online is really damaging. It contributes to stigma. It’s very othering, people talk about like we’re some separate species to look at in a zoo.
And I think dramatising what is a mental illness, well, it’s unhelpful, but I think it goes beyond unhelpful, into actively, actively destructive.
And I appreciate, obviously, that hoarding is not something that happens in isolation, and it’s not something that has no impact on other people, especially if we have children or other people who live with us, it’s an issue, but it can also affect neighbours.
It’s not a problem-free mental illness, but it is a mental illness.
When hoarding is turned into something exciting or funny or lurid to talk about to get clicks, we are dehumanised Share on XAnd when it is turned into entertainment, when it is turned into something exciting or funny or lurid to talk about to get clicks, to your website, to your YouTube video to your podcast, we as hoarders are dehumanised just a little bit and the more that happens, the more people feel they have the right to continue that dehumanisation and to humiliate us.
And that’s not okay. It’s not okay. It’s not okay for any mental illness. It’s not okay to laugh at somebody who’s hearing voices. It’s not okay to be disgusted by somebody who is having a manic episode. It is not okay to think that somebody who’s depressed is a bad person.
And it’s not okay to make TV shows designed to turn us into a spectacle to be gawked at.
That dehumanisation, that othering, it turns us into “them” in and “us and them” scenario. We’re kind of outsiders, and then people come in to help us and I use help in very much inverted commas. And then we may be distressed when that happens.
And all of that is turned into entertainment. And this is presented as helping the hoarder in question because their house gets cleared out, for instance, and it is presented as a way to educate the general public on this illness, that’s usually the two main justifications for hoarding as entertainment.
And I saw a tweet recently from somebody who tweeted while watching hoarders, the hoarders TV show. And that person said, I’m up at 1am, watching hoarders and talking to the TV, you’re not a perfectionist, you’re a loser and a pig.
And that was what that person took from the Hoarders TV show.
That person didn’t watch it and think now I have a better understanding of a quite debilitating mental illness, they watched it and thought you’re a loser and a pig.
And that’s not an unusual takeaway from programmes like that.
And that convinces me that this is not media that is helping people to understand what’s really going on with us.
It convinces me that this is not media that is helping people to understand what's really going on with us. Share on XAnd I’m not saying it’s okay to live in a hoard. And I’m certainly not saying it’s okay to subject other people to live in your hoard. But I am saying that this kind of approach is not helpful.
It doesn’t get anybody anywhere. The houses that are cleared dramatically, to the accompaniment of lots of screaming and crying, are so often full again, within months or certainly years. Things are not solved and resolved and fine from then on. And by increasing stigma, it makes it harder for other hoarders to then say, Oh, I’ve got this problem, too.
It makes it harder to do that, and therefore harder to seek help.
And this episode has been prompted by a podcast episode I saw. The title of the episode was the horrible hoarder. So that caught my attention. My first thought, oh, no, a hoarder has done a horrible thing. Has a hoarder killed somebody? Has a hoarder, I don’t know, kidnapped somebody?
But no, this person is being called the horrible hoarder on this podcast, based solely on his illness and the consequences of his illness.
Was he a bad person? Or is he an ill person?
I listened to the podcast and I’m going to share little clips of it just to highlight kind of what we’re dealing with.
And I’m going to remove the name of this hoarder from the clips for the sake of his anonymity, for the sake of his dignity. What I’m about to outline, what this podcast was talking about, is not a situation that left him with much, if any, dignity at all. Indeed, the way he was living didn’t leave him with much dignity.
It’s all been a really sad, sad story. And I don’t think he needs podcasts naming him 10 years on from what happened.
So this podcast, talking about the horrible hoarder, describes him like this – is it really necessary?
[name]’s neighbours didn’t describe him as violent or intimidating. Terms like creepy, weird and smelly, would be far more appropriate.
It just seems unnecessarily cruel to me. There’s no need.
Again, we’re talking about somebody’s ill. His personality traits, his creepiness? I don’t know, is that appropriate to talk about somebody you don’t know like that?
Well, all you know about him is that he was severely affected by hoarding disorder and struggled… well, found it impossible to get on top of it. There’s just no need to mock him.
The first violations of city health code are reported that year, with seven additional cases being opened by August of 2012. The neighbours started to notice odd behaviour coming from the little wiry guy living at [redacted].
