Show notes
- Podcast ep 87: Papering over the cracks – when short-term fixes get in the way of long-term progress
- Podcast ep 103: Scarcity and hoarding with Dr Jan Eppingstall
- Podcast ep 110: Do you own your stuff or does it own you? Freeing yourself and your home with Jasmine Sleigh, author of Being Owned
- Our Messy Collective podcast
- Podcast ep 82: Dehoarding when you’re drowning with KC Davis of Struggle Care
- Website: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding
- Become a Dehoarding Darling
- Submit a topic for the podcast to cover
- Questions to ask when dehoarding: https://www.overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/podquestions
- Instagram: @thathoarderpodcast
- Twitter: @ThatHoarder
- Mastodon: @ThatHoarder@mastodon.online
- TikTok: @thathoarderoch https://www.tiktok.com/@thathoarderoch
- Facebook: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Pinterest: That Hoarder
- YouTube: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder
- Reddit: Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder subreddit
- Help out: Support this project
- Sponsor the podcast
Subscribe to the podcast
Transcript
Welcome to the Overcome Compulsive Hoarding with That Hoarder podcast. I am drowning in stuff and trying to find a way out. Listen as I explore the issues and delve deep, as somebody profoundly affected by hoarding disorder.
Find out more, including links to subscribe to the podcast and all my social media, at overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk.
Finally, I am not a doctor, I’m just a hoarder doing her best, so do seek professional support if and when you need it.
Hey, how are you? Things here are good.
I am going to start this week with my first success of the week and weird dilemma of the week for ages.
And then I’m going to talk about one of the big questions: what if I regret dehoarding? What if I put in all this work and wish I hadn’t.
And then I have a shout out at the end with a top tip.
So, let’s go!
So my success of the week is that I put some pictures up on my walls.
Now that might sound like an odd one, especially because I’ve done a whole episode before about not rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic, not papering over the cracks.
And as I was putting these pictures up and feeling quite pleased with them, I was thinking, is that what I’m doing? I could be getting on with actually dehoarding, but instead, I’m spending time hammering nails into the wall and getting these pictures up.
But I think the reason it felt like it wasn’t a matter of papering over the cracks was this little glimmer of hope that came with putting these pictures into frames and hanging them on the walls.
And that was that I realised it wasn’t that I was doing that and pretending it was the same as dehoarding.
It wasn’t that I was doing that and thinking it would fix the problem.
It wasn’t any of those kind of denial or distraction things.
What it was, and this is what makes it a success rather than a distraction, was a little glimpse of me making my home a place I like. Me making my home a place that feels a little bit like it represents my character, my style.
And of course it doesn’t make my home a neat, tidy, acceptable place to be. It doesn’t.
But what it does do is show me that, in the midst of all the dirge of day-to-day-to-day dehoarding, something in me can actually see a future, where things like what’s on the walls will be representative of how my home looks, rather than everything that’s on the floor.
So that is my success of the week.
My weird dilemma of the week is very much an example of “do as I say not as I do”, because I often talk about the importance of when you’re donating stuff, don’t agonise over where it goes, don’t agonise over donating it to the precisely most perfect place.
If you need to get rid of a lot of stuff, just get rid of it.
And if that means a slightly less optimal charity shop gets it, that is okay. That’s fine. Don’t worry about it. It’s most important that the things get out of your home, all of that stuff.
And then, because this whole podcast is me working this stuff out, and me talking about stuff I’m learning but haven’t necessarily nailed, I found myself in a position last week where I was in a different town, I went to get something from the car boot. And it is so full of charity shop donations ready to be given, but not actually given.
And I just thought this is ridiculous. Find a charity shop here in this town and leave the bags here.
And I had this whole weird dilemma about should I give my stuff to a charity shop in a different town? Or should I keep that stuff in circulation in the city I live in?
And you wouldn’t think that would be a big dilemma. But my goodness, I really got stuck.
Part of me was like, well, I can benefit a charity in this town, as a little thank you for being a nice place to visit. And then part of me was like, Yeah, but you love the city you live in. And surely you want to benefit the people who live in the city you live in.
And then I was like, but most of the charities are national charities anyway. So whereas my first round of thinking about the people who would be shopping in the charity shops, one of the other benefits, of course, of charity shops, is the charity benefits. And in that case, whether it’s Oxfam or British Heart Foundation, or Save the Children, all the profits go to the national or international charity.