Two cars sat in the driveway yet they never moved. Instead, neighbours saw [name] going up and down the street at all hours on any number of children’s bicycles. These bicycles made convenient getaway vehicles for [name]’s favourite hobby, stealing his neighbor’s garbage.
And was he combing through the trash for personal information like some especially filthy CIA operative? Nope, he was just keeping the garbage because he liked it.
This wasn’t the least of it, though, and [name] was observed washing his clothes in the gutter, which to look at photos of him seemed to work about as well as you might expect.
So it sounds like this man was creating legitimate problems for his neighbours and that his illness was impinging on them.
This means it does have to be addressed. I’m not pretending that that’s not something that needs to be looked at.
I am all for accountability and responsibility.
This man’s hoarding got out of control following the death of his mother. And as you know, if you’re a regular listener, hoarding and grief are seriously interlinked a lot of the time. There are big, big links between hoarding and grief.
The smell was so foul, I gagged slightly close quote. Spoiler alert, this is going to be a theme moving forward. In one particularly memorable quote, a neighbour tells her and I quote, it’s horrendous. This is a nice neighbourhood, and people take care of their homes. This is like a junkyard, it smells putrid. We go for walks and it’s terrible. We crossed the street so we don’t have to smell it. Close quote.
The article then closes with ingenious simplicity by asking the rhetorical question, would do you want to live next to [name]?
So this needs to be, you know, it needs to be looked at, this man needs help. And from the start, what he was approached with was warnings of code violations rather than any kind of… like, I’m sure he knew, I’m sure he knew that the way he was living was not ideal. And he may well have welcomed help.
But what wasn’t offered was help. What was offered was punitive enforcement action.
And so one of his neighbours went to the newspapers. And the authorities then started taking action. And I understand the frustration and impotence of the neighbours.
But again, is this a helpful way forward? For this man, who is clearly struggling in every way. He’s lost his mother, and everything’s gone out of control. And the podcaster can’t pretend that he doesn’t know that people don’t hoard for fun. He can’t pretend that he’s got no idea that we’re talking about a mental illness because he acknowledges this.
Finally, hoarders know that they have a problem. They might not be able to put it into words, but they do know they have a serious issue.
Frost and Steketee escape that 60% of hoarders they studied met with the criteria for major depression. And to be clear, major depression is exactly what that sounds like, with episodes lasting two plus weeks and leaving the sufferer basically unable to function.
Hoarders inevitably start hoarding during childhood, and the authors anecdotally note that many of their patients had cold, unfeeling parents. Though they’re clear that they don’t have sufficient data to prove a causal linkage between parenting and hoarding.
There’s a strong reason to suspect that there’s a genetic basis for hoarding as a shocking 80% of hoarders have a first degree relative with some degree of the same issue.
They go on to say that a potential genetic abnormality has been uncovered on the 14th chromosome that might be interpreted as a quote unquote hoarding gene. But there’s no smoking gun on this yet.
It’s been hypothesised that perhaps hoarding might have some origin in childhood poverty, given that somebody growing up without a lot of possessions might be reluctant to part with their stuff when their financial situation improves. But Frost and Steketee are dismissive of this, as the case is presented in the book involve all social strata, including some very wealthy old money individuals.
And after lots of failed attempts to get this man to clear out his home, a forced clear out was ordered.
Now, generally speaking, forced clear outs are not helpful in the long term. Generally speaking, they either don’t have lasting positive effects, or they actively have lasting negative effects.
So, if a hoarder, if their hoard is cleared out against their will, then it will clear space. But they may react to that by the sense that they need to cling even more, keep clinging, keep clinging, need to bring more stuff in. If the issues have not been addressed that led to them getting into that situation, then it’s almost guaranteed that a space will be filled up again.
Now, that’s not to say there’s never a call for it. In absolutely extreme situations, sometimes a forced clear out is required, but very much as part of a holistic approach, helping the person to address what’s gone so very wrong.
So bear in mind, sometimes I believe they are required. But they are also not… they can’t be expected on their own to solve a problem.
And so there’s some details of his hoard here that do highlight that this was a very serious situation, but be aware, it is quite distressing, and it does include some animals that have died.
So what exactly was behind that door that I’ve been teasing this entire show? Here’s your answer: trash, and more trash.
Trash packed so tightly that the front door couldn’t even be opened at first, trash stacked so high that [name] could only get around his house by crawling through a 12 inch gap between the top of the trash and the ceiling.
Hoarders typically leave little trails called goat paths to navigate their hoards. [name] just crawled around on top, like Gollum.
[name] may have been the owner, ut he wasn’t alone. [name] claimed that he had 12 cats. But when it was all said and done, that number was an excess of 50.
And if you look closely at the photos taken that day, you can clearly see brown discolorations on the ceiling that have the unmistakable look of what happens when you turn your whole house into a litter box.
What else can we see in that trash pile? At first, it just looks like random crap. But if you look hard enough, it almost becomes a feat of archaeology.
The mind reels at what could have been learned if one of [name]’s ancestors had owned a villa at Pompeii.
In one photo, you can see a gold handled refrigerator just to the left of the front door and mostly surrounded by plastic grocery sacks. And within those grocery sacks appears to be even more trash, apparently in various states of liquification.
Another photo shows a Siamese cat, its ears within an inch of the ceiling, peering down from atop a wall of cardboard shipping boxes. And within those boxes are hoses, empty bottles and scraps of cloth, all filthy and discoloured from an unknown liquid dripping all over them for an unknown time period.
A closer look at this photo may provide some insight into [name]’s hoarding habit. Several of the large boxes are easily identifiable as having come from Pizza Hut. These are the sort of boxes that things like frozen dough and toppings arrive in bulk in.
Putting the pieces together here, it looks to me like [name] was riding his bike down to the strip mall about a half a mile away at the corner of Lake Mead and rampart, and raiding the dumpsters of both the Pizza Hut and the Smith’s grocery store there and then taking his winnings home and adding them to the pile.
I mentioned earlier that Diogenes syndrome hasn’t been well studied or understood. But county mental health services knew things had the potential to go sideways and they showed up in force.
Things got tense with [name] trying to lock himself inside when the cleanup crews moved in. But they never boiled over into violence, and [name] didn’t make any sort of a scene beyond the fact that his very existence was pretty much the dictionary definition of a scene.
So this was really serious. This was not a happy guy who was functioning well in his life. This was a serious situation for him and his home.
And I need to be really clear that having animals in your hoard in this way is not fair on the animals.
This man believed he had 15 cats. And it turned out he had 50 and some of them had not survived.
It is unfair to make children live this way and it’s unfair to make animals live this way.
And I know this is hard to hear if you are living this way with children or animals. But if that can be an extra motivation for you to really, really try and get on top of this, then use that. Because when you ask yourself really, really honestly, is this the way cats are happy living? You have to acknowledge that no, it’s not.
But I still feel strongly that turning it into a sensational story. Whether that’s that local newspaper reporter at the time or this podcast today, when it’s actually a depressing story of one man’s serious illness following the death of his mother is irresponsible at best and cruel at worst.
So this is ultimately what happened. In terms of his home:
Jane Anne Morrison had a front row seat to the whole thing. Her story the next day related that the city offered to get [name] a hotel for the night, but he declined and said that he would sleep on the porch.
Before the day was out, the Las Vegas Department of Building and Safety would deem the residence uninhabitable and posted a decal on the front window which reads as follows and I quote, Notice to vacate, do not enter unsafe to occupy this house is substandard. It is a misdemeanour to occupy this building, or to remove or to face this notice, close quote.
And there’s more questionable media involvement.
The clean outs started on a Friday, which means that for the second Saturday in a row, Jane Anne Morrison had a cover story about the issue.
This time, the story had the sort of accompanying visuals that the national press can’t resist, with outlets like CBS and ABC News, Radar Online and the New York Daily News all picking up the story.
It even got circulated overseas, with the Daily Mail of London running a story with those photos I mentioned earlier prominently featured.
Closer to home, the story was still Jane Anne Morrison’s baby, and she would run daily updates as the cleanout continued.
Again, it’s just should this really be a cover story?
Somebody has been so ill and so bereaved that they couldn’t cope to this degree. Is that something we should feel empathy towards? Or is it something we should plaster on the front page of the local paper, naming the person and sharing photographs of their hoard?
Somebody has been so ill and so bereaved that they couldn't cope to this degree. Is that something we should plaster on the front page of the local paper, naming the person and sharing photographs of their hoard? Share on XI can’t imagine how that was for him. And again, I will keep saying this – that is not to detract from the problems that his illness was causing.
But is this a caring, thoughtful approach? I’m just not convinced.
And it was picked up by the Daily Mail, which should disqualify anything from being a decent story.