There are some local charities, obviously, but the money doesn’t look any different to Cancer Research UK Head Office, whether it came from a shop in the city I live in or shop in the town I was visiting.
And so whereas my first thought was yeah, okay, just find a charity shop in the sat nav, go there and drop it off before you have too much time to think about it. And then I faced this weird, unexpected resistance from within myself, saying, maybe this stuff belongs in my city, though. Maybe that’s where it should be.
Or maybe this is the right thing, on and on in my head, and it kind of came from nowhere. I wasn’t really expecting it.
But the good news is, I left the big charity shop donation bag in the town I was visiting. In a national charity shop in the end, because that was the one that the sat nav suggested.
And it all worked out well.
But it just goes to show that just because I know the best advice, it doesn’t always mean it’s easy to follow.
So today, I’m talking about regret. It came up in a previous episode with Dr. Jan Eppingstall, that people who hoard often have a really strong anticipation of regret.
People who hoard often have a really strong anticipation of regret Share on XWe won’t get rid of something in case we regret it. Or we acquire something spontaneously in case we regret not doing so.
And that kind of anticipating future regret, and acting accordingly, can end up being quite negative for the state of our homes, and the state of our lives and our approach to dehoarding, because that ongoing fear, oh I’d better keep it just in case, that kind of insurance policy approach to dehoarding is what gets us in trouble and keeps us in trouble.
And I know this is something I have to battle all the time and there’s two layers to it really. There’s: I have one item in front of me. What if I get rid of it and regret it? But there’s also a bigger: what if I spend all of this time and energy dehoarding and I regret the whole project?
So that’s what I’m going to talk about today, and I think a good place to start is that while we might regret something, I’m not going to say you will never make a decision you regret in the process of dehoarding, we might regret doing some of these things.
But the regret that we forget to anticipate is, if we don’t do it, would we regret that?
And I think there’s a fairly high chance that we would.
If we didn’t make any effort to make our homes easier to live in, easier to get repaired, easier to heat up, easier to use, that could be a massive source of future regret.
And also, what if I don’t regret it? is a question we don’t ask. What if I regret it might come to mind very quickly. But what if I don’t, isn’t something we often consider?
I know, years ago, in a previous attempt to dehoard, a previous short-lived attempt to dehoard, I was getting rid of things by donating them to charity shops. But I also could not stop acquiring from charity shops.
And I remember the first time I gave a full bag, to a particular charity shop.
And my worry was next time I was in there shopping, if I saw something on sale that I had donated, would I feel regretful? Would I feel like, oh, I should have kept that?
And, sure enough, within a couple of weeks, I was in that same shop. And there was a couple of things on display that I knew I had donated.
And I was so relieved to find not just that I didn’t regret it, but that I actually felt really proud.
And I remember looking at each of these items, and looking at the price tags, and adding up the amount that this charity – and I remember very well which charity it was, it was a hospice, adding up how much this hospice was going to get, just from me giving those things.
And then visualising what a hospice can do with that amount of money, whether that’s just stocking up the supplies of tea and coffee for visitors, or whether it’s providing therapy for one of their patients, or whatever it helps with.
And so my fear that I might regret it was big.
But the reality was not just that I didn’t regret it but that actually, I felt really proud and like I accomplished something.
So when we focus on potential regret, we’re not focusing on potential benefits of whatever it is we’re scared of, whether that’s dehoarding or whether it’s not bringing something new in.
And if we can think beyond what if I regret it to what might I miss out on if I don’t do this?
What could I gain by doing this?
What could I gain by dehoarding?
What could I miss out on if I don’t dehoard?
And sometimes just reframing those questions when you find that what if I regret it pops into your head, try asking those questions, not necessarily instead of what if I regret it, but maybe as well as?
So if you say what if I regret it? Try. And what if I don’t regret it? And what could I miss out on if I don’t try this? What could I gain if I do try this?
And it’s common for fear of regret to hold all kinds of people back in all kinds of things.
And knowing that hoarders have a particular propensity for this fear feels like even more of a reason to try and get on top of it really.
And often with any kind of fear. especially if it’s chronic and ongoing, it’s worth probing a bit to find out what is the fear?
Beyond what if I regret it, what are you afraid of at the core of that?
Because once you can identify that you can start to address it a bit.