So this forced clear out was agreed on. Well, I say agreed on, was decided on, not agreed on by him. But remember, this episode is about a horrible hoarder.
So to justify that label, I thought perhaps like he was really awful to the clean-up crews. Perhaps he kicked up a massive fuss and got in the way.
But no:
[name] wasn’t giving the cleanup crews any problems. And Morrison saw him trying to clean off a set of ski poles in hopes of keeping them.
When she approached for a quote, [name] told her to quote unquote, write whatever you like about me and otherwise refused comment.
[name] continued to be mostly cooperative, playing his guitar for the cleanup crews and cleaning off items that he wanted to keep, which were then placed into steel shipping containers. And in retrospect, I think the city was offering this as a carrot to ensure [name]’s cooperation.
He says local reaction was a mixture of fascination and revulsion. And that is exactly what this podcast’s approach is as well. Just listen to this:
As you might imagine, local reaction was a mixture of fascination and revulsion. I think it probably trips the same place in the brain that makes us slow down for accidents.
Jane Anne Morrison’s reporting states that looky loos were already driving past the house constantly the day that the story broke, and while the pace would slow down, they continued until the process was done.
We’ve got to keep in mind that rather than a good story, we’re talking about the manifestation of a person’s serious mental health problems.
That’s what this fascination and revulsion is with. And remember I said earlier that this podcaster was aware that this isn’t something hoarders do for fun? He was aware that this is a mental health condition.
He also reads a letter to the editor out that again clarifies that he’s not unaware of the ethical and exploitative nature of covering hoarding in this way.
The first letter, which I’m going to read now, is by somebody I’ll call Christopher x.
To the editor, Jane Anne Morrison’s recent columns about the Sun City hoarder were appalling, irresponsible and unethical.
This gentleman likely suffers from a severe mental illness. Most hoarders also suffered from depression. It has been shown in numerous medical studies that elderly depressed males living alone have a higher suicide rate than any other group.
Additionally, this man clearly values his privacy and almost certainly is deeply embarrassed to be featured in a front-page article containing his name, pictures, personal information and a printed map to his home.
Undoubtably, gawkers have been driving by his home taking pictures at all hours since Miss Morrison irresponsibly printed her news.
This may further worsen any coexisting depression and could potentially lead to a fatal outcome.
In a city of more than 2 million people, this story is not news. It is simply another example of the media and the American people taking pleasure in other people’s misfortune.
I understand that the neighbours feel victimised and that the respective HOAs and city failed in their responsibility for code enforcement.
That aspect of the situation is a valid news story. But that story could have been reported just as effectively without revealing this gentleman’s identifying information, the tragic loss of his mother and without describing him as quote unquote, dishevelled with his pubic hair showing.
Shameful.
So ultimately, 44 truckloads of stuff were removed from this man’s house. The house had to be gutted, all the drywall, pipes and wires even removed.
And further reinforcing that this was not a well man, he was hospitalised in a psychiatric ward.
His extended family said they were considering having him committed. And then he got criminal charges.
Turns out that [name]’s legal problems went beyond spending 72 hours in a psych ward.
Before he got out, Metro brought the following charges.
Failure to register a pistol. They found one in the house and it’s an open question as to whether or not even knew that he had it.
Public nuisance, two counts on that one.
Unjustifiable injury to animals. This is on account of all those sick cats that had to be euthanised.
Failure to have a cat fanciers’ licence, you need one of these to own more than three cats in Clark County.
And last but not least, a fire code violation.
Bail was set at $15,000, the city wanted 25 and [name] appeared in court his long thinning white hair crowning his head in a way that would have made Einstein smile.
He wore the iconic orange jumpsuit and you can tell from the photos that he’s not all there.
So his lawyer said that he knew he needed help, and he wanted help.
And the bit that possibly blew my mind the most was that because of all this, he spent four days in jail, and then a week in a mental health facility
To go to prison because your distress manifests in this way, it’s just a bit mind blowing.
So ultimately, he was ordered to pay $95,000 The animal cruelty charges were dropped and he pleaded no contest to everything else and got a 358-day suspended sentence.
And he moved into a new home and was ultimately evicted for guess what… hoarding!
No surprise there, nothing was resolved. Of course nothing was resolved! He had a forced clear out, which sounds like it was necessary, but then he was put in prison. Like, that’s not a solution to mental health problems.