So what if I regret it? And you probe that a bit and it might be, and therefore end up with no books to read at all? If I donate these three books, what if I regret it becomes what if I have nothing to occupy my time?
And once you know that that’s what the specific fear is, you can start to go, is that realistic? I do have bookshelves with at least 500 books, getting rid of these three is not going to cause any damage, especially because I’ve already read them and I don’t reread books, or especially because I started them and didn’t enjoy them. So I wouldn’t want to go back to them anyway.
Alternatively, if you find yourself saying I can’t get rid of that, what if I regret it? And you probe and the fear is, because if I then need one of these things, another pasta bowl, I won’t be able to replace it.
You can probe that a bit and say realistically, is that a realistic fear? Given an honest look at my finances, could I afford a pasta bowl if it turns out I don’t have enough of them?
And given where I live and what transport I have access to, or whether Amazon or online shops deliver here, could I physically get hold of a pasta bowl, if it turned out I don’t have enough?
And once you know what the fear is, it’s a lot easier to see whether it’s a reasonable fear, or whether it’s some kind of panic inside of you that’s grasping onto these things, through a fear that is actually quite easy to disperse when you shine a light on it.
Another good protection against fear of regret is to start gradually move gradually.
If you can do it one step at a time, you can assess at each step how it’s going.
If you’ve done a little bit, it’s like testing it out. And you can see whether your anticipation that you will feel a lot of regret actually comes true.
It might be that you think you’ll feel a lot of regret. And then you get rid of something or you don’t bring something in and actually you feel relief, or actually you feel nothing at all. It’s just neutral.
And if you do it bit by bit, you can then, at the next time you think what if I regret it, you can look at the previous time and say, well, I was worried about that then, it didn’t come to pass, so maybe I can try with this as well.
And do it gradually.
And I know that that’s not always unfortunately possible, depending on your circumstances. If you’re about to be evicted or something like that, that kind of gradual approach isn’t always realistic, which I think is an argument for trying to start to tackle this before you’re in trouble for it, or before anybody’s taking action about it.
Again, I know life doesn’t always work out that way.
But if you can dehoard in a steady, ongoing way, that can help you to reassure yourself and to weigh up the pros and cons, weigh up what the fear really is about and make more considered decisions and measured decisions that can help to insulate you against future regret.
Another important thing to consider when you’re worried about whether you’ll regret something or not is, as I mentioned at the start, the cost of not doing that thing.
It’s all very well thinking, I can get rid of this and that’s a risk. Or I can not get rid of it, and I have no risk in my life.
But that’s not how it actually works.
You can get rid of it and that's a risk, or you can keep it and that's a risk Share on XYou can get rid of it and that’s a risk, or you can keep it and that’s a risk.
There are things you will miss out on if you avoid making the hard decisions.
If you keep everything in case of future regret, that creates conditions to regret a whole different thing, which is coming to a point where you realise your life has been absolutely controlled and limited by this need to hold on to everything.
Think about the opportunities of getting rid of things, think about the opportunities that you will have if you don’t bring everything home with you, if you don’t place that order online, if you don’t keep hold of every pencil that you find.
It’s not dehoarding = potential regret and not dehoarding = no regret at all.
It’s just different regret. And we’ve got to weigh that up realistically.
It’s nice to think I won’t take the risk, I’ll keep it because I can’t face the risk. But it’s not as simple as dehoarding is risk, not dehoarding is pure safety.
There are things you will miss out on if you avoid making the hard decisions. If you keep everything in case of future regret, that creates conditions to regret a whole different thing Share on XAnd like when you’re overwhelmed with a task, and breaking it down into smaller parts can really help with that, you can do the same with decisions.
If you’ve got a big decision to make, say, whether to get rid of a storage unit that’s costing you money every month, or get rid of a particularly difficult item for you. You can also break down that decision into smaller steps, make it more of a process, more manageable.
And like with doing the whole thing gradually, use those increments, and make the decision bit by bit by bit.
It’s less overwhelming, it’s less intimidating. And you’ll feel less like you’re rushing into an important decision, completely unequipped to deal with it.
Setting yourself a timeframe can also be great for this kind of fear of regret, because… it’s a bit of a roundabout way.
But basically, if we don’t have a deadline, we might end up procrastinating, because hard decisions are hard. And so we don’t want to make them.