So I think this case really reinforces that forced clear outs on their own on not a cure.
That’s not to say that in this extreme case, it wasn’t necessary. But, like with the TV shows where dramatic clear outs happen, and then people refill their homes within months, we’re presented as untreatable or ungrateful for the treatment we’ve received, when in fact, what we’ve received is the wrong treatment, if it’s treatment at all.
And this… I didn’t try to dehoard for ages because I kept seeing, Oh, they always fill the house up again. Or it’s got a 97% recidivism rate. And I just kept thinking, what’s the point in trying to clear out my house when everything says that all that work will be in vain, because I’ll fill it up again later?
When the message goes out, see, look what we did for this guy, and he’s still filled up his next place, we look like we;re digging our heels in, rather than that our distress has been magnified.
And it all makes it harder to seek help as well.
I think if you were a hoarder in that area at that time, and you’d seen that somebody else’s case had been on the front page of the newspaper with their name and photos of their hoard. And you thought that was a possible outcome, would you seek help? Or would that discourage you?
If you saw someone on Twitter saying you’re a pig, because of something they saw on TV, would that help you seek help? Or would it discourage you?
I am so conscious of the shame that I feel. And I know from your messages that you feel. I’m so conscious of how much it limits the help I access, how much it limits the steps I take, and TV shows and podcasts that go “here’s a gross story for your entertainment”, are not something that contributes to an environment where we can openly say, I hoard and I need help.
Because we don’t know if the therapist or the doctor watches those shows. We don’t know if that’s their view of us.
We don’t know if we can tell our closest friends, because we don’t know if they think it’s a mental health problem or if they think we are ungrateful pigs that will never get better.
I am not opposed to people who hoard being held accountable. I am not opposed to us facing up to the consequences of what we’re doing.
But I fail to see how criminalising people, putting them on the front page of the local paper and putting us on TV at our most vulnerable help us rather than hinder our progress.
Do you want to be a Dehoarding Darling? You can be now at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling
If you love the podcast and want a bit extra, you can finally sign up to be a Dehoarding Darling.
Members will get an exclusive monthly post with an additional top tip, some podcasts and music recommendations and a personal update from me about how things are going.
Find out the full details at https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/darling
So my top tip this week is from the podcast Ten Percent Happier, where Dr. Robert Waldinger has something interesting to say that could be really helpful I think, if you have strained relationships with family members, or anybody… and this does not apply if we’re talking about somebody who is outright abusive or toxic for you to know. But if there’s somewhere you have a tense relationship, this is quite a helpful thing to try.
Have a listen:
You also talk in the book about family relationships, what have you learned there?
Well, again, that idea of constant change, we’ve found a very helpful framework.
Because one of the issues for families as we know each other, often we know each other from the time we’re tiny, right? So you knew your siblings, or your parents knew you as some little kid.
So my 30 year old son is about to go out the door, and I find myself wanting to ask him, don’t you want a warmer coat? And then I have to stop and think, Wait a minute, he’s not six years old, he’ll manage with whatever kind of coat he chooses, right, he’s 30 years old.
What I notice is that my own sense of who he is doesn’t always shift with time.
We see this with siblings, where an older sibling was always the bossy older brother or older sister, and the younger ones are resentful.
We all change. And in fact, yeah, this person could still be bossy, but often they’ve moved on and we might want to move on too.
So we all want to keep looking closely at each other, right, to see, okay, who are you now?
And for this, I go back to actually one of my meditation teachers who gave me an instruction that I found very helpful with family members, which is: with this person who I feel I know everything about and I know so well, what’s here right now that I haven’t noticed before?
And if you can just set yourself that exercise with the person you think you’ve known forever and always know, that can be really helpful in making you more curious again, and being more open to somebody showing up differently than they did 10 years ago.
I’m definitely going to keep this in mind with certain relationships with people I’ve known for such a long time. And am I really seeing who they are now? Am I giving them a chance? Or am I, somewhere, treating them as difficult because they were difficult when they were 10?
Or treating them as overbearing because they were overbearing when I was 10?
It seems like an interesting idea, and I’m going to try it.
Okay, thank you for listening, and I will speak to you next time.
Thank you for listening to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding podcast. You can find more online at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk
You can find me on Twitter @ThatHoarder. And on Facebook at Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder.
To find out more about how you can support this podcast and the overall project, go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/support and do subscribe to this podcast, so you make sure you don’t miss any future episodes.