And so we kick it down the road and we’ll do it later. We’ll do it later. We’ll do it later.
But we also know, just through life experience, that every time we do that, in our minds, that decision or that task gets bigger and bigger and bigger, and more and more and more frightening.
It’s that really difficult thing where you put something off for nine months, and then you do it in five minutes. And you could have done it nine months earlier, and not had nine months of niggling stress knowing you’ve got to do it.
It's not dehoarding = potential regret and not dehoarding = no regret at all. It's just different regret. And we've got to weigh that up realistically. Share on XAnd it’s the same with decisions that we might regret.
If we know it’s a tough decision and so we delay it, the fact of delaying it makes us think I will It must be really, really tough if I’m putting it off.
So we put it off a bit more and then we go well, I’ve delayed it this long, it must be virtually impossible to make this decision without risking regret.
And so it’s hard to put time limits on things, especially if that’s just internally, and we don’t have an external method of accountability. If we just say to ourself, you’ve got to make this decision by four o’clock today or you’ve got to make this decision by Friday, it’s harder to stick with but it can still help because we need something, often, with some kind of parameters in order to make the hard decisions so that we don’t keep kicking the can down the road and putting it off and creating in our heads some kind of monster decision.
Asking for help can also help. Asking for advice. Saying to a counsellor or therapist, I need to make a decision on this, and I’m worried I’ll regret it. Or I want to try and start dehoarding and I’m worried I’ll regret it. That can be such a valuable conversation to have, or friends, family, anonymous people on social media.
When you can share your fears, that can help to quieten them a bit. And when people respond with, oh, I had a similar situation, I was really worried I’d regret this and actually turned out brilliant, I’ve never looked back.
Or, you know, I did a thing, and I regretted it. But it wasn’t that awful, actually, I just felt a few pangs and then I moved on.
And the other person doesn’t have to be a hoarder. We’ve all, in every aspect of our life, faced decisions that we’ve worried will regret.
You get a new job and you don’t know, if you’re moving out of the frying pan into the fire. Or if you’re moving to your perfect new setting, or you’re moving house or you’re moving your child’s school.
And we come across those decisions all the time.
And then the very minor ones. I quite fancy trying a new sandwich for lunch. But what if it’s not as good as the one I normally get?
We experience that kind of very small regret as well.
And so even if other people don’t have lived experience of hoarding, they do have lived experience of life. And that has included facing decisions that they’ve worried they might regret.
And if you can get their perspectives on how they got through them, that can only help.
And then finally, we do need to address the fact that you may make a decision you regret.
Over the course of dehoarding a whole home, there’s a fairly high chance that you’ll regret a decision or two that you make.
Maybe you see something in the reduced section in the supermarket and you think no, I’m not going to get that. And then you get home and you really think, Oh, I wish I’d bought that. And then the next time you go back, it’s not there.
Or maybe you get rid of a load of crockery, and then realise you don’t have quite enough left.
I’m not going to pretend that’s not going to happen, because it probably will.
But what we’ve got to face up to is that it’s something that happens in life, and that we are better equipped to deal with it than we might think we are.
We might think, oh, I wouldn’t cope, I would feel so terrible.
But actually, it happens and you go, oh, that’s a pain, and then you move on with your life.
Years ago, it was a long time ago because I was having visitors. I’d been splurging on dehoarding over weeks and weeks and weeks to prepare for these visitors. And that included donating a lot of mugs to the charity shop.
And then in the days before I was having a load of family over, I realised I didn’t have enough mugs left for everybody to have a drink at the same time.
And any Brit knows that you have to, as somebody arrives, put the kettle on and everybody gets a tea or coffee. You can’t say only four of you can have a hot drink any one time!
And I did have a brief pang of regret. Why did I donate all of those? Now I’m short!
But actually, while I felt that, it was brief, and then I felt like it was kind of funny. It was funny that I’d created this situation.
And then it meant that I was kind of allowed to go to a charity shop and buy some mugs. And so it turned out so fine, because I got to shop legitimately.
And it was kind of a funny story.
Even though people in my life don’t really know I hoard, I could say, I donated a load of mugs to the charity last week, and then had to rebuy some today, because I’ve got visitors coming. And that’s quite a funny story.
And there are there will also be regrets that are more painful than that.
I think we are so afraid of that feeling that we can still overestimate how awful it would be.
And we can’t shut ourselves down and say, okay, I will never make a hard decision again, in case that feels bad.
Because as I said earlier, it’s not like inaction leads to no regrets at all.
But also because sometimes life just throws regrets at you.
And sometimes that’s a result of a choice we personally, individually made. And it’s unpleasant, and it’s uncomfortable.
But it doesn’t kill you. It doesn’t have to ruin your life.
I think the best we can do when we’re faced with real, painful regret, which I have to assure you is not going to happen with every bag you throw out, is not going to happen with every bag you donate, it’s not going to happen with everything you sell on eBay.
It’s going to vary from person to person. But that kind of deep, painful, agonising, regret is an occasional thing.
And more often, as I talked about in the episode with Jasmine Sleigh, more often, dehoarding leads to discoveries, like, I thought this was lost forever. And now I’ve found it.
And that joy can massively counteract the occasional bits of regret.
But when those bits of regret happen, it’s not nice. But we can look at it and say, okay, what is going on here? Is it as simple as I got rid of something and I wish I hadn’t?
Or is it bigger than that? Is it something about fears you have about your life? Is it bringing up other things for you?
But also, what can I take from this that will inform future decision making? What can I take from this that will hopefully minimise the chance of this happening again?
But not using it as an excuse to shut down and stop trying.
And it’s a balance, but it can be a learning experience, it can be a step towards personal growth and improving our lives, and improving our coping skills, and hopefully, improving the state of our homes at the same time.
I make this podcast because I think it’s important. I started it as an outlet for myself, but it’s become much more than that. And I hear from people all the time about how listening to me talk about my experience and interview specialists and experts is helping them hearing those stories makes the time and cost absolutely worth it.
But if you want to help to ensure that the future of the podcast is sustainable, you can donate to help with costs.
To send a one off or recurring donation just go to overcomecompulsivehoarding.co.uk/donate
Thank you.
So, shout out this week to a podcast called Our Messy Collective which I will link to in the show notes. They interviewed one of my former guests, KC Davis.
And KC here is making a point about ethics. And it was this kind of philosophy that made me approach her in the first place to say, would you like to come on my podcast because your message is so valuable?
Have a listen to KC talking about ethics:
If you find yourself in a spot where you have to make a choice between doing what’s right for the world, and doing what’s right for you, you are ethically obligated to do what’s right for you.
I’m letting that sink, like that, ethically obligated to do what’s right for you is so…
This isn’t about ‘you have permission to not follow the rules’. Or ‘well, you really should be using sustainable coffee filters, right?’
No. You are ethically obligated. When the choice is between, throw out the recycling into the garbage so that you can function and don’t throw the recycling out at all and let it pile up in your house so you stay more paralysed. You are ethically obligated to throw it in the garbage.
It’s about being honest with yourself about what your real choices are and making the choice that provides the most good for yourself, your family, your community in the world.
Right. Right.
And if you need to replay that, and replay that and replay that, do it.
Okay, thank you for listening. And I will speak to you next time.
There may be links in this podcast that mean money. This doesn’t come at any extra cost to you if you ever make a purchase through the link and it helps to support the future of the podcast.
Audio credits
- Intro and outro music: cheesepuff
- Transition whoosh: Vilkas_Sound
- Piano Playing Classical Music: IESP
- Hallelujah chorus: deleted_user_2906614
- Uh oh: stib
- Angels: pycckuu20032003
- Phone: HarryPeeks and Aesterial-Arts
- Yay!: Reitanna
- Fanfare: humanoide9000
- Explosion: Iwiploppenisse
- What? What? What? max_cristos
- Why? Why? Why? Why? Reitanna
- Celebration: Gabriela_Melo
- Not again: xtrgamr
- Atmosphere 17: DaveJf
- Wah wah: SpliceSound
- Giggles: kim.headlee
- Help me: brandonreese
- Please don’t flush: PMBROWNE
- Horror laugh: klankbeeld
- Oohs and aahs: noah0189
- Applause: Sandermotions
- Heartbeat: Tobias Ludwig
- Countdown – female : Tim Kahn
- Game Over – evil: Rocotilos
- Countdown – male: jppi_sstu
- Oh yeah: metrostock99
- Amen: klankbeeld
- Cuban happy music: szegvari
- Suspense: Warped_Tension
- Ding dong: MatthewWong
- Former intro and outro music: grapelemon
